Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone here actually thinks a step parents wage should be considered for CMS?

258 replies

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 10:45

Because my husband's ex seems to think so and is currently enraged that I have zero plan or requirement to.

I'm fully aware that CMS do not take into account a SPs earnings and that legally she is not entitled to anything from my wages. I'm just curious as to whether more people think like her (entitled as imo) that they should take it into account.

YANBU - no it's right that CMS don't take into account a step parents earnings

YABU - they don't but they should.

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 28/06/2023 12:31

I don’t think step parents income should be taken in to account at all. Their actual parents should financially support them.

I also don’t think resident step children should be relevant to CMS payments, if the NRP is in a relationship with someone with children, or goes on to have more children.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/06/2023 12:30

Usernamenotavailab · 28/06/2023 12:27

if the nrp becomes a sahm parent though, he could do all the school runs etc enabling the rp to work full time

why is that never considered? As dh is such a low earner we did suggest it, but ex didn’t want to up her hours from 16/week, even if childcare was taken care of and she would have increased her earnings by far more than she’d lose in CMS.

So because you and your husband have decided he shouldn’t work you think she should up her hours instead.
not saying that she shouldn’t be working more to support her children but you can’t make a decision based on what’s best on your household and try and push it on her.

SemperIdem · 28/06/2023 12:29

ApplesInTheSunshine · 28/06/2023 11:51

You decided to get together with someone who had children.

Therefore you take them on as your own and should contribute towards them when they’re at yours and hers, because they are now part of your family.

You’re deluded.

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:28

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

That is atrocious. I am so sorry to hear about your husband. His ex should be utterly ashamed of herself.

OP posts:
PositiveLife · 28/06/2023 12:28

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

That's awful. I think the whole system is not working properly. I've seen lots of reviews saying that the RP gets believed over the NRP (though that's not been my experience)

funinthesun19 · 28/06/2023 12:27

No it shouldn’t.

Until the RP’s partner’s earnings are considered too and it becomes a figure taking in to account everybody, then no way should the NRP’s partner’s income be included.

None of the RP’s business how much the stepmum earns.

I say this as both an RP/single mum/providing everything for my children AND an ex stepmum.

Usernamenotavailab · 28/06/2023 12:27

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:17

I'm not sure what to do in the case of female non custodial parents having more children and staying at home but I think one idea would be, to be like universal credit and have the expectation that they will start work around age three 🤔 and pick it back up from there....maybe

I don't think it should be any different for male and females surely? Whether or not the NRP is male or female should be irrelevant, they should still be paying for their first children and if they cannot do that and be a SAHP to any new children, then they can't afford to be a SAHP.

if the nrp becomes a sahm parent though, he could do all the school runs etc enabling the rp to work full time

why is that never considered? As dh is such a low earner we did suggest it, but ex didn’t want to up her hours from 16/week, even if childcare was taken care of and she would have increased her earnings by far more than she’d lose in CMS.

LorW · 28/06/2023 12:25

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

I’m so sorry, that’s horrific 😔

CadMan · 28/06/2023 12:23

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

That’s horrific.

PositiveLife · 28/06/2023 12:21

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 12:05

Ways to make it fair without taking into account the step parents wages

Stop deduction for non bio children you had children pay for them

No reduction for future children again your choice first families should not be disadvantaged by second

Where the non custodial parent has quit work and become a stay at home parent to children that arnt theirs the child support should continue as previously set

Where a parent repeatedly stops and starts work to keep their contribution down sanctions should include the continuous payment of child support set while they are working

I'm not sure what to do in the case of female non custodial parents having more children and staying at home but I think one idea would be, to be like universal credit and have the expectation that they will start work around age three 🤔 and pick it back up from there....maybe

I also think a lot more should be done about self employed people and people clearly mis declaring their income for example my ex drives a new car but he claims it as his girlfriend's car its in her name etc etc except she can't drive and isn't having lessons its CLEARLY his car can't prove it apparently common sense isn't proof

^this

I think a lot needs to be done around the self employment type of stuff.

Also assets. My ex-h has assets that he should pay some extra maintenance on, according to the CMS rules. However the only way to get the additional money is for me to provide the proof - I have no idea how I'm expected to get the paperwork to prove it.

I generally don't expect a step parent's income to be taken into account (though I'd hope they treated the kids as theirs when they are with them) but I'd make an exception for the cases where the parent was living solely off the step parent's income.

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

frazzledasarock · 28/06/2023 12:20

Absolutely not. Ex barely pays CMS anyway. His current wife should not be paying for his previous DC. Altho I do think their combined income should be considered before discounting the amount he pays for his older dc, as his having more dc doesn’t mean my dc need less financial support from the pittance I’m able to get from him.

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:19

It definitely shouldn't be reduced if a man moves in with a woman's children. Definitely not.

OP posts:
TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:19

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/06/2023 12:17

I think the current system is too rigid.

So generally I think a step parents income shouldn’t be included, but it the NRP is saying their contribution should come down due to step kids or additional children living in the house, then yes it should be factored in.

I think there should also be attention paid to deliberate reduction of income by NRPs, including by making the step parent the bread winner and NRP being a SAHP to younger kids so that they have zero income for their older kids maintenance.

So it depends.

I definitely agree there are already scenarios in the current systems which are unfair / hypocritical. I don't think you'll ever have a perfect system where no one ever takes the piss or finds loop holes though unfortunately.

I don't think just because some deadbeats become a SAHP to avoid maintenance, then all step parents the country over should have their income considered though.

OP posts:
TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:17

I'm not sure what to do in the case of female non custodial parents having more children and staying at home but I think one idea would be, to be like universal credit and have the expectation that they will start work around age three 🤔 and pick it back up from there....maybe

I don't think it should be any different for male and females surely? Whether or not the NRP is male or female should be irrelevant, they should still be paying for their first children and if they cannot do that and be a SAHP to any new children, then they can't afford to be a SAHP.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/06/2023 12:17

I think the current system is too rigid.

So generally I think a step parents income shouldn’t be included, but it the NRP is saying their contribution should come down due to step kids or additional children living in the house, then yes it should be factored in.

I think there should also be attention paid to deliberate reduction of income by NRPs, including by making the step parent the bread winner and NRP being a SAHP to younger kids so that they have zero income for their older kids maintenance.

So it depends.

CadMan · 28/06/2023 12:15

I don’t think it’s fair that CMS is reduced if a NRP moves in with someone else’s children, though.

And the calculations for student loans isn’t great either.

CadMan · 28/06/2023 12:14

The only way this could work would be if it was half the current percentage ie 8% of dual-income household’s income rather than 16% of NRP’s income. And in that scenario many children would probably get less as it’d incorporate non-working or part-time second wives (more of those around than breadwinner new wives).

It’d be an administrative nightmare to vary in this way but I do think whether CMS is enough is largely dependent on the child(ren)‘s age. Nursery and teenage = often not enough; primary age = often more than enough.

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:14

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 11:54

Except if a "dad" moved in with you and your children he would get his child support reduced because he would be paying towards raising your children this disadvantages his bio children who now have 1- 1/2 parents paying for the non bio children who now have 2 1/2 parents paying

It's all weighted in the favour of the non custodial parent

I don't agree with that either.

OP posts:
Screwballs · 28/06/2023 12:13

Fuck no, I already spend my money on them, plus half the household we have to have to accommodate them instead of the 1 bed flat i'd be happy with, am I fuck willing to have my wage considered so their mother gets even more. And on that basis, if she meets someone, surely his income should be accounted for in terms of what their household can afford to reduce the liability. If my wage should be considered, why shouldnt his.

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 12:08

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 11:46

I would possibly agree with this in exceptional circumstances as long as there was no obligation for the stepparent to be the one to pay it - the parent should. And I'd want the receiving parents actual needs to be taken into account.

It's for the child, the receiving parent could be a millionaire but the CHILD is still entitled to support from both parents

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 12:05

Ways to make it fair without taking into account the step parents wages

Stop deduction for non bio children you had children pay for them

No reduction for future children again your choice first families should not be disadvantaged by second

Where the non custodial parent has quit work and become a stay at home parent to children that arnt theirs the child support should continue as previously set

Where a parent repeatedly stops and starts work to keep their contribution down sanctions should include the continuous payment of child support set while they are working

I'm not sure what to do in the case of female non custodial parents having more children and staying at home but I think one idea would be, to be like universal credit and have the expectation that they will start work around age three 🤔 and pick it back up from there....maybe

I also think a lot more should be done about self employed people and people clearly mis declaring their income for example my ex drives a new car but he claims it as his girlfriend's car its in her name etc etc except she can't drive and isn't having lessons its CLEARLY his car can't prove it apparently common sense isn't proof

Sceptre86 · 28/06/2023 11:58

In general no. The only exception is that if the dad becomes a sahp and has no income. That might work for his relationship with a current partner (perhaps if she is a higher earner or for childcare reasons) but his older children don't stop existing and would still need expenses to be met. At that point I think the stepparents income should be considered and they should think carefully about the whole family including step kids.

lieselotte · 28/06/2023 11:56

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 11:29

What about when mum decides not to work and lives of maintenance/benefits

You can't do anything about benefits, but I see no reason why an ex should pay maintenance for their ex-partner except if eg they are in their 60s and haven't worked because they were facilitating the ex-s career. Otherwise they can get out there and get a job like the rest of us do (with the ex paying towards childcare).

As for the kids, no, you should not take into account a step parent's earnings. You are responsible for your own kids and should pay accordingly.

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 11:54

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 10:56

Well obviously if people choose to do it then that's different and kudos to them. But I certainly don't think it should be law/mandated. At the end of the day my husband and his ex made his children and should be responsible for them (in the main), just like me and him are responsible for our children, I don't have a random 3rd party helping to fund my kids!

Except if a "dad" moved in with you and your children he would get his child support reduced because he would be paying towards raising your children this disadvantages his bio children who now have 1- 1/2 parents paying for the non bio children who now have 2 1/2 parents paying

It's all weighted in the favour of the non custodial parent