Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband expects me to do so many out of school activities

506 replies

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 22:50

I have a 4 & 6 year old and current time table is;

monday acting class for both in our local area, an hour later my son has football out of our area and leaves a lot of hanging about as not enough time to go home.

tuesday - football for my son, meaning I’m driving home to go back out of town

Friday - tennis in local area this is fine (for both)

Saturday - football out of town and then dancing (dancing for both)

sunday - park run out of our area

I messaged him and spoke today about how I need to drop something as I’m going into my final
year of nursing and I work bank shifts too, I simply can’t cope anymore. But instead of any compassion he’s asked me to now take my son to golf lessons on Thursday evenings (6 week course) I should point out that most of these activities are on during the summer holidays.

he’s making me feel like I want my own children to miss out. Of course I don’t, I’m just so mentally drained.

so am I being unreasonable to say no the golf (not that I have much of a choice, I most likely will be forced)

OP posts:
TheseThree · 28/06/2023 21:42

I have only caught part way up, so apologies if the conversation has since moved on, but I must say, that you are “not allowed” is concerning to me. I would talk to your DC about needing to give something up and have a discussion about what they would struggle most to give up. Basically, let them each choose one thing that is “protected”. Then give up what you feel would best give you the balance you need. Your DH has made it such that this can not be a family discussion and joint adult decision as it should be so you’ll simply have to handle it yourself with DC.

Let your DH know that you will no longer be taking them to those activities, so it seems unwise to continue paying unless he will be taking them. You do not need to be “allowed”. If you are in fear of his reaction, then you have a much larger issue to deal with.

FusionChefGeoff · 28/06/2023 21:42

Agree with everyone - he's a dickhead and you'd be better off without him. I can't see counselling working as he sounds too stubborn

To add: the longer kids do something, the harder it is to 'take it away' from them so nip this in the bud now otherwise you really will be causing them upset.

I used the covid break to cut right back on activities.

The main thing that's helped us is sticking to stuff that's run at school - so they do loads, but it's all just an early drop off or later pick up. That actually makes my life a lot easier as I get a longer day to work / exercise / sort life out

stichguru · 28/06/2023 21:34

You and your husband are both totally unreasonable. In the week I'd say your 4 year old should be doing at least 0 activities outside school time, and at most 2, but only if one is a weekday evening and 1 is at the weekend. Your 6 year old between 0-3 things - Maximum 1 at the weekend. These should be their own things that they want to do/progress at. Otherwise some reading/spellings/other homework, lots of playing, family trips out (often local, walks in woods, park, etc), but sometimes maybe bigger - seaside, theme park, soft play, farm etc. What your kids need most is family time to be loved and cherished and to share stuff together. Also make time for seeing family and friends.

Happinessisnowhere · 28/06/2023 21:31

This

Sillyname63 · 28/06/2023 21:31

How the hell will you manage to work as a nurse once you qualify? If he expects you to be available every afternoon for ferrying your children to after school activities? Does the child want to play golf? Or don't they get a way in the matter much like you?

Oioicaptain · 28/06/2023 21:29

It's really none of his business what activities you do with the kids when he's at work! You don't tell him what to do when he's at work. You are 'working' when you are looking after the children. He clearly has issues. This is very controlling behaviour and very wrong of him to tell the kids that you don't want to take them. I would explain to them that actually you feel as that downtime would be beneficial to you all.
You also need to stand up to him and also do this in front of your children. If you don't, then you are teaching them that it is ok for some people to control others. Would you like them to grow up like you (without much of a voice) or worse, like your husband? Or do you want them to grow up with healthy ideas about how to manage relationships. It sounds very much to me that he doesn't want you to succeed because then he has the upper hand.

lauraisa · 28/06/2023 21:25

Is he a brain surgeon or what is he doing that's so important that he can't take his kids to their activities?

Doone21 · 28/06/2023 21:22

Whys he not doing this? It's totally ridiculous. I get that people don't want to miss out but they're babies, they don't know what they like or don't like. It's just as important to teach children how to cope with too many choices. Each child should pick one, stick with it for a year before they're allowed to swap, etc

BungalowBuyer · 28/06/2023 21:16

Absolutely crazy, far too much for your very young dc never mind you. I had a three activity rule with dd, if she wanted to do a fourth activity she had to drop one, off I'd had more dc it would probably have been two activities.

Oioicaptain · 28/06/2023 21:15

Bloody hell. That is crazy. Children do far too much today! they need downtime. At that age, school is enough! When they get a little older, then one or two hours of activity a week is plenty. Ask him where his research is that keeping busy over downtime is best for brain development in children? Also tot up the costs (Inc petrol) and the time commitment upon you and the children each week. He sounds as though he hasn't got a clue to be honest.

3AndStopping · 28/06/2023 21:12

Honestly by Monday I thought that’s enough. This is madness.

Nursejackie1 · 28/06/2023 21:10

You say you are “not allowed “ to not do things.
You are an adult. You are allowed to do what you want and don’t do what you don’t want!
Why on earth don’t you tell him to fuck off with his demands?

OhcantthInkofaname · 28/06/2023 21:07

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 22:59

He will just lay on massive guilt trips or say stuff to my son like “mum doesn’t want to take you” and that hurts. I do want the best for my kids but I am so mentally exhausted.

Speak up - when he tries to guilt trip. Tell your son mum can't do any more and dad doesn't help.

ZickZack · 28/06/2023 21:06

Your wording speaks volumes. "Not allowed to drop things". That's madness. Why does he get to dictate without doing any of the work?

Bizarre.

I'd be dropping either Football or acting classes as well as the park run. Dancing and tennis for both is more than enough right now.

Perfect28 · 28/06/2023 21:05

Lots of people talking about the activities and not the clearly abusive relationship. Why isn't he doing these tasks? How on earth could he force you?

Lifeomars · 28/06/2023 21:02

I felt exhausted just reading that

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 28/06/2023 21:02

Someone may have already suggested this but why not ask your ds what he wants to do, but phrase it in an either/or fashion e.g. "you can start golf but you'll need to give up dance/drama/a football session a week" and see what he says.
My niece goes to club after club and wanted to start gymnastics so she was asked to choose which one to give up in place and soon realised she'd rather keep doing what she's doing. They need that downtime, particularly at 4 and 6.

If his dad is so desperate for him to do it (which sounds a whole lot like he's projecting his dreams on to your kid!), then I'd play him at the same game and say to your ds "you can go if your dad takes you but as I already take you to lots of clubs and have to work too, I can't squeeze any more in". Dad sounds like a dick BTW.

OhcantthInkofaname · 28/06/2023 21:01

Children can be exhausted by too many activities. Two is supposed to be an adequate number per child.

swimminginthesun · 28/06/2023 20:55

Sorry, haven’t rtft, but I’m baffled. How is any of this possible during a nursing degree? What do you do while on placement?! You can’t just run off to take your kids to their activities. What child care do you have in place? How do you see this working once you are qualified and have a job?

lartgut · 28/06/2023 20:50

Personally I'm a fan of extracurricular activities and my 4yo DD does loads, but we stick to fairly local stuff and I'm a sahm so I'm not trying to do studying and shift work on top! I think with your nursing you need to cut back on them or insist on an after school nanny to take them, I can't see how it could logistically work with nursing shifts and 2 dc once you've finished studying. Most of my DD's activities are at her school so it gives me more of a break before picking her up, so you could look at what's on offer at school, or even switching to a school with better extracurriculars on offer. DH does 2 weekend classes with DD - one is a parent+child class so a nice bonding time as well as fun for DD.

porridgeisbae · 28/06/2023 20:48

At that age I don't think kids are that bothered about activities- they're still doing and seeing something new every day without even having to go to 'activities' much to find it.

jojo2202 · 28/06/2023 20:48

sorry but at 4&6 2 activities a week are more than enough. Even the kids i suspect are exhausted. I would drop acting and tennis at that age. Dancing and footy enough but footy once a week max

Ffion21 · 28/06/2023 20:48

I think the focus on the kids schedule by everyone is kinda irrelevant. For a 4 year old if they’re not doing huge amounts during the day (assuming pre-school) then the amount of activities isn’t too much. The 6 year old seems a lot given he has school, but again different kids cope with different amounts of extra curricular.

the real focus and concern is that YOU are struggling. If you weren’t doing your nursing qualifications and having to juggle two kids diaries on your own, and were happy with the arrangement it would be different.

However you’re feelings are being ignored and in quite a major way.

kids don’t need golf and acting (or even football!). They need a happy mum.

my own son (finishing Yr1):

Monday and Tuesday - after school club

Wednesday - nothing

Thursday - beavers (2 weeks in). Starts 515pm though, so downtime beforehand.

Friday - cricket (8 week course, last one tomorrow) (5-6pm).

Saturday - swimming and football (if he fancies it)

The only one I won’t compromise on is swimming as that’s a life skill. The rest he does for fun. He loves cricket and is gutted that course is ending. He however is loving beavers.

He doesn’t ‘need’ football, so if tired after swimming or he just wants to relax we do that and play it by ear.

Typically it’s me who does most of the clubs, not because husband won’t , but because I love going. Husband always comes to cricket because he really enjoys playing with him.

Neither of us would dream of forcing our son or each other to do any of this.

You need to question why he’s behaving this way and being quite so controlling.

Twoboys2023 · 28/06/2023 20:47

This sounds like a controlling relationship at best, abusive at worst. This is not normal in any kind of healthy partnership. He should be supporting you in your studying and lightening the load as much as he possibly can. Not adding to your list of things to do. You are absolutely right in wanting to drop things and make your life simpler. Are you happy in the relationship? If not, do you think counselling might help? If he won’t engage with that, I’d suggest thinking about how you might be able to get out.

porridgeisbae · 28/06/2023 20:46

I agree. I think his communication is very poor and has always been.

Oh he communicates what he wants all he wants very well, and repeatedly, repeatedly it seems.

You need to improve you're communication because you're saying how you feel and then ending up doing something else.

Who made him God?

Say no to him on repeat OP when you feel it, and mean it, and do it, don't back down.

You're not being unreasonable at all.

Him saying negative stuff to your children about you is abusive to you all.