Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone here actually thinks a step parents wage should be considered for CMS?

258 replies

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 10:45

Because my husband's ex seems to think so and is currently enraged that I have zero plan or requirement to.

I'm fully aware that CMS do not take into account a SPs earnings and that legally she is not entitled to anything from my wages. I'm just curious as to whether more people think like her (entitled as imo) that they should take it into account.

YANBU - no it's right that CMS don't take into account a step parents earnings

YABU - they don't but they should.

OP posts:
Smiffette · 28/06/2023 18:45

As a SP I do not agree that my earnings should count towards CMS. When SC was staying with us of course I would buy things like clothes and food. But it was ever mandated that my earning had to go towards his mother who at the time didn't work, I would move out.

Cloverforever · 28/06/2023 18:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it was posted by a previously bas

Stop it. The judge did not chuck it out. He asked for clarification on a couple of issues (such as had i moved back in!) but it was nothing to do with the sums agreed. These remained the same.

I will not air my dirty washing on here anymore. It is actually 9 years today that I moved out of the family home, after a 20 year marriage. A long time ago now.

Please move on. Like I have.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 18:42

SideWonder · 28/06/2023 18:35

No I don't think your salary should be taken into account for CMS purposes @TheSpoonAndTheFork You obviously help support your stepDC by contributing to the household you & their father share.

BUT - the problem is that CMS is nowhere near enough, nor a reasonable amount on which to raise children, and resident parents often get a really raw deal.

This hits harder on mothers as resident parents because women are generally paid less than men, and often a single mother/resident parent has given up her career and diminished her earning capacity by the very act of having children. Men very rarely pay enough to make up for the financial sacrifice many women make create a family. This is OK unless they divorce - then the financial sacrifice many women make becomes very visible.

For example, fathers who refuse to pay for childcare, or activities, or holiday camps, or uniforms unless they fall exactly on the days he has them. And so on.

So unless your DH is paying the true half of what it actually costs to raise HIS children, I can see why the DC's mother is antsy about it.

I have to disagree with this though. Expecting true half of huge expenses isn't realistic either. 2 homes have to be ran and I do agree with posters that a bedroom is needed for the child to stay in and so on. However it's not just about money so things like split childcare should be looked at and school holidays rather than mum having to foot the bill solely. When people suggest half of nursery fees this will only work if someone is on a decent to high salary. By all means if the dad can afford it then yes he should pay for those things.

If someone earns 20k a year then what?

Cloverforever · 28/06/2023 18:40

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 18:33

@Cloverforever I'm sorry to ask but I'm guessing other people will be thinking it.

For clarity - did you try to get the other posters income included in maintenance?

Just because it's a v random lie to come out with out of the blue.

Not in maintenance no. My solicitor requested it so that it could be taken into account for division of assets in the divorce as my exh was living with the previous poster and so it would reduce his living expenses. There was a thread on it recently and the family law solicitors who were posting agreed that this was a perfectly normal and proper thing to do. In the end she moved out so it was not an issue. The poster omits to mention that there was a completely fair and agreed division of assets, signed off by a judge. My ex kept many assets and it was all done fairly.

Theunamedcat · 28/06/2023 18:37

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 12:17

I'm not sure what to do in the case of female non custodial parents having more children and staying at home but I think one idea would be, to be like universal credit and have the expectation that they will start work around age three 🤔 and pick it back up from there....maybe

I don't think it should be any different for male and females surely? Whether or not the NRP is male or female should be irrelevant, they should still be paying for their first children and if they cannot do that and be a SAHP to any new children, then they can't afford to be a SAHP.

Well men can have another baby and continue working the same day if they want to women not so much there is my difficulty and she might be breastfeeding so who are we to say get that baby onto formula and get back to work instantly

This is my dilemma

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 18:37

I'm glad you asked!! Is it even possible to request a partners income in the calculation?? I didn't know about it if so.

Shicking considering plenty of dad's get away with not paying of the self employed claiming a very low income!

SunnySaturdayinJune · 28/06/2023 18:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it was posted by a previously bas

SideWonder · 28/06/2023 18:35

No I don't think your salary should be taken into account for CMS purposes @TheSpoonAndTheFork You obviously help support your stepDC by contributing to the household you & their father share.

BUT - the problem is that CMS is nowhere near enough, nor a reasonable amount on which to raise children, and resident parents often get a really raw deal.

This hits harder on mothers as resident parents because women are generally paid less than men, and often a single mother/resident parent has given up her career and diminished her earning capacity by the very act of having children. Men very rarely pay enough to make up for the financial sacrifice many women make create a family. This is OK unless they divorce - then the financial sacrifice many women make becomes very visible.

For example, fathers who refuse to pay for childcare, or activities, or holiday camps, or uniforms unless they fall exactly on the days he has them. And so on.

So unless your DH is paying the true half of what it actually costs to raise HIS children, I can see why the DC's mother is antsy about it.

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 18:33

@Cloverforever I'm sorry to ask but I'm guessing other people will be thinking it.

For clarity - did you try to get the other posters income included in maintenance?

Just because it's a v random lie to come out with out of the blue.

SunnySaturdayinJune · 28/06/2023 18:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cloverforever · 28/06/2023 18:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Just stop it, you are very wrong.. I am far from lazy and I have never contacted the CMS in my life.

Please just leave me alone and get on with your own life.

SunnySaturdayinJune · 28/06/2023 18:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cloverforever · 28/06/2023 18:23

No, I don't have the wrong thread, but thanks for checking. The poster knows I am on here and will read these disgusting things she has repeatedly said about me over the last 7 years.

LtotheOG · 28/06/2023 18:22

@Cloverforever Ooh! Do continue 🍿

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 18:19

@Cloverforever do you know that poster or have you got the wrong thread?

Cloverforever · 28/06/2023 18:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You need help. You are delusional. Please stop these lies about me right now.

R2G · 28/06/2023 18:07

My husbands ex thinks like this. One of her kids lives with us she pays nothing and thinks it's OK coz their is two of us. I am a step parent but I am also a parent to my own son, I don't have money to spare for what she assumes I should be doing

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 18:07

@DownWithBreadsticks I have to say this is really awful.

I'm so sorry your dealing with this. I would also stop paying.

NastySting · 28/06/2023 18:02

DownWithBreadsticks · 28/06/2023 12:21

My husband is dying of cancer and has had to give up work. In March, he was taken to a CMS tribunal by ex and it was ruled that we should continue payments from my salary to the same amount as it was before he left work, because his ex wife argues that he only gave up work to avoid paying her. She also told the judge he only has them EOW and judge wouldn’t accept our proof of otherwise.

Payments are currently around £1750 pcm and yet we have my step children 3 days out of 7 every week, plus half of all school hols etc. (My husband used to be a high earner before he had to stop working.

Our mortgage is £1500, so it’s actually my highest expense. My parents are now subbing me so that I can afford to pay for food and clothes for my child (shared with husband), until my husband dies and our mortgage insurance kicks in. We have a provision in his will to ensure that she still gets her payments after he’s dead, so that she can’t force me to sell the house.

I cannot help but be bitter. My best friend is dying and I’m being hounded for money I can’t afford while my SC’s mum hasn’t worked since 2008!

I know there will be no sympathy for me on here, because I’m the second wife and I “knew what I was getting into” and I shouldn’t be a “breeder” etc. Heard it all before, naturally.

We just sold his old car to raise some extra funds and then she emailed us to let us know she will be telling the next tribunal about this “windfall” so they can apportion her some of it. It was £4,000 ffs.

All of the focus is on how the CMS is biased towards the paying parent but that has NEVER been our experience. We have tried to appeal and with no success.

Good grief that is awful, the woman should be ashamed of herself.
I always told my partner (at the time, now husband) that if there was ever a hint my income would be taken into account that I would be moving out.
His ex wife works sporadically at best and worked very little when their children were younger, no way was I funding her to sit on her arse all day whilst I worked like a dog.

FatCatBum · 28/06/2023 17:45

*You decided to get together with someone who had children.

Therefore you take them on as your own and should contribute towards them when they’re at yours and hers, because they are now part of your family*

Nope, I'll contribute to them when they are at mine, when they are at hers is her responsibility. DH is the one who contributes to both

gogomoto · 28/06/2023 16:49

No it shouldn't be taken into consideration generally but in limited circumstances I would support the (resident) step parent's income reducing the non resident parent's contribution where the step parent's income is very high.

The scenario I'm thinking of the dad is earning around £40k and handing over money to the mum who is married to a very rich man, she openly admits the cms is used for luxuries, she doesn't work. He wants more child contact but the rich husband could afford solicitors etc.

LittleOwl153 · 28/06/2023 16:47

I don't agree that step parents should be responsible for CMS payments/have income included.

I DO however think that CMS should be set at a minimum of that payable assuming the NR parent is earning national minimum wage for 40 hours a week. So for a single child who doesn't do overnights with NRP that would be around £45 a week. If the NRP does ear this - tough. They should be made to - or face the job centre. It is never in the interests of the children for the NRP to stay home to look after someone else's kids, or live off someone else money and use that to not contribute in my view.

SunnySaturdayinJune · 28/06/2023 16:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 16:36

@Gytgyt she does 😅 I get on with both mum and her current husband and I believe he's also tired of it.

I put it down to different folk's different strokes tbh

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 16:26

@namechangenacy what on earth so she has a husband too! 😳

Swipe left for the next trending thread