Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the current vogue for allowing kids to be "bored" is a bit misguided

241 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 16:18

Have been thinking about this a lot recently, prompted by posts on here and things in the media. It's become very fashionable for people to talk about how important it is for children to be allowed to "be bored" sometimes.

I totally understand and support the principle of this: which is that overzealous scheduling and helicopter parenting is not great for many kids. I think there is a place for not having your entire life planned out from dawn to dusk and for learning to entertain yourself.

But in reality I think this "leave them to get bored" is often quite unworkable. Once kids get "bored" these days they invariably reach for screens. Now, obviously it's up to us as parents to manage this. But there's a limit to how much you can police this, short of removing all devices. It would be great if "being bored" always meant directing kids out to rough and tumble play in the hayfields or making dens in the living room or finger painting, but that usually isn't what it means. It either means screen time or it means getting into things they shouldn't. Stopping this happening means endless policing of what they do. So, forgive me but given the choice I'd rather my kid was doing an after-school club than playing four hours of Minecraft (sorry Minecraft) or watching TV or being bullied by me to be "creatively bored".

"Constructive" boredom as its preached is one of these lovely ideas (a bit like "free range" parenting) that's much much easier to achieve if you have a huge five-bedroom pile in the home counties than if you live in a cramped two bed flat (from which you also work). It's pretty unworkable for most parents and I'm starting to find it increasingly irritating when people parrot this as if it were a solution to all parenting dilemmas.

OP posts:
Whatkindofuckeryisthis · 29/06/2023 20:07

I think it means that entertaining them 24/7 means making a rod for your back. I did this with my 4.5 year old because lock down. He then struggled to play alone. Rather than give him something to do every minute or playing with him all the time, I leave him and let him get ‘bored’ so he has to get his toys out. Sure enough he sits chatting away with his toys after five minutes!

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 20:05

That said, there is currently a large box in the garden which is apparently more attractive than any screen right now.

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 20:03

TimeToMoveIt · 29/06/2023 19:55

No, I'm not micro managing them . I don't restrict screens either, they get board of them after a while and do something else. They are playing table tennis at the minute (without a table )

That's amazing! My kids were much less good at regulating themselves when it came to screens without those limits in place; now they have enough other things to be getting on with that they don't always reach for the screens in the allowable times but they definitely do need those limits in place right now.

NotmyRLname · 29/06/2023 19:56

I’ve only ever heard this idea coming from myself. There’s definitely not a fashion for it.. in fact I don’t think kids know the meaning of the word bored nowadays and judging from parents I see and hear they haven’t subscribed to this notion and are still carting tarquin and Winnie to trombone lessons and dance at every opportunity.

TimeToMoveIt · 29/06/2023 19:55

No, I'm not micro managing them . I don't restrict screens either, they get board of them after a while and do something else. They are playing table tennis at the minute (without a table )

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:53

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 19:45

But why would being ignored by adults and generally bored make them more able to entertain themselves with books or do the other activities?. When my children were younger I used to do those activities with them. It didn't mean they couldn't entertain themselves when older.

So... you gave them access to those things, suggested things that were available to them when they were bored, helped them explore things and develop skills, so that as they got older they had lots of things they could reach for and felt confident exploring for themselves? You didn't just let them reach for a screen whenever the smallest amount of boredom hit? You suggested things that they could do? Some time in the preschool years you started leaving them to play solo for longer periods while you got on with stuff?

Yeah we're not a million miles apart. If my kids complain to me they're bored, I'll suggest things they can do, including helping me with whatever I'm busy with, jobs that need doing or many of the things available for them to play with. I spend lots of time playing with them, reading to them, doing stuff with them - particularly those things where they still really need or benefit from a parent's input. But I'm not going to drop everything the minute someone says they're bored. Five minutes later, they've found something.

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:47

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 19:37

I don't think there is any evidence that young children who are ignored by adults and left to find their own entertainment are more likely to read, draw, play outside when older than those whose parents read, draw, took them to parks and other activities. Quite the opposite.

Straw man. No one is suggesting that parents should never do those things with their kids, or that kids should be left to their own devices all the time.

Only that filling every waking moment of their day with parent-led activities, or allowing screens to be the only thing that fills the gap in adult-led activities probably isn't the best for kids either.

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 19:45

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:29

I mean, you're not locking them in a sensory deprivation chamber, right? Your kids have sometime in their lives expressed hobbies and interests, and they may have some things that cater to those hobbies and interests?

Available to my kids: books, library cards, Lego, art supplies, more books, games, puzzles, paper and pens to write a story, toys to make up stories around, playing cards, marble run, electronics kit, science kit, other stuff. We're lucky enough to have a tiny garden so add basketball + hoop, football, a bit of grass to play on/lie on.

Stuff I've come across my bored kids (4 years apart) doing: Parliament of stuffed toys, science experiments making 'potions', youngest makes almost homeopathic fruit juices by mixing trace elements of a raspberry in water, they both like making potions/seeing what dissolves/playing with baking powder, they'll bake a cake or biscuits with a small amount of supervision (but not me coordinating the activity/jollying them along - I'm there for advice), recreating movie scenes in Lego, making their own superhero movie, reading, writing stories, playing/making up music, occasionally they'll even do something 'wholesome' and straightforward like play a board game or card game together. I sometimes have to intervene when the basketball gets heated or whatever. And often I'll join in when asked but I'm not there filling every waking minute for them.

They're not particularly exceptional kids and it wasn't particularly easy when we decided to have stricter limits on screens. Youngest still whines 'I'm boooooored' two minutes after the iPad goes off. But ten minutes later he's just getting on with stuff.

That said, my kids also do a fair amount of clubs and stuff by choice.

But why would being ignored by adults and generally bored make them more able to entertain themselves with books or do the other activities?. When my children were younger I used to do those activities with them. It didn't mean they couldn't entertain themselves when older.

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 19:37

sunglassesonthetable · 29/06/2023 19:11

Entertain themselves with what?

Books, toys, games , activity, drawing, reading, the outdoors, you name it.

I don't think there is any evidence that young children who are ignored by adults and left to find their own entertainment are more likely to read, draw, play outside when older than those whose parents read, draw, took them to parks and other activities. Quite the opposite.

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:29

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 18:54

Entertain themselves with what?

I mean, you're not locking them in a sensory deprivation chamber, right? Your kids have sometime in their lives expressed hobbies and interests, and they may have some things that cater to those hobbies and interests?

Available to my kids: books, library cards, Lego, art supplies, more books, games, puzzles, paper and pens to write a story, toys to make up stories around, playing cards, marble run, electronics kit, science kit, other stuff. We're lucky enough to have a tiny garden so add basketball + hoop, football, a bit of grass to play on/lie on.

Stuff I've come across my bored kids (4 years apart) doing: Parliament of stuffed toys, science experiments making 'potions', youngest makes almost homeopathic fruit juices by mixing trace elements of a raspberry in water, they both like making potions/seeing what dissolves/playing with baking powder, they'll bake a cake or biscuits with a small amount of supervision (but not me coordinating the activity/jollying them along - I'm there for advice), recreating movie scenes in Lego, making their own superhero movie, reading, writing stories, playing/making up music, occasionally they'll even do something 'wholesome' and straightforward like play a board game or card game together. I sometimes have to intervene when the basketball gets heated or whatever. And often I'll join in when asked but I'm not there filling every waking minute for them.

They're not particularly exceptional kids and it wasn't particularly easy when we decided to have stricter limits on screens. Youngest still whines 'I'm boooooored' two minutes after the iPad goes off. But ten minutes later he's just getting on with stuff.

That said, my kids also do a fair amount of clubs and stuff by choice.

sunglassesonthetable · 29/06/2023 19:11

Entertain themselves with what?

Books, toys, games , activity, drawing, reading, the outdoors, you name it.

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 18:54

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 11:48

Which is generally a good motivator to go and find something they do enjoy or find interesting to do.

The key is that they're being self-driven to find something to entertain them, driven by that little bit of boredom.

Entertain themselves with what?

LakieLady · 29/06/2023 14:30

Backtoreality1 · 28/06/2023 16:34

Or they could be really rebellious and read a book!!

I was going to post similar.

I think that the boredom threshold of children falls in proportion to the rise in the range of diversions available to them. I grew up in an era when there was nothing on telly between Watch With Mother at lunchtime and programmes starting again around 4pm, but I don't recall ever being bored.

Mind you, we were allowed to do things that would probably end up leading to social services getting involved these days - going to the woods on our bikes or swimming without any adults to supervise, getting the bus 6 miles into town to mooch around the shops, playing in old houses that were awaiting demolition.

It's a miracle any of us survived to adulthood.

CoffeeCantata · 29/06/2023 13:59

OP, I agree that kids will reach for screens if not actively engaged in anything else, and the sort of 'creative' boredom which is beneficial is hard to foster in 2023. What you need is a formal, constrained type of situation where they don't have the option to look at screens.

The sort of thing I'm thinking of goes back to my youth, long ago. We had very formal assemblies in school each morning, lasting about 40 mins, with a hymn, a sort of 'Thought for the Day' sermon from a teacher, announcements and music on entering and leaving the hall.

Of course, everyone claimed to hate assemblies, but I remember that lovely feeling of staring out of the hall windows while the teacher was droning on giving their talk, sort of 'loosening your consciousness' and letting it wander anywhere it wanted to. All kinds of thoughts and ideas drifted through my head, and I'm sure I wasn't the only one. I didn't mind it at all - I found it a great way to start the day, and I'm sure it had some of the benefits of meditation. Kids would also have got this experience in the days when they had to sit through church services (not child-orientated ones like today), and stay silent and not fidget.

When I was teaching it became the accepted wisdom that children shouldn't be subjected to any kind of formality, with expectations of silence and sitting still and listening. It was, and still is, very out of fashion. But I've always thought that's a mistake. There are huge benefits from a bit of enforced quiet and contemplation. Yes, they might think they're bored, but it's a pleasant kind of boredom where your mind takes a kind of holiday and goes off somewhere else.

georgarina · 29/06/2023 13:55

Disagree. I was bored as a child so I learned to tell myself stories - and, later, write them down. No need to use your imagination if you're always occupied.

SkankingWombat · 29/06/2023 13:53

Lovetotravel123 · 29/06/2023 12:04

I agree with what you are saying. We put limits on our child’s screen time but because he is an only child he wants us to do the alternative activity with him. His preference is actually to be outside or doing something with us, but that isn’t always possible. Then he reverts to a screen. He used to build with Lego but is growing out of that now. When we were kids we played outside a lot but then also watched a lot of TV.

In essence, my kid is fine with ‘being bored’ but insists on us filling the void with him. Not sure how I fix that without him feeling rejected?

He won't feel rejected if he understands it's because you're busy. Presumably he's welcome to come and pitch in with the chores you're trying to crack on with if he wants a bit of company? Constantly entertaining your DCs is a modern concept.
I'm an only child of a single parent. My DM did occasionally sit down and play with me, but she worked long hours and when we were home she mostly needed to spend her time on cooking, house keeping, gardening, and DIY. There were only 4 TV channels and by the time we got home the kids' programmes had finished, so I rarely watched it. I played with Lego & Sylvanians, read (lots!), did crafting, helped DM, and played out/rode my bike with my friends. I didn't outgrow Lego until around yr7/8, which was normal - I often see parents on here saying their DCs have outgrown toys much sooner and wonder why that is. Once I had grown out of toys, I was old enough to get the bus into town with friends, so would arrange things like that instead. My eldest is 9yo and, although she is pickier over what she plays with now, still very much plays with toys; I can't see that changing any time soon.

threecupsofteaminimum · 29/06/2023 13:48

I tend to disagree. DS7 and I live in a 2 bed apartment in London and I wfh. I don't think it's constructive to have a strict schedule at all times, he goes off and plays with his toys and reads, draws, paints (if I get the bits out for him) whilst I'm busy either at the laptop or cooking and this worksmwell. He's a very imaginative and smart kid.

He is never allowed to stare at a screen as for me that's out of the question but we watch game shows like House of a games and Pointless together, almost everything has an educational component even if it's a silly cbbc programme or wildlife on tv.

Lovetotravel123 · 29/06/2023 12:04

I agree with what you are saying. We put limits on our child’s screen time but because he is an only child he wants us to do the alternative activity with him. His preference is actually to be outside or doing something with us, but that isn’t always possible. Then he reverts to a screen. He used to build with Lego but is growing out of that now. When we were kids we played outside a lot but then also watched a lot of TV.

In essence, my kid is fine with ‘being bored’ but insists on us filling the void with him. Not sure how I fix that without him feeling rejected?

dameofdilemma · 29/06/2023 12:00

"What’s wrong with leaving a kid alone with their thoughts?"

There's a fine line for a teen between having some quiet reflective time and being lonely. For many teens the way they talk through problems, ease anxieties, etc is communication with friends.
And however much we might not like it (and I really don't like it) that line of communication now revolves around phones for most teens.

The landscape is so different to how I and many posters on this thread grew up. I wish smartphones were never created - I genuinely think they are bad for everyone, not just teens, in the way they can define and influence relationships and don't get me started on mental health.

WeWereInParis · 29/06/2023 11:56

Depends on the age I guess. My DD is 4, so I appreciate its a lot easier to manage screen time as she obviously doesn't have a phone/tablet/laptop/tv in her room etc. But I think for that age I disagree with you, I don't make it my job to entertain her all the time and I do think it's good for her to be a bit bored and then find something to do. Obviously I play with her, but sometimes she has to play by herself because I'm busy, and the tv is off. She has plenty of toys so any whinge of "I'm boreddddd" she just gets pointed in that direction.

As I said, I do completely acknowledge that as she gets older, screen time will be harder to manage.

StarmanBobby · 29/06/2023 11:54

‘Being bored does not mean not being antertained by adults. It means not doing anything they find enjoy or find interesting.’

disagree entirely with that. If they’re not doing anything they find interesting or enjoy then they can either self motivated to change that or accept the fact that not every moment of their lives will be filled with something they find interesting or enjoy.

my ‘bored’ 13 year old took a nap that he clearly needed. When he woke up he went off to the Basket ball courts alone, no-one around. Where he then bumped into some kids he knows from school and ended up having a great time.
When he came home he moaned a bit about being ‘bored’ but I told him to bugger off or I’d give him chores.
Don’t know what he actually did then in his room but he was phoneless, and had no screens so it wasn’t that.

dameofdilemma · 29/06/2023 11:51

"Bored teens are rather implicated in anti-social behaviour."

I think this is a fair point. It's one thing for a 'bored' teen to have a spacious home where they can hang out with friends; independent access to sports/leisure activities (walkable or public transport); money etc.

It's quite another for a teen who doesn't have access to any of those things.

StarmanBobby · 29/06/2023 11:49

‘As others have said, boredom doesn't necessarily result in a wholesome activity. ‘

so? It’s doesn’t have to. What’s wrong with leaving a kid alone with their thoughts?
we teach ‘meditation’ in primary schools now - pretty much the same thing isn’t it?

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 11:48

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 11:01

Being bored does not mean not being antertained by adults. It means not doing anything they find enjoy or find interesting.

Which is generally a good motivator to go and find something they do enjoy or find interesting to do.

The key is that they're being self-driven to find something to entertain them, driven by that little bit of boredom.

dameofdilemma · 29/06/2023 11:46

I used to look on smugly as dd was constantly able to keep herself occupied with lego, toys, arts and crafts etc and not a screen in sight.

Then she hit puberty at 9. I no longer look on smugly.

We limit screen time and take screens away. Dd (11) stays in her room listening to music, maybe reading, maybe writing in her diary about how much she hates her parents for taking her phone away - who knows, we're not allowed in.

Ironically when she has her phone she speaks to her friends, arranges to meet up locally or continues learning a language on Duolingo. (Amongst all the youtube rubbish).

As others have said, boredom doesn't necessarily result in a wholesome activity.

And forget about comparing one 11 year old with another - puberty is the game changer.