Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would I be a scab

245 replies

Badlands1 · 28/06/2023 10:00

NC
My union have voted to strike. I have voted not to - am I scab if I work? I don't disagree with the unions requests but I am not happy with the effects the strike will have.

OP posts:
GrinAndVomit · 28/06/2023 14:55

PurpleChrayne · 28/06/2023 14:19

Nowt lower than a scab.

🤢

Child molesters?
Rapists?
Murderers?
Sex and people traffickers?
Domestic abusers?

GrinAndVomit · 28/06/2023 14:53

LaReinaDelMar · 28/06/2023 14:49

There is if OP would accept what they are striking for, whilst not being will to strike herself.

So say they want better pay and get it, if she doesn't strike, she should turn the payrise down.

What about staff in different unions who aren’t striking?

GrinAndVomit · 28/06/2023 14:52

Is there an alternative to being in a union? Some sort of insurance policy which you pay into and they would provide legal advice and representation but you wouldn’t be obligated to participate in strikes that you disagree with?

Ultimately, unions work on “strength in numbers” but if you’re explicitly told to leave if you have differing views on one particular strike, well that’s going to affect numbers and that will affect strength.

It seems a bit shortsighted to have an all or nothing policy.

Cherrysoup · 28/06/2023 14:50

I’m my union’s rep at work and you have to do with what sits with you as morally correct/right for you. These people saying you’re a scab (you asked for it!) are ridiculous. Financially, it has an impact, so if it’s going to affect you, then go to work. You voted against striking, if it’s school, then consider swapping to a less militant union eg the NAS/UWT. I certainly haven’t told my members they’re ‘scabs.’

Burning braziers and donkey jackets, Yosser Hughes for those of a certain age! Given it’ll be the 6th and 7th day of strikes if you’re in education, I frankly can’t blame you.

LaReinaDelMar · 28/06/2023 14:49

Mari9999 · 28/06/2023 14:38

@Badlands1
Do what you think best and assume that your colleagues, like you, are doing what they think best. There is no superior position in this situation.

There is if OP would accept what they are striking for, whilst not being will to strike herself.

So say they want better pay and get it, if she doesn't strike, she should turn the payrise down.

SerafinasGoose · 28/06/2023 14:40

Malarandras · 28/06/2023 13:27

This isn’t the 1970s and childish name calling achieves nothing. Being a member of a union does not, regardless of what anyone else may think, oblige you to strike. I would say that if you disagree with the union you should leave. That’s what I did. Mine was abysmally run, did not communicate with members and went off and did whatever it liked regardless of what members thought.

So does mine. I have other gripes with them too. I've long considered leaving, but a precarious situation in relation to my workplace specifically means that leaving at present would be really ill-advised. Union members are better-protected than those staff who are not, and this union is the strongest we've got.

My local branch are fantastic and right on the ball - unlike the General Secretary who has IMO seriously mismanaged the current dispute - and are another reason I'm still there.

I won't be voting 'YES' in any further ballots for action - I didn't in the last - as from my current position it's akin to shooting myself in the foot. But having taken the decision to remain in the union, I view that as also being a decision to back the majority view.

It's becoming increasingly difficult, I've lost a country fortune, and the MAB in particular has been very unpleasant and divisive. There are reasons as to why the General Secretary has painted herself into a corner with that one. Seriously, she's inept. But union means union.

These dilemmas are always difficult, nuanced, and require weighing up the lesser of the evils available. No one nowadays should be treated unprofessionally and certainly not called a 'scab'. But there's nothing you can do about losing the trust of your colleagues, and once that's gone it can be very difficult to get it back.

Mari9999 · 28/06/2023 14:38

@Badlands1
Do what you think best and assume that your colleagues, like you, are doing what they think best. There is no superior position in this situation.

RosesAndHellebores · 28/06/2023 14:34

If you don't strike you are behaving honourably and with decency towards your key stakeholders/patients. The people who, like you, pay tax to receive NHS Services.

I am rather tired of the annual allowance/pension tax argument. Dr's are not the only people affected by this but they have bleated the loudest and complained to their customers. Dreadful behaviour.

You voted against the strike. Therefore don't strike. You could, however, decline your pay for that day whilst working or donate it to your union.

LoisPrice · 28/06/2023 14:32

Most teachers I don't know about Dr but unions are foe your own protection against false or even true allegations. They are not joined because people want a collective force but as insurance essentially. All teachers are told this is the one reason to be in a union, the other stuff is secondary. So to tell people to leave the union if they don't agree with some if the very weird views of all leftie extremist unions is a bit rich. No safeguarding lead would be in any teaching union if we thought like that.

Oh I see you want them to have the protection but give fuck all back in return - I see where you're coming from now.

The clue was in the name, if not happy about the way a union works they should start there own body

Boomboom22 · 28/06/2023 14:27

LoisPrice · 28/06/2023 11:38

Being a union member doesn’t mean you have to agree with everything the union does, any more than voting for a particular political party has to mean you agree with every part of their manifesto.

it would be like the majority voting for the Green Party but the Labour Party disregarding it and putting themselves in power. If you agree to go with the majority and then back down when you don’t get your way, what does that make you? Why take part in any of it? Why vote? Why be a member?

Most teachers I don't know about Dr but unions are foe your own protection against false or even true allegations. They are not joined because people want a collective force but as insurance essentially. All teachers are told this is the one reason to be in a union, the other stuff is secondary. So to tell people to leave the union if they don't agree with some if the very weird views of all leftie extremist unions is a bit rich. No safeguarding lead would be in any teaching union if we thought like that.

Fluffyhoglets · 28/06/2023 14:26

I've left my union rather than strike if that's what they vote to do.
My work isn't important like DRs though and the only person who suffers if I strike is me.
I dont know the outcome of our ballot yet but I believe if I'm a union member and they vote to strike then I should support the strike and Ihave done so in the past. So I've left the union for the time being

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/06/2023 14:25

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 14:22

It all sounds very rough and a bit uncouth.

Have you perhaps posted on the wrong thread? Your comment looks like a non sequitur in this context.

User163876621 · 28/06/2023 14:22

It all sounds very rough and a bit uncouth.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/06/2023 14:22

That some people would abuse a strikebreaker is not a reason not to strike.

Two wrongs don't make a right.

PurpleChrayne · 28/06/2023 14:19

Nowt lower than a scab.

🤢

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/06/2023 14:19

I don't get to strike if the rest of union voted not to. So why should someone not strike when the rest of the union voted to?

YABU and you should strike. The whole point is to demonstrate the impact of you not working.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 28/06/2023 14:18

I personally don't agree with striking, it gets nobody anywhere

Are you for real? 😂

If it wasn't for people striking, many of us would not have half the terms and conditions we have in our jobs today, or are fighting for in the future.

Honestly, educate yourself. That is a massive insult to people who strike.

Maybe have a look at the Matchgirl strike of 1888, for starters.

Scirocco · 28/06/2023 14:18

If you want to be one of the clinicians for cover arrangements, just do that. No need to get worked up about it.

Seebit · 28/06/2023 14:15

Personally I think if the Union votes to strike and you are part of that union then you should follow the majority.

LoisPrice · 28/06/2023 14:12

MsPavlichenko · 28/06/2023 13:15

Weekends, annual leave, public holidays won by unions. Maternity and paternity leave and pay. Salary, sick pay, holiday pay, pensions. Unions got you that. Yea breaks/lunches etc. Unions. I could go on.

You may not have had call to use their services at an individual level but you have benefitted from the collective struggle unions have made and are making. I assume you’ll take any salary increase they negotiate after you stop paying dues?

All those saying that you don't have to act as a collective and strike - will you give up all the benefits that the unions collectively got you?

Happy to forgo 4 weeks holiday and reduce it to two weeks, forgo parental leave, bank holidays, maternity and paternity rights and pay? Work weekends for the same money you get now etc

ATeamsvan · 28/06/2023 14:11

Well the answer to your question is yes, you would fit the definition!
Up to you though, but you should leave your union if you don't strike

TattyOne · 28/06/2023 14:04

Only shrike if YOU want to. Don't feel pressured to doing something you don't feel comfortable with.
I personally don't agree with striking, it gets nobody anywhere.
Hubby and I used to work on the buses and we were threatened with physical harm, we were spat at by colleagues, totally ignored, verbally abused, they threatened to bomb our car even if we were in it at the time, because we refused to strike.
Please be very careful with unions and work colleagues ....

Southwest12 · 28/06/2023 14:01

Isn't one of the reasons for the consultants vote for strike action to help the trainees coming behind them? It's not just about you, but those that are going to still have £60k+ of student loan debt when they hit CCT and unless consultants pay is restored then there's even less to keep trainees in the NHS.

I guess at the end of the day you do what feels right for you, but I suspect most clinics and elective surgery will be cancelled anyway, whether you strike or not.

ShoesoftheWorld · 28/06/2023 14:01

'Scab' is a dehumanising term and I therefore wouldn't use it. But, although I obviously wouldn't subject you to abuse for it, I would have no problem with describing you as a strike-breaker.

If a union has binding ballots, it's part of members' moral obligations to abide by them, IMO.

mycoffeecup · 28/06/2023 13:54

I'm interested in how you see the future of the NHS. It seems pretty clear that the trickle of doctors leaving has turned into a flood and that successful strike action is actually the only way to benefit patients in the long term, which will massively outweigh damage done on the day. So I find it difficult to understand how anyone who had thought it through could disagree with strike action. What would be your long-term plan?