Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the current vogue for allowing kids to be "bored" is a bit misguided

241 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 16:18

Have been thinking about this a lot recently, prompted by posts on here and things in the media. It's become very fashionable for people to talk about how important it is for children to be allowed to "be bored" sometimes.

I totally understand and support the principle of this: which is that overzealous scheduling and helicopter parenting is not great for many kids. I think there is a place for not having your entire life planned out from dawn to dusk and for learning to entertain yourself.

But in reality I think this "leave them to get bored" is often quite unworkable. Once kids get "bored" these days they invariably reach for screens. Now, obviously it's up to us as parents to manage this. But there's a limit to how much you can police this, short of removing all devices. It would be great if "being bored" always meant directing kids out to rough and tumble play in the hayfields or making dens in the living room or finger painting, but that usually isn't what it means. It either means screen time or it means getting into things they shouldn't. Stopping this happening means endless policing of what they do. So, forgive me but given the choice I'd rather my kid was doing an after-school club than playing four hours of Minecraft (sorry Minecraft) or watching TV or being bullied by me to be "creatively bored".

"Constructive" boredom as its preached is one of these lovely ideas (a bit like "free range" parenting) that's much much easier to achieve if you have a huge five-bedroom pile in the home counties than if you live in a cramped two bed flat (from which you also work). It's pretty unworkable for most parents and I'm starting to find it increasingly irritating when people parrot this as if it were a solution to all parenting dilemmas.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 15:51

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 15:49

Don't worry, they will have the skills not to want your company by the time they are teenagers. And whether they use screens as teenagers/adults will be a matter of personality rather than skills learned as young children.

You keep telling me not to worry - I'm not worried because my kids are great at this! But lots aren't, as is evident from folk on this thread and widely elsewhere.

Like I said - you and I aren't going to agree here, so maybe we should just drop it, eh?

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 15:49

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 15:37

So you do loads of activities with your children and they only ever experience the slightest wisp of boredom?

I do loads of activities with my kids - as I've said on this thread already. Less than I used to as they get older, as you'd expect. Sometimes they say they're bored. They have the skills and access to lots of things to entertain themselves and generally find something to occupy themselves pretty quickly!

It's my job to give them the skills and opportunities to occupy and entertain themselves as well as being the entertainer.

I totally agree with the PP who talked about the benefits of the enforced boredom of church/assemblies/etc. I found eldest son on his bed earlier in the year just staring at the ceiling. Asked if he was ok. 'Yes, just we had a really boring assembly today and I started just thinking about other things and it was quite good and I thought about a lot of interesting things, and I wanted to do more of it.'

What life is this, etc etc.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 15:49

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:50

Basically what people are saying is - it's a process. You give your kids the skills and set the boundaries that they are increasingly able to entertain themselves in a variety of ways over time, rather than rely on external entertainment (parent or screen led).

Don't worry, they will have the skills not to want your company by the time they are teenagers. And whether they use screens as teenagers/adults will be a matter of personality rather than skills learned as young children.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 15:37

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:48

Again, you're back to the 'all or nothing' - somehow arguing that parents who sometimes don't drop everything because their child has uttered the slightest wisp of boredom don't also do loads of activities with their kids.

So you do loads of activities with your children and they only ever experience the slightest wisp of boredom?

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:50

Basically what people are saying is - it's a process. You give your kids the skills and set the boundaries that they are increasingly able to entertain themselves in a variety of ways over time, rather than rely on external entertainment (parent or screen led).

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:48

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 14:43

I don't think a preference for technology is reduced by ignoring them when they are young children to the extent they are often bored though. The young adults I know who spend all their free time gaming aren't the ones whose parents did a lot of activities with them when they were younger. If anything it's the other way around.

Again, you're back to the 'all or nothing' - somehow arguing that parents who sometimes don't drop everything because their child has uttered the slightest wisp of boredom don't also do loads of activities with their kids.

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 14:44

am making the point that they don't choose screens because they are unable to do other things without their parents input. They just prefer screens to other things.

They lose that ability to push past the initial demands of creating your own entertainment. Of imagination.

One click and it's all consuming. It's been designed to be like that. It becomes a habit. Like fast food.

It's not about 'ignoring' your children. It's about allowing space for their own creativity.

ThatOnePlease · 30/06/2023 14:44

Blingb · 28/06/2023 16:30

Obviously it means off screens!

^This nailed it in one.

Letting them be bored means no screens. It means not consuming media, and instead allowing them to fall back on the resources of their own brains, their imagination and creativity. Daydreaming. Making up songs or games.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 14:43

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:34

And sometimes that preference becomes so all-consuming - because of the nature of the technology - that it depletes their ability to occupy themselves without screens. And so the 'choice' becomes less of a choice than it would likely have been otherwise.

I don't think a preference for technology is reduced by ignoring them when they are young children to the extent they are often bored though. The young adults I know who spend all their free time gaming aren't the ones whose parents did a lot of activities with them when they were younger. If anything it's the other way around.

inappropriateraspberry · 30/06/2023 14:41

It's very easy to police screen time - just use many of the apps available to lock the device after x time. My children have a 1hr limit per day, a little longer at weekends. It's usually their first choice of activity, but once time is up they move on to playing, drawing etc.

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 14:34

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 14:28

I'm not suggesting that their pure preference should override other factors. I am making the point that they don't choose screens because they are unable to do other things without their parents input. They just prefer screens to other things.

And sometimes that preference becomes so all-consuming - because of the nature of the technology - that it depletes their ability to occupy themselves without screens. And so the 'choice' becomes less of a choice than it would likely have been otherwise.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 14:28

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 13:03

I think we should just agree to disagree - our styles are quite different, certainly by age four or five I didn't want my kids to be looking to me to fill the gap every time they were at a momentary loose end.

And I don't think for older kids when it comes to screens that pure preference should override other factors, such as quite a few discussed on this thread - including OP's original dilemma.

I'm not suggesting that their pure preference should override other factors. I am making the point that they don't choose screens because they are unable to do other things without their parents input. They just prefer screens to other things.

mumda · 30/06/2023 13:34

Quiet indoor hobbies?

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 13:09

Finding stuff to do is a bit of a skill and it sounds like she needs a bit of practice/support until she gets the hang of it.

This very much resonates with me!

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 13:03

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 12:12

I would define young as preschool and maybe reception. I don't think leaving them to be bored benefits them. They don't need to be bored to learn how to entertain themselves or play with friends their own age. It will happen once they are at school anyway. Older children who spend a lot of time on screens do so because that is their preference rather than because they can't find anything else to do.

I think we should just agree to disagree - our styles are quite different, certainly by age four or five I didn't want my kids to be looking to me to fill the gap every time they were at a momentary loose end.

And I don't think for older kids when it comes to screens that pure preference should override other factors, such as quite a few discussed on this thread - including OP's original dilemma.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 30/06/2023 12:36

CoffeeCantata · 29/06/2023 13:59

OP, I agree that kids will reach for screens if not actively engaged in anything else, and the sort of 'creative' boredom which is beneficial is hard to foster in 2023. What you need is a formal, constrained type of situation where they don't have the option to look at screens.

The sort of thing I'm thinking of goes back to my youth, long ago. We had very formal assemblies in school each morning, lasting about 40 mins, with a hymn, a sort of 'Thought for the Day' sermon from a teacher, announcements and music on entering and leaving the hall.

Of course, everyone claimed to hate assemblies, but I remember that lovely feeling of staring out of the hall windows while the teacher was droning on giving their talk, sort of 'loosening your consciousness' and letting it wander anywhere it wanted to. All kinds of thoughts and ideas drifted through my head, and I'm sure I wasn't the only one. I didn't mind it at all - I found it a great way to start the day, and I'm sure it had some of the benefits of meditation. Kids would also have got this experience in the days when they had to sit through church services (not child-orientated ones like today), and stay silent and not fidget.

When I was teaching it became the accepted wisdom that children shouldn't be subjected to any kind of formality, with expectations of silence and sitting still and listening. It was, and still is, very out of fashion. But I've always thought that's a mistake. There are huge benefits from a bit of enforced quiet and contemplation. Yes, they might think they're bored, but it's a pleasant kind of boredom where your mind takes a kind of holiday and goes off somewhere else.

This is so true - I used to go to mass as a kid and though I complained about it, in fact I loved it, to the extent that I really miss it now as an adult. I'd feel hypocritical going when I don't believe but there is something lovely about just following the process of the ritual with other people - it's very good for your brain. To your point, I think the popularity of meditation and mindfulness comes from a lack of access to these calming rituals - it's a replacement. I hate meditation because it's generally solitary - what I liked about mass was being in a room with many other people.

OP- I'm sure someone's said this already but I think it's unfair for posters to compare your situation to theirs if they have more than one child or a partner. Siblings fight but they also play together - if I tell my two to get off screens they're usually tearing around the house screaming (which has its own drawbacks!) within minutes.

Could it be that your daughter lacks ideas as to what to do with her time? You could help her set up a meetup with her friends, start her on a project, etc so that she can have a go-to thing while she gets used to organising her own time? Finding stuff to do is a bit of a skill and it sounds like she needs a bit of practice/support until she gets the hang of it.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 12:12

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 23:15

Define 'young'?

I know a fair few kids (and you hear it on here) that there are a lot of kids who don't know how to entertain themselves without their parents doing the entertaining, or or without a screen.

From the preschool years I've been encouraging a degree of independent play - and as they get older, yes, figuring out what it is they were going to fill their time with rather than relying on someone else to do it for them.

So that when their brain goes 'I don't have anything to do right now!' they have the resources to fill the gap themselves rather than being reliant on someone else for it. To have the experience of letting their mind wander for a bit because

And yep, I think there is some advantage in not having someone fill every single gap in their mental lives so that they have space to let their minds wander, to figure things out for themselves, and he's, sometimes (horrors!) experiencing some fleeting boredom before getting on with it and finding something to do.

Perhaps we have different definitions of 'ignoring' and 'boredom'? To me, it's important that my kids know from a young age that other people also have priorities which are just as valid as theirs, and that their parents won't always drop what they're doing to cater to the child's immediate whim, so the child will have a choice - find a way to entertain themselves, or do a (to them) dull task with their parents.

I would define young as preschool and maybe reception. I don't think leaving them to be bored benefits them. They don't need to be bored to learn how to entertain themselves or play with friends their own age. It will happen once they are at school anyway. Older children who spend a lot of time on screens do so because that is their preference rather than because they can't find anything else to do.

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 23:17

TimeToMoveIt · 29/06/2023 20:14

🤣 how old are they?

Youngest is seven and calmly informed me that it was his home now, and the kid would keep foxes and robbers out at night.

But the eleven year old, though too cool most of the time, is certainly not above making the occasional foray into a furniture box.

I've had to promise to leave it there for the weekend as apparently it is a not-at-all-obvious spy base.

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 23:15

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 20:12

I appreciate you are not suggesting that they are ignored all the time but you seem to think there is some advantage to being ignored to the extent they are bored. What do you think happens if parents lead the activities when children are young? Do you think they will be less able to entertain themselves as teenagers and still require parents input? I assure you that won't happen.

Define 'young'?

I know a fair few kids (and you hear it on here) that there are a lot of kids who don't know how to entertain themselves without their parents doing the entertaining, or or without a screen.

From the preschool years I've been encouraging a degree of independent play - and as they get older, yes, figuring out what it is they were going to fill their time with rather than relying on someone else to do it for them.

So that when their brain goes 'I don't have anything to do right now!' they have the resources to fill the gap themselves rather than being reliant on someone else for it. To have the experience of letting their mind wander for a bit because

And yep, I think there is some advantage in not having someone fill every single gap in their mental lives so that they have space to let their minds wander, to figure things out for themselves, and he's, sometimes (horrors!) experiencing some fleeting boredom before getting on with it and finding something to do.

Perhaps we have different definitions of 'ignoring' and 'boredom'? To me, it's important that my kids know from a young age that other people also have priorities which are just as valid as theirs, and that their parents won't always drop what they're doing to cater to the child's immediate whim, so the child will have a choice - find a way to entertain themselves, or do a (to them) dull task with their parents.

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 21:02

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:53

So... you gave them access to those things, suggested things that were available to them when they were bored, helped them explore things and develop skills, so that as they got older they had lots of things they could reach for and felt confident exploring for themselves? You didn't just let them reach for a screen whenever the smallest amount of boredom hit? You suggested things that they could do? Some time in the preschool years you started leaving them to play solo for longer periods while you got on with stuff?

Yeah we're not a million miles apart. If my kids complain to me they're bored, I'll suggest things they can do, including helping me with whatever I'm busy with, jobs that need doing or many of the things available for them to play with. I spend lots of time playing with them, reading to them, doing stuff with them - particularly those things where they still really need or benefit from a parent's input. But I'm not going to drop everything the minute someone says they're bored. Five minutes later, they've found something.

My children are now adults so the only screens were TVs so no they didn't reach for a screen. I didn't leave them to be bored either though. I would do activities with them when they were younger and I don't remember them complaining they were bored.

SkankingWombat · 29/06/2023 20:47

TimeToMoveIt · 29/06/2023 20:14

🤣 how old are they?

Or species... DCats would happily spend hours with a box in the garden 😸😸

TheHateIsNotGood · 29/06/2023 20:24

Being bored prepares many dc for adult life - very few grown ups don't experience some form of boredom, even those that lead 'exciting' lives.

And when you break it down, a lot of stuff like chores, etc are very boring, and many jobs are too. Most grown-ups learn to deal with coping with the boredom of it all, so best that boredom is regularly experienced from a young age.

2bazookas · 29/06/2023 20:20

It really is not hard to control the use of screens.

TimeToMoveIt · 29/06/2023 20:14

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 20:05

That said, there is currently a large box in the garden which is apparently more attractive than any screen right now.

🤣 how old are they?

WomblingTree86 · 29/06/2023 20:12

JassyRadlett · 29/06/2023 19:47

Straw man. No one is suggesting that parents should never do those things with their kids, or that kids should be left to their own devices all the time.

Only that filling every waking moment of their day with parent-led activities, or allowing screens to be the only thing that fills the gap in adult-led activities probably isn't the best for kids either.

I appreciate you are not suggesting that they are ignored all the time but you seem to think there is some advantage to being ignored to the extent they are bored. What do you think happens if parents lead the activities when children are young? Do you think they will be less able to entertain themselves as teenagers and still require parents input? I assure you that won't happen.