Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone here actually thinks a step parents wage should be considered for CMS?

258 replies

TheSpoonAndTheFork · 28/06/2023 10:45

Because my husband's ex seems to think so and is currently enraged that I have zero plan or requirement to.

I'm fully aware that CMS do not take into account a SPs earnings and that legally she is not entitled to anything from my wages. I'm just curious as to whether more people think like her (entitled as imo) that they should take it into account.

YANBU - no it's right that CMS don't take into account a step parents earnings

YABU - they don't but they should.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TiredManDad · 06/07/2023 09:17

Should not be mandated.

I'm a step dad who earns a decent if not staggering wage (it should be more for the job I do as my union agrees even as I type but we will gloss over that) and I pay my ex over and above the monthly amount I'm meant to even though I have my kids every weekend and she has a new partner - because I don't want my kids to miss out on things and I trust my ex to use the money wisely for the children.

My new DPs ex is a complete Arsehole. Works for his mate as a dodgy salesman - gets maid NMW and all his commission is paid to his dad so it isn't in his name. He pays, when he can be bothered less than 100 quid for two girls who we have pretty much full time because as he tell my ex "your dickhead boyfriend earns enough". All this while he goes away on holidays nearly every month with just his new GF and not his kids (despite telling them every time it he will take them next time), has bought a brand new motorhome and three big cars between him and his new girlfriend while we have scrimped and saved to go on a foreign camping trip with all of the kids. Doesn't surprise though as he was a nasty, controlling piece of work when he was with my DP so no wonder it extends to this.

So no - new partner's wage should not be taken into account - it gives an excuse for complete dickheads like this to continue to be absolute arseholes.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 29/06/2023 08:29

Nope. They're not the step parents children. They have two parents.

It would prevent an awful lot of single parents from finding love again.

Neodymium · 28/06/2023 22:57

Australia has a very confusing system where both biological parents incomes are added together, less a ‘self support’ amount and then this total is used to work out that the child support owed would be. It is then apportioned to each parent based on the percent of the income they contributed to the child support income. the paying parent can be given credit for some of what they have to pay for having regular visitation

what this means is that if both parents earn similar wages, there is little child support paid. But if the payee parent gives up work to have another baby, their income is now 0, and the child support to be paid goes up by a lot. So the paying parent essentially ends up paying for the other parents new biological kids.

if the paying parent has more kids there there is a small correction to the self support amount. But it makes very little difference. Step parents income isn’t included and neither is other non bio kids in the household. You can apply to get them included in some circumstances.

there is also something called capacity to earn, where if one parent stops working or reduced their income you can apply to have the payments based on what they used to earn. I think it’s a fairly involved process though.

i think no matter what you do, someone will always think it’s unfair. My dh earned good money. When we got together I was still studying, he was paying CM and the mortgage on the house his ex lived in. It was a real struggle. Once I started working I straight away went onto a high income. His ex didn’t like that and caused all kinds of issues. We could afford things she couldn’t and she didn’t like that. She didn’t work and didn’t want to. Dsc are now mid 20s and she still doesn’t work and still is struggling and bitter, like it’s dhs fault she has nothing.

poormanspombears · 28/06/2023 21:00

My income has nothing to do with BM or SS and if they asked for it to be taken into consideration, they'd be told to fuck off to the far side of fuck.
My husband made him with BM, how they fund him is between them.
I fund my own kids and I do whatever is necessary to make that happen.
My DH is in no way a high earner (not to avoid CMS, it's always been this way) but his CMS payments are his business. They have gone up over the years and he sorts that himself. I tell him how much to put into our bills account and what's left is his to spend as he wishes or needs. If he can't survive it's on him to find a job that makes that happen.

I don't think the current system is fair for anyone. Everyone I speak to has different things affect their payments; court ordered overnights whether they're followed or not for example. It needs to be a 1 rule for everyone, not whatever the advisor is in the mood for on the day, because that's what it feels like at the moment.

I just think it should be about the biological parents, their collective income because that's what they would have to spend on their children if they were together, vs the time they each have the child. I don't think overnights works because they eat, do activities etc in the day and some, not all, BM's refuse overnights to manipulate the system.

There also needs to be something in place to stop dads playing the system by not working because we all know it happens. But what that is, I have no idea. L

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 20:56

@3BSHKATS I'm not sure about fair but definitely the system needs to be improved. You could be a single parent but a higher earner and you could be getting CMS but on paper the minium that is my case it is really complex. DS dad Banks me a higher amount I've informed CMS but they aren't interested despite it looks so odd on our annual review calculations.

What would you suggest to make it fair?

3BSHKATS · 28/06/2023 20:20

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 20:01

@Turnleftturnright you are right it is conflicting. They are so many variations. A rule has to be made though and ultimately there is no one fits all solution.

But there could be fairness. There is the option for it to be fair. It’s a decision for it not to be.

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 20:20

I do think it's bullshit that single parents who don't have dad paying cms gets stinged by benefit rules.

I also think that taking a sp income into account when looking at student loans is also bullshit.

I certainly believe that loop holes need to be closed re maintenance dodgers and self employed ect. We should be more like America and it's approach with missed maintenance payments.

I also don't think cms should be reduced due to dad moving in with a women with kids. In my circle no dad has reduced their maintenance because of their partners kids or any subsequent kids but I do believe it happens. But if it does that's down to dads morals, and I don't think that's suddenly becomes his partners fault by proxy. That choice is dads.

I don't think a step parent income should be included in maintenance.

I truly do believe though that as women if we stopped blaming each other for the faults of bad men there would be a lot less bullshit going around.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 20:01

@Turnleftturnright you are right it is conflicting. They are so many variations. A rule has to be made though and ultimately there is no one fits all solution.

Turnleftturnright · 28/06/2023 19:56

@Gytgyt You get me wrong. I don't have a specific side of the argument.

I was trying to make a point that the rules are conflicting.

If a step parent shouldn't be liable then a single mother who moves her boyfriend in shouldn't lose her child tax credits or whatever the new benefit for this is no? One rule is always in conflict with another.

If I had to pick a side cms shouldn't be taken into account but then single parents who don't receive a penny in maintenance and have their children 24/7 should be able to earn that same amount into their household on top of whatever the current entitlement is before their benefits get deducted.

Surely it isn't fair that a single mother with no maintenance would say lose something like 50p in every pound whilst someone who gets that money without working gets to keep every pound. Not all work and childcare as a single parent is reliable either.

FelicityFlops · 28/06/2023 19:43

I had a very bizarre telephone conversation with the (lady) solicitor during my husband's divorce. She mentioned holidays we had been on and had included my step-son. Why did they have to be so expensive? Clearly she thought my husband had paid. She went completely silent when I told her who had actually paid. Silly cow.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 19:33

@3BSHKATS she should take him to court or let's hope the daily mail pick this one up! I bet they message you for more info.

3BSHKATS · 28/06/2023 19:30

@Yousee I don’t think you can put a number on it and actually I don’t think the number it’s self is relevant. When you live with children and they are part of your life my kids pretty much get 100% of my salary. I would say I could live on 90% of what i earn if I didn’t have kids.
So, therefore, it seems reasonable, that no matter how many children, no matter how much the parent earns a percentage of that salary is paid towards the children. I think 25% would be fair.

I also do not think high earners should have a limitation placed on it. I have a friend who has two children with a well-known soap star who you would recognise. He pays £300 a month for two children and child-support whilst earning in excess of half 1 million a year. Even if the CSM could be arsed to nail him, he would still only be paying a percentage on a maximum amount of £150,000

3BSHKATS · 28/06/2023 19:26

No, I absolutely do not think the stepparents salary should be taken into account, however. Living with somebody with additional children who are receiving support from their own to parents, should not take anything away from the first family, the resident parent etc.

Also additional children that that couple might have together shit again, not to reduce the payments that are due to the first family. If you want more kids pay for the first lot first. They should not suffer.

Yousee · 28/06/2023 19:26

SideWonder · 28/06/2023 18:35

No I don't think your salary should be taken into account for CMS purposes @TheSpoonAndTheFork You obviously help support your stepDC by contributing to the household you & their father share.

BUT - the problem is that CMS is nowhere near enough, nor a reasonable amount on which to raise children, and resident parents often get a really raw deal.

This hits harder on mothers as resident parents because women are generally paid less than men, and often a single mother/resident parent has given up her career and diminished her earning capacity by the very act of having children. Men very rarely pay enough to make up for the financial sacrifice many women make create a family. This is OK unless they divorce - then the financial sacrifice many women make becomes very visible.

For example, fathers who refuse to pay for childcare, or activities, or holiday camps, or uniforms unless they fall exactly on the days he has them. And so on.

So unless your DH is paying the true half of what it actually costs to raise HIS children, I can see why the DC's mother is antsy about it.

Getting to the bottom of what "true half" actually is would be a challenge in itself.
For example, does "true half" include the NRPs expenses? Because my DSDs bedroom in our house costs alot of money for a start.
Then theres what is required and what is discretionary. My DH refused to pay extra for childcare as he wanted to look after DSD himself but mum refused. So he was paying a lawyer £££ to sort that out. Would the lawyers fees be included in "true half"? It was still money spent on DSD after all.
Did DSD really need to be doing 5 extra curriculars at age 6? What about her salon appointments? Holidays? Gifts? Airmax instead of Primarks finest footwear?
Nightmare stuff to unpick as people have such a varied opinion on what their bottom line basics are.
I do think that in the case of non paying NRP, for whatever reason, there should be a mechanism to claim against their NI. So if they dodge paying for their child it's coming out of their pension and no child is left high and dry. What the base figure should be though is anyone's guess.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 19:25

Turnleftturnright · 28/06/2023 19:16

It's a tricky one.

I do find it odd that step parents income isn't taken into account for cms.

But, child maintenance isn't taken into account for benefits. Yet, if that money was in the house it would've been taken off.

If a partner moves in and earns reasonably well then the previously single mother loses her benefits yet they are not for instance the step fathers children to pay for?

Capital isn't taken into account for child maintenance yet it is for single parent benefits.

There are so many conflicting situations. None of them make sense when you look at them all together.

Step parents don't have a legal obligation and not all step families get along. It would mean everyone paying for other people's kids I mean my own child is an expense as it is but why would I want to pay for my boyfriends kids?

That would mean that my boyfriends kids get money from BOTH his parents and me as well that's 3 people. Then my own kids dad could ask my own child's dad to pay as he too is step parent 🤣

CMS is not means tested because its unreliable, CMS in general are useless at investigating and is that how low we are stooping begrudging a single parent the bare minium in most cases.
The thread is mind boggling.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 19:18

@namechangenacy no it's not fair at to mandate people to pay for kids that are not theirs. It's a slippery slope really next thing they will be demanding inheritance.

Honestly I've read CMS threads before on here but oh my this one definitely has been an eye opener. No offence to anybody but I am glad I just have the one child because I have enough bloody drama... with DS dad at times.

Turnleftturnright · 28/06/2023 19:16

It's a tricky one.

I do find it odd that step parents income isn't taken into account for cms.

But, child maintenance isn't taken into account for benefits. Yet, if that money was in the house it would've been taken off.

If a partner moves in and earns reasonably well then the previously single mother loses her benefits yet they are not for instance the step fathers children to pay for?

Capital isn't taken into account for child maintenance yet it is for single parent benefits.

There are so many conflicting situations. None of them make sense when you look at them all together.

confusedallthetime1 · 28/06/2023 19:12

Ooooh the drama!! 😂
In response to the OP no I think it's the parents job to provide for their offspring AS LONG AS they aren't providing for other children that aren't theirs.
I actually paid CMS when my ex husband lost his job for a month or two, cheeky bitch moaned it wasn't enough so I told her to fuck off and didn't pay another penny

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 19:04

@Gytgyt I don't mind people asking.

I do mine being told this is what will happen and when they don't like the answer being guilt tripped, when I have done more than enough off my own back because I want to.

Again I can only speak for myself - but many sm happily contributed to the children in their care for their house. Being mandated to would take for granted that kindness.

I'm a mum also and my dd has a sm and I treat mum as I would like to be treated as mum and treat my dd sm as I would like to be treated as sm.

On the whole maintenance holes and loop holes need to be tightened . It's not ideal to say cms has many holes it's not fair on mums (which certain holes are defo not fair) let's make it the females with these men pay instead.

1FootInTheRave · 28/06/2023 19:00

I'm just here for the drama 👀

I absolutely do not think a step parents earnings should be taken into account for anything.

MirandaWest · 28/06/2023 18:57

Slightly different but I do find it a bit odd that for calculating student finance the non resident parent isn’t included at all but a step parent is and so would be assumed to contribute where necessary to the student's living expenses.

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 18:56

@Cloverforever look I don't know there ins and out but it does sounds very much like you asked for the court to take into account the previous posters income. Which ok is a thing you could ask the courts.

But it does sound very much like that poster was telling the truth.

As to drawing attention to it - no one knew who that poster was talking about until you highlighted it was about you so kinda aired your own dirty laundry here.. and if I'm completely honest it's mn so no one actually knows anything bar two posters under whatever username are having a ding dong.

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 18:55

@namechangenacy blimey! Definitely shouldn't be allowed.

wanttokickoffbutcant · 28/06/2023 18:54

Well @DownWithBreadsticks you certainly have all my sympathy. The judge was a fool and his ex wife is a bitch.

namechangenacy · 28/06/2023 18:48

Gytgyt · 28/06/2023 18:37

I'm glad you asked!! Is it even possible to request a partners income in the calculation?? I didn't know about it if so.

Shicking considering plenty of dad's get away with not paying of the self employed claiming a very low income!

I mean it's a question that can be asked either directly or in court (although I believe courts rule only applies for a year - then handed over to cms) - someone can come along and tell me I'm wrong on this one as I'm not 200%

Mum asked my dh directly and then she told me she would go to cms directly if I didn't comply 🙄. I politely reminded her that she gets well over the odds for what she would get from cms and they have a private arrangement that worked for years and I didn't want to be dragged into it and I doubt cms would be interested but she was welcome to check.

This was around the time I was setting up a trust for the children (dsd included) from my own money. And she then said I got off on a technicality 🙄 and I married the man I should be providing for my family. Which I pointed out I was, but when I married him I married him and extended my family to include dsd. But I didn't marry her.

Her dh did step in at that point and said come on girls don't argue over money we are all family.

Anyway as I said bar money issues I don't have any issues with mum. She's sane normally so I imagine there's something I don't know about re her current situation which makes her react the way she does and try to approach it with empathy (and when it kicks off - usually me screaming into a pillow at how insane it all is)