Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I speak some home truths?

111 replies

Clareanscombe1964 · 28/06/2023 13:51

Before I get into this story I should prefix that at different periods of time I’ve really struggled with bad relationships and money so what I’m about to say is not meant to seem judgemental at all.
There is a mum of a child in my dad class at school, the children are pretty good friends. We got chatting one time before Christmas and the topic of presents came up where became apparent quite quickly that she was struggling to get her child gifts and that by comparison we were in a fortunate position to be able to buy things for ours. The conversation honestly made me feel really bad and it was a prompt for me to reevaluate the meaning of gifts. Anyway it was after this that she asked me to go food shopping with her to keep her company. All the way round she was hinting that she couldn’t afford the shopping and she how she was so
worried she couldn’t cover it. I felt at the time trying to guilt me into paying for it. I was left a little annoyed.
regardless she asked me to lend her some
money to help with food, a few weeks later and as I could I did. But the messages
for money have increased and on more than one occasion have made less sense. In context I’ve given her probably 500
now. But I would send her 120 only to get a message two days later saying she had no
food again. I’ve had to stop as we are also feeling the squeeze and need to prioritise my kids. She promised a small
amount back, which is the only
part I’ve asked for due to
my phone bill, it didn’t come which left me
with late payments to manage. I feel pretty used and am
left thinking there’s more to this than simply money worries, to go through that much cash in a short period. She has a boyfriend living with her which without going into
detail, he’s contributing nothing, won’t look for work but is happy to eat all the food and take money from her account that was meant for bills. My previous caveat re relationships was important as I know how hard they can be but she’s openly said she’s not afraid to tell him to go. I said to her that he is happy to take take take so that her son basically goes hungry but she is also
guilty of allowing it to continue.
the last random request was that her sister was in trouble and she needed money for a taxi to go and help her. I said no.
But what’s really annoyed me is that her bf sister is staying with them and this morning they were asking for food from the school for apparently her son. Not only do I feel
mugged off but there are also
other kids struggling and knowing there is Something amiss here with the money I’m frustrated she’s taking resources away from
others. To be honest I want to block her but feel uneasy due to the kids friendship group. I don’t know if it’s drugs or what but something is going on and feel she needs some home truths. Am i being unreasonable?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 15/08/2023 10:47

Don't give the woman any more money.
If you must, give the child a sandwich or fruit if you are nearbyorbake the odd biscuits.

You could research charities or banks that offer free financial/budgeting help and attend that with your friend.
It would be great if the boyfriend would also attend and he might learn about supporting himself by mowing lawns or bringing in some contribution.
Also seek lists of places where she can access seconds canned food and misshaped vegies etc.

rainbowstardrops · 15/08/2023 10:25

I thought they're probably spending it on drugs too. I'd definitely raise concerns with the school or SS.

beeswaxinc · 15/08/2023 10:23

So sorry OP.

My sister is in this position and it's drug abuse. The asking for relatively large sums of money for "food" only for it to be gone in a couple of days (with only 2 adults and a DC) is exactly their situation. Sponging cuckoo of a boyfriend coming into the home to take advantage of the vulnerable situation. Awful.

My mum had to cut her off mostly from lending money and it seems to be the only thing that has helped her get relatively back on track.

Pressthespacebar · 15/08/2023 10:07

I would guess she’s on coke tbh. Stop giving her money.

jlpth · 15/08/2023 10:04

You’ve been kind, she’s a scammer.
It’s common - mums with little kids aren’t threatening and can easily pretend that they can’t afford stuff and tug on your heart strings as there’s a kid involved.

Basically, you need to write off all the money you’ve lent/given - none is coming back. If you see her in person, just be polite, don’t say anything personal. Just chat about the weather. I wouldn’t even say she’s made your phone bill late. I wouldn’t reply to any messages asking for help - it’s all lies - just ignore.

And you won’t be the only person she’s scoring money from. You’ll probably fine she has some nice stuff in her house - better than you could afford. She’s just a lying piece of shit and gives people who are really in poverty and really need help a bad reputation. This child is already known to SS so I’d leave them well alone. Kids can socialise at school, that’s it.

Zodfa · 15/08/2023 09:58

I met a beggar once, said she needed £10 for the bus home, then suddenly it was £20, then £30 ... Of course I just walked away

Someone telling you they've spent £120 on food and are going hungry three days later is in the same category. It just isn't believable.

Grimbelina · 15/08/2023 09:52

ZairWazAnOldLady
She’s stolen £500 from her child’s friends mother. She really doesn’t have any morals. Ask to see the safeguarding person at your child’s school. Tell them you want to tell them something because you are worried about a child but you don’t want to discuss it or hear what happens and you understand you have been foolish. Explain the child may be hungry and how much and when you have given money. Thank them and leave. Dont give her any money again for anything.

This. You have been naive and/or foolish. If you genuinely have concerns about the child's welfare then report to safeguarding and SS. Obviously don't give her another penny.

redactle · 15/08/2023 09:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

orangegato · 15/08/2023 09:46

YABU for giving her money. Short term solution she needs to sort her life and lazy arse partner out. £500 from you does fuck all but kick the can of reality down the road.

Florawest · 15/08/2023 09:46

You seem a lovely kind and considerate generous person who unfortunately got taken advantage of.

But you did what you thought was the right thing ( having experiences something similar to that woman and shame on her, her lump of a boyfriend and sister. The poor child in all this.

Do not give her anymore, hope her child will be ok and services will step in ( as badly needed). Definitely say can you pay the money back as have few unexpected bills.

Terrible how vulnerable innocent children are made to suffer at the hands of so called parent/s.

Fallingthroughclouds · 15/08/2023 09:41

You've been really generous and so kind hearted. Tell her you can't lend her any more money as you simply can't afford it, you've given her a lot already and you hope she gets her finances sorted out. I wouldn't tell her any home truths as who knows what this could unleash.

Zimunya · 15/08/2023 09:31

Landndialamrhf · 28/06/2023 15:37

I voted YABU because you’re focusing on entirely the wrong things

But what’s really annoyed me is that her bf sister is staying with them and this morning they were asking for food from the school for apparently her son. Not only do I feel
mugged off but there are also
other kids struggling and knowing there is Something amiss here with the money I’m frustrated she’s taking resources away from
others. To be honest I want to block her but feel uneasy due to the kids friendship group. I don’t know if it’s drugs or what but something is going on and feel she needs some home truths.
not one part of this is relevant. and you don’t need to do any home truths.
you need to stop giving her money.
just stop.
you don’t need to tell other people how to live their lives. You need to stop giving people money.
Especially when it leaves you short.

Agreed. Not your business how she lives her life. It is your business whether you give her money or not. That's the only part of this you have control over.

1967buglet · 15/08/2023 09:19

I had a friend start doing this to me. My dad was a landlord and even gave her a place to stay at very reduced rent. She lived upstairs in the house where there were two flats, I lived downstairs. She started not paying rent, or paying part of it, and it and very late. She was asking for money from me. I was a grad student and didn’t have a deal and was living on student loans and a couple part time jobs. This went on about 2 years, as she had a baby, and father was nowhere to be found. She was in a bad spot, and we wanted to help. I had known my friend for some time, so assumed that after a bad patch, she would pull it together. But that didn’t happen.

My dad told me after two years or this, honey, I can’t keep subsidising her, as this is part of my income too (he was retired), and she needs to stand on her own feet now. The other tenant had moved out because he didn’t like being disturbed by the baby crying at night, so my dad was losing a lot of money. He told me that she needs to pay something and you need to talk to her, or she is going to have to leave. My dad was living in another state, so I had to be the one to break the news.

I finally said to her,look, I value our friendship, but I’m not a bank. I don’t have a lot of my money myself, so I can’t lend you anymore. And you at least need to pay the very reduced rent as this is part of my dad’s retirement income. Her mother was well off, and I said maybe you should stay with her, or ask her for some help? Maybe you need to get your daughter’s dad to contribute? Can you get some help from social services (this was in the States, so it is admittedly more difficult there).

Nothing happened after another few months, I brought it up again and was ignored. Finally my dad came up and had a talk with her, and she moved out to stay with her mum. Needless to say, I never heard from my friend again, nor did we get any money back from her.

Lesson learnt about setting more boundaries.

NewNextOfKin · 15/08/2023 09:18

It is possible for someone to be simultaneously vulnerable and manipulative.

Therealjudgejudy · 15/08/2023 09:18

You are being scammed. She is a grifter...

Fraaahnces · 15/08/2023 09:16

Start hassling HER for money. “I can’t pay my electricity bill. Could really do with the £500 I’ve lent you.”

backtogrey · 15/08/2023 09:12

You’re being scammed by a total sponger.

JustEatTheOneInTheBallPit · 15/08/2023 09:07

OP, I had a friend whom I met in my first part time job when we were both sixth form age. Over the years, our lives went in different directions but we remained fast friends. We always had so much to talk about and she was always so kind and (I thought) generous.

I studied and worked really hard and in my thirties, I landed a fab job and my husband and I bought a lovely home for us and our kids. I think it was at this point that my friend became grabby. I think it was because she could see with her own eyes how well I was doing.

I’m trying not to denigrate her lifestyle, but it was so different to mine and, as we both had children, the divergence in our ideals and choices just became more and more obvious. But still, we retained something of a friendship. Only… she kept asking me for money. Repaying small amounts and then asking for more.

It never prevented me from paying my own bills, because I was in a very fortunate position. But, at the end, she owed me £500 - like yourself.

By this stage in our lives, I had a lot of “home truths” I wanted to share with her. About money, school attendance, drugs, kids, boyfriends… it was all just coming from a place of wanting my recompense. A pound of flesh in place of my hard earned cash. Worthless words!

I wrote the money off and said nothing. It was the strongest message.

First she messaged me asking for another £20. Ignored. Then again. Message more desperate now - about her kids and bailiffs. I ignored this too. A few days later she messaged to ask me over for coffee. I responded and said yes and she asked me to bring her some cigarettes when I came. So I ignored and didn’t go.

A few weeks later she sent me an apology and £70 to my bank. I still ignored her. That was the last I ever heard of her.

I walked away from that decades-long friendship £428 worse off. But I could still be “friends” with her now, and owed £3,000 if I hadn’t wised up!

My story is supposed to demonstrate that the best way to deal with this is to write the money off and say nothing. No words will actually make the blindest bit of difference. And, the longer you keep this line of communication open, the more open to manipulation you are.

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 15/08/2023 09:05

She won’t give a shit if you tell her home truths or cut her out of your life. That sort are totally thick-skinned, and she will just move on to the next target.

Bumcake · 15/08/2023 08:52

FedUpMumof10YO · 15/08/2023 06:20

No is a complete sentence. You don't owe anyone false reasons or explanations. You can just say no.

Exactly! No need to tell her you’re hard up, it’s none of her business.

There are three adults in that house, if they cannot feed one kid it’s because he’s not a priority to them and no amount of income will change that sadly.

ichifanny · 15/08/2023 08:49

I wouldn’t tell her she doesn’t need to pay you back , I’d let her think she does if only to stop her asking for more , but I’d write it off on my head as gone . What a manipulative free loader , asking you to come shopping with her is chilling.

BellaJuno · 15/08/2023 08:33

Jenjen21 · 15/08/2023 08:27

Next time she asks say "oh actually I was going to ask you for the money you owed me as I'm broke myself"

Was just about to post similar. Next time she asks, say “Actually I could do with you starting to pay back the £500 I’ve lent you as things are starting to get tight here, here’s my bank details if you want to set up a standing order……” (obviously with no expectation you’ll see a penny).

Jenjen21 · 15/08/2023 08:27

Next time she asks say "oh actually I was going to ask you for the money you owed me as I'm broke myself"

FireflyJar · 15/08/2023 08:25

She is using the child to pull at your heart strings. Just say you aren't prepared to give her money. Tell her to get a cleaning job if she needs cash. She wont be dropping £15 on a taxi if it takes her an hour to earn it will she?
She is scrounging off you like her BF is scrounging off her

Sunshineboo · 15/08/2023 08:25

Meeting · 28/06/2023 15:30

I'd send her a very clear message, if you lose the 'friendship' then so be it. It doesn't seem much of a friendship anyway.

-Hi X, I'm not going to ask you to pay back what you owe me, but I'm no longer going to give you any money for any reason. Please don't ask me again as moving forwards.-

this.