Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the current vogue for allowing kids to be "bored" is a bit misguided

241 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 16:18

Have been thinking about this a lot recently, prompted by posts on here and things in the media. It's become very fashionable for people to talk about how important it is for children to be allowed to "be bored" sometimes.

I totally understand and support the principle of this: which is that overzealous scheduling and helicopter parenting is not great for many kids. I think there is a place for not having your entire life planned out from dawn to dusk and for learning to entertain yourself.

But in reality I think this "leave them to get bored" is often quite unworkable. Once kids get "bored" these days they invariably reach for screens. Now, obviously it's up to us as parents to manage this. But there's a limit to how much you can police this, short of removing all devices. It would be great if "being bored" always meant directing kids out to rough and tumble play in the hayfields or making dens in the living room or finger painting, but that usually isn't what it means. It either means screen time or it means getting into things they shouldn't. Stopping this happening means endless policing of what they do. So, forgive me but given the choice I'd rather my kid was doing an after-school club than playing four hours of Minecraft (sorry Minecraft) or watching TV or being bullied by me to be "creatively bored".

"Constructive" boredom as its preached is one of these lovely ideas (a bit like "free range" parenting) that's much much easier to achieve if you have a huge five-bedroom pile in the home counties than if you live in a cramped two bed flat (from which you also work). It's pretty unworkable for most parents and I'm starting to find it increasingly irritating when people parrot this as if it were a solution to all parenting dilemmas.

OP posts:
Nicecow · 01/07/2023 00:51

SilverGlitterBaubles · 30/06/2023 18:14

Given that very young kids sit in pushchairs, cars and trolleys attached to a device and seem to struggle to do anything at all that does not involve a screen or a snack I think society has a big problem coming up.

Absolutely. It's disturbing that a child (even a baby!) needs a screen all the time, what wrong with just looking out and observing your surroundings. Definitely the parents fault for even introducing them at such a young age

Nicecow · 01/07/2023 00:48

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 00:36

No because they didn't exist when my children were young. No-one suggested they needed to be bored then either. I played with my children when preschool age and as they got older they played with their friends, read books, watched TV etc etc. It happens naturally with no boredom required.

With respect - if you haven't juggled the impact of screens on children I'm not sure you would really get the idea of boredom having a positive impact.

I think the idea has come as a direct result of the impact of screens and also over scheduling.

Agree and probably also big cause of so many behavioural issues and even issues like ADHD. Kids should be running around to burn off energy and using their brains (playing, using their imagination etc). Instead of being spoon fed everything. It's not natural.
I don't understand why so many kids have to be constantly supervised and entertained, mine can easily entertain themselves with toys or books or anything, and always have done this from birth.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 00:36

No because they didn't exist when my children were young. No-one suggested they needed to be bored then either. I played with my children when preschool age and as they got older they played with their friends, read books, watched TV etc etc. It happens naturally with no boredom required.

With respect - if you haven't juggled the impact of screens on children I'm not sure you would really get the idea of boredom having a positive impact.

I think the idea has come as a direct result of the impact of screens and also over scheduling.

Nicecow · 30/06/2023 22:38

I think if you're child can't be 'bored' and needs a device there is something very wrong with them

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 22:20

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 17:38

haven't suggested children should play games all the time.

Do you have much experience of young children and screens?

No because they didn't exist when my children were young. No-one suggested they needed to be bored then either. I played with my children when preschool age and as they got older they played with their friends, read books, watched TV etc etc. It happens naturally with no boredom required.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 22:13

jannier · 30/06/2023 19:33

Pre school children don't get bored they play unless you've taught them to only play with you rather than give balance.
Older children have been encouraged to use screens from early childhood with many being sat in front of them at every opportunity...eating I'm pushchairs even when in the woods basically as an extension of dummies then as they get older things like no where too busy to get the toys out or too much mess. Over the years I've had many toys given to me because the kids are too old for them... they are brand new toys and the too old kids don't stop playing with them.

You are not making a lot of sense.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2023 20:17

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 17:13

Yes and she does see friends a lot.

Should have been clearer probably. I did have a policy of no screens during the way at weekends and only half an hour in the week until she turned 11. It’s unsustainable now due to homework and friendships relying a lot on devices for contact and scheduling.

Even before this though she would constantly mither me to do stuff with her. I ended up being incapable of doing anything else.

I have always felt like a complete failure as a parent and now I feel like my failure to police screen more zealously has damaged her.

You haven't failed as a parent, you've done your best to spend time with your daughter. It's the modern world that's making things difficult. I think you can do 2 things - firstly, enable her to socialise face to face with friends as much as possible. And secondly she is old enough now that you can talk to her about the benefits of non screen activities and decide together what limits you will put on. Maybe an hour before bedtime of screen free time. Help her think of things to do during that time, maybe provide some materials. Maybe you can have an hour screen free too and do something alongside whether reading a book etc. but not actively entertaining her.

jannier · 30/06/2023 19:33

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 12:12

I would define young as preschool and maybe reception. I don't think leaving them to be bored benefits them. They don't need to be bored to learn how to entertain themselves or play with friends their own age. It will happen once they are at school anyway. Older children who spend a lot of time on screens do so because that is their preference rather than because they can't find anything else to do.

Pre school children don't get bored they play unless you've taught them to only play with you rather than give balance.
Older children have been encouraged to use screens from early childhood with many being sat in front of them at every opportunity...eating I'm pushchairs even when in the woods basically as an extension of dummies then as they get older things like no where too busy to get the toys out or too much mess. Over the years I've had many toys given to me because the kids are too old for them... they are brand new toys and the too old kids don't stop playing with them.

Bemyclementine · 30/06/2023 18:18

For me , letting them."be bored" means removing screens. I don't mind TV, but not YouTube etc. They will only watch so much mainstream telly.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 30/06/2023 18:14

Given that very young kids sit in pushchairs, cars and trolleys attached to a device and seem to struggle to do anything at all that does not involve a screen or a snack I think society has a big problem coming up.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2023 17:38

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 16:42

I understand the theory. I'm just not really sure how this works in practice because if anything it seems to be the opposite for me.

Maybe I'm just a really shit parent: I'm a single mother to a 12 year old and I work from home a fair bit of the week. My DD is at school most of the time obviously and in some after school clubs so it's only a few hours during the working week when she's at home and I'm working. But if she is left alone for any length of time at home when I'm working she will eventually default to wanting to go on screen. I can obviously wander in and stop this (and I do, frequently). But that means me constantly having to go in and say "come off Minecraft/Stop watching TV". She then gets "bored" and it leads to her being distracted and round and round it goes. Yes she will paint and read. But only with encouragement from me. I have to actively facilitate this.

Maybe I've failed hideously, but for me the "boredom = creativity" doesn't compute. If anything it's more the other way around. The more bored she gets, the more she wants to go on screens and the more I have to intervene to stop that happening. So it doesn't really work that way for me.

Of course bored children want screens. The idea is not to allow the screens and after they have passed through a fairly painful moaning phase they eventually find something to do. If you allow the screens and they are used to having them then that's what they will do. Having bored children is harder work for parents too. I admit to letting my children have too much screen time just to make my own life easier!
For a 12 year old who's not home that much you probably need to get rid of screens completely for 2 weeks before she'll start to be able to be comfortable without them.

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 17:38

haven't suggested children should play games all the time.

Do you have much experience of young children and screens?

longestlurkerever · 30/06/2023 17:34

Lol at being 12 being a drip feed. Plenty of kids are 12! Especially ones who are pushy about device time.

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 17:34

My point is that children will learn to entertain themselves without enforced boredom.

Who 'enforces boredom' ?

I just don't jump in and entertain every time.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 17:32

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 15:49

I do loads of activities with my kids - as I've said on this thread already. Less than I used to as they get older, as you'd expect. Sometimes they say they're bored. They have the skills and access to lots of things to entertain themselves and generally find something to occupy themselves pretty quickly!

It's my job to give them the skills and opportunities to occupy and entertain themselves as well as being the entertainer.

I totally agree with the PP who talked about the benefits of the enforced boredom of church/assemblies/etc. I found eldest son on his bed earlier in the year just staring at the ceiling. Asked if he was ok. 'Yes, just we had a really boring assembly today and I started just thinking about other things and it was quite good and I thought about a lot of interesting things, and I wanted to do more of it.'

What life is this, etc etc.

My point is that children will learn to entertain themselves without enforced boredom.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 17:25

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 16:35

I don't play computer games and neither do my adult children because we don't enjoy it. It has nothing to do with our skills and certainly nothing to do with creativity,

If that was all you did in your down time as a child I expect you would be playing it now.

I haven't suggested children should play games all the time.

JassyRadlett · 30/06/2023 17:23

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 16:29

You can't say that because someone chooses one activity over another it is because they have lost some skill or ability or haven't been taught something or were not bored enough as a child. That is ridiculous. I don't play computer games and neither do my adult children because we don't enjoy it. It has nothing to do with our skills and certainly nothing to do with creativity,

No when it comes to screen tech I would say they have lost something.

And I don't think it's ridiculous to say it's addictive.

There's a reason it's especially not advised before 2.

Yep, there's lots of evidence that screens - and particularly a lot of the apps designed for phones and tablets - are addictive and have distinct downsides.

And just like when my kids say 'I'm thirsty' I generally won't say 'ok, have a sugary fizzy drink', when they're feeling bored I don't want a screen to be their default.

pandarific · 30/06/2023 17:12

‘Even before this though she would constantly mither me to do stuff with her. I ended up being incapable of doing anything else.

I have always felt like a complete failure as a parent and now I feel like my failure to police screen more zealously has damaged her.’

@Thepeopleversuswork don’t be so hard on yourself!! She is 12, she’s becoming a young adult, she’s not going to be into imaginative play, which is what those statements are angling toward.

when I was 12, I: played The Sims (a lot), I went into town to see my friends, I did a hobby and in the evenings at home I watched tv with my sister. Not hugely exciting, but in retrospect I was shattered after secondary every day.

At that age, maybe you can start to see screens as more of a gateway for interesting hobbies for her, things you could recreate at home?

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 16:38

I was actually joking when I said that they will have the skills not to want your company as teenagers. It is quite funny that anyone thinks that it is a skill they have to learn though.

Well you said it.....

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 16:35

I don't play computer games and neither do my adult children because we don't enjoy it. It has nothing to do with our skills and certainly nothing to do with creativity,

If that was all you did in your down time as a child I expect you would be playing it now.

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 16:29

You can't say that because someone chooses one activity over another it is because they have lost some skill or ability or haven't been taught something or were not bored enough as a child. That is ridiculous. I don't play computer games and neither do my adult children because we don't enjoy it. It has nothing to do with our skills and certainly nothing to do with creativity,

No when it comes to screen tech I would say they have lost something.

And I don't think it's ridiculous to say it's addictive.

There's a reason it's especially not advised before 2.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 16:28

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 15:59

Don't worry, they will have the skills not to want your company by the time they are teenagers. And whether they use screens as teenagers/adults will be a matter of personality rather than skills learned as young children.

"wanting your company "

"ignore"

I think you're putting some very emotional twists on this.

I do loads of stuff with my kids and we enjoy each other's company. But If they say " I'm bored" I don't necessarily jump in to fill that space - as entertainer or with screens. I let them use their imaginations. I feel like that's a muscle that needs exercising and space to grow.

I was actually joking when I said that they will have the skills not to want your company as teenagers. It is quite funny that anyone thinks that it is a skill they have to learn though.

WomblingTree86 · 30/06/2023 16:23

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 14:44

am making the point that they don't choose screens because they are unable to do other things without their parents input. They just prefer screens to other things.

They lose that ability to push past the initial demands of creating your own entertainment. Of imagination.

One click and it's all consuming. It's been designed to be like that. It becomes a habit. Like fast food.

It's not about 'ignoring' your children. It's about allowing space for their own creativity.

You can't say that because someone chooses one activity over another it is because they have lost some skill or ability or haven't been taught something or were not bored enough as a child. That is ridiculous. I don't play computer games and neither do my adult children because we don't enjoy it. It has nothing to do with our skills and certainly nothing to do with creativity,

sunglassesonthetable · 30/06/2023 15:59

Don't worry, they will have the skills not to want your company by the time they are teenagers. And whether they use screens as teenagers/adults will be a matter of personality rather than skills learned as young children.

"wanting your company "

"ignore"

I think you're putting some very emotional twists on this.

I do loads of stuff with my kids and we enjoy each other's company. But If they say " I'm bored" I don't necessarily jump in to fill that space - as entertainer or with screens. I let them use their imaginations. I feel like that's a muscle that needs exercising and space to grow.

Dolphinnoises · 30/06/2023 15:53

@Thepeopleversuswork if you’re working, and your DD doesn’t have siblings, then it’s the art of the possible really.

My kids are 10 and 13 and have screen-free time between 10 and 4 on weekends / holidays and no iPads after dinner (blue light). Today for example (on holiday already) they were playing top trumps and doing some sort of fashion show upstairs. But if you’re going to get your DD to do that reliably you may need to invest in games which can be played solo and / or craft/ painting.

i would perhaps tighten up at weekends but in the working day accept it is what it is…