Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike... what will actually happen in end?!

382 replies

SpringPop · 28/06/2023 18:55

My school is striking again next week with others that have teachers from the particular union.

All that is happening is parents are getting massively angry. Kids are missing out. I've used so much holiday on strike days as I have multiple children. I know my anger should not be directed to school but exactly where can I direct it to? I'm pretty sure my MP wouldn't care. He's completely useless.

The government don't seem to care.

I personally think something needs to change in that profession and funding in my area is shocking! It's probably not attracting the best people to the profession and certainly is driving people away.

However, am I right in thinking rishi and co don't care?! Teachers could do 5, 10, 100 days and it seems they won't budge right?

Parents don't seem to care or get angry enough, short of tweeting about it or writing to MP. It isn't really enough to get this resolved.

How do you think this situation will end?

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 29/06/2023 22:59

Anyone who thinks they can say teachers don’t get paid enough. Come as. Be one for a day. What a joke.

??

SpringPop · 29/06/2023 22:48

There's some interesting thoughts here.

I actually considered being a teacher at one point. I have a science degree and have worked in private sector for years. Pay is decent but job security at moment is poor. I've already been made redundant this year and current job is looking a bit dodgy. It's really not making me happy either and I like the idea of making a difference and helping others. Pension is crap. Very little holiday.

The main thing that put me off teaching was:

  1. the training - I can't drive and live far from good transport so getting around to uni or different schools would be a nightmare! I have kids now myself and couldn't spend hours travelling.

  2. teachers saying "don't do it"

  3. I'm a bit put off that 90% of job would be fighting fires and dealing with problem parents, problem pupils, behaviour, mental health issues, crappy headteachers, OFSTED etc. etc.

OP posts:
Abbimae · 29/06/2023 21:08

Anyone who thinks they can say teachers don’t get paid enough. Come as. Be one for a day. What a joke.

Philandbill · 29/06/2023 21:01

I'd go back now in a heartbeat as financially I'd be much better off plus I actually liked the job, but nobody wants to employ a 50 year old it would appear! @TheSnootiestFox Have you actually tried? Plenty of jobs going in my area and I know several fifty plus year olds who have been snapped up by schools.
I've been teaching for over thirty years and education is on its knees. Recruitment is a huge issue, and there's a reason for that, but there are some experienced teachers who are sticking it out because we believe we have something to offer to pupils. I work sixty hours every week and yes, I am posting on an internet forum now, because having been non-stop all day in school from 7.15 this morning until 7.20 this evening I think some down time is justified. I think your criticism of @noblegiraffe daring to post on an internet forum is appalling. Easy to sound off when you are not now actually walking the walk....

Fairislefandango · 29/06/2023 20:59

I repeat, teachers are not badly paid. Therefore no, I don't think we need to pay more for teachers.

Well they are very clearly not paid enough to attract enough people to the profession or make them stay in it, are they?
It's naïve to argue about whether it's the pay or the conditions/workload. The main problem is the latter, but more people might be more inclined to tolerate the serious drawbacks of a career in teaching if you paid them more.

Gytgyt · 29/06/2023 20:40

babbscrabbs · 29/06/2023 13:33

I would be VERY interested to see attendance numbers since the strikes started. I'd say 80% of parents I've spoken to have become more lax about attendance due to the strikes.

Not the working parents I know. School would call you at my school.

Shinyandnew1 · 29/06/2023 18:55

If I didn’t need to bring in a wage to pay the bills/mortgage, I wouldn’t be working. Is that an ok attitude to have if you work in an office/shop/WFH, but not if you are a teacher?

neverbeenskiing · 29/06/2023 18:21

Education during Covid was an absolute shit show, lessons not put online when they were promised, work not assessed, teachers refusing to go into schools once they reopened etc

This is a massive generalisation. None of these things happened at my school, or the school my kids go to, or any my friends and family members kids schools. I'm sorry if your kids had a bad experience during that covid but that doesn't mean that all Teachers deserve to be shafted on pay and schools have their budgets decimated even further.

neverbeenskiing · 29/06/2023 18:17

If you're just there for the money, you're in the wrong job anyway.

This is such a lazy, inane argument. It is possible to care about two things simultaneously. Teachers can be passionate about the job and care about the kids, but still be worried about how they're going to cope with massive increases in their utility bills, childcare fees, rent or mortgage payments.

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 18:17

Bullying from leadership has come up plenty of times as an issue in teacher retention. Maybe take note?

Why do you think I should take note?

neverbeenskiing · 29/06/2023 18:11

GreenwichOrTwicks · 29/06/2023 15:33

It is completely illogical for teachers on here to say that they are striking about pay only because that is all they are allowed to strike for, but actually the issue is not about pay….
And then they say the pay is not enough to recruit or retain decent teachers.
How can you resolve a dispute of you pretend it’s about something else?
No wonder people have lost patience and sympathy.

Nobody is pretending. The issue of pay is very much interlinked with the other issues in Education staff are concerned about. The problem is that any rise in pay that has been offered so far is expected to come out of schools existing budgets, which the Government have cut year on year for over a decade. Schools are skint, our business manager was in tears when we got the last electricity bill. They don't know how they're going to find the money for these pay rises, in my school TA's who are leaving aren't being replaced. But those that remain are struggling with the COL and this contributes to the crisis in recruitment and retention. So Teachers and Support staff are asking for a fully funded pay rise that will address genuine concerns about the COL crisis, and help to slow the tide of experienced staff that are leaving, without further decimating our already woefully inadequate budgets to the detriment of children.

0021andabit · 29/06/2023 17:47

Teachers are massively under paid for what is expected of them, in terms of hours but also responsibilities- with the decimation of social services they’ve become the safety net for so many vulnerable children. State schools are massively underfunded. I have 3 school aged children & of course the strikes are a massive pain but I don’t see what choice teachers have. I know lots of teachers (consequence of an English degree!) & so many have either left the profession or gone into teaching in private schools in the hope of better conditions. Genuinely worrying for the future of education. Roll on a general election & hopefully some kind of solution.

TheSnootiestFox · 29/06/2023 17:40

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 17:19

I repeat, teachers are not badly paid. Therefore no, I don't think we need to pay more for teachers.

How do you propose tackling the extreme shortage of teachers and enticing the graduates who can earn lots more elsewhere into the classroom?

The basics of teaching remain the same whatever.

The fact that you don’t have a clue what I’m talking about when I say your experience is hideously out of date says it all.

Are you sure it's not your attitude causing you to struggle for staff?

Yes. There has been extensive research and a current parliamentary inquiry into why we, as a country, cannot recruit and retain teachers and my attitude has not come up once.

Bullying from leadership has come up plenty of times as an issue in teacher retention. Maybe take note?

If you're just there for the money, you're in the wrong job anyway. Graduates that don't consider teaching their vocation need to toddle off to banking or accountancy or wherever because it is bloody hard and you need to understand it to do it properly.

Education during Covid was an absolute shit show, lessons not put online when they were promised, work not assessed, teachers refusing to go into schools once they reopened etc and it has never recovered. Yet here you are making all sorts of demands on the government so by default me as a taxpayer, when the teaching profession didn't keep it's side of the deal during Covid and so many kids suffered long term consequences as a result. Your Unions are seriously having a laugh if they think that parents are supportive of you now!

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 17:19

I repeat, teachers are not badly paid. Therefore no, I don't think we need to pay more for teachers.

How do you propose tackling the extreme shortage of teachers and enticing the graduates who can earn lots more elsewhere into the classroom?

The basics of teaching remain the same whatever.

The fact that you don’t have a clue what I’m talking about when I say your experience is hideously out of date says it all.

Are you sure it's not your attitude causing you to struggle for staff?

Yes. There has been extensive research and a current parliamentary inquiry into why we, as a country, cannot recruit and retain teachers and my attitude has not come up once.

TheSnootiestFox · 29/06/2023 17:08

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 16:56

Yes, it's not like I have two school age children and see what they put up with in terms of teacher quality,

And you don't think that perhaps if you want better quality teachers perhaps we might need to pay more?

some of their teachers are as fit for for the job as you sound

I still know what makes a good teacher

Are you sure, because apparently you think that how someone posts on an internet forum in their free time is somehow an indicator of how they are in the classroom.

I didn't suddenly unlearn my training and 15 years in a classroom.

No but your experience of the classroom is hideously out of date.

Anyone who hasn't taught since covid can't really comment with any great insight, tbh.

I repeat, teachers are not badly paid. Therefore no, I don't think we need to pay more for teachers.

I'm amazed that you have any time to comment on an Internet forum actually, given how overworked you all claim to be these days.

The basics of teaching remain the same whatever. The basic principle of standing up in front of 30 kids and delivering a subject you're passionate about doesn't change. And yes, the assessment etc will have changed since I left but my experience as a parent of a Year 10 and a Year 8 is current and I know what I see isn't great.

Are you sure it's not your attitude causing you to struggle for staff?

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 16:56

Yes, it's not like I have two school age children and see what they put up with in terms of teacher quality,

And you don't think that perhaps if you want better quality teachers perhaps we might need to pay more?

some of their teachers are as fit for for the job as you sound

I still know what makes a good teacher

Are you sure, because apparently you think that how someone posts on an internet forum in their free time is somehow an indicator of how they are in the classroom.

I didn't suddenly unlearn my training and 15 years in a classroom.

No but your experience of the classroom is hideously out of date.

Anyone who hasn't taught since covid can't really comment with any great insight, tbh.

Shinyandnew1 · 29/06/2023 16:55

playing cowboys and Indians with the education of the next generation isn't it, I'm afraid!

Perhaps the education secretary should start actually talking to teachers and sorting the whole mess out then.

TheSnootiestFox · 29/06/2023 16:50

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 16:25

Well given that we've had to put anyone with a pulse in front of our DT classes, perhaps you should try again.

And then you'd be able to comment on the current situation in teaching from a position of experience.

Yes, it's not like I have two school age children and see what they put up with in terms of teacher quality, some of their teachers are as fit for for the job as you sound 🙄 Of course I can speak from experience, I didn't suddenly unlearn my training and 15 years in a classroom. I still know what makes a good teacher and playing cowboys and Indians with the education of the next generation isn't it, I'm afraid!

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 16:25

TheSnootiestFox · 29/06/2023 15:28

The nastiness going on with my two neurodivergent then primary school aged sons was far more pressing. I'd go back now in a heartbeat as financially I'd be much better off plus I actually liked the job, but nobody wants to employ a 50 year old it would appear!

Well given that we've had to put anyone with a pulse in front of our DT classes, perhaps you should try again.

And then you'd be able to comment on the current situation in teaching from a position of experience.

BoohooWoohoo · 29/06/2023 15:38

I think that the government are happy for the current situation to continue until the GE next year.

Come September the other teaching unions, support staff and heads may be joining the striking too. I don't think that people are angry enough for the government to act yet. Not everyone had kids in state schools so the private school educating people on power are happy to wait it out and increase the difference between the 2 sectors.

Zebedee55 · 29/06/2023 15:34

What will happen? The government will ignore it, knowing that, sooner or later, it will run out of steam. Like the nurses strike.

GreenwichOrTwicks · 29/06/2023 15:33

It is completely illogical for teachers on here to say that they are striking about pay only because that is all they are allowed to strike for, but actually the issue is not about pay….
And then they say the pay is not enough to recruit or retain decent teachers.
How can you resolve a dispute of you pretend it’s about something else?
No wonder people have lost patience and sympathy.

TheSnootiestFox · 29/06/2023 15:28

noblegiraffe · 29/06/2023 13:47

Nasty is disruptiing the education of thousands of kids that have already suffered so much through Covid

There is a massive shortage of D&T teachers. Kids at my school have basically had to teach themselves their GCSE due to no qualified teacher being available.

Do you consider it nasty that you fucked off out of teaching and left those kids up shit creek for far longer than a few days?

The nastiness going on with my two neurodivergent then primary school aged sons was far more pressing. I'd go back now in a heartbeat as financially I'd be much better off plus I actually liked the job, but nobody wants to employ a 50 year old it would appear!

ichundich · 29/06/2023 14:55

babbscrabbs · 29/06/2023 13:30

Thing is, school will be even more shit and stop to function unless the problems including pay are sorted. Children won't have much to "miss out" on if there are no bloody teachers!

Our school has shut to ALL pupils every strike day. Secretly I'm quite happy to have the extra time off with the children.

You sound very privileged. Most people will have to work throughout the teacher strikes, which means the children are left to their own devices / get dumped in front of screens yet again.

OhmygodDont · 29/06/2023 14:35

I joke that my youngest school might not even open come September. It’s got just under 20 known members of staff leaving. Apparently we shouldn’t worry. Aha

Thankfully my older two’s school/future school seem to be ok, one a specialist stem school.

I fully back that teachers should get a raise, that it should be fully funded, however as a parent who’s never taken her children out of school for a holiday because every day is so so important I have actually booked a holiday a because well if a strike can happen what feels like every month for a few days what’s a couple of days of me taking them out 😬

Fortunate I work from home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread