Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike... what will actually happen in end?!

382 replies

SpringPop · 28/06/2023 18:55

My school is striking again next week with others that have teachers from the particular union.

All that is happening is parents are getting massively angry. Kids are missing out. I've used so much holiday on strike days as I have multiple children. I know my anger should not be directed to school but exactly where can I direct it to? I'm pretty sure my MP wouldn't care. He's completely useless.

The government don't seem to care.

I personally think something needs to change in that profession and funding in my area is shocking! It's probably not attracting the best people to the profession and certainly is driving people away.

However, am I right in thinking rishi and co don't care?! Teachers could do 5, 10, 100 days and it seems they won't budge right?

Parents don't seem to care or get angry enough, short of tweeting about it or writing to MP. It isn't really enough to get this resolved.

How do you think this situation will end?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fairislefandango · 02/07/2023 07:59

I'm an MFL teacher and my school still teaches three languages, fortunately. Unusually, the students do all three in Y7, then drop to two in Y8 and have to take at least one for GCSE. We run A Level courses in all 3 (though often with pretty small classes). It is a grammar school though, but obviously that doesn't mean it has more money. We also have a full hour lunch break.

Piggywaspushed · 02/07/2023 07:50

Oh, that first paragraph sounds so familiar!! Laughably, people still refer to school 'lunch hours'. It's one of the biggest squeezes on our time since I started teaching - and it's no use for enrichment or extra curricular either, for those who want to put something on. It's just a treadmill, sadly. DH works in an independent school where they still have an hour and ten minutes for lunch. Sure, he finishes later but there is at least a point in the day to eat something properly, catch up with colleagues, read , go for a stroll, nip to the shop, have a cuppa.

cafesandbookshops · 02/07/2023 06:30

Something that has appeared a few times on this thread has been the reduction of languages offered at schools and the use of non qualified teachers. I was an MFL a teacher but left at Christmas as I couldn’t take the 60 hour weeks, getting up at 5.30 to read emails and work before getting to work, teaching five periods a day with ever decreasing breaks, meetings galore before and after school, running interventions for GCSE pupils who never turned up, constant rudeness, defiance and disrespect for my subject, the never ending re writing of schemes of work and
lesson plans, soul crushing levels of scrutiny and unrealistic data targets… the list goes on.

i started off as an enthusiastic Spanish teacher hoping to inspire pupils, become head of department, lead trips abroad etc etc and what I found was most pupils do not value my subject and even at GCSE level the ones who picked it often gave up when they realized they had to actually do some work. Many parents I called admitted they had told their kids to focus on other more important subjects and ultimately i paid the price by having to give up my time chasing up every piece of homework and substandard grade.

Now I’ve heard a non subject specialist who doesn’t speak Spanish is teaching my classes. No idea how and I find this upsetting on one hand but also this is what happens when you make teachers feel like crap and like their subject is worthless.

I may return if things change in the future but am currently retraining as a speech therapist in the hope of finding a job where I can make a difference and not be abused everyday. One can hope.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 21:27

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 21:15

They most definitely were a thing and I too was a teaching HOY. In academic year 2007/8 I was on a protected salary doing nothing as all our pastoral care was turned over to two pastoral managers (KS3 and KS4) and I ended up being appointed as Head of IAG/Citizenship/PSHEE instead. It sticks in my mind as I was pregnant when I interviewed for it!

Thinking about it now, that was when the rot set in for me as I was a D and T teacher with curriculum responsibility for another area (and taught it too) and when I came back from my second maternity leave I had a new curriculum leader who couldn't cope with the fact I was on the same TLR as him. Also hated women of a certain age, which was most of his department, and behaved appallingly to all of us. Nothing to do with being managed out because I was crap. Oh, happy days 😂

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 21:18

Possibly as an outcome then of the generally sound Teachers' Workload Agreement.

They were rare, and vanishingly rare in the late 90s to mid 2000s.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 21:15

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 21:10

I think I started teaching well before you. Non teaching HOYs definitely were not a thing. Ofsted was a very different beast.

I also was there. As a teaching HOY. Yes, New Labour introduced some dubious things but we didn't have free schools, huge MATs, the madness of data obsession in anything like the same way. The behaviour and uniform thing goes in circles. Most parents actually judge a school on the smartness of uniform. We have gone from blazers to ties and jumpers, to polo shirts to hoodies and back to ties and blazers.

Your education policies definitely don't sound like Tory ones.

They most definitely were a thing and I too was a teaching HOY. In academic year 2007/8 I was on a protected salary doing nothing as all our pastoral care was turned over to two pastoral managers (KS3 and KS4) and I ended up being appointed as Head of IAG/Citizenship/PSHEE instead. It sticks in my mind as I was pregnant when I interviewed for it!

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 21:10

I think I started teaching well before you. Non teaching HOYs definitely were not a thing. Ofsted was a very different beast.

I also was there. As a teaching HOY. Yes, New Labour introduced some dubious things but we didn't have free schools, huge MATs, the madness of data obsession in anything like the same way. The behaviour and uniform thing goes in circles. Most parents actually judge a school on the smartness of uniform. We have gone from blazers to ties and jumpers, to polo shirts to hoodies and back to ties and blazers.

Your education policies definitely don't sound like Tory ones.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 21:03

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 20:49

Nearly all of those good things happened under -oooh- a Labour government.

I can assure you they didn't. There was still Ofsted inspections, catering contracts, non teaching progress managers, ridiculous marking policies, glorified social work etc etc up until 2010 and I remember my first years at one particular school (2004 until about 2008 ish) being all about counting five stripes on a tie and removing make up. There was also if you recall, the whole diploma debacle. Which were a complete waste of money that sold a couple of cohorts down the river academically, I was there, remember!

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:55

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:37

No, I'm just baffled to see someone trying to position the Tories as caring about people going hungry.

I see you're making no attempt to answer my questions though. Again.

I'm not. I'm positioning me as caring about people going hungry. I just happen to be more politically aligned with Conservatism.

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 20:49

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 20:36

@TheSnootiestFox well to be fair actually I agree with all you have put.

Quite sensible in my view and I can't quite fathom why all of those things disappeared. That said my industry isn't education.

Should be interested to see if any other teachers agree. I suspect they might.

Nearly all of those good things happened under -oooh- a Labour government.

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:37

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:35

You really are spoiling for a fight today, aren't you?

No, I'm just baffled to see someone trying to position the Tories as caring about people going hungry.

I see you're making no attempt to answer my questions though. Again.

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 20:36

@TheSnootiestFox well to be fair actually I agree with all you have put.

Quite sensible in my view and I can't quite fathom why all of those things disappeared. That said my industry isn't education.

Should be interested to see if any other teachers agree. I suspect they might.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:35

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:34

Plus not all Tories think the same.

So with their massive majority they must have reduced child poverty, put food banks out of business and extended the FSM offering?

Is that what the Tories have done? With their massive majority?

You really are spoiling for a fight today, aren't you?

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:34

Plus not all Tories think the same.

So with their massive majority they must have reduced child poverty, put food banks out of business and extended the FSM offering?

Is that what the Tories have done? With their massive majority?

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:29

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:26

Like when the Tories voted not to extend FSM into the holidays during covid and kept having to backtrack because of Marcus Rashford?

Or the fact that they haven't raised the FSM threshold since 2017 despite inflation?

Or that their policies have led to a massive increase in food bank usage?

What is it about the Tories that makes you think they really care about feeding hungry people?

I said desirable not mandatory. Plus not all Tories think the same. I'm sure that I have different taste in curtains from Rishi too!

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 20:26

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:21

Feeding hungry people is desirable cross party I think you'll find 🙄

Like when the Tories voted not to extend FSM into the holidays during covid and kept having to backtrack because of Marcus Rashford?

Or the fact that they haven't raised the FSM threshold since 2017 despite inflation?

Or that their policies have led to a massive increase in food bank usage?

What is it about the Tories that makes you think they really care about feeding hungry people?

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 20:22

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:21

Feeding hungry people is desirable cross party I think you'll find 🙄

Not in my experience.

Anti poverty suggests campaigning.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:21

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 19:07

I'd be fascinated to know what charity aligns with this values and beliefs. Specifically an anti poverty one.

Feeding hungry people is desirable cross party I think you'll find 🙄

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 20:07

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 19:38

@TheSnootiestFox you haven't answered the question which is

What would you do about the recruitment crisis in teaching ?

You have told us that you don't think teachers need a pay rise, your political views and money doesn't grow on trees ect

Let's not be pedantic about things. The thing is you won't address this question because you can't.

It's like having a debate about summer holidays abroad and you toodling along saying you hate cars and all car users.

Anyway as I said your response is not surprising or even slightly enlightening 🤷‍♀️

OK, if I must, I would suspend Ofsted inspections for at least 12 months. That would free up HMI to go into schools to act as a bit of a school improvement service. I would prescribe a marking policy that all state schools must adopt, that was more in line with what we did when I first started teaching rather than 3 marks with silly coloured pens etc. The NHS needs to pull its weight re CAMHS and ASD/ADHD and schools would go back to being educational establishments and not an extension of social services, at least in the short term. I'd take school catering back in house and make sure all kids have a decent breakfast and lunch and if I could these would be universally free. Exams would cease to be the be all and end all and kids would be encouraged to get the best grade they can without anybody worrying about their value added. I'd remove performance related pay and teachers would progress up the scale as per the old days. Then noone is disadvantaged by taking on a challenging class. I'd try and reduce class sizes a bit but obviously if there's teacher shortages that would be tricky. As long as kids are cleanish and tidyish uniforms could come from anywhere and not have to be an exact length or have an exact logo. And teachers would not waste time chasing the wrong trousers etc but would teach. And probably controversially but I'd bring back old fashioned teaching heads of year but with a decent timetable adjustment. Discipline started to go downhill when glorified admin managers started behaviour managing kids. I like the idea earlier of all teachers having an MSc. but this would be CPD for a few years and fully funded. And that's just off the top of my head.....

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 19:56

I give up! Well, not literally, I love my job, the team I work with and the kids. I give up trying to fight for education. I have so much respect for noblegiraffe she is very knowledgeable. I just can’t lose pay and pension contributions fighting a flight that I think is lost.

I'm not convinced all is lost. The DfE recommended 3% to the independent pay review body. Then they offered us 4.5% plus £1000 mostly unfunded BUT tried to work really hard to show that it was actually funded because they acknowledged that pay rises being unfunded is actually a massive issue.

Now the independent pay review body has said 'look, everything in teaching is on fire, we need to increase pay more than the government would like in order sort it out' and suggested 6.5%.

The government are talking about rejecting the independent pay review recommendations BUT it means it's going to be far harder for them to argue that whatever they do offer is fair or reasonable. And if it's unfunded, they can't justify that either, given the arguments they made for the 4.5% being funded.

Progress is being made.

noblegiraffe · 01/07/2023 19:49

Just because I'm a Tory doesn't mean that I want to see people starve and it saddens me beyond belief to see people that are busting a gut to do their best struggling.

Do you not see the link between the increase in people, particularly children, living in poverty, and the Tory policies that put them there?

I'm starting to see a pattern.

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 19:38

@TheSnootiestFox you haven't answered the question which is

What would you do about the recruitment crisis in teaching ?

You have told us that you don't think teachers need a pay rise, your political views and money doesn't grow on trees ect

Let's not be pedantic about things. The thing is you won't address this question because you can't.

It's like having a debate about summer holidays abroad and you toodling along saying you hate cars and all car users.

Anyway as I said your response is not surprising or even slightly enlightening 🤷‍♀️

Piggywaspushed · 01/07/2023 19:07

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 18:21

Your point is? I am politically aligned with the Conservatives because I believe in family, marriage, education, working hard to support said family and providing for yourself as far as possible, rather than sitting back and expecting state hand outs for everything. Too many people have just done what they want, taken no responsibility for their actions and expected the state to pick up the mess and that why we're in the mess we're in. Just because I'm a Tory doesn't mean that I want to see people starve and it saddens me beyond belief to see people that are busting a gut to do their best struggling. That's why I did what I did for a few years. Doesn't need a rude comment 🙄 and apparently I'm the one that doesn't come across well 🤣

I'd be fascinated to know what charity aligns with this values and beliefs. Specifically an anti poverty one.

TheSnootiestFox · 01/07/2023 18:53

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 18:49

@TheSnootiestFox see that's exactly what I mean.

You have been asked this question several times by other posters, and me twice and you seem to have still not answered the question (undoubtedly it will be all our faults rather than the actual answer) I suspect because you don't have one ?

You can only ignore outright for so long before it looks like what it is (name calling, outrage, ect) actually a complete diversion.

As I said previously I wasn't expecting a answer although always love to be proven wrong. I don't give a fig who or what you vote for frankly.

But like the government is doing right now which is flat out refusing to engage with talks, it doesn't solve the problem and hoping it goes away. Bit like your doing with this question.

I've written chapter and verse a couple of times today. It's evening, I'm tired, I've said what I'd change more than once and I'm relaxing with a lovely big glass of wine. I refuse to be goaded further and if you don't like it, well I guess I'll just have to live with it 😁 Good evening.

namechangenacy · 01/07/2023 18:49

@TheSnootiestFox see that's exactly what I mean.

You have been asked this question several times by other posters, and me twice and you seem to have still not answered the question (undoubtedly it will be all our faults rather than the actual answer) I suspect because you don't have one ?

You can only ignore outright for so long before it looks like what it is (name calling, outrage, ect) actually a complete diversion.

As I said previously I wasn't expecting a answer although always love to be proven wrong. I don't give a fig who or what you vote for frankly.

But like the government is doing right now which is flat out refusing to engage with talks, it doesn't solve the problem and hoping it goes away. Bit like your doing with this question.

Swipe left for the next trending thread