Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would I be a scab

245 replies

Badlands1 · 28/06/2023 10:00

NC
My union have voted to strike. I have voted not to - am I scab if I work? I don't disagree with the unions requests but I am not happy with the effects the strike will have.

OP posts:
Mintelderflower · 28/06/2023 12:10

I think this really is when it isn’t black and white @LividHot . I know that won’t be accepted by a lot on here though.

Mintelderflower · 28/06/2023 12:09

So do people accept one can choose not to be in a union and that this is a principled stance and not an idiotic one? Because that’s not what generally happens on here.

LividHot · 28/06/2023 12:07

I’m getting divorced and downsizing the house.

I’m on the bones of my arse: selling clothes on Vinted to buy petrol.

I was declined a mortgage last month because there were strike deductions on my payslip and the company said they’d lend me £18k less than I needed because of it.

I’ve had to find another mortgage offer and I won’t be striking next week.

I simply can’t risk losing this offer or the house.

Sometimes ethics isn’t black and white.

I’ve striked (struck?) for the last twenty years whenever called. I just can’t do it this time.

Side note: I spent all the strike days earlier this year working unpaid from home because when else was I going to catch up on all the stuff that needed catching up on? Fuck them all.

Badlands1 · 28/06/2023 12:06

@eggsbenedict23 It's not the 2 days pay I am concerned about

OP posts:
eggsbenedict23 · 28/06/2023 12:05

Good on you for doing your job. You don't want to forego the pay. That's fine

roundtable · 28/06/2023 12:04

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:59

I think you could make your point without the rudeness.

Where was I rude?

Surely it's obvious that if you are in a union it's not there just to help you individually, without collectively acting to help all members.

How else would the union be able to negotiate pay and conditions, if they weren't able to speak on behalf of your members?

So sorry, if all the people you know don't understand that, I would still argue they aren't very bright.

You dont see why saying people aren't very bright is rude?

Okay then, I'll leave you to it as this won't go anywhere but into unpleasantness and I have no wish to derail the op's thread.

Enjoy being right.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 12:03

@Superdupes

But not only their personal benefit!

Read the rest of my post you quoted. It is the collective action that gives unions their power (with employers). If it's the case that every union member does what they want, the premise collapses.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 12:02

Well said @Enterthewolves

It is the sticking point for me - I believe in unions and what they stand for. I question not having joined my own union, ethically. But I don't agree with the approaches local union reps have taken, which are often dealing with their own grievances really, rather than genuinely advancing issues for the wider workforce.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 12:00

Just telling people they're not very bright is using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

Except I didn't do that? I explained (twice) why it's incorrect 🤷🏻‍♀️

ilovesooty · 28/06/2023 11:59

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:45

You don’t have to do anything you don’t agree with.

Then you don't join a union.

Implicit in membership is acceptance of collective action. Leave if you don't want this.

Some of these answers ...

Couldn't agree more.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:59

I think you could make your point without the rudeness.

Where was I rude?

Surely it's obvious that if you are in a union it's not there just to help you individually, without collectively acting to help all members.

How else would the union be able to negotiate pay and conditions, if they weren't able to speak on behalf of your members?

So sorry, if all the people you know don't understand that, I would still argue they aren't very bright.

Superdupes · 28/06/2023 11:57

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:53

Most people I know are in a union to protect them against any accusations or workplace injustice (the irony!) I don't think they think of it as a collective hive mind rightly or wrongly.

Well, sorry but 'most' people you know aren't that bright then!

Why should they assume a union exists for their personal benefit, while be unwilling to give the union the power it has through collective action? That's why unions have some ability to support workers in difficulty. Because they speak collectively.

Why should they assume a union exists for their personal benefit?

Because they pay to be a part of it. They don't sign up to it by agreeing to always do what the majority wants, they sign up to it by paying. That's why unions have some ability to support workers in difficulty - because people pay.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:57

People aren’t always going to agree on everything.

No. So that's why there's a vote. And the vote is accepted by members.

There's no other way to run a union - if you're not willing to accept the democratic vote, you have to leave. You can't make individual choices in a union.

Devilrocknroller · 28/06/2023 11:56

It wouldn’t have to if the government agreed to responsible pay increases etc then members wouldn’t have to strike

Enterthewolves · 28/06/2023 11:56

All unions have hardship funds that support members who are sole earners or would be vulnerable.

I find the idea that you only pay into a Union as an insurance policy unpleasant and the ‘I’ve never got anything out of it’ view is grim. Unions are collective organisations of workers that negotiate pay, push employers to meet legal and ethical obligations and provide support to members in need. I’ve paid Union subs in every job I’ve ever had since I was 16 and am now 48 and will keep paying. I’ve never had nor needed advice but I have benefited- through negotiated pay rises, improvements in working conditions and in knowing that colleagues have had fair pay settlements, the lowest paid have had much improved pay and that members of my union have had legal advice, subsidised holidays, education opportunities, been supported to keep jobs, get disability adjustments etc. My ‘benefit’ has been the collective benefits that have strengthened my community. If you think the only be fit that matters is one you personally receive then yeah, a trade union probably isn’t for you, get an insurance policy and stop accepting collectively negotiated pay rises.

roundtable · 28/06/2023 11:55

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:53

Most people I know are in a union to protect them against any accusations or workplace injustice (the irony!) I don't think they think of it as a collective hive mind rightly or wrongly.

Well, sorry but 'most' people you know aren't that bright then!

Why should they assume a union exists for their personal benefit, while be unwilling to give the union the power it has through collective action? That's why unions have some ability to support workers in difficulty. Because they speak collectively.

I think you could make your point without the rudeness.

Just telling people they're not very bright is using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:55

@nokidshere

You're incorrect. If someone doesn't want to accept the collective decision, they'll need to leave the union. That's literally the premise of a union - a union or coming together of workers to act collectively & have strength in their numbers.

Devilrocknroller · 28/06/2023 11:55

You also can’t say the union hasn’t done anything for you, you can thank your leave increases, pay rises etc for your union. Negotiating those agreements is incredibly time consuming and difficult. As is organising workplaces. Your employer doesn’t just give you a pay increase out of the goodness of their own heart. You union won that for you. Look up the wage differences in non unionised workplaces. So don’t say your union has done nothing for you. The pay increases more than pay for your union fees

Badlands1 · 28/06/2023 11:55

@Devilrocknroller
Thats true but the responsibility falls on the hospitals who are caught in the middle while the government agrees the wages

OP posts:
CleverLilViper · 28/06/2023 11:53

It’s not remotely nuts.

People will always do what suits them in the long run. Not everyone has access to these so called funds to help to strike.

Some will have a moral reason to not strike in this instance. You should be able to disagree with something and still agree on other things. Collectives are what is nuts. People aren’t always going to agree on everything.

Unions are left wing bullies and often the members are too.

Superdupes · 28/06/2023 11:53

'you do not have to take part in a strike and cannot be disciplined by your union if you refuse'

Unions are there for a 100 other things apart from striking, you pay to be a part of it and are perfectly entitled to not participate in any strike action if you choose not to. The idea that you're 'a scab' because you're concerned about the impact on patients if you don't work that day is just grim.

I think Unions as a whole need a good look at and the whole thing updating. They say they're all about this that or the other but when it boils down to it all they ever seem to be really worried about is more pay. More pay is not the answer to the doctor or teaching crisis - but all we ever seem to hear is they're striking for more pay.

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:53

Most people I know are in a union to protect them against any accusations or workplace injustice (the irony!) I don't think they think of it as a collective hive mind rightly or wrongly.

Well, sorry but 'most' people you know aren't that bright then!

Why should they assume a union exists for their personal benefit, while be unwilling to give the union the power it has through collective action? That's why unions have some ability to support workers in difficulty. Because they speak collectively.

ilovesooty · 28/06/2023 11:53

ChaToilLeam · 28/06/2023 11:16

If you don’t support the union, then you should leave.

I presume you would wish for Union support if treated badly or unfairly? So much for solidarity…!

Exactly.

Nowvoyager99 · 28/06/2023 11:52

RattyHealy · 28/06/2023 10:19

Yes you would be a scab. If you will break strikes you should resign from the union and not benefit from the other aspects of union membership.

Totally agree with this.

If you cross a picket line, your colleagues will remember.

nokidshere · 28/06/2023 11:52

No one needs to strike if they don't want to, regardless if you belong to the union. You can belong to a 'collective' with agreeing with everything it does. It's ok for the rich union bosses to encourage people to strike but frankly, right now when we are being stretched to the hilt, people cant afford to keep losing pay even if they do agree with the strikes.

No one should be berated for doing what is best for them let alone be called such revolting terms a 'scab'. And you can still support your colleagues and the reasons they are striking even if you aren't taking part yourself.