Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take out health and critical illness insurance?

34 replies

FrenesiGates · 28/06/2023 17:31

I'm nearing 40 and am getting increasingly worried about what would happen if I were to get seriously ill (no foundation for this, just general worries about getting older!) I am thinking about health insurance and critical illness insurance but have no idea where to start and what to look for... any advice? Is health insurance worth it in the UK with the NHS? I keep hearing different things. It also seems very expensive from what I've seen and I don't have lots of disposable income, but am scared of getting ill and having to deal with illness and financial worries. Thank you!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedDoughnut · 07/07/2023 09:46

I was coming to the thread to mention Beneden. Not so much medical insurance but possibly a useful safety net?

Roselilly36 · 07/07/2023 06:38

We have private health insurance via Benenden, been members for over 25 years, sensible premiums, our whole family is covered. We have all claimed over the years, children have seen dermatologist, ENT consultants, paediatric gastroenterologist, and Ed psych. I had my MS diagnosis funded by them. And my gallbladder surgery. Everything we have ever needed they have authorised.

Grumpy101 · 06/07/2023 22:26

Not sure on critical illness insurance but definitely yes to the private health insurance. I left the UK 2 years ago now, but in my 15 years prior I always had private health insurance. It was useful, I got treatment very quickly for various things, I got an MRI within 2 days of an injury, I got access to great surgeons etc. I never ended up using the NHS because every time I needed something it was 2 weeks wait just for an initial appointment!

I convinced my mum to get private insurance and she relatively soon after that got thyroid cancer and received excellent and quick care.

When we go back to the UK, we are definitely taking private health insurance again.

mauveiscurious · 06/07/2023 21:44

Plans will pay out if you have disclosed your medical history, smoking or vaping history.

Claims are honoured if you have the condition like any insurance.

The benefits are free of taxation. It's the most valuable investment of your life and lifestyle

PermanentTemporary · 06/07/2023 21:44

I'm glad someone mentioned income protection insurance, that's what I went for in the end. But no idea if it's right for you - I agree 100% with getting a broker.

Look very very carefully at Vitality before you go with them. They are cheaper but they have a lot of restrictions, like having to keep to a particular weight. I decided I couldn't be sure of that.

FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:36

@mauvish I did consider income protection as I work freelance but felt that the serious / critical illness cover was more suitable – I have no idea if that was the right decision or not tbh!

OP posts:
FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:34

@MoonMum90 thank you for the names! I'll reach out

OP posts:
mauvish · 06/07/2023 21:24

Have you considered getting income protection insurance rathan than critical illness? The latter often has so many exclusion clauses that claims can be difficult, but the former simply pays out if you can't work through illhealth (there will still
be the usual exclusions of course).

swg1 · 06/07/2023 21:19

I suspect that having a broker pays off when you need to make a claim. I would have struggled to fill that amount of forms in myself and made mistakes but I was very clearly and carefully talked through them.

MoonMum90 · 06/07/2023 21:17

I say this on every thread about this subject but definitely use a broker and I mean a qualified advice giving in your best interest broker

MmB
Willis towers Watson
Premier choice
IHC are a few I would recommend

FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:15

@Swg I haven't looked at AIG Life, but will look into them too! I'm also thinking of using a broker – there's just too many options and it's all quite confusing to know what you need etc.

OP posts:
FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:14

@AmandaHoldensLips I'm looking at Bupa and Vitality – and thinking about maybe speaking to a broker (I have no idea if it's better to go through a broker or go direct!)

OP posts:
FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:13

@MissyB1 I'm so sorry you had to fight for what you were owed at such a stressful time – that sounds awful. But, I'm glad it's been resolved and it sounds like it made a big difference when it came through. I hope your DH is doing well.

OP posts:
FrenesiGates · 06/07/2023 21:12

@Appleofmyeye2023 I've just seen all your replies – thank you so much for taking the time to reply with so much useful information! I'm going to go through it all carefully and make some decisions next week. I have already taken out the serious / critical illness cover – and did go through a full (probably too full!) medical history (including for my parents) so they definitely have everything. I'm not covered for mental health as I'm currently on anti-depressants but I was expecting that.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 04/07/2023 20:24

Dh had critical illness cover, they fought tooth and nail not to pay out though when he was diagnosed with a brain tumour! 😡 We finally got the money out of them and it paid off the mortgage.

AmandaHoldensLips · 04/07/2023 20:19

@FrenesiGates we went with BUPA and it's hundreds per month. I now drive a really cheap car bought off ebay and have made all sorts of other economies too. Our health insurance is non-negotiable to me.

Kerplonker · 04/07/2023 19:30

A financial planner will be able to help you find the right policy. Different companies cover different conditions, so it’s important to be clear about what you are buying.
Vitality are a good value option, particularly if you are active - you get activity based discounts.
Critical illness cover is less expensive on a decreasing basis - the level of cover reduces as you pay off you mortgage. This can make it more affordable.
you can also consider Income Protection. This covers a % of your salary if you are unable to work because of your health. Income protection will usually cover mental health and back problems. These wouldn’t be covered under a critical illness cover.

Swg · 04/07/2023 19:14

Oh and if you want recommendations I was with AIG Life. I had a broker help me find cover which helped - he helped me with the forms which made me a lot more confident I hadn't missed anything. Whilst getting the consultant to fill out a form was awful once they had it they confirmed full pay out within a week and the money was in my bank days after that.

Swg · 04/07/2023 19:08

I have both and I needed them and used them when I was diagnosed with thyroid cancer last year.

Some things to be aware of:

People are correct when they say NHS cancer care is usually decent. However private insurance grants you a couple of things. It makes it a lot easier to change if the NHS gives you a consultant you don't gel with - and some of them can be awful. If you don't trust the person in charge of saving your life it's a problem.

The NHS is also sometimes not great at treating the side effects that result from cancer treatment. The NHS sorted my actual treatments, but I've been left with a couple of lifelong conditions that need careful management. The NHS consultant who did my operation decided I didn't need a specialist endocrinologist to handle this and I was in and out of hospital for a few months as my calcium levels roller coasters until I got a private referral. Since then I've been much more stable.

Critical illness cover is absolutely great when it pays out. The problem I had here was not with the company but that getting it to pay out meant a consultant filling in a form about my condition (same guy who decided I didn't need a specialist...). My consultant held onto my form for six months with shrugs of "Oh I'll get to it" "he's busy" and "..oh honestly I don't know when he'll get to it" from his secretary until I made a complaint through PALS and my MP - magically filled in within a week. Luckily I had savings to fall back on but I couldn't work within that time and as a single parent if I hadn't had savings we would hVe been utterly screwed. I also held bavk several times in making complaints about what was some really shoddy treatment because I was scared if I did that form would never happen - its a six figure sum and I could not afford to risk it. When I started researching I found out about other people who nearly turned down potentially life saving treatment because their consultant had just said they "didn't do those kind of forms". I was very polite and very conscious I was bugging people who were probably overworked to do extra admin but if I had the time again I'm pretty sure they were taking the piss and I should have complained sooner.

If I get life and critical illness insurance again it will be specialist and through a broker and have a ton of exclusions. They won't even look at me for any if them until October when I get another scan. It may still be worth doing however as my children will be covered by it - there's no way to cover minors seperately from a parent.

GarlicGrace · 04/07/2023 18:51

It's a long time ago now, and I'm still living the consequences. I had masses of cover and, when things went pear-shaped, was grateful that I could still pay my bills & mortgage. I also got counselling via BUPA to help me cope with the sudden reversal of fortunes.

However, I hadn't paid enough attention to the pages of tiny-print clauses. Before two years were up, every single policy had found a reason to stop paying out and to ban me from future cover unless I paid absurdly large fees, which of course I couldn't afford (and wouldn't be worthwhile if I could).

My illness wasn't defined as 'critical' so I never qualified for a large payment that could've stabilised my situation.

So - yes, it's worth having for a modicum of security BUT you must realise these firms are not there to look after you! They'll leap on any reason to deny claims, and to cease cover. They've foreseen most of these reasons, and you sign away those rights when you begin the contract.

If you really want to be covered, you need to have savings & investments that would fill the gaps in a worst-case scenario. Depending on your circumstances, it may be better to do that instead of taking insurance.

It's also true that private healthcare instantly defaults to NHS critical. This makes me very angry, ever since I realised an ambulance was on standby to take me to an NHS hospital when a BUPA surgery was taking too long. It was nice to be comfortable and solicitously cared for at the private facility, but wtf? Whoever signed that agreement on behalf of the NHS was a sucker! Or, probably more likely, being paid on the down-low.

@Appleofmyeye2023 made good points, imo.

Roselilly36 · 04/07/2023 18:43

Critical health insurance is wise, assuming you can afford the premiums, the rates have increased significantly, I had a small policy and it paid out very quickly when I was unexpectedly diagnosed with Multiple Sclerosis at 40.

DH also has critical illness and life insurance.

We also have private medical insurance for us and our family, claimed many times on that over the year, sadly.

ByTheSea · 04/07/2023 18:35

I was diagnosed with stage 4 breast cancer last year at 58 and just paid off my mortgage yesterday using my critical care insurance payment. I have been able to go part time at work now without a mortgage payment. If I really need to, I can retire comfortably. I am so glad I opted to get it.

I also get private health insurance through work. They pay me per diagnostic test and treatment I get on the NHS and at this point, there are no treatments they could provide that I'm not getting. I cannot fault the cancer care I'm receiving on the NHS.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 04/07/2023 18:24

Appleofmyeye2023 · 04/07/2023 18:13

The reasons it’s so expensive for you is

  1. you’re female - need morecstuff
  2. your approaching 40 , it’ll keep going up at 50, 60 etc- and oddly enough (🤦‍♀️) the older you are the more likely you’ll need it

my cover is free from my company, but I do pay tax benefit in kind on it. Most private care is covered by people in company schemes- not private individuals , and in USA most people’s medical cover is also through their employer. This works out cheaper per person as costs Of treatment are spread right across the workforce- in effect the young subsidise the older groups. otherwise private medical care would be unaffordable to companies as well.

the other way to fund it is to pay as you go/ need and create your own savings into your own ISA , that way you can use it if and when you need it. Search on line for typical costs of procedures or protocols you’ll probably most want to use, and that’ll give you better option. Also, think about a separate pension pot - you can take it at 55 if needed ( realistically more likely you’d need treatment for something serious after 55 at youngest) , or wait as long as 75, and that way government pension tax relief contributes 👍.

Sorry, should say, saving into separate pension pot, you can then take as your tax free lump sum if and when needed. As long as it’s less than 25% of your combined “ pots”:

Appleofmyeye2023 · 04/07/2023 18:18

Re critical health insurance- read the small print carefully. Numerous stories of people being refused payouts . Just like insurance for anything.
if they can find wriggle room out they will.
you will have to declare all historical conditions and illnesses, and if you’re having ANY test at the time, or waiting on results, no matter how minor, don’t think about applying until you’ve been given all clear.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 04/07/2023 18:16

I had cover with Legal and general and claim process was straightforward and they paid the claim quickly. My life cover is still with them. I will look into getting critical illness cover again soon as think I may be able to again.