Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the current vogue for allowing kids to be "bored" is a bit misguided

241 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/06/2023 16:18

Have been thinking about this a lot recently, prompted by posts on here and things in the media. It's become very fashionable for people to talk about how important it is for children to be allowed to "be bored" sometimes.

I totally understand and support the principle of this: which is that overzealous scheduling and helicopter parenting is not great for many kids. I think there is a place for not having your entire life planned out from dawn to dusk and for learning to entertain yourself.

But in reality I think this "leave them to get bored" is often quite unworkable. Once kids get "bored" these days they invariably reach for screens. Now, obviously it's up to us as parents to manage this. But there's a limit to how much you can police this, short of removing all devices. It would be great if "being bored" always meant directing kids out to rough and tumble play in the hayfields or making dens in the living room or finger painting, but that usually isn't what it means. It either means screen time or it means getting into things they shouldn't. Stopping this happening means endless policing of what they do. So, forgive me but given the choice I'd rather my kid was doing an after-school club than playing four hours of Minecraft (sorry Minecraft) or watching TV or being bullied by me to be "creatively bored".

"Constructive" boredom as its preached is one of these lovely ideas (a bit like "free range" parenting) that's much much easier to achieve if you have a huge five-bedroom pile in the home counties than if you live in a cramped two bed flat (from which you also work). It's pretty unworkable for most parents and I'm starting to find it increasingly irritating when people parrot this as if it were a solution to all parenting dilemmas.

OP posts:
WomblingTree86 · 01/07/2023 10:44

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 10:06

I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

People didn’t talk about boredom as a good thing the way it’s sometimes talked about now, but they didn’t see it as something that needed parental involvement to avoid. I remember “Only boring people get bored” being the standard response to any complaint about boredom way back in the 70s. The idea being you should go off and entertain yourself.

I was only going back 20 years ago when my own children were young. No-one argued that boredom was a good thing or that less parental involvement was good. Quite the opposite.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:43

I remember sitting waiting ( test card ) for jackanory to start.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:42

Yep there were screens. TV was invented.

But literally no comparison to now.

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 10:38

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:17

People didn’t talk about boredom as a good thing the way it’s sometimes talked about now, but they didn’t see it as something that needed parental involvement to avoid. I remember “Only boring people get bored” being the standard response to any complaint about boredom way back in the 70s. The idea being you should go off and entertain yourself.

Exactly.

They didn't see it as a good thing because they didn't contend with screens.

But we did have screens. All the talk about the dire state of children because of TV foreshadowed the current concern over Internet screens.

We had the TV program Why Don’t You…? urging us to stop watching and go and do something more interesting instead. There was worry about spending too much time in front of the TV ruining your eyesight. And lots of horror at the sorts things we might learn if we watched the wrong program (or anything at all on ITV if you came from a posh family).

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:17

People didn’t talk about boredom as a good thing the way it’s sometimes talked about now, but they didn’t see it as something that needed parental involvement to avoid. I remember “Only boring people get bored” being the standard response to any complaint about boredom way back in the 70s. The idea being you should go off and entertain yourself.

Exactly.

They didn't see it as a good thing because they didn't contend with screens.

P1ckledonionz · 01/07/2023 10:10

Blingb · 28/06/2023 16:30

Obviously it means off screens!

This!

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:09

Parents don't have to contend with screens now if children are young. Just don't give them access.

I'm not talking about tiny children.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 10:07

Than average? You what? What is average?

More bored? They're not bored though.

Boredom is only a constant state if you don't innate or innovate entertainment.

They have the habit of doing this. They've learnt this habit .

You seem to think advocating a bit of boredom means kids sat round listlessly rather than as the catalyst for other self generated activity. ( the good bit )

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 10:06

I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

People didn’t talk about boredom as a good thing the way it’s sometimes talked about now, but they didn’t see it as something that needed parental involvement to avoid. I remember “Only boring people get bored” being the standard response to any complaint about boredom way back in the 70s. The idea being you should go off and entertain yourself.

WomblingTree86 · 01/07/2023 10:02

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:49

I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

People years ago didn't contend with screens.

Parents don't have to contend with screens now if children are young. Just don't give them access.

WomblingTree86 · 01/07/2023 09:57

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:50

Also my kids don't have 'a lack of parental input' .

It's not black or white. It's about balance.

Presumably they are more bored and have less parental input than average though.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:50

Also my kids don't have 'a lack of parental input' .

It's not black or white. It's about balance.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:49

I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

People years ago didn't contend with screens.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:47

I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

WomblingTree86 · 01/07/2023 09:38

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:26

It is just an idea though and the people with young children don't know that boredom now will gave a long term positive impact and reduce screen use when older. Having had more experience of bringing up children i think boredom has a negative impact generally. And if they are young why offer screens in the first place?

I don't advocate hours of 'boredom.'

And it's something I came to naturally and under my own steam where I didn't always jump in and entertain my kids, but let them generate their own ideas. Which they do according to their interests.

Why offer screens in the first place? Indeed.
But take a look around.

The fact that your children have their own ideas doesn't mean lack of parental input or boredom has had a positive impact though. I think it would have happened anyway as it did years ago when people didn't think boredom was a good thing.

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:26

It is just an idea though and the people with young children don't know that boredom now will gave a long term positive impact and reduce screen use when older. Having had more experience of bringing up children i think boredom has a negative impact generally. And if they are young why offer screens in the first place?

I don't advocate hours of 'boredom.'

And it's something I came to naturally and under my own steam where I didn't always jump in and entertain my kids, but let them generate their own ideas. Which they do according to their interests.

Why offer screens in the first place? Indeed.
But take a look around.

WomblingTree86 · 01/07/2023 09:14

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 00:36

No because they didn't exist when my children were young. No-one suggested they needed to be bored then either. I played with my children when preschool age and as they got older they played with their friends, read books, watched TV etc etc. It happens naturally with no boredom required.

With respect - if you haven't juggled the impact of screens on children I'm not sure you would really get the idea of boredom having a positive impact.

I think the idea has come as a direct result of the impact of screens and also over scheduling.

It is just an idea though and the people with young children don't know that boredom now will gave a long term positive impact and reduce screen use when older. Having had more experience of bringing up children i think boredom has a negative impact generally. And if they are young why offer screens in the first place?

MrsMikeDrop · 01/07/2023 09:05

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 06:43

Grin It sounds like a salacious tale, but it was just normal teenage stuff really. It seems like most of the girls I knew who went to church groups smoked, drank and lost their virginity on a church residential but that's just because that was where they socialised. If they'd been into musical theatre they'd have done it there.

I've clearly led a sheltered life! 😅

sunglassesonthetable · 01/07/2023 09:02

Kids who teach themselves latin and get 2 years ahead of their maths curriculum whilst developing a keen interest in musicals have no problem managing their screen time and sound like they can self regulate perfectly.

But Kids who zone out all day on X box or tick-tock. They probably can not.

They need a break. And they will be bored. Until they're not.

It's all a matter of balance. It's not black and white.

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 06:43

MrsMikeDrop · 01/07/2023 03:03

At your church group! I think that warrants is own thread 😁

Grin It sounds like a salacious tale, but it was just normal teenage stuff really. It seems like most of the girls I knew who went to church groups smoked, drank and lost their virginity on a church residential but that's just because that was where they socialised. If they'd been into musical theatre they'd have done it there.
MrsMikeDrop · 01/07/2023 03:03

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 02:59

My kids are pretty bright, but the other kids they interact with online (many of whom they also know IRL) run the gamut. While most are as “accomplished” in the sense of succeeding academically etc., they are still doing all sorts of things that are beneficial to becoming their own person - learning from each other, exchanging ideas and developing their understanding of the world and how they fit into it. They’re also developing great online communication skills - which are going to be even more important as they get older.

There are issues when kids go down the wrong rabbit holes online, so we do keep an eye on things. And we have lots of discussions about peer pressure that include how to cope with it online and how not to pressure others. But it’s also not as though kids haven’t got into trouble with bad influences in real life groups like sports teams. When I was their age I was dodging the pressure to drink, smoke and have sex at my Church youth group.

At your church group! I think that warrants is own thread 😁

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 02:59

MrsMikeDrop · 01/07/2023 02:31

I think your children are the exception to the rule tbh, and probably naturally bright. Most teens and young adults I see have very little social skills, are constantly on their phones and have serious anxiety issues. I can only assume it'll get worse as so many jobs are wfh. I think it's the inability to not constantly be scrolling through something that is the underlying issue. Adults are becoming more like this too. Devices are addictive, no doubt about it

My kids are pretty bright, but the other kids they interact with online (many of whom they also know IRL) run the gamut. While most are as “accomplished” in the sense of succeeding academically etc., they are still doing all sorts of things that are beneficial to becoming their own person - learning from each other, exchanging ideas and developing their understanding of the world and how they fit into it. They’re also developing great online communication skills - which are going to be even more important as they get older.

There are issues when kids go down the wrong rabbit holes online, so we do keep an eye on things. And we have lots of discussions about peer pressure that include how to cope with it online and how not to pressure others. But it’s also not as though kids haven’t got into trouble with bad influences in real life groups like sports teams. When I was their age I was dodging the pressure to drink, smoke and have sex at my Church youth group.

MrsMikeDrop · 01/07/2023 02:31

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 01:16

I would rather my kids played 4 hours of Minecraft a couple of nights a week and went to clubs a couple of nights a week than went to clubs 4 nights a week.

Left to be bored with screens one of my kids has become a prolific writer, winning competitions and getting published in journals, and created animations for youtube that have earned hundreds of pounds. The other has taught herself Latin, some quantum theory, Python and worked through her school’s maths curriculum so that she’s now 2 years ahead. They’ve both developed a keen interest in musicals.

They’ve also watched a lot of trash TV and have significant online discussions with friends on two continents.

They are self-motivated and able to entertain themselves.

It’s been really positive for us.

They also have plenty of time without screens when they entertain themselves - some along the same lines but on paper, not a screen, some much more IRL like board games, etc. But the screens add a richness and a degree of social interaction they don’t get without them (as no other kids round our way).

I think your children are the exception to the rule tbh, and probably naturally bright. Most teens and young adults I see have very little social skills, are constantly on their phones and have serious anxiety issues. I can only assume it'll get worse as so many jobs are wfh. I think it's the inability to not constantly be scrolling through something that is the underlying issue. Adults are becoming more like this too. Devices are addictive, no doubt about it

NumberTheory · 01/07/2023 01:16

I would rather my kids played 4 hours of Minecraft a couple of nights a week and went to clubs a couple of nights a week than went to clubs 4 nights a week.

Left to be bored with screens one of my kids has become a prolific writer, winning competitions and getting published in journals, and created animations for youtube that have earned hundreds of pounds. The other has taught herself Latin, some quantum theory, Python and worked through her school’s maths curriculum so that she’s now 2 years ahead. They’ve both developed a keen interest in musicals.

They’ve also watched a lot of trash TV and have significant online discussions with friends on two continents.

They are self-motivated and able to entertain themselves.

It’s been really positive for us.

They also have plenty of time without screens when they entertain themselves - some along the same lines but on paper, not a screen, some much more IRL like board games, etc. But the screens add a richness and a degree of social interaction they don’t get without them (as no other kids round our way).

SarahDippity · 01/07/2023 01:01

I’ve a friend who’s an only child, born to parents who were older when they had her (dad was in his 50s.) When she was little, they used to put her in a room on her own and tell her she had to learn to entertain herself. It struck me as so unnecessarily unkind to isolate her and deprive her of company.

it doesn’t have to be full-on devoted attention, but side by side inclusion is important. At 12, ask her to do a few errands - go to the post office, buy birthday cards, return library books - that give her independence. For screen time (negotiable) ask her to research things to do on holidays, or create a Pinterest board for a shopping trip.

Swipe left for the next trending thread