Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would I be a scab

245 replies

Badlands1 · 28/06/2023 10:00

NC
My union have voted to strike. I have voted not to - am I scab if I work? I don't disagree with the unions requests but I am not happy with the effects the strike will have.

OP posts:
RoseAndRose · 28/06/2023 13:54

The whole point of unions is that they are collectives.

If you don't want to be part of a collective which has binding strike votes, then you should join one which has non-binding actions.

It's just plain wrong to undermine what is at the very core or an organisation

CheshireCat1 · 28/06/2023 13:54

I don’t like the word scab and I’ve never called anyone that when I’ve been on strike. Ask yourself that if the strike resulted in better conditions and a wage rise would you be happy to accept them. I don’t think you should be in a union if you’re not going with the majority vote.

peachicecream · 28/06/2023 13:50

Mintelderflower · 28/06/2023 11:24

I know this is not the MN approved view but I do think that you have to do what sits most comfortably with you personally. Being a union member doesn’t mean you have to agree with everything the union does, any more than voting for a particular political party has to mean you agree with every part of their manifesto.

This. Do what sits most comfortably with you. There are many reasons to be in a union and being in it doesn't mean you have to agree/ join in with everything they do if you disagree on principle.

BloodyPrime · 28/06/2023 13:48

All the people saying the OP should leave the union. She'd still be a scab... a scan is a derogatory term that is used for people working during a strike, people who won't join a union, people who replace striking workers..... So basically, the name calling is for anyone who won't do what the union wants, including non-members.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/scab

Definition of SCAB

scabies of domestic animals; a crust of hardened blood and serum over a wound; a contemptible person… See the full definition

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/scab

User1367349 · 28/06/2023 13:48

Don’t worry, I imagine there will be derogations. I can’t imagine the BMA wanting the downsides of an all-out strike. Find a derogated area and offer to cover. It will be ok.

BusMumsHoliday · 28/06/2023 13:36

If you feel sorry for the patients, isn't the quality of care they get going to diminish even further if conditions in the NHS don't improve? That's the way I look at it as someone whose child might have an outpatient appointment cancelled because of the junior drs strike. A relative of mine was dying in a hospital during the earlier drs strike and I was still pleased to support them on the picket line.

I'm a lecturer and I also feel bad when my students miss learning because of strikes. They've had a lot of disruption. My pay is relatively good across the board, but in proportion to what colleagues nearing retirement earnt relatively back in the day, it's terrible. Plus no final salary pension. It's not the career it was and it comes after a long long time studying and a lot of precarity. I imagine it's the same for consultants.

And a union is about collective bargaining and support so I have to follow the decisions of the majority. This is a bit different, but I also hope I'm teaching my students that if their working conditions aren't satisfactory then they can do something about it.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 28/06/2023 13:35

( I think the nurses should have held out!)

But the majority never, and the ones who voted to strike, will have to suck up the majority result.

I assume you will want the protection of the union should you wish to find yourself submitting a grievance, or to represent you in a disciplinary and free legal assistance for employment issues should you ever find yourself in that position?

Wouldn't it be great to cherry pick the bits we only found useful to ourselves as an individual.

StarmanBobby · 28/06/2023 13:32

If you want the union to be there for YOU when you need it, then you support it's action.

Will you be a scab? Yes. But it's your choice. If I was your striking colleague I wouldn't be impressed, but I would accept the fact it's your choice. Just as striking would be mine. And I would hope and pray that there weren't too many like you.

Pigeon31 · 28/06/2023 13:31

If you're a union member and your union holds a legal ballot and decides to strike then members are expected to go with the collective decision.

Your call if you want to do that, but collective bargaining does depend on a bit of collective action. It's the managers job to work with the union to make sure things are safe.

Natsku · 28/06/2023 13:29

Don't strike if you disagree with it but leave the Union if you don't agree with collective action.

StarmanBobby · 28/06/2023 13:29

Yes, the point of a union is it's strength in numbers. Perhaps next time it will be something YOU want to strike on, how would you feel if your fellow members refused to even though the vote went your way.

You should strike. You have the support of most of the public. And the government is NOT listening. This is a way to put pressure on them.

Inconvenient though it is for parents like me, I don't know a single parent who isn't supporting the strikes. We want our kids to be educated by motivated people, who are decently paid and have good working conditions.

This government don't give a damn because their children are in private schools.

LaffTaff · 28/06/2023 13:29

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 13:25

What happens if you are called a scab, is it just name calling like at school or does it get violent.

No violence (i'd hope!) and no name calling either. People who cross a picket line know they're scabs, without a word needing to be said 🙂

Livinginanotherworld · 28/06/2023 13:28

Yes, you would be a scab if you don’t want to strike that’s your choice, but you shouldn’t have the benefits of a union so should leave. Are you prepared to cross a picket line ?

GrinAndVomit · 28/06/2023 13:28

Dryinginthesea · 28/06/2023 10:53

For goodness sake it is a Union not a cult. You are allowed to have your own opinions and exercise them. If you want to work absolutely do.

I have worked through a strike before, my colleagues were outside I bought them a round of coffees that I gave them on my way past. They weren’t in anyway upset that I worked, and I wasn’t in anyway upset that they striked.

Way, way too measured and sensible

Malarandras · 28/06/2023 13:27

This isn’t the 1970s and childish name calling achieves nothing. Being a member of a union does not, regardless of what anyone else may think, oblige you to strike. I would say that if you disagree with the union you should leave. That’s what I did. Mine was abysmally run, did not communicate with members and went off and did whatever it liked regardless of what members thought.

5128gap · 28/06/2023 13:26

You should leave the union then OP. You should also feel at least at little embarrassed if you benefit from any positive change brought about by the strike action. Unless you disagree with the reasons for the strike itself, then I think its pretty poor form to be avoiding any moral conflict from troubling your own conscience while your colleagues take it for you.

ReachForTheMars · 28/06/2023 13:25

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 13:18

Of course you are not desperately sad, you couldn't care less.

Dont forget you are talking to an actual person.

You have no basis to say that doctor isnt desperately sad.

Take your tantrum somewhere else.

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 13:25

What happens if you are called a scab, is it just name calling like at school or does it get violent.

LaffTaff · 28/06/2023 13:23

I'm in Scotland. My husband works in a specialist NHS (non clinical) role.
If NHS Scotland staff hadn't gone on strike over the past year, they wouldn't have got the pay deal they did - it would've been far less.

You're absolutely a scab (and you're seriously letting down your colleagues) if you cross a picket line.

sigfey · 28/06/2023 13:21

oops

^I agree that no-one should be pressured into striking if they don't agree, but then you do need to leave the union

sigfey · 28/06/2023 13:20

NEScribe · 28/06/2023 13:18

It sounds like you need new union reps. They should be working for the good of all staff. Did you vote in the elections for your reps? If you are unhappy with things then you need to use your vote - or even stand as a rep yourself?

If it's the BMA consultant strike, then 86% voted for industrial action.

It was never going to be 100% agreement but it's pretty high.

I ag

Enterthewolves · 28/06/2023 13:20

Seriously?!

LaSalleRoom · 28/06/2023 13:18

EarringsandLipstick · 28/06/2023 11:57

People aren’t always going to agree on everything.

No. So that's why there's a vote. And the vote is accepted by members.

There's no other way to run a union - if you're not willing to accept the democratic vote, you have to leave. You can't make individual choices in a union.

‘ you have to leave.’

what you mean by have to? You get kicked out?

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 13:18

Medstudent12 · 28/06/2023 12:59

@Badlands1 fellow doctor here. Yes I’d say you’re a scab. We work in unsafe conditions every single day, we watch patients be out at risk due to poor pay and working conditions for staff meaning that we cannot retain safe numbers.

During strikes there are more staff than ever before. Emergency care will be maintained.

Sadly some elective work will be cancelled, I’m desperately sad for patient who this affects. But not taking action means more pain for patients in the long run, not taking action means we wait and watch the nhs collapse. This is the only way the govt will listen, if we sacrifice pay and walk out.

I’m not just striking for fair pay, I’m striking because we are haemorrhaging staff and we cannot have a health service if all of the future consultants have left.

Of course you are not desperately sad, you couldn't care less.

Enterthewolves · 28/06/2023 13:18

But that’s not what a union is or is for, it is a collective of workers that makes decisions democratically to support all union members - if you want to be an individualist get a private insurance policy