Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Responsibility towards niece and nephew

369 replies

Emotionalstorm · 28/06/2023 15:09

I don't know if I'm being unreasonable.

My sister in law is a qualified GP but has chosen not to work because she said that she found the job bad for her mental health. After 6 months of sick leave, she has been a stay at home mum for three years now.

Her husband has failed his medical exams so won't be able to make consultant. His income is around £65k as a trainee doctor and has stagnated. He's also not hungry and won't take locum work for extra pay.

My husband earns quite a lot (more than £1M each year) but it varies based on the profits of the business. He thinks there will be a slowdown in work in the next 12 months so his income may go down.

We are planning to send our daughter to private school in September. SIL caught wind of this and sent her husband over to ask us to help them out because the cost of living crisis is hitting them hard. They think that their kids should also be sent to private school if their cousin gets to go. They said it might cause resentment between cousins.

We can comfortably afford to send all three kids to private school this year but there's no guarantee we can fund this for all three kids up until they're 18 so we don't want to make this kind of financial commitment. I also find it a bit insulting that my SIL chose not to work as a GP or find an alternative career. Both my husband and I work (although I work only 3 days a week part time - I earn around £120k a year so much less than my husband). Why should we be subsidising their lifestyle so they get the same thing as us when they have a SAHM. My husband has also been on stress leave in the last 12 months and is very overworked. We have been discussing cutting his working days to 3 or 4 days a week but he would not feel comfortable doing this if he has to fund three kids through private school till they're 18.

When we go out together (with in laws) we always settle the whole bill and when we go on holiday we also pick up the bill.

My husband and I make financial decisions jointly so if one of us vetoes then we don't go ahead with the plan. I plan to veto and he is not keen to fund his nephew and niece's school fees either. We help them out here and there. We buy them everything on their wishlist (toys books etc) so it's not like we do not help out.

However, this may of course put my husband in a difficult position with his brother and we are worried they may restrict our access to their children. I am very close to my niece and she misses me terribly when I am too busy to visit her. She sends me voice messages asking me to come.

I feel a bit guilty because I do love her. Should I just suck it up and take on this financial responsibility.

Please note that although my husband earns more than me, I have more assets than him so we have equal say over what we do with our money.

OP posts:
MIBnightmare · 28/06/2023 15:51

Another one asking if this is a cultural expectation ? It is the only thing I can think of that makes this request even a tiny bit 'normal' ... or perhaps the business your DH earns such a fabulous income from was maybe a 'family business' that he inherited as the eldest and somehow feels he 'owes' his brother some of the income ?

If either of the above..

My response would be that we could possibly help towards the fees occasionally BUT only if SIL got a job to cover the lions share . Because with her qualifications it shouldn't be hard.

Put the onus back on them .

Fraaahnces · 28/06/2023 15:51

Hell no! Why should BIL be hungry when you pay for everything? SIL doesn’t need to work to contribute to his salary because YOU do. Tell them their kids had better start studying because they’re going to need to apply for scholarships if they haven’t got their shit together. *Also, stop subsidizing them. Cousins aren’t the same as siblings. You are not obliged to equalize the lifestyles that their parents have no intention of supporting.

clarebear111 · 28/06/2023 15:50

That they have asked this seems completely unreasonable to me. It sounds like it would be an enormous burden for you and your DH to take on for the best part of 20 years. And what's to say they wouldn't expect you to pay their tuition fees at uni too? Or help with a deposit for a house? I don't think you can say anything but no tbh.

standardduck · 28/06/2023 15:44

That's really cheeky.

You should definitely not commit to paying for their private education.

Chocolateship · 28/06/2023 15:43

I'd say you should be assessing your finances and considering what you'd do if your DH had to give up work if he's prone to going off with stress. I certainly don't think you should be splashing the cash although your DHs choice should hold a lot of weight as it's his family and he earns a significant amount more.

WeWereInParis · 28/06/2023 15:42

Honestly I wouldn't even consider doing this.

Krickley · 28/06/2023 15:42

Cheeky beggers! No absolutely not. Sounds like you pay for far too much as it is!! SIL needs to get a job. Living the life of riley

Spidey66 · 28/06/2023 15:41

Sorry the point of my post was in our family, 2 kids got the independent education and the other 2 the comprehensive. So why should cousins get the same education?

ColdHandsHotHead · 28/06/2023 15:40

*they weren't

Nordicrain · 28/06/2023 15:40

I think it's fine, sensible in fact, to say no.

But I wonder if your reasoning is the source of the bad reactions. You seem to mainly be concerned about them getting what you have. It's not a competition you know.

ColdHandsHotHead · 28/06/2023 15:39

I doubt your children's cousins would resent it if your kids were educated privately and they were, but obviously your SIL would. Just who the fuck does she think she is, to demand your husband fund her children's education while she herself doesn't work?

Spidey66 · 28/06/2023 15:38

My older brothers went to an independent school on an Assisted Places Scheme. They then went to Oxford and Durham. One in particular earns £££ in finance. The other's a state primary school teacher, so is OK but not rich.

By the time me and my sister started secondary school, the council had stopped it, so we went to a comprehensive. We're both doing OK, I'm a nurse (but did my training pre diploma/degree so I didn't go to uni) and my sister after working for a few years did a degree in Hospitality. Her college had just changed from a poly to a university so wasn't as prestigious as Oxford or Durham.

This bothered our parents far more than it bothered us, the two youngest, and girls in particular, getting the "inferior" education. I've never been bothered, I'm not particularly academic and wanted to go to the comprehensive! I can't speak for my sister, but she's never brought it up (if she was upset by it, she would have said so.) It was just one of those things, timing etc. I reckon I would have been miserable at an independent school tbh, I'd worry I was l letting people down by not making the most of it.

(Plus unlike my brothers I've got a strong London accent and would have felt out of place....imagine Kat Slater being privately educated and you get my drift!

LiOLeary · 28/06/2023 15:37

TheGreenSketch · 28/06/2023 15:30

@LiOLeary why does she sound insufferable to you?

"chosen not to work because she said that she found the job bad for her mental health" ... "My husband has also been on stress leave in the last 12 months and is very overworked"

As I said she's not being unreasonable, but she clearly has a double standard where the SIL is "saying" she has mental health issues but her huband "actually" does.

babbscrabbs · 28/06/2023 15:36

How old are the DC?

TheCatterall · 28/06/2023 15:36

@Emotionalstorm yanbu in not helping them live a lifestyle beyond their means when behind closed doors you have your own worries especially about the sustainability of their suggestion.

you said it yourself that DH is often bailing out his brother - maybe that needs to stop now and this is where it ends.

I reckon the only folks bothered will be the top good too work in laws not the children.

Stand firm. This is a no. You have other things to consider beyond finances and they don’t need to know it all.

Lesssugarketchup · 28/06/2023 15:35

I would wager a lot you don’t get on with the sil

banjaxxed · 28/06/2023 15:35

I don't think it's relevant if you earn a million, 2 million or 20 million and could fund the lot with small change

Not your responsibility

'No. We won't be doing that'

Their family made a lifestyle choice. They live with the consequences of that

Quietasamouuse · 28/06/2023 15:35

Other options are to offer to pay a % towards the school fees and limit it in time to primary only (put this in writing). Or perhaps consider helping for secondary education when your financial position is more secure.

But ultimately it comes down to whether you want to do this and/or whether you can afford to give help should your DH have a drop in salary.

Greentree1 · 28/06/2023 15:32

I think it's a real cheek to ask, is it GPs wanting the same for all their GCs and saying you should pay?

If things were reversed would they be happy to pay for your children? It's like you giving your BiL/SiL an extra income every month, why should you. And what about extras if the cousins want all the extra curricular things, music lessons, trips abroad, extra tuition, etc, it could become a bottomless pit.

If you can afford it you could offer a lump sum as a contribution and say that's it. Once that's gone they have to earn the money themselves, like everyone else. Although I bet they would come back for more!

Lesssugarketchup · 28/06/2023 15:32

SIL caught wind of this and sent her husband over to ask us to help them out because the cost of living crisis is hitting them hard

sounds like the men in this family need to get themselves a spine

although… how do you know he didn’t do it if his own accord?

OneInEight · 28/06/2023 15:31

Why stop at your nephew and niece. Sure some distant cousins would love to have their children educated privately as well.

tortiecat · 28/06/2023 15:31

They're cheeky fuckers to even ask you and your DH.

Lesssugarketchup · 28/06/2023 15:31

It would be nothing short of reckless and irresponsible for all concerned for you to agree to this

TheGreenSketch · 28/06/2023 15:30

@LiOLeary why does she sound insufferable to you?

Lesssugarketchup · 28/06/2023 15:30

Potential fall out sounds like it would be a good thing

Bloody hell I feel sorry for your DH

Mind you - bit of a limp lettuce