Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Responsibility towards niece and nephew

369 replies

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 15:09

I don't know if I'm being unreasonable.

My sister in law is a qualified GP but has chosen not to work because she said that she found the job bad for her mental health. After 6 months of sick leave, she has been a stay at home mum for three years now.

Her husband has failed his medical exams so won't be able to make consultant. His income is around £65k as a trainee doctor and has stagnated. He's also not hungry and won't take locum work for extra pay.

My husband earns quite a lot (more than £1M each year) but it varies based on the profits of the business. He thinks there will be a slowdown in work in the next 12 months so his income may go down.

We are planning to send our daughter to private school in September. SIL caught wind of this and sent her husband over to ask us to help them out because the cost of living crisis is hitting them hard. They think that their kids should also be sent to private school if their cousin gets to go. They said it might cause resentment between cousins.

We can comfortably afford to send all three kids to private school this year but there's no guarantee we can fund this for all three kids up until they're 18 so we don't want to make this kind of financial commitment. I also find it a bit insulting that my SIL chose not to work as a GP or find an alternative career. Both my husband and I work (although I work only 3 days a week part time - I earn around £120k a year so much less than my husband). Why should we be subsidising their lifestyle so they get the same thing as us when they have a SAHM. My husband has also been on stress leave in the last 12 months and is very overworked. We have been discussing cutting his working days to 3 or 4 days a week but he would not feel comfortable doing this if he has to fund three kids through private school till they're 18.

When we go out together (with in laws) we always settle the whole bill and when we go on holiday we also pick up the bill.

My husband and I make financial decisions jointly so if one of us vetoes then we don't go ahead with the plan. I plan to veto and he is not keen to fund his nephew and niece's school fees either. We help them out here and there. We buy them everything on their wishlist (toys books etc) so it's not like we do not help out.

However, this may of course put my husband in a difficult position with his brother and we are worried they may restrict our access to their children. I am very close to my niece and she misses me terribly when I am too busy to visit her. She sends me voice messages asking me to come.

I feel a bit guilty because I do love her. Should I just suck it up and take on this financial responsibility.

Please note that although my husband earns more than me, I have more assets than him so we have equal say over what we do with our money.

OP posts:
OhwhyOY · 28/06/2023 20:50

Can't you just say 'DH I'd planning to reduce his hours to do 3 days pw as work is getting very busy and stressful. So apologies but we can't make that kind of financial commitment right now.' And leave it at that.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:49

They say things like, look who's the scary controlling iron lady

My husband would be livid if his family said anything like that about me and they wouldn’t be saying it twice.

Has he actually got your back here?

I don’t get why either of you want to have anything to do with any of them except his mum.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/06/2023 20:45

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:43

They say things like, look who's the scary controlling iron lady because my husband earns more than 10x what I earn but I stop him from spending money on them. They ignore the fact that my family home in Wimbledon was gifted by my dad and I have rental properties that I inherited from my granny. I don't like feeling like some kind of gold digger freeloading off my husband when I brought in most of our wealth and it would take him decades to save for the equivalent.

They sound nasty. I wouldn't be able to spend any much time with these people.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:44

Frankly your BIL and SIL sound awful so I wouldn’t give a shit what they think. I’m guessing you don’t see her parents much anyway-you’re not related to them, and they are probably just like her.

What’s your relationship with FIL like?

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:43

They say things like, look who's the scary controlling iron lady because my husband earns more than 10x what I earn but I stop him from spending money on them. They ignore the fact that my family home in Wimbledon was gifted by my dad and I have rental properties that I inherited from my granny. I don't like feeling like some kind of gold digger freeloading off my husband when I brought in most of our wealth and it would take him decades to save for the equivalent.

OP posts:
Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:40

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:39

So if your MiL is lovely and you get on well, who are you referring to here…

But my husband's family think I'm being stingy

Who thinks you are being stingy, @Emotionalstorm ? What are they saying to you?

BIL, SIL, FIL, SIL's parents.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:39

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:35

She tends to just want to avoid conflict and is normally walking around egg shells around my SIL. As a MIL she is lovely. When I am ill she comes over with tupperware of food and wants to look after all of us. She looks after SIL's kids for her 5 days a week. She wanted to do a day for us too but SIL said no so my mum helps out. She generally just does what the SIL wants. She knows I'm not going to give her a hard time so she doesn't prioritize me. I also don't expect anything from her.

So if your MiL is lovely and you get on well, who are you referring to here…

But my husband's family think I'm being stingy

Who thinks you are being stingy, @Emotionalstorm ? What are they saying to you?

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:38

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:33

And Katie and her brother both need houses at university as they can’t live with other people. And deposits on houses which you’ll probably be helping your on child with. Can you stump up for school fees for their kids too-as it’s only fair if you’re paying for your own grandchildren?! It will never stop.

I wouldn’t pick up another bill for them, they sound vile. Your BiL ignoring his own mother suggesting he get a dinner bill shows that he’s as bad as his wife.

Yes I will go with my husband to put a stop to this thus weekend at the family BBQ. When we help I just wish they would understand it's something nice we are doing voluntarily. I feel like I owe SIL money sometimes when I don't.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 28/06/2023 20:36

If I was offered this kind of support from family for my child (I would never ask for it!), I would be looking for a trust fund which covered the fees from the start of the education to the end. As I would not want to put anyone under the stress of having to maintain this on an ongoing basis.

So looking at my local private school which is probably mid ranking outside of London. It's £6000 a term 11+ and £4000 a term 4-11. That would be fees only £126000 plus £84000 total £200,000. Clearly your local figures will be different.

Do you have £300,000 (because inflation etc). you can put aside for your child's eduction first. Then can you comfortably afford to do the same for both of your niblings without detriment to your family? Only then would I consider it. If you do not have that £900,000 to establish these trusts then you cannot afford it without adding pressure to your household- at the likely expense of your husbands health.

I'd say you need to looknat the whole level of support your family is offering your BILs tbh.

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:36

Breezycheesetrees · 28/06/2023 20:34

I voted YABU purely because you describe your husband's £1m+ income as "quite a lot" when surely you know that's a fuck load of money.

Ok it's a lot. It's just how I talk. I put quite or a bit in front of everything. 😂

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 28/06/2023 20:36

OP they wouldn't even be grateful. They just expect.

Imagine expecting a handout to the tune of around £500K, and feel entitled to it.

Fuck them.

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:35

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:30

Once my partner's mum told my BIL that he should take this particular meal since it was at a fish and chip shop and is fairly cheap and he pretended not to hear. My partner couldn't bear it so picked up the bill and paid it

Is your partner’s mum one of the family members who also thinks your DH should pay for their private schooling?

She tends to just want to avoid conflict and is normally walking around egg shells around my SIL. As a MIL she is lovely. When I am ill she comes over with tupperware of food and wants to look after all of us. She looks after SIL's kids for her 5 days a week. She wanted to do a day for us too but SIL said no so my mum helps out. She generally just does what the SIL wants. She knows I'm not going to give her a hard time so she doesn't prioritize me. I also don't expect anything from her.

OP posts:
Potsto · 28/06/2023 20:34

We don't have the same lifestyle as BIL and SIL, because they have better paying jobs and different priorities to us.

Both families have made different educational choices for our children. It never occurred to me that there'd be resentment between the cousins!

Isn't that just life?

Breezycheesetrees · 28/06/2023 20:34

I voted YABU purely because you describe your husband's £1m+ income as "quite a lot" when surely you know that's a fuck load of money.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:33

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/06/2023 20:30

@Emotionalstorm then there's Katie & her brother's uni fees, they want to go to Cambridge by the way. Then they need a first car because your child got one for their 18th birthday and there will be resentment between cousins if you don't buy Katie and her brother a car too. Katie wants a pony too, so there's the coat of that plus livery fees. Then there's Katie's wedding, you need to pay for that too because you have more money than they do. They need to catch themselves on, cheeky fuckers.

And Katie and her brother both need houses at university as they can’t live with other people. And deposits on houses which you’ll probably be helping your on child with. Can you stump up for school fees for their kids too-as it’s only fair if you’re paying for your own grandchildren?! It will never stop.

I wouldn’t pick up another bill for them, they sound vile. Your BiL ignoring his own mother suggesting he get a dinner bill shows that he’s as bad as his wife.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:30

Once my partner's mum told my BIL that he should take this particular meal since it was at a fish and chip shop and is fairly cheap and he pretended not to hear. My partner couldn't bear it so picked up the bill and paid it

Is your partner’s mum one of the family members who also thinks your DH should pay for their private schooling?

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/06/2023 20:30

@Emotionalstorm then there's Katie & her brother's uni fees, they want to go to Cambridge by the way. Then they need a first car because your child got one for their 18th birthday and there will be resentment between cousins if you don't buy Katie and her brother a car too. Katie wants a pony too, so there's the coat of that plus livery fees. Then there's Katie's wedding, you need to pay for that too because you have more money than they do. They need to catch themselves on, cheeky fuckers.

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:28

blackrabbitwhiterabbit · 28/06/2023 19:54

This is mental. Why on earth do they expect you to pay for their dc? Just say no. And stop covering the bill for meals and holidays!

Don't worry I will tell them no. When we go out to eat as a family they never reach for the bill. It gets a bit uncomfortable so me and my partner end up settling it and they never offer to pay us back. Once my partner's mum told my BIL that he should take this particular meal since it was at a fish and chip shop and is fairly cheap and he pretended not to hear. My partner couldn't bear it so picked up the bill and paid it.

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/06/2023 20:28

@Emotionalstorm oh and, it's not just 14 years of school fees for them, there's ALL the extras too, uniforms, school trips...etc. it's non-stop. Think of all the extras involved in sending a child to state school, then multiply it by many. Then if you turn down school trips, the rich kids will tease them etc. It's all a class thing at private school. I am friends with several people who have sent their children to private and it makes me glad we didn't to be honest. That's not me saying you shouldn't, it's just that had we sent ours to private, we'd have been scraping by financially as it was.

Lessonsinbiology · 28/06/2023 20:26

Very entitled behaviour. You make your choice in life and then live within your means. Why should their choices impact you. It would be a no from me. The children aren't entitled to private education. They will only have a problem with your children being private if the parents make it an issue.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 28/06/2023 20:25

Your bil and sil are already benefitting from your generosity, don't let them take the piss. You don't know what's in the future and your dh might decide he can't work.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/06/2023 20:25

@Emotionalstorm your SIL is delusional.

Just ignore all their noise.

Stop letting them become privy to your own financials. Don't discuss your child's schooling with them anymore. Just you do you and keep your own business to yourself. Just to help minimise their noise.

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:24

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 28/06/2023 20:17

They are totally taking advantage of you already and they are not even grateful. What jumped out at me was this:

They think that their kids should also be sent to private school if their cousin gets to go. They said it might cause resentment between cousins.

That's a threat right there. Why would it cause resentment? on the part of the children. More likely on the part of BIL and SIL who would point it out to them. And then the rest of the family wade in with their headshaking and disapproval. Why don't they pay the fees if they are that bothered about it?

Its the threat that you will be resented if you don't just stump up and hand over the cash that I find so repugnant about their "request" and getting the rest of the family to join in too.

You are clearly generous and you love your niece, but you have your own family to think of. Just because times are good now, things could go wrong, sickness, unemployment etc.. And 14 years of fee paying for x number of other people's children is crackers.

The other issue is you say that your DH's health is being affected by his current job and he wants to cut his hours... how much do they care about that?
It means he is providing for two sets of children and this will influence his employment choices and his ability to find a way to make his job less stressful.
Its just not on.

Say no. Firmly and clearly.. I guarantee you will be funding all of them for life. Take the hit and the disapproval.

One alternative thing you could do, is to set up a savings account to build up savings for them for university expenses when they reach 18/20. That would be extremely generous, would grow as the years go by, and would not have such a significant impact on your own lives.

Don't discuss finances with them ever again, even if they ask. They are grabby freeloaders and it would be different if they cared as much about your Dh's health as they do about their holidays, free meals, and school fees.

Yes I would like to help out my niece and nephew if I can in the future with uni fees and maybe her deposit for buying their first property but I want to do it in my own terms. I have been careful not to mention any of this in case it creates expectations. I also think it's more likely to feel entitled to my money rather than treat it as a nice gesture on my part.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 28/06/2023 20:24

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:21

It's really not my BIL. He's not that sort of person. He just does what he's told. It's his wife. She has a very clear plan for everything and when things don't end up exactly the way she wants she gets really depressed and grumpy. My BIL is a bit spineless and never says no. He said he wouldn't take offence but his wife definitely will and we all know who controls access to his children. It isn't him. Her reasoning is just 'its for Katie' (I've changed the name to avoid identification). She thinks we as a family should prioritise her children over everything if we have the money. She's also told me several times that 'Katie's headmaster has said she has great potential for X prestigious private school' and has turned down places at a really good state nursery. At this rate her kid might not get anywhere good and then she will tell us we need to send her to the private school to avoid going to the undesirable one. She thinks that she and her husband should have the same standard of living as us since they are brothers. I have no issue with her having the same thing but I'm worried because this is a lot of money and a long term commitment. I don't want to jeopardize our ability to look after our kids and set them up by making such a promise.

Why are you giving this headspace-honestly she sounds delusional?!

Just say it won’t be happening.

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 20:21

medianewbie · 28/06/2023 15:58

This. You are not ABLE to garuntee that you could fund them until age 18.
Therefore, you can't. Nor should they ask imo.
My Autistic children & I live on state benefits (as I am their Carer & my husband walked off as it was 'too hard'). My BIL&SIL have their own Co & earn the thick end of £1M per annum, (I understand). They give the kids £30 for Bday & Xmas.
Now I appreciate that my circs are not yours but it's just to give an example of the other end of the 'entitlement spectrum'. I don't expect anything from my 'rich' inlaws, so why should your BIL/SIL expect from you as the 'richer' relatives?

It's really not my BIL. He's not that sort of person. He just does what he's told. It's his wife. She has a very clear plan for everything and when things don't end up exactly the way she wants she gets really depressed and grumpy. My BIL is a bit spineless and never says no. He said he wouldn't take offence but his wife definitely will and we all know who controls access to his children. It isn't him. Her reasoning is just 'its for Katie' (I've changed the name to avoid identification). She thinks we as a family should prioritise her children over everything if we have the money. She's also told me several times that 'Katie's headmaster has said she has great potential for X prestigious private school' and has turned down places at a really good state nursery. At this rate her kid might not get anywhere good and then she will tell us we need to send her to the private school to avoid going to the undesirable one. She thinks that she and her husband should have the same standard of living as us since they are brothers. I have no issue with her having the same thing but I'm worried because this is a lot of money and a long term commitment. I don't want to jeopardize our ability to look after our kids and set them up by making such a promise.

OP posts: