Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take out health and critical illness insurance?

34 replies

FrenesiGates · 28/06/2023 17:31

I'm nearing 40 and am getting increasingly worried about what would happen if I were to get seriously ill (no foundation for this, just general worries about getting older!) I am thinking about health insurance and critical illness insurance but have no idea where to start and what to look for... any advice? Is health insurance worth it in the UK with the NHS? I keep hearing different things. It also seems very expensive from what I've seen and I don't have lots of disposable income, but am scared of getting ill and having to deal with illness and financial worries. Thank you!

OP posts:
Appleofmyeye2023 · 04/07/2023 18:13

The reasons it’s so expensive for you is

  1. you’re female - need morecstuff
  2. your approaching 40 , it’ll keep going up at 50, 60 etc- and oddly enough (🤦‍♀️) the older you are the more likely you’ll need it

my cover is free from my company, but I do pay tax benefit in kind on it. Most private care is covered by people in company schemes- not private individuals , and in USA most people’s medical cover is also through their employer. This works out cheaper per person as costs Of treatment are spread right across the workforce- in effect the young subsidise the older groups. otherwise private medical care would be unaffordable to companies as well.

the other way to fund it is to pay as you go/ need and create your own savings into your own ISA , that way you can use it if and when you need it. Search on line for typical costs of procedures or protocols you’ll probably most want to use, and that’ll give you better option. Also, think about a separate pension pot - you can take it at 55 if needed ( realistically more likely you’d need treatment for something serious after 55 at youngest) , or wait as long as 75, and that way government pension tax relief contributes 👍.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 04/07/2023 18:01

If you mean is private health care worth it, it depends what for imho

most private hospitals do not have emergency facilities- if you have a bad reaction to an GA, or have a stroke or cardio event while in their care they’ll have to call 999 effectively. Any serious consequences of care going wrong - also picked up by nhs. Personally if I’m having serious surgery I’d rather not risk that ambulance transfer time.

the consultants in private hospitals are mostly either retired or nhs workers, who are doing private work part time. Worse case they’re doing it after full shift rotas at nhs. So, again prefer not to take my chances on significant stuff with someone who is in 60s or 70s and may not be trained on latest techniques, or some knackered tired person at the end of a long working week 🤷🏼‍♀️

so, it’s probably not surprising then that I’ve had more op’s and procedures going a bit wrong, or not working under private (BUPA scheme for over 30 years with my employer) than I ever have had with nhs. I’ve had 12 op’s and numerous procedures in my life so not a small sample size comparison . Ok, I’ve not had serious stuff go wrong, but infections, procedures just not working etc,

I avoid private for anything in way of surgery now - if it can wait on nhs list so be it. But, admittedly I’ve not had to face long list for say hip replacement. But I’d sure be happier to wait it out on nhs for a good time, than jump straight to private option

what private cover is brilliant for is testing, scans and physio. A first port of call to get a diagnosis for straight forward stuff, and to get outpatient treatment like physio or ongoing minor treatment like getting my ears microsyringed once in a while due to recurrent bouts of ear ache. All the standard out patient stuff.

they’re also good with mental health issues, quick access to counselling and, at a push for serious issues even to psychotherapy.

but you only get an allowance per year .so, you have to use carefully. There are allowances for outpatient, for scans and then for each procedure, but the outpatient can add up,quickly and limit how long you can get treatment for.

the costs charged at cost price ( you get to see invoice even if bills settled directly through insurance) will make your eyes water - god forbid nhs collapse s and you can see why in USA, medical bills literally bankrupt people

But it’s just my opinion

FrenesiGates · 04/07/2023 17:38

@AmandaHoldensLips I'm so sorry you and your father went through this... I'm hearing a lot of horror stories about this kind of thing at the moment with the NHS and it's fairly terrifying. I can't imagine anything worse than not getting the care you need and the consequences that might have. I have now taken out critical illness insurance (I went with Vitality) but am also looking at private health insurance. It's so expensive though and seems extortionate to get worthwhile cover that would ... Do you mind me asking who you went with and how much you pay monthly for health insurance?

OP posts:
AmandaHoldensLips · 29/06/2023 17:48

We took out private health insurance after I saw the way my father was (not) treated in hospital. It was utterly shocking. The NHS is a total shit show. The insurance is expensive but I would rather go without other things than be left to rot in a hospital corridor.

FrenesiGates · 29/06/2023 17:39

@Loverofoxbowlakes I don't have DC (and unfortunately likely won't due to infertility). I'm more concerned about mitigating any financial stresses while ill, especially as I work freelance.

@Toffeesgirl thank you for sharing your experience. It definitely seems like it was very worthwhile for you, and these are the kinds of things I worry about. I'm glad that it was there to support you! May I ask what kind of insurance / who you went with?

@sunflowerdaisyrose thank you for sharing. could I ask what kind of critical insurance cover you did have?

@Shopper727 this is exactly the kind of thing I'm worried about. I work freelance and so would have no financial security if I were ill – I'd be entirely relying on DP / family, which I don't want to do. I'm also talking to DP about him getting the same kind of insurance as he is also self-employed. I'm so glad to hear your sister is better now, and all the best to your SIL.

Does anyone have any recommendations for critical illness cover?

OP posts:
Shopper727 · 28/06/2023 18:03

My sister had life insurance etc 12 years ago at 30 something when she had thyroid cancer and they bought a new house. She’s been fine since but thankfully she was covered. Sil just diagnosed with breast cancer at 44 sorting her finances at the moment. Her job is temporary too so no security for her it’s terrifying to worry about money when you’re having treatment and feeling dreadful.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 28/06/2023 17:59

I had cancer and was grateful for mine too. We hadn't taken out as much critical illness as it was expensive but was still hugely beneficial. Getting the treatment quicker and in more comfort was also good. We still pay for health insurance (though it excludes the sort of cancer I had) and it is expensive but both worth it I think. I have a separate life insurance policy too.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 28/06/2023 17:57

Do you have dc or other dependents op?

You are far more likely to need critical illness cover than life insurance (during the term of a mortgage, which is the usual prompt for taking cover). The former will protect YOU financially if you are unable to work due to diagnosis of a number of conditions, the latter will support your dependents in the event of your death.

Health insurance is a bit of a luxury and cannot beat the nhs for cancer pathway/treatment (to quote my dh's private healthcare provider after his recent diagnosis 'we have a suite in the oncology wing (of the local nhs cancer) but all it means is you get tea in a nicer mug and a carpet in the waiting room, everything else is NHS) and it can be incredibly expensive AND at 40 you might face exclusions if you have ever had any sort of health investigations.

Toffeesgirl · 28/06/2023 17:44

I had both when I was diagnosed with breast cancer 10 years ago.

The critical illness cover was enough to pay off our excising mortgage which was a massive weight off our shoulders at the time (and since of course).

Although cancer care is (maybe was due to the effects of covid) very good on the NHS, my private cover gave me options in my treatment which I wouldn't have had on the NHS.

since, and totally unrelated, I've had 2 other major surgeries privately. One was my gallbladder removed. I initially went to my GP and he referred me on the NHS as I was having frequent gallbladder attacks. I then decided to go privately and had all the pre assessments and was actually back at work having had the gallbladder removed, by the time the initial NHS appointment came through.

All this was pre-covid and the affect that has had on the NHS.

for our family, we scrimp and save and do without other things to keep it. On the other hand, DH has paid out every month too and never (touch wood) had to use it.