Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think peoples lives are crap enough without needing the government to interfere with Meal Deals

581 replies

Jeansmeansheinz · 27/06/2023 20:32

FFS just let people have the pleasure of a Meal Deal. I really don't need the Government telling me what I can and can't eat.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Screwballs · 28/06/2023 11:37

Theoldgreygoose · 28/06/2023 11:09

Funnily enough walking has always worked for me, at any stage of my life. With the amount I eat I should be huge, but I'm not because I walk everywhere and go for a long walk every day. Any time I have started to walk more than usual I have lost weight.

Walking everywhere/having a dog etc, thats a difference, but going out for a half hour walk a day just isnt effective. Good on you though, Im really not trying to be disparaging, I just think that if people want to lose weight that arent usually active, there are better ways to do it. Walking isnt a strenuous activity, people would be better off swimming or on a push bike

Badbadbunny · 28/06/2023 11:36

Theoldgreygoose · 28/06/2023 11:09

Funnily enough walking has always worked for me, at any stage of my life. With the amount I eat I should be huge, but I'm not because I walk everywhere and go for a long walk every day. Any time I have started to walk more than usual I have lost weight.

Ditto. Walking is exactly what caused my weight loss (5 stones to date), and what brought down my blood pressure and blood sugar levels.

Prior to that, I was dieting on and off, going to the gym once or twice a week, doing occasional golf, tennis, squash, etc., but nothing consistently every day, and weight wouldn't shift.

Daily walking 10,000 steps has worked miracles. I'm ashamed that I still eat a lot of crap, but weight has come off and has stayed off, by consistent daily walking, rain or shine.

SunnyEgg · 28/06/2023 11:34

Hecate01 · 28/06/2023 09:47

Drakeford is determined that we will not enjoy ourselves in any capacity in Wales. Alcohol tax, meal deal interfering, driving 20mph everywhere etc.

Maybe if he pumped more money into educating people and into the NHS instead of wasting millions on upgrading A&E waiting rooms with wifi, buying farms for festivals, stopping road construction halfway through and wasting millions and buying airports that don't make a profit things would be very different.

Be careful what you wish for when you say you'd rather a labour government because we've had one in Wales for a long time and we are no better off for it.

I know people are thinking Labour getting in here will be great and all that but Wales makes me feel more reticent.

I don’t want that here tbh (and feel for those who don’t want it there either)

Fizbosshoes · 28/06/2023 11:28

Twiglets1 · 28/06/2023 11:06

Agreed. MIL always makes a big thing about how great she used to be always cooking from scratch until she reached her 80s and couldn't do it anymore.

Her and FIL are both obese with diabetes. Huge portions and lots of home made puddings combined with little exercise will do that for you.

Ready meals do at least give you dietary information these days so you are aware when your portion size is ridiculously high in calories or fat/sugar/salt etc. She always claims she doesn't eat much but she does. I also notice at home that when we have home cooked food my husband and son will routinely have seconds where available. This is not possible when we have ready meals and they are content with the amount they have eaten once they leave the table.

My mum was overweight, possibly obese. I think partly was genetic (I didn't know my GPS but pictures of them show they were definitely overweight and also her brother was very overweight). She was a very good cook and cooked a lot from scratch. She would say she was "naughty" if she had a 2 stick kitkat or a penguin biscuit for example (probably 110 kcal ish) but wouldn't have any qualms about having a slice of cake that either she or a friend had baked because it was home made
If she made a quiche for example it would be nicer than a bought one but also much bigger.

Having said that I think homecooking is healthier if you are careful about portion sizes.

Jeansmeansheinz · 28/06/2023 11:26

600 calories is actually quite a lot for lunch!
Especially considering it's probably 5 days a week

That really depends on the persons lifestyle and what else they're eating that day. Plenty of manual labourers for example get meal deals.

How about if they heavily subsidised leisure centres and built new ones. Get heavily discounted healthy lunch options in workplaces more, encourage employers to give an hour or two off per week to attend a gym or have classes yoga aerobics or whatever in workplaces at the end of the day. There's lots that could be done. Being nanny state and stopping people getting an affordable lunch that they choose is wrong to me.

OP posts:
BlockbusterVideoCard · 28/06/2023 11:16

In all the meal deal places that I go to, there are lots of healthy options in the snack and drink options. Therefore I think that the same people who go for the full fat crisps and coke option will just go for this in other ways without meal deals, and vice versa.

However, some people will go for the higher calories-for-cost option because they are managing their budget and their calorific needs this way. I do a bit of both, depending what else I am going to eat that day.

I don't think it is the 2-fors and meal deals that are the issue per se, I think it's other complex factors in society. Stress and lack of sleep being two important ones. Time and energy costs and lack of facilities to cook being 3 more.

Twiglets1 · 28/06/2023 11:12

Badbadbunny · 28/06/2023 10:31

Realistically, so many things are contributing to society's obesity and other health issues.

School games/sports only really work for the sporty/team kids - they put off those who are less fit or who don't like team sports. Most games teachers are the team sports lovers/bullies of 20 years ago, so the problem just perpetuates from generation to generation. We need a whole new attitude to exercise in schools, concentrating more on alternatives such as gym work, yoga, "solo" sports/exercise, so that the less "sporty" ones who can't do well in team games can do other things. I hated sports at school and ended up pretty inactive, but in later life, I've done all kinds of "non team" sports, such as golf, swimming, squash, tennis, skiing, cycling, walking, etc and found I was actually pretty good at them and enjoyed them.

School cookery is a shambles. When I was at school 40 years ago, it was all bakery, i.e. scones, cakes, etc. When my son was at school 10 years ago, it was all curries, vegetarian/vegan, etc. One extreme to the other. How about teaching basics/fundamentals such as how to make a roast dinner, how to cook a chicken, how to make a lasagne/cottage pie, etc?

NHS dietary advice is pathetic. I have diabetes and have had "consultations" with several NHS dieticians and diabetic nurse specialists. None have given me any workable/sensible eating options. All their advice is "eat more lentils", or "have fruit and nuts for breakfast" - basic text book "advice" more or less just regurgitating what their guidance books say. But absolutely zero practical advice! For someone with no interest in lentils or nuts for breakfast, I need someone with more realistic advice. In the real world, due to caring and work commitments, I'm going to eat something from a packet in the morning, and probably an evening meal including something from a tin. When I've said this and asked for advice as to which kind of breakfast packet cereal is best, or which tinned soup is best, they can't answer - they just go back to their "lentils and nuts" speech. Yes, I know whatever Kelloggs packet I have at breakfast time isn't perfect, but in reality, it's what I'm going to have, so I'd like to know which would be best to minimise diabetic issues. They can't answer because they don't know. I've had to work it out for myself by trial and error, checking my blood sugar levels after each type, likewise with tinned food. The NHS "specialists" aren't in the real world, and that's why the "healthy eating" message isn't working - they're just parroting the "perfect world" options rather than real life/practical options which would help!

Totally agree.

I hated PE at school too and it's taken me years to find things I enjoy because in my own mind I was someone not suited to any kind of exercise.

And the NHS dietary advice should be more pragmatic and accept no one's perfect (even the people regurgitating the "perfect" advice are sometimes overweight so they should know). I aim for making small steps in the right direction and that's more likely to be successful than trying to completely overhaul my diet and lifestyle.

Anxioys · 28/06/2023 11:12

@Comedycook - true. But I bet you don't eat it every day as some do with McDonalds, and it will have much greater nutritional value than McDonalds. I bet that you are also reasonably active and have a balanced diet. But 60 percent of the country appear to be struggling with that one because they are overweight.

If you eat a high fat diet of mostly junk food it can be very bad for your liver. Effectively it can become fatty, like pate. For a lot of people, eating high fat food is a daily habit.

putthatdownsteve · 28/06/2023 11:10

There’s also a huge amount of seed oils in UPF. If you look into the side effects of seed oils, the studies on weight gain etc, it’s very enlightening.

I stick to butter, extra virgin olive oil (I drink 2 tablespoons of olive oil, the juice of a lemon and a teaspoon of turmeric and cayenne pepper each morning, it’s amazing), and cook with coconut oil or ghee for curries.

Do you know the amount of people in my life have told me that I will definitely die of a heart attack? Usually while they are stuffing down some processed crap or something made of sugar or fake sugar that I haven’t touched in years.

My mother in law gets very worried about that, and pulls faces that my children eat good fats.

She’s deeply entrenched in the view that vegetable oils or those awful 1 cal spray oils are the healthiest. She’s been losing and gaining the same stone and feeling tired and like crap at weight watchers for a decade living off their fake food bars and ready meals. I’ll stick with what I’m doing.

Theoldgreygoose · 28/06/2023 11:09

Screwballs · 28/06/2023 08:35

Walking is not an effective way to lose weight, its great for general mobility but anything that does not get the heart pumping is having no more effect than wandering around your own home.

Funnily enough walking has always worked for me, at any stage of my life. With the amount I eat I should be huge, but I'm not because I walk everywhere and go for a long walk every day. Any time I have started to walk more than usual I have lost weight.

Twiglets1 · 28/06/2023 11:06

Comedycook · 28/06/2023 10:12

Cooking from scratch is a fallacy. Yes it's better than eating takeaways every day...but it's very easy to become overweight or obese eating home cooked food. I can make a home made lasagna from scratch with lovely fresh ingredients and it will probably contain more calories than a ready made one.

Agreed. MIL always makes a big thing about how great she used to be always cooking from scratch until she reached her 80s and couldn't do it anymore.

Her and FIL are both obese with diabetes. Huge portions and lots of home made puddings combined with little exercise will do that for you.

Ready meals do at least give you dietary information these days so you are aware when your portion size is ridiculously high in calories or fat/sugar/salt etc. She always claims she doesn't eat much but she does. I also notice at home that when we have home cooked food my husband and son will routinely have seconds where available. This is not possible when we have ready meals and they are content with the amount they have eaten once they leave the table.

Comedycook · 28/06/2023 11:00

I'm making roast pork belly for dinner tonight with roast potatoes, Yorkshire puddings and apple sauce, all from scratch. I can guarantee it will have more calories in it than a burger and fries from McDonald's.

flurbubbly · 28/06/2023 10:56

Bread (unless you're making your own bread from scratch) is UPF.

Cheese can be UPF.

Cured meat is UPF.

Supermarket sandwiches don't have scary chemicals in them that other sandwiches somehow magically don't have.

The comments here about pre-packaged sandwiches vs homemade/sandwich shop sandwiches show that people really don't understand what UPF are or the science behind them.

Twiglets1 · 28/06/2023 10:52

Hecate01 · 28/06/2023 09:47

Drakeford is determined that we will not enjoy ourselves in any capacity in Wales. Alcohol tax, meal deal interfering, driving 20mph everywhere etc.

Maybe if he pumped more money into educating people and into the NHS instead of wasting millions on upgrading A&E waiting rooms with wifi, buying farms for festivals, stopping road construction halfway through and wasting millions and buying airports that don't make a profit things would be very different.

Be careful what you wish for when you say you'd rather a labour government because we've had one in Wales for a long time and we are no better off for it.

Drakeford is awful I agree. I pity Wales having him as their leader. His behaviour during Covid was woeful.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/06/2023 10:44

MissyB1 · 28/06/2023 08:05

It would be perfectly easy to make your own packed lunch too…..

Tell me that again when you've had it leak all over your work laptop whilst travelling between sites.

SunnyEgg · 28/06/2023 10:38

neverbeenskiing · 28/06/2023 10:27

The only way I will get behind a tax on unhealthy food is if they use that money to lower the cost of healthy food. And yes you can live off chickpeas that are cheap but lots of people would rather good quality meat and veg and that shouldn't be beyond the reach of anyone.

This, with bells on. It is so tediously predictable that the current Government would come up with an "initiative" like this. Yes, rising rates of obesity and weight related health issues need to be tackled. But they're not commitimg to taking meaningful steps to stabilise the rocketing costs of decent quality food, or addressing the causes of poverty and poor Mental Health which are often linked to obesity, or properly funding health services so they can focus on prevention and early intervention to help people to manage their weight before they become clinically obese. No, let's make Meal Deals more expensive...that'll sort it. This is nothing more than paying lip-service.

I would happily pay more tax on unhealthy food if I believed for a second that it would be used to subsidise healthy food, or anything at all that was even vaguely useful and in the best interests of people's health and wellbeing. I have no confidence that this is the case at all.

It is so tediously predictable that the current Government would come up with an "initiative" like this

When you say current government you mean Labour in Wales?

It’s just Wales that are doing this. Stopping BOGOF has been postponed in rest of U.K.

Xeren · 28/06/2023 10:38

I look forward to the subsidised meals and bars in Parliament being closed down. Alcohol and caviar are just empty calories and we need to be concerned about of the health of our dear leaders!

ModernLifelsRubbish · 28/06/2023 10:37

Anxioys · 28/06/2023 10:28

@ModernLifelsRubbish - most meal deals will have the following. Stabilisers, preservatives, high levels of sugar and fat. It's a crap UPF sandwich with a chocolate bar and crisps.

Now that is just the food industry selling a highly processed product to you. All of this stuff is on the label.

If I go to a sandwich shop, they make it from scratch for me. That's not junk. But what Boots or say Tesco are selling is. Yes there will be people saying I eat sushi and carrot sticks. But who sees tons of that? What you see in the majority of cases is sandwiches (with bread made with palm oil and sugar for taste), whatever filing which will also have preservatives and taste enhancers included, and that is before you get to the chocolate or crisps. Those last two are very cheap to make, highly fatty and definitely are junk. They have calories. Their nutritional value is very small.

I don't eat any of that when I buy a meal deal. I was talking about my choices. I check the salt and sugar content scrupulously (health reasons for doing this).

A sandwich shop will still be using processed ingredients, including bread. And when I buy my lunches I see plenty of healthy looking people buying sushi and the like. When the Boots Meal deal was launched many years ago it was marketed as a healthy lunch choice and it absolutely still can be.

My health has improved drastically thanks to my new diet but I absolutely knew there would be someone along to tell me how unhealthy my diet is 😂

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/06/2023 10:36

Hawkins0001 · 28/06/2023 02:24

Fruit salad ?

A fruit salad is lunch? I thought it was dessert. And I'm not sure how I'm meant to sit at my desk chopping fruit...

Xeren · 28/06/2023 10:35

neverbeenskiing · 28/06/2023 10:27

The only way I will get behind a tax on unhealthy food is if they use that money to lower the cost of healthy food. And yes you can live off chickpeas that are cheap but lots of people would rather good quality meat and veg and that shouldn't be beyond the reach of anyone.

This, with bells on. It is so tediously predictable that the current Government would come up with an "initiative" like this. Yes, rising rates of obesity and weight related health issues need to be tackled. But they're not commitimg to taking meaningful steps to stabilise the rocketing costs of decent quality food, or addressing the causes of poverty and poor Mental Health which are often linked to obesity, or properly funding health services so they can focus on prevention and early intervention to help people to manage their weight before they become clinically obese. No, let's make Meal Deals more expensive...that'll sort it. This is nothing more than paying lip-service.

I would happily pay more tax on unhealthy food if I believed for a second that it would be used to subsidise healthy food, or anything at all that was even vaguely useful and in the best interests of people's health and wellbeing. I have no confidence that this is the case at all.

Yup! It’s not lost on me that this Government have been the harbingers of austerity, chipped away at NHS funding and pushing towards privatisation and profiteering. Been shamed by footballers to give poor children free lunch meals and food banks have become normalised and are a photo op for MPs and Royals, but meal deals are the problem! 😂

ModernLifelsRubbish · 28/06/2023 10:31

Comedycook · 28/06/2023 10:12

Cooking from scratch is a fallacy. Yes it's better than eating takeaways every day...but it's very easy to become overweight or obese eating home cooked food. I can make a home made lasagna from scratch with lovely fresh ingredients and it will probably contain more calories than a ready made one.

Absolutely. Plus it's easy to go back for seconds or to have larger portions than a measured, 450cal single serving ready meal one. Also you can monitor the salt and fat content more easily (don't tell me that everyone who cooks from scratch counts the saturated fat/salt in every ingredient, for every meal they make).

Ready meals are often seen as the devil incarnate but chosen carefully they can be a boon, particularly to those who can't cook from scratch for any number of reasons (disability, coat, older people, etc).

When I lost my five stone a ready made low fat cannelloni or fish pie was a staple, served with a bucket of fresh veg.

Badbadbunny · 28/06/2023 10:31

Realistically, so many things are contributing to society's obesity and other health issues.

School games/sports only really work for the sporty/team kids - they put off those who are less fit or who don't like team sports. Most games teachers are the team sports lovers/bullies of 20 years ago, so the problem just perpetuates from generation to generation. We need a whole new attitude to exercise in schools, concentrating more on alternatives such as gym work, yoga, "solo" sports/exercise, so that the less "sporty" ones who can't do well in team games can do other things. I hated sports at school and ended up pretty inactive, but in later life, I've done all kinds of "non team" sports, such as golf, swimming, squash, tennis, skiing, cycling, walking, etc and found I was actually pretty good at them and enjoyed them.

School cookery is a shambles. When I was at school 40 years ago, it was all bakery, i.e. scones, cakes, etc. When my son was at school 10 years ago, it was all curries, vegetarian/vegan, etc. One extreme to the other. How about teaching basics/fundamentals such as how to make a roast dinner, how to cook a chicken, how to make a lasagne/cottage pie, etc?

NHS dietary advice is pathetic. I have diabetes and have had "consultations" with several NHS dieticians and diabetic nurse specialists. None have given me any workable/sensible eating options. All their advice is "eat more lentils", or "have fruit and nuts for breakfast" - basic text book "advice" more or less just regurgitating what their guidance books say. But absolutely zero practical advice! For someone with no interest in lentils or nuts for breakfast, I need someone with more realistic advice. In the real world, due to caring and work commitments, I'm going to eat something from a packet in the morning, and probably an evening meal including something from a tin. When I've said this and asked for advice as to which kind of breakfast packet cereal is best, or which tinned soup is best, they can't answer - they just go back to their "lentils and nuts" speech. Yes, I know whatever Kelloggs packet I have at breakfast time isn't perfect, but in reality, it's what I'm going to have, so I'd like to know which would be best to minimise diabetic issues. They can't answer because they don't know. I've had to work it out for myself by trial and error, checking my blood sugar levels after each type, likewise with tinned food. The NHS "specialists" aren't in the real world, and that's why the "healthy eating" message isn't working - they're just parroting the "perfect world" options rather than real life/practical options which would help!

Xeren · 28/06/2023 10:30

Badbadbunny · 28/06/2023 10:16

The food processing/wholesale/retail industry is very clever and has designed itself to be within the rules of the monopolies/mergers commission etc.

That's why they do "retro" bonuses paid back by suppliers or "sell" prime shelving space to suppliers, etc. It's so they can show the M&M commission an invoice showing they pay 50p per tin of beans which they sell at 55p so it looks like they only make 5p profit per tin - perfectly reasonable. But then they get "kick backs" in other ways, such as tens of thousands of pounds for putting those tins of beans in the prime shelf (end of aisle, middle of stand, etc., rather than top/bottom shelf or a corner). Or they charge back the supplier tens of thousands if they hit sales targets. Lots of tricks like that which are designed solely to trick the regulators into making their pricing look sensible! Either the regulators are too thick to see what goes on, or they're in on the scams.

Wow! I had no idea!

Anxioys · 28/06/2023 10:28

@ModernLifelsRubbish - most meal deals will have the following. Stabilisers, preservatives, high levels of sugar and fat. It's a crap UPF sandwich with a chocolate bar and crisps.

Now that is just the food industry selling a highly processed product to you. All of this stuff is on the label.

If I go to a sandwich shop, they make it from scratch for me. That's not junk. But what Boots or say Tesco are selling is. Yes there will be people saying I eat sushi and carrot sticks. But who sees tons of that? What you see in the majority of cases is sandwiches (with bread made with palm oil and sugar for taste), whatever filing which will also have preservatives and taste enhancers included, and that is before you get to the chocolate or crisps. Those last two are very cheap to make, highly fatty and definitely are junk. They have calories. Their nutritional value is very small.

neverbeenskiing · 28/06/2023 10:27

The only way I will get behind a tax on unhealthy food is if they use that money to lower the cost of healthy food. And yes you can live off chickpeas that are cheap but lots of people would rather good quality meat and veg and that shouldn't be beyond the reach of anyone.

This, with bells on. It is so tediously predictable that the current Government would come up with an "initiative" like this. Yes, rising rates of obesity and weight related health issues need to be tackled. But they're not commitimg to taking meaningful steps to stabilise the rocketing costs of decent quality food, or addressing the causes of poverty and poor Mental Health which are often linked to obesity, or properly funding health services so they can focus on prevention and early intervention to help people to manage their weight before they become clinically obese. No, let's make Meal Deals more expensive...that'll sort it. This is nothing more than paying lip-service.

I would happily pay more tax on unhealthy food if I believed for a second that it would be used to subsidise healthy food, or anything at all that was even vaguely useful and in the best interests of people's health and wellbeing. I have no confidence that this is the case at all.