Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone here actually thinks a step parents wage should be considered for CMS?

258 replies

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 10:45

Because my husband's ex seems to think so and is currently enraged that I have zero plan or requirement to.

I'm fully aware that CMS do not take into account a SPs earnings and that legally she is not entitled to anything from my wages. I'm just curious as to whether more people think like her (entitled as imo) that they should take it into account.

YANBU - no it's right that CMS don't take into account a step parents earnings

YABU - they don't but they should.

OP posts:
Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:19

@veryfluffyfluff the 1st family's needs needs aren't trumped though and I know this is uncomfortable for you to hear but it is true the question OP is asking. Other women shouldn't be paying for other people's kids despite being a higher/lower earners.

People going on to create more kids whilst the 1st family is left for mum to support the household solely. Trumping needs? Hardly because 2 incomes and 2 people able to juggle childcare between them is harding trumping the new family's needs.

Daleksatemyshed · 28/06/2023 14:17

@CadMan yes, if Dad left the marriage without much money he's not going to be to buy a place to see the DC, his CM goes up if he can't do overnights and Mum never gets a break. Different of course if he earns really well

funinthesun19 · 28/06/2023 14:16

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:07

@funinthesun19 your post is a contradiction within itself. The first set of kids need to be provided for still so if CMS is a "struggle" which is a bit piss poor considering the rates are low ultimately it means perhaps the person shouldn't of gone on to have more kids in the first place.

I’m not contradicting myself. Where did I say in this example that the NRP is struggling to pay it? I didn’t. You’re making that bit up. I’m saying that that household shouldn’t have less and then struggle by the partner topping it up.

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 14:13

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:07

@funinthesun19 your post is a contradiction within itself. The first set of kids need to be provided for still so if CMS is a "struggle" which is a bit piss poor considering the rates are low ultimately it means perhaps the person shouldn't of gone on to have more kids in the first place.

The first kids do not trump the child of the new family.

Once a child exists it is pretty cruel and nasty to be saying it shouldn't.

CadMan · 28/06/2023 14:08

Daleksatemyshed · 28/06/2023 14:05

Regardless of the ethics of making SP's pay CM , I could see it affecting a lot of relationships. A woman takes on a man with DC, he lives in her house and she's prepared to carry more of the financial load but then being asked to pay CM too? If it was only for married couples some of the high earning women would refuse to marry, if it was for partners too then would they just live apart?

Yes. And ultimately the children lose out, because their quality of life with their NRP is significantly lower than it would be if he remarried.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:07

@funinthesun19 your post is a contradiction within itself. The first set of kids need to be provided for still so if CMS is a "struggle" which is a bit piss poor considering the rates are low ultimately it means perhaps the person shouldn't of gone on to have more kids in the first place.

Daleksatemyshed · 28/06/2023 14:05

Regardless of the ethics of making SP's pay CM , I could see it affecting a lot of relationships. A woman takes on a man with DC, he lives in her house and she's prepared to carry more of the financial load but then being asked to pay CM too? If it was only for married couples some of the high earning women would refuse to marry, if it was for partners too then would they just live apart?

funinthesun19 · 28/06/2023 14:03

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:01

@funinthesun19 I don't really understand your post. Firstly you have to address the person whoever has gone on and created a second family. Surely?

Why have more children in the first place?

Well maybe they can afford to have more children, but it would be a struggle if the new partner pays towards maintenance? So just don’t pay towards the maintenance and have a baby instead. What do you not get?

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 14:02

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:01

@funinthesun19 I don't really understand your post. Firstly you have to address the person whoever has gone on and created a second family. Surely?

Why have more children in the first place?

Because children are a joy to treasure?

CadMan · 28/06/2023 14:02

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 13:59

If you want more money from that household then there is less for your child when your child goes to stay in their other home, because it went to you instead. totally agree with this point. My SDC have to share a room at their mums they get one each. If they want to start taking my income into consideration then they'll be relegated to sleeping on the floor in the living room as we'd have to downsize.

I expect this is the case for the majority. Stepparents are already subsidising and improving the lives of the SC in the non-resident home. The RP gets child benefits, other benefits and social housing consideration for the children; the NRP doesn’t even if they have them three nights a week.

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 14:02

If anything part of the reason why I work so hard and do a well paid job instead of scaling back and spending more time with my child is because DH has to pay maintenance so the household pot has less. If my income was being taken into account I'd go part time or divorce and she wouldn't get any of my cash.

funinthesun19 · 28/06/2023 14:01

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 13:59

If you want more money from that household then there is less for your child when your child goes to stay in their other home, because it went to you instead. totally agree with this point. My SDC have to share a room at their mums they get one each. If they want to start taking my income into consideration then they'll be relegated to sleeping on the floor in the living room as we'd have to downsize.

Exactly. If your own money goes to her then you have less money as a household to provide a big enough home for the children when they stay.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 14:01

@funinthesun19 I don't really understand your post. Firstly you have to address the person whoever has gone on and created a second family. Surely?

Why have more children in the first place?

veryfluffyfluff · 28/06/2023 13:59

If you want more money from that household then there is less for your child when your child goes to stay in their other home, because it went to you instead. totally agree with this point. My SDC have to share a room at their mums they get one each. If they want to start taking my income into consideration then they'll be relegated to sleeping on the floor in the living room as we'd have to downsize.

MavisBeacon1234 · 28/06/2023 13:58

I would 100% divorce my DH if I had to pay a penny to his ex wife. Why should I work extremely hard for her to be allowed to sit in her arse all day? Fuck that!

funinthesun19 · 28/06/2023 13:55

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 13:08

I hope I've not misunderstood your post if I have I will apologise now. The issue is once you have a family one person A and it doesn't work out people seem to casually go on and meet person B which is fine but then they pop out more kids. I don't want to cause offence to anybody.... but family A was on the scene first honestly I would be utterly fucked off if DS dad went on to have more children AND then expect me to have sympathy for him because he now has family B to provide for which is optionally choose to put himself in that situation.

Can you see my point?

I’m talking in terms of the NRP’s partner. Not the NRP. Family A needs providing for, but that’s on the parents to sort out. That’s what maintenance from the NRP is for, and I fully support that.

My point was that the NRP’s household might not have a good standard of living if the partner is also sending money to the ex too. Or subsidising the maintenance payment through her paying more on other bills etc.. That would still be technically her paying towards the maintenance and ultimately less money going in to that household as a result. Why should she go out to work just live like that? And why should her own children have less money to live on because their mum is providing another woman with their money? And it also then becomes a problem when the SC come to stay, doesn’t it? As I said, you can’t have it all ways. If you want more money from that household then there is less for your child when your child goes to stay in their other home, because it went to you instead. 🤷🏼‍♀️

My post wasn’t about the NRP getting out of paying maintenance. It’s about other people not paying it.

CadMan · 28/06/2023 13:55

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 13:49

@CadMan when @mindutopia agreed to have her 2nd child though and she would of been aware of the joint cost together as she was in a relationship. When sc are created the bio parents have no control over the matter.... but the first set of kids still need paying for why should they suffer?

Because when you split up, you stop having a say in your ex’s reproductive rights. Otherwise, should the NRP be able to block the RP from having another baby? That’ll affect the existing children too and mean less is spent on them.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 13:49

@CadMan when @mindutopia agreed to have her 2nd child though and she would of been aware of the joint cost together as she was in a relationship. When sc are created the bio parents have no control over the matter.... but the first set of kids still need paying for why should they suffer?

putthatdownsteve · 28/06/2023 13:45

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 13:43

@putthatdownsteve God I know you can't judge a book by its cover but he sounds awful. As if he was a Cardiologist too I feel sick just reading your post.. I've worked previously in that area. Absolutely shocking you deserved every penny! 👏

I only mentioned his job as I’ve spoken about him and his antics on here before and most people assume he was out of work, or very young, that type of thing.

Anyone, no matter how professional or well respected they are can be a complete knob.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 13:43

@putthatdownsteve God I know you can't judge a book by its cover but he sounds awful. As if he was a Cardiologist too I feel sick just reading your post.. I've worked previously in that area. Absolutely shocking you deserved every penny! 👏

CadMan · 28/06/2023 13:43

moneymatr · 28/06/2023 13:33

If step parents are not financially responsible for step kids why were my dp finances taken into account for university?

Because at this point they’re considered adults and it’s based on their primary household. The whole student loan policy is wrong for many reasons. No parent’s income should be the basis for another adult’s funding imo.

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 13:41

Usernamenotavailab · 28/06/2023 13:37

If both parents are choosing to have more kids and spread their income, that’s their decision.

but if only one parent chooses to have more kids, and reduce income per child, why does the same not apply to the other parent?

a nrp having more kids paying the same maintenance doesn’t affect the existing kids. An rp having more kids it does affect the existing kids financially.

Well that's why I said it's a thin argument (one I've seen in here before). I'm not saying I agree with it just saying I can see why some people may use that.

Imo it shouldn't reduce maintenance if you have more children.

OP posts:
CadMan · 28/06/2023 13:40

mindutopia · 28/06/2023 13:10

I don't think it a step-parent's income should be factored into CMS payments, no. But I don't think CMS payments should be reduced if the parent goes on to have new children either. When dh and I had a 2nd child, we had to factor in that that would cost us more. Our first child didn't magically get cheaper. We just had to stretch the same money across two children and cut down other things.

I have a friend who has a dd and her ex left before his dd was even born (never met her). He already was the mostly SAHP to avoid paying CMS, I like he pays £40 a month (he's a perfectly employable software engineer who has simply chosen not to work much). That tiny amount has reduced for each of the 3 children he then had with his new partner. Which is ridiculous. No need to have more children if you can't or won't afford the ones you already have.

But when you had your second child, you would have had less disposable income to spend on your first. I’m pretty sure the CMS calculation if the NRP has another child is something like -5-10%.

Usernamenotavailab · 28/06/2023 13:37

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 13:32

I think there probably is a (thin) argument that even in nuclear families funds spent on existing children may be reduced / cut (luxuries obviously not necessities) and therefore it's only the same when it happens in separated houses. I.e. Sarah may have to have a cheaper coat or only one type of instrument lessons instead of two because new brother Billy has to go to nursery so it'll be a bit tight for a few years but it's doable still.

But there is obviously a big difference there that both parents choose to have more children according to their one household income in a nuclear family whereas that doesn't happen in a separated co parenting situation.

If both parents are choosing to have more kids and spread their income, that’s their decision.

but if only one parent chooses to have more kids, and reduce income per child, why does the same not apply to the other parent?

a nrp having more kids paying the same maintenance doesn’t affect the existing kids. An rp having more kids it does affect the existing kids financially.

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 13:35

moneymatr · 28/06/2023 13:33

If step parents are not financially responsible for step kids why were my dp finances taken into account for university?

They shouldn't have been imo.

I can think that a SPs income shouldn't be included in CMS payments whilst also disagreeing that they should be included in uni applications.

I don't think a SPs income should be included in anything, at all, for children who are not theirs.

OP posts: