Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband expects me to do so many out of school activities

506 replies

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 22:50

I have a 4 & 6 year old and current time table is;

monday acting class for both in our local area, an hour later my son has football out of our area and leaves a lot of hanging about as not enough time to go home.

tuesday - football for my son, meaning I’m driving home to go back out of town

Friday - tennis in local area this is fine (for both)

Saturday - football out of town and then dancing (dancing for both)

sunday - park run out of our area

I messaged him and spoke today about how I need to drop something as I’m going into my final
year of nursing and I work bank shifts too, I simply can’t cope anymore. But instead of any compassion he’s asked me to now take my son to golf lessons on Thursday evenings (6 week course) I should point out that most of these activities are on during the summer holidays.

he’s making me feel like I want my own children to miss out. Of course I don’t, I’m just so mentally drained.

so am I being unreasonable to say no the golf (not that I have much of a choice, I most likely will be forced)

OP posts:
Throwncrumbs · 28/06/2023 10:54

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 23:02

If he’s not working he can, depends on the weekend. Not sure how it will all work in the future when I graduate. I think I will have to take a community 9-5 post

Do not take a 9to5 community post. That’s an end of career job, not for a newly qualified nurse. It’s a waste of your hard earned degree. You should aim to do a position that will enhance your career, where you will get the experience to forward yourself and your potential earnings. Your partner doesn’t want you bettering yourself does he!

BlueMongoose · 28/06/2023 10:53

BlockbusterVideoCard · 28/06/2023 10:43

Goodness, I'd cancel most of that and focus on my full-time/condensed degree until it is finished. One class a week each, preferably together, would be fine. Even none would be fine at a critical point.

I suspect that Big Important Man either hasn't got a clue what either a nursing or full care parenting involves (and doesn't want to know because it's all women's work) or he's setting you up to fail, consciously or otherwise, and be dependent upon and a skivvy to him.

I'd be working on ditching him. Which is perhaps what you ARE doing? How is the childcare going to work once you are qualified, since he never does anything with regard to that and (deliberately) doesn't know his schedule in advance?

Btw I know lots of people with Big Important Jobs (men and women) who aren't like this, and use the fact that they do run the show to actually get more flexibility in taking Jonny to football once a week and Jenny to nursery most mornings. Or at the very least they appreciate and support what the partner is doing while they do genuinely work ridiculously long hours.

Yep. Like those blokes on the train in the early days of mobile phones who were 'doing deals' and 'checking in' to work very loudly (often you could tell they were completley pissing off the people they were talking at just by listening to one side of the conversation). A serious buisnessman once said that that sort of behaviour just proved they were low down the pecking order and/or completely disorganised or lousy bosses, as an efficient senior exec in a well-run company doesn't want or need to be in frequent contact when travelling.

GiveOverRover · 28/06/2023 10:51

He is trying to run you into the ground.

If you feel unable to say no to what "husband expects.." because you fear his reaction or it's not worth the punishment then you are being controlled.
Keep your head in the game with your qualification, because you will need your own career when you leave this prick, and I sincerely hope that you do. I have been where you are, it is real, it is happening, as mad as it seems. It is not you. Head down, guard yourself, get help from people who will believe you, and get out. This is not how you have to spend your life.

123wdcd · 28/06/2023 10:49

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/06/2023 10:27

Yes I’ve heard of a primary school child in a similar situation. Burst into tears at school as he had activities every night and no downtime. It’s awful

I know some with similar issues. Major anxiety and not good at integrating with other kids in an informal setting. Kids learn so much by unstructured play with friends it is sad when those opportunities are taken away from them.

Years ago I read a study claiming that children who were heavily hothoused with pressure to achieve had similar levels of stress to those living in dysfunctional/abusive homes.

With after school activities, we found the best ones were those that were easy for the children to do. For example, the local football club (widened their friendship group at school as other pupils there, including older ones who ended up looking out for them a bit in the playground), after school clubs which did not involve a commute, etc.

BlueMongoose · 28/06/2023 10:48

GCalltheway · 28/06/2023 09:17

My friends son had a breakdown at school
during a rugby match, something snapped within him, it was so shocking to all of us parents as we were watching the match.he was carried off screaming. It was frightening. He was off school for months, and had extensive treatment for his mental health. He was ten. His timetable looked a lot like yours op, back to back activities every single day.

The worst thing was that the parents blamed him, and continued with the same timetable for his younger sister who looked like a bloated ghost with dark circles under her eyes and a heavy exhaustion. She always ate crap food on the go in the back of the car, never had a second to herself and barely spoke at school.

It felt to me like child abuse.

I'd agree about it looking like child abuse. I have a bit to do with horses, some parents are so pushy and demanding of their kids it is unbelievable. It would be regarded as unacceptable bullying if a teacher did exactly the same. It ruins the kids' enjoyment, and for some of them, pushes them too far from their comfort zone into places where they are just scared and lose confidence. I saw one kid in tears at a competition who clearly didn't want to compete- the parents were telling the kid off and saying 'we have spent all this money, you have to'. What a stupid reason for forcing a child to do anything.

BlockbusterVideoCard · 28/06/2023 10:43

Goodness, I'd cancel most of that and focus on my full-time/condensed degree until it is finished. One class a week each, preferably together, would be fine. Even none would be fine at a critical point.

I suspect that Big Important Man either hasn't got a clue what either a nursing or full care parenting involves (and doesn't want to know because it's all women's work) or he's setting you up to fail, consciously or otherwise, and be dependent upon and a skivvy to him.

I'd be working on ditching him. Which is perhaps what you ARE doing? How is the childcare going to work once you are qualified, since he never does anything with regard to that and (deliberately) doesn't know his schedule in advance?

Btw I know lots of people with Big Important Jobs (men and women) who aren't like this, and use the fact that they do run the show to actually get more flexibility in taking Jonny to football once a week and Jenny to nursery most mornings. Or at the very least they appreciate and support what the partner is doing while they do genuinely work ridiculously long hours.

Panapan · 28/06/2023 10:39

Studies have shown that it’s actually so important for children to have unstructured play time - not just for fun but it’s part of their development. They learn problem solving skills, independence, collaboration etc - so much key development happens through play. If they are timetabled every minute this allows no room for this kind of development. It’s not a case of your children missing out if you drop some of the activities. You can tell your husband that they are missing out at the moment precisely because of the activities!

BlueMongoose · 28/06/2023 10:39

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 22:57

Please note I want to drop some of it but I’m simply not allowed.

Allowed?
I don't like the sound of that.
What are you thinking he would do if you just said, 'No, I am not doing that'?

123wdcd · 28/06/2023 10:38

With that schedule at those ages your husband is the one making the kids 'miss out' - on socialising and learning to unwind.

Swimming is the most important extra curricular activity and well worth doing a lot of to be safe in the water. So much more important than golf as a skill to learn when young.

A bit of football is useful when young to have basic skills in place when lessons start at school, but if the kids want to they will push to do more when older/play a lot with friends at the local pitch (I did sport to a high level, so not anti-coaching at all).

If I was still living in a flat I would do more after school activities, to be outside and away from screens. In a house with a garden they get lots of exercise and can easily have friends over to kick a ball around if they want to.

pastelmagenta · 28/06/2023 10:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/06/2023 10:27

GCalltheway · 28/06/2023 09:17

My friends son had a breakdown at school
during a rugby match, something snapped within him, it was so shocking to all of us parents as we were watching the match.he was carried off screaming. It was frightening. He was off school for months, and had extensive treatment for his mental health. He was ten. His timetable looked a lot like yours op, back to back activities every single day.

The worst thing was that the parents blamed him, and continued with the same timetable for his younger sister who looked like a bloated ghost with dark circles under her eyes and a heavy exhaustion. She always ate crap food on the go in the back of the car, never had a second to herself and barely spoke at school.

It felt to me like child abuse.

Yes I’ve heard of a primary school child in a similar situation. Burst into tears at school as he had activities every night and no downtime. It’s awful

Frankenpug23 · 28/06/2023 10:20

Flopberry · 27/06/2023 22:59

He will go on and on and the guilt will be unreal. It’s awful

Tell him to shut the fuck up and if he wants them to go he can take them - that is far to much activity the kids must be knackered too! I am sorry you need to stand your ground and don’t give into the guilt! He is being a total idiot I am afraid, this is bullying and dickish behaviour!

Just cancel the activity.

How much housework does he do to support his family?

Hairyfairy01 · 28/06/2023 10:18

How is he supporting you with your degree OP? What will happen if you can't get a 9-5 community job?

PinkIcedCream · 28/06/2023 10:13

That’s far too much stuff going on for such young children. Mine did no more than one after school activity a week which got dropped by about 12yrs old. Kids really don’t need all that extra curricular stuff but some middle class parents seem to think they must do a million activities in order to be successful in life. 🙄

OP, the ‘not allowed’ is a massive red flag here. This is the problem you need to focus on resolving, not the amount of after school activities.

You need to sit down with him and tell him it’s not working for you currently and that you need to make changes. Explain about how you’re feeling overwhelmed etc. and tell him you want to drop down to a maximum of 2 after school activities.

If he’s unwilling to consider any changes, you have to look into your options going forwards. Take some control back and stop letting another person run your life. This is not a healthy relationship and is also harming your children as well as yourself.

VestaTilley · 28/06/2023 10:13

YANBU. If he’s signing them up to all this he should take him. And if he isn’t going to take him then the activities will need to drop to a more manageable level.

If your DC are only 6 and 4 they’re probably exhausted with this on top of a school day, and the 6 year old needs to leave time for homework. Also you can’t be expected to run yourself ragged when you’re already nursing!

Viviennemary · 28/06/2023 10:09

Don't say no to the golf. If he takes them or arranges for somebody else to take them fine. He isnt your boss.

billy1966 · 28/06/2023 10:09

He never knows what his schedule is for the next day for his big important job?

Bullshit

He just likes not having to ever be responsible for anything to do with his family.

He dictates your day and controls you all from afar.

So abusive and coercive.

Coercive control is a crime.

You are afraid of him.

Your poor children.

Thehokeypokey · 28/06/2023 10:06

He's getting ready to make you feel terrible about starting your new nursing career which he knows means that something will have to give for him. You're already considering limiting your career options by saying you'll have to look at community roles. I really feel for you but you have to stand your ground now otherwise you'll find it more and more difficult to claim it back.

missingeu · 28/06/2023 10:03

I'd recommend speaking to a counsellor attached to uni - it'll be free and if your uni works suffers due to home life the counsellor can support you with this. This would be my frist course of action, plus womens aid.

Discuss with your children which actiivites they like the most and do just do these.

If your DH gets stroppy let him, ignore him and move forward. It'll help build up the resilience required in nursing.

Wobblybobble · 28/06/2023 10:02

Yeah that’s too much, OP. My 7 year old does 4 extracurriculars, but three of those are very low-commitment ‘show up and have fun for an hour/week’ things that we can skip if she’s tired (or if I’m tired). One is on a Saturday when DH can take her, and we carpool with the neighbors for one, which cuts down on the shuttling back and forth.

I’d tell your husband that you need to drop something if you are taking on something else, otherwise he needs to take on the responsibility for getting the kids to/from lessons.

What do your kids say? Are they actually really wanting to do all these things? I’d sit down with them to see which of these they actually want to continue doing.

Our policy is only one intensive extracurricular each year. DD is welcome to sign up to try whatever else might catch her interest that year, but it needs to be low-commitment and school-adjacent. For my daughter, her intensive is music. She plays an instrument which entails daily practice, weekly music theory classes, weekly lessons, occasional performances, and (when she gets older) ensembles. She loves it, but it’s more than enough activity in the week just on its own, so everything else she does needs to be chilled out and low-commitment.

We drop everything structured, instrument lessons included, over the summer. She absolutely needs those two months to recharge, rest, and experience boredom.

mummymeister · 28/06/2023 10:00

FFS they are 4 and 6 when do they actually get time on their own to play make believe and just lie around and relax. absolutely bonkers competitive parenting that leaves kids exhausted and unable to just be.

Kennykenkencat · 28/06/2023 09:56

Please note I want to drop some of it but I’m simply not allowed

People are not allowed to do lots of things like shop lift, murder, park on a double yellow line. But people still do these things and when caught they get community service, prison or a fine.

What is your “punishment” if you do something you are not allowed to do.

If it is him haranguing you for not doing as you are told then divorce so you don’t have to listen to it

This doesn’t sound like a relationship of equals but more of Company Director and office assistant.

He issues instructions to make things happen and you toe the line or you get fired.

I think there are serious problems in your marriage once you start saying you are not allowed to not do something you don’t want to do.

StillWantingADog · 28/06/2023 09:52

sorry op this sounds like a difficult situation. There is no way your kids need to do that much. But more to the pointt forcing you to take them here there and everywhere is completely unacceptable.

For context my kids are a bit older and yes I've done a fair amount of shuttling them to and forth but they are not nearly as busy as yours. I am quite insistent on fitting in my own extra curricular activities in the weekly schedule too. However the taxying has been done by both of us, I probably do slightly more as I work p-t however he has done around 40% of the ferrying over the years and has certainly never pressed it as being my responsibility.

I think you have two choices.

  1. leave him (admit that's not straightforward)
  2. grow a backbone, cancel some of the activities, refuse to take on more, and tell him how it is.
OhCrumbsWhereNow · 28/06/2023 09:47

This is nuts for a 4 and 6 year old - and I say that as someone with a child with a very full-on extra curricular timetable.

Swap the acting and dance classes for one weekend MT class where they cover acting, dance and singing in one session, and cut the football down to once a week - twice max.

Golf is fine for a holiday club, but not to add the a weekly schedule.

Once the kids are older and it's led by them, then fine... add some more if finances and scheduling allow, but your husband is being completely mad expecting you to do all of this. If he dictates, then up to him to facilitate.

TheOrigRights · 28/06/2023 09:47

Are they his children, too? Only you talking about 'my son' etc a lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread