Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike... what will actually happen in end?!

382 replies

SpringPop · 28/06/2023 18:55

My school is striking again next week with others that have teachers from the particular union.

All that is happening is parents are getting massively angry. Kids are missing out. I've used so much holiday on strike days as I have multiple children. I know my anger should not be directed to school but exactly where can I direct it to? I'm pretty sure my MP wouldn't care. He's completely useless.

The government don't seem to care.

I personally think something needs to change in that profession and funding in my area is shocking! It's probably not attracting the best people to the profession and certainly is driving people away.

However, am I right in thinking rishi and co don't care?! Teachers could do 5, 10, 100 days and it seems they won't budge right?

Parents don't seem to care or get angry enough, short of tweeting about it or writing to MP. It isn't really enough to get this resolved.

How do you think this situation will end?

OP posts:
BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 17:14

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 17:12

I've held QTS for 22 years now, taught full time secondary for 15 of those, in Adult Education for 3 years, several years working for an anti-poverty charity and a little bit longer in a youth work capacity. Now I work in local government formulating policy and strategy,.some educational. Plus I have two secondary age children. I have a pretty clear picture of what goes on in a classroom and I've always specialised in challenging kids.

You have laudable experience in education, so what do you think schools should do about the recruitment and retainment issue if you don't think teachers deserve a pay rise? Because the two issues ARE inextricably linked.

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 17:12

I know the masses are always know for their smart moves. But @TheSnootiestFox can't you see a rather lot of people are saying actually your coming across badly.

I still haven't heard from you what your suggestion is re tackling the recruitment issue in this sector as a whole ? Although granted I'm willing to say I may have missed it treating parents with respect or only teaching those what want to listen isn't going to suddenly draw people to the career ?

Because people are voting with their feet and again this is happening on mass but something is going wrong.

I want to see the other perspective on this, but I don't have time with insults, diversions or the whole they hit me first so type games. I have kids and I get enough of that as it is.

Frankly

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 17:12

Fairislefandango · 01/07/2023 17:05

I'm sure it was posted some while ago where I mentioned improving behaviour and attendance by treating parents, many of whom will have had a less than sparkling experience of education themselves, with a bit of respect and not treating kids like lumps of meat going through a processing factory would be the plan. Happy kids and happy parents equal less disruption and you can do the job you all keep telling me you're so good at in peace. If kids want to learn and can see the relevance along with accessing an appropriate curriculum then that's half the battle won.

Are you a teacher then? Because I'm wondering what qualifies you to think you know what 'equals less disruption' and what actually goes on in schools. Teachers generally bend over backwards to make the curriculum as accessible and interesting as possible and to treat students with respect and encourage them to treat each other and staff with respect. Unfortunately it quite often doesn't work. You say 'if kids want to learn'? Yes, well the problem is that quite a lot of them simply don't, however relevant or accessible the subject matter. As for treating parents with respect... we do. They sometimes don't return the favour though.

I've held QTS for 22 years now, taught full time secondary for 15 of those, in Adult Education for 3 years, several years working for an anti-poverty charity and a little bit longer in a youth work capacity. Now I work in local government formulating policy and strategy,.some educational. Plus I have two secondary age children. I have a pretty clear picture of what goes on in a classroom and I've always specialised in challenging kids.

lifeissweet · 01/07/2023 17:11

What is then, @lifeissweet? Genuine question, what is the solution?

Where to start?!

This is the ideal:

To begin with, I want an Education Secretary who values education (outlandish, I know) and one who is advised by a board of education experts from a range of backgrounds.

I want an overhaul of inspections. They need to be far less prescriptive. I want them to go into schools and judge what they actually see and not pre-judge based on data. I want less focus on data all round - it can be manipulated and children aren't products where you put in x and get out y.

I want them to come up with plans for improvement rather than a list of faults with no suggestions. I think Ofsted reports are horribly unhelpful about what improvement looks like.

The whole thing needs to be less punitive and more focused on improvement. Bin the grading. Inspect every school on the same timetable (outstanding schools are left alone for far too long). Parents can read the reports and choose a school based on the strengths noted. Want great pastoral support? Choose one with that as a strength. It would stop parents going for one with an 'outstanding' badge just because of that. It causes inequality.

I want more involvement from local authority - or other - improvement partners, so schools are given tools to help and regular peer inspections to share good practise across schools. Some do this and do it brilliantly. Some (mostly MATS) are very insular and don't take advice very readily.

I want an overhaul of SEN provision and some actual research about the impact of so many more SEN children in mainstream schools. If they want to close special schools or limit access, then teachers need more training, schools need to be resourced to manage it and a more holistic approach needs to take place (I'm thinking more mini-resource bases where resources and expertise are pooled. This is far less wasteful and more efficient and reduces the pressure on mainstream teachers)

I want investment in buildings (that one is obvious and shouldn't be an outlandish suggestion)

There needs to be more admin support so that teachers are able to concentrate on planning and resourcing great lessons and not getting bogged down in data input which isn't using their skills. It's a waste of money for teachers to be photocopying and data inputting in their PPA time.

I want well trained and well paid TAs to run teacher lead and planned interventions. Not putting up displays or babysitting, but supporting learning. This is supposed to happen, it increasingly doesn't - and now they are all being laid off anyway.

I feel like much of this was in place when I started teaching. I've just read it back and, Ofsted aside, we did a lot more collaborative work across schools and had more input from LA advisors than now. It did make a difference - and it doesn't cost the Earth.

Unfortunately, cuts to LAs and academisation has ruined all of those brilliant networks. Schools are more like stand-alone businesses now.

As for recruitment, I think the idea of having all teachers having M.Eds is not such a bad idea of a previous Ed Sec (can't even remember which, now. We've had so many).

Teaching is more attractive if it is better respected. What garners respect is higher qualification and skill, plus good pay. If you judge a profession to be well qualified and well respected it becomes attractive. Not necessarily for the pay in itself, but because of the message it sends about what society thinks of a profession. Well paid = well valued.

This costs money. You'd need training providers, bursaries for training to that level and then a tempting starting salary.

So:

  • stress reduced by a different inspection regime
-stress reduced by a DfE who understands and values education and doesn't move the goalposts all the time with unevidenced initiatives.
  • stress reduced by proper SEN support
  • stress reduced by proper TA support
  • stress reduced by admin support
  • better trained teachers who are incentivised to stay

...

All with benefit to the children.

Idealistic. I know.

Fairislefandango · 01/07/2023 17:08

Bloody hell... reading back, it seems you were a teacher. Well, there's no accounting for your opinions then.

Fairislefandango · 01/07/2023 17:05

I'm sure it was posted some while ago where I mentioned improving behaviour and attendance by treating parents, many of whom will have had a less than sparkling experience of education themselves, with a bit of respect and not treating kids like lumps of meat going through a processing factory would be the plan. Happy kids and happy parents equal less disruption and you can do the job you all keep telling me you're so good at in peace. If kids want to learn and can see the relevance along with accessing an appropriate curriculum then that's half the battle won.

Are you a teacher then? Because I'm wondering what qualifies you to think you know what 'equals less disruption' and what actually goes on in schools. Teachers generally bend over backwards to make the curriculum as accessible and interesting as possible and to treat students with respect and encourage them to treat each other and staff with respect. Unfortunately it quite often doesn't work. You say 'if kids want to learn'? Yes, well the problem is that quite a lot of them simply don't, however relevant or accessible the subject matter. As for treating parents with respect... we do. They sometimes don't return the favour though.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 17:03

Baconisdelicious · 01/07/2023 16:49

in which case you'll be happy to see your children taught online/in the hall with 150 others/by non-specialists in a subject they are desperate to excel in because they need it for their career aspirations?

Then they'd go to an Independent School.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 17:03

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:51

Of course you can disagree, you just don't have to resort to personal insults.

I don't recall doing so apart from.in.one case when I told someone I thought they were being ridiculous. And I hold that opinion.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 17:01

Saywhatevernow · 01/07/2023 16:54

This. ND does not equal obnoxious, it’s offensive to everyone out there who is ND.

I only mentioned the fact I was ND because I had my mentality questioned and that is offensive. I don't offer it as an excuse, I don't need to. Unless I'm now not allowed any sort of opinion other than yours 🙄

Baconisdelicious · 01/07/2023 16:59

if kids know there will be consequences for serious or consistent bad behaviour then thats another massive step, and I doubt there will be many parents who wouldn't support that

there are plenty of parents who won't support it. Too many in my experience but I've worked at the two extremes - in independents and in schools with serious levels of deprivation. There are many, many parents who cannot fathom that their child is the one who is bullying/stealing/vandalising/not working and so on. Too many parents who believe that it is up to the school to somehow get their child to magically pass their exams without the child having to put even 5 minutes worth of work in.

And if you oust all these children (and there will be alot of them), where are they going to go? They still have a legal entitlement to an education, regardless of their beavhiour. Indeed, it is to our benefit as a society as a whole that we do everything we can for children struggling to ensure we have an educated work force able to tackle whatever is thrown at it. Wash your hands of them, and what happens next?

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:59

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:50

You started with the personal insults though! It was a robust and even-handed debate until you came on @ing the teachers on the thread to tell them they must be shit at their jobs and they're the problem. Being ND is not an excuse either.

I let noble giraffe draw that conclusion because they were hell bent on telling me I knew nothing about teaching. I have never called anyone a shit teacher, its not my terminology for a start! And I don't care about being ND and don't use it as an excuse, ever, I only brought it up because someone though it OK to 'question my mentality' just because I don't agree with the majority of you on here! Just have a read of all the things said about me before you take me to task on my responses.

I repeat, for clarity, I don't think teachers are underpaid, I don't think striking is right and just, and I think teachers have a lot to answer for in terms of the culture in schools now being so toxic, and I gave examples of people being promoted too early in their careers and not handling things desperately well to illustrate my opinion. I also believe that schools are intolerant of anyone that doesn't hold a particular set of political beliefs and I stand by that. No need to froth and argue, and if you don't agree than that's fine as there'd be no need for democracy if we all thought the same!

Saywhatevernow · 01/07/2023 16:54

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:50

You started with the personal insults though! It was a robust and even-handed debate until you came on @ing the teachers on the thread to tell them they must be shit at their jobs and they're the problem. Being ND is not an excuse either.

This. ND does not equal obnoxious, it’s offensive to everyone out there who is ND.

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:51

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:49

But I disagree with that opinion so why would I say that? I believe that the problems with the NHS are down to poor decision making and the existing budget being mismanaged. Pretty much the same with Education!

Of course you can disagree, you just don't have to resort to personal insults.

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:50

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:38

Well, I'm sure you'll not be surprised to learn that if someone attacks me, and there has been page after page after page of posters doing so, I am not going to sit by and be insulted, called names, frequently told I don't know what I'm talking about when actually I'm very much clued up. Currently I'm paid to be clued up and advise local government accordingly. So I will argue my case. The trouble is everyone thinks they're right. But instead of saying ' I don't agree, we'll have to agree to differ' I was frequently told I knew nothing and I was just a 'snotty parent' trying to insult teachers. It's clearly OK for lots of people to insult me but I can't retaliate - and that's called bullying. I do hope that clarifies the situation somewhat!

You started with the personal insults though! It was a robust and even-handed debate until you came on @ing the teachers on the thread to tell them they must be shit at their jobs and they're the problem. Being ND is not an excuse either.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:49

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:46

I did read the rest of the thread actually and I agree with much of it - the NHS is a lottery and much of it isn't fit for purpose. But once again you attacked the people working within it as being to blame and made it personal, rather than acknowledging that years of funding cuts have led to it being on its knees – just like education.

But I disagree with that opinion so why would I say that? I believe that the problems with the NHS are down to poor decision making and the existing budget being mismanaged. Pretty much the same with Education!

Baconisdelicious · 01/07/2023 16:49

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:12

Oh Jesus not this again. You're not underpaid as a profession and every government body had their funding cut due to the overspending that went on before. Not understanding this, and certainly not understanding that there is a finite pot of resources so if you demand a big pay rise and receive it then more jobs will have to go, is very much your fault, yes!

in which case you'll be happy to see your children taught online/in the hall with 150 others/by non-specialists in a subject they are desperate to excel in because they need it for their career aspirations?

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:46

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:46

I did read the rest of the thread actually and I agree with much of it - the NHS is a lottery and much of it isn't fit for purpose. But once again you attacked the people working within it as being to blame and made it personal, rather than acknowledging that years of funding cuts have led to it being on its knees – just like education.

And don't dear me. It's patronising.

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:46

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:28

No dear, I'm just hacked off to the back teeth of people not doing what they are paid by the government to do. If you read back through that thread you will see the utter shit shows that caused me to form that opinion. I'm taking it you've never had to sell your family home to pay for medical treatment because of you don't you'll end up in a wheelchair? Nope, didn't think as much. The NHS is similarly full of people wanting more money when there's little value for money shown already, and many many NHS employees would have been sacked long ago if they worked in the private sector. I can actually think of a few teachers like that actually. Tory yes, troll no, I've been on Mumsnet for years!

I did read the rest of the thread actually and I agree with much of it - the NHS is a lottery and much of it isn't fit for purpose. But once again you attacked the people working within it as being to blame and made it personal, rather than acknowledging that years of funding cuts have led to it being on its knees – just like education.

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 16:45

@TheSnootiestFox but that's the point. I have read the thread and actually not only do you start throwing insults around first, you do not once - say let's agree to disagree.

The thing is your entitled to your opinion, but I have yet to hear what you would propose as a actual solution. Which you have ignored repeatedly and several posters have asked.

If your advising local government, then I would hope you had a solution to the proposed issues place in front of you re recruitment ?

The only thing that would surprise me is a actual answer that doesn't say something in the same vein of "stop whinging and do your job you leftie wokiest" or ignoring the question completely.

Like actual answer. I really do hope the government is having some actual advice on the matter, because I can well believe that just as many of your responses so far diversion seems to be the only response.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:39

Saywhatevernow · 01/07/2023 16:38

That’s how the tone is coming across - thoroughly unpleasant too.

Fortunately, I can live with your opinion of me.

Saywhatevernow · 01/07/2023 16:38

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:22

Hmm. I've just come across TSF on a thread about whether we can rely on the NHS any longer and her response to that was to sack staff for doing their jobs badly. And now she's popped up on this saying all teachers are shit. I'm starting to wonder if she's not a genuine poster but a Tory troll hijacking threads about public bodies with inflammatory statements and personal digs designed to cause offence.

That’s how the tone is coming across - thoroughly unpleasant too.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:38

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 16:24

@TheSnootiestFox hold on.

I'm ND (not that it matters and not that anyone would have known since you and I have just posted have posted this)

But you were literally making comments to another poster implying they were a bad teacher (based on their posts on MN), you have thrown insults around, and names and when people have called you out, you cry bullying. People ar

You haven't engaged with any type of debate other than "I'm right your all wrong" and have avoid every question posed to you re what you think the solution is to solving the teaching crisis ?

Being ND doesn't mean you can't be called out as a bully. But since I am ND I can.

Also as a teacher with years worth of experience- reflection would have been part of your skill set. Have you reflected that any part of you is accountable to what happened then and now ? No ... 🙄

Well, I'm sure you'll not be surprised to learn that if someone attacks me, and there has been page after page after page of posters doing so, I am not going to sit by and be insulted, called names, frequently told I don't know what I'm talking about when actually I'm very much clued up. Currently I'm paid to be clued up and advise local government accordingly. So I will argue my case. The trouble is everyone thinks they're right. But instead of saying ' I don't agree, we'll have to agree to differ' I was frequently told I knew nothing and I was just a 'snotty parent' trying to insult teachers. It's clearly OK for lots of people to insult me but I can't retaliate - and that's called bullying. I do hope that clarifies the situation somewhat!

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:31

lifeissweet · 01/07/2023 16:18

That all sounds like another local problem to you, to be honest. Many schools don't operate like that.

As I say, I teach in around 40 different schools and the management around those issues are different in each depending on the culture of the leadership.

The leadership is influenced by what Ofsted want to see, what the parents want and what ever the DfE agenda is.

You seem to have a problem with the way schools are lead and I'm not really in disagreement about that in itself. I just think the mechanisms that cause that are ALSO not down to ordinary classroom teachers, who have to follow the policies and procedures in place or be fired.

I could show you a number of schools who foster fabulous relationships with their families. I would happily take you round them if you wanted to see.

Yet they are facing the exact same problems with recruitment and retention of staff, with poor SEN provision and falling-down buildings.

'Just improve relationships and behaviour' is an outcome, not really a solution.

What is then, @lifeissweet? Genuine question, what is the solution?

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 16:28

BookLover7777 · 01/07/2023 16:22

Hmm. I've just come across TSF on a thread about whether we can rely on the NHS any longer and her response to that was to sack staff for doing their jobs badly. And now she's popped up on this saying all teachers are shit. I'm starting to wonder if she's not a genuine poster but a Tory troll hijacking threads about public bodies with inflammatory statements and personal digs designed to cause offence.

No dear, I'm just hacked off to the back teeth of people not doing what they are paid by the government to do. If you read back through that thread you will see the utter shit shows that caused me to form that opinion. I'm taking it you've never had to sell your family home to pay for medical treatment because of you don't you'll end up in a wheelchair? Nope, didn't think as much. The NHS is similarly full of people wanting more money when there's little value for money shown already, and many many NHS employees would have been sacked long ago if they worked in the private sector. I can actually think of a few teachers like that actually. Tory yes, troll no, I've been on Mumsnet for years!

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 16:24

Ignore the typo - hopefully you all get the gist