Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want the dc in economy while we are in business?

316 replies

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 19:30

Would be great to get others opinions...
We had some flyer miles and managed to book a much looked forward to, long haul, trip in business class for us and our 2 DC - 10 &11 in the summer holidays. Fast forward a few months and the PIL have decided to join us for the beginning part of the trip and booked economy tickets to join us. (They don't have any miles and the price a few months later for business for them both was unaffordable.)I feel terrible that my in-laws who are in their 70s will be in the back of the plane while my DH, DC and I will have big seats to ourselves. My DH thinks that both DC should take the economy seats and that they will be okay alone for 8 hours given we aren't too far away if they need us but I think one of us parents should be with 1 DC in economy instead as I don't want them alone on the flight. He thinks IBU to not let them and that I should enjoy my seat and not sit in economy. (I don't mind either although business will be a nice start to the holidays) Am I being overprotective? (Kids are good flyers generally and have done quite a few long hauls in the past)

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 28/06/2023 05:19

The children need to be with adults responsible for them. Doesn't matter what people did back in the day, unaccompanied minors etc.
2023 Children need to be with adults.

So children in their BC seats.
Either with parents or grandparents.

And I suggest you speak with the airline to check if you are allowed to swap with the ILs or is that an additional charge to have the names changed on the seats.

Birdsmakingnests · 28/06/2023 05:15

6 of us on a flight….

hubby , DS1 and I sat together, and parents in law with DS2 sat together about 6 rows behind us.
all good!

then we hit severe turbulence, it was horrific. And I was separated my DC2. All around people were petrified, in all honesty, I thought we were all doomed and I wouldn’t be with DC2. Crazy, I know, but if im going to fall 30,000 feet from the sky in a metal capsule, then I want to be holding my kid’s hands!

Glittertwins · 28/06/2023 05:07

If FIL "has a tricky back" then he should have thought about flights etc before choosing long haul flights. Seems to me that they had every intention of trying this guilt trip out. My parents are slightly older, they factor in business class tickets for every holiday flight they take.

JoanOfAllTrades · 28/06/2023 04:56

Adult ticket of the same kind. Not price!

JoanOfAllTrades · 28/06/2023 04:56

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/06/2023 23:29

They aren't locked in the hold. If there is a problem, one of their parents can go back to them.

Sitting around fabricating scenarios about a perfectly routine airline flight is absurd. Are they really such snowflakes? How do they manage school or walking around the neighbourhood?

Ten and 11 year olds should be capable of being responsible and well-behaved in public without a parent hovering over them.

But they aren’t in public per se are they? Or at school or whatever other silly comparison you wish to make.

They will be in an environment that is completely new to them and they won’t be able to get to their parents and possibly their parents won’t be able to get to them either, depending on the airlines policy regarding walking about from economy to business. Regardless of whether they are seasoned travellers or not, these children may be on an aeroplane that they’ve never been on before.

Plus, is it really fair to expect people who have actually paid, as opposed to getting free flights with air miles to have to put up with kids possibly coming in and out all the time? Or parents doing the same.

Since you don’t have children of that age can you really know what you would do in that situation? And with the best will in the world, children do bicker or tease each other or just generally be silly, more so when it’s more than one child as they egg each other on.

Just because the children have flown before, doesn’t mean they won’t get air sick due to food, or perhaps have mean adults glaring at them or worse, telling them off for going to the toilet too often etc.

@Flymeinbusiness pp have mentioned that the cost of an under-12 bc ticket may well be much cheaper than an adult ticket of the same price. A better bet would be to be with PIL as they check in at the counter and say something to the effect of what a shame they can’t be travelling with you in bc. Perhaps they might get an upgrade or perhaps their own child should consider swapping with one of them!

Costco121 · 28/06/2023 04:48

Oh no no keep your kids with you. 70 if they are fit enough to travel is no age, my mil just went in 7 hour flight yesterday in the economy and she is 85

noenergy · 28/06/2023 04:13

Surely a kids business class ticket is cheaper than an adults so I don't think a swap is going to be so simple!

You and your husband should sit in economy

momonpurpose · 28/06/2023 04:11

MissTrip82 · 28/06/2023 01:46

For many many people it’s a cultural norm to prioritise older people.

I’m finding this resistance to ageism very refreshing, usually MN is full of people aghast at someone over 35 having a baby as they’re ‘on their knees’ at 28.

I agree. In my culture it's elderly and children first then everyone else

JoanOfAllTrades · 28/06/2023 04:10

I haven’t, as yet, read through the whole thread but a few things occur to me:

@Flymeinbusiness , you say that the PIL are joining you for the first leg - does this mean they disembark after 8 hours whilst you all fly onwards?

Also, forget all this stuff about predatory people seeing the kids alone, it strikes me that the reason why you wouldn’t be allowed to swap and/or constantly change seats would be for a far more sensible reason: should something happen, and the air stewards need to do a passenger count/check, they wouldn’t know who was who. They’re expecting 2 elderly people in those seats and instead get two unaccompanied minors and/or a child and a much younger person.

There’s also a good reason why a few airlines have changed their unaccompanied minors policy and it’s quite simply that their staff aren’t trained in childcare and the staff have to attend to the needs of all the passengers and can’t be tied up looking after 2 young children.

I don’t personally think that it matters how often the children have flown or how experienced they are at travelling, I used to fly 8 times a year as an under 12 and I did this on my own, navigating plane changes etc., and back in those days there wasn’t an unaccompanied minors policy, the staff knew that a child was flying unaccompanied and you sat near the staff seats, but I wouldn’t allow my children to fly unaccompanied until they were 16.

specialassistance · 28/06/2023 04:00

I wouldn't be too happy if I was sat next to a 10 and 12 year old in economy whilst their parents were in business.

I'd feel like I had to look out for them and that's not my role!

aloris · 28/06/2023 02:29

They never travel more than 2 hours away but you've bought seats in business class for a long haul trip and they've now decided for the first time ever to join you? Hmmm. Something tells me they were banking on switching their economy seats with your business class seats.

SunnySun1 · 28/06/2023 02:19

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 22:39

Thank you so much for all the comments! Lots to consider but I think the "What if something happens?" angle has made me feel like I need to stick to my guns and have at least one adult with a DC.. hopefully they won't mind one swap! We'll
ask first!
For context- we are pretty savvy with our miles credit cards and booking well in advance so have managed this a few times but my in-laws have never flown business and it'll be a huge treat for them.. plus - I think I'd feel uncomfortable sitting in a nice seat while the in-laws didn't especially as I've done it before- FIL has a bit of a tricky back too...They never travel more than 2 hours away and haven't left the UK for 3 years as they were nervous because of covid.. The way out is a day flight so I don't really mind being in economy with just 1 DC watching films...and I'd make DH swap half way - perhaps with the other DC so they both get a turn..
We aren't flying back with PIL so I'll enjoy my comfy seat on the way back.

PS: I definitely don't present a show with Phil but do love a good house programme!;)

Don't give up your business seat! If your DH is so bothered about his dad's 'tricky back' then he should swap with him for the entire journey. That means him sitting in economy with his mum whilst you, children and Fil sit in business class. His in laws knew this was a long flight so they could've bought business class seats too. Plenty of 70 odd year olds sit in economy and are fine.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/06/2023 02:16

SmartHome · 27/06/2023 23:40

I'd suggest your DH and his dad take the economy seats and you, MIL and the DC have a lovely time in business.

Realistically you could start off in your purchasesed seats and then let MIL and PIL.swapmwoth DH and one of the kids swap with them for an hour or so during the flight.

I would under no circumstances leave both kids to it at one time in economy, that's really unfair to them.

Whyis it"unfair to them"?!

MissTrip82 · 28/06/2023 01:46

EggInANest · 27/06/2023 21:17

If I was a grandparent (I am plenty old enough) I would be furious over the ageism of ‘OMG people in their 70s can’t endure a perfectly ordinary flight in economy’

For many many people it’s a cultural norm to prioritise older people.

I’m finding this resistance to ageism very refreshing, usually MN is full of people aghast at someone over 35 having a baby as they’re ‘on their knees’ at 28.

Betterlatethanontime · 28/06/2023 01:41

Why don’t you sit in economy and let the pil sit in business with the kids?

azlazee1 · 28/06/2023 01:25

Best solution - everyone stays in the seats they purchased.

Wanttobefree2 · 28/06/2023 01:19

Why should anyone else on the plane be responsible for your kids because all the adults want a jolly up the front :-( Because they will be if something happens.

YeahIsaidit · 28/06/2023 01:09

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/06/2023 23:08

I flew overseas as an unaccompanied minor at that age, with no problems. My parents weren't even on the aircraft let alone a cabin's length away.
What exactly are you worried about? Can they not use the entertainment system, sleep, eat, read, talk among themselves?

Put the kids in economy, let your in-laws enjoy an adult treat and relax.

If they wanted an adult treat, they should have booked business class seats when they decided they were going along too. Sure it's nice to treat people but not when it means your children missing out

DreamTheMoors · 28/06/2023 00:59

Why don’t you add money to the grandparents’ funds and upgrade them to Business Class?
Then everybody’s happy.

There’s absolutely no way, no how, I’d move my kids - or as a grandparent ask them to move from Business back to Economy.

There’s no shame in sitting in Economy.

Seddon · 28/06/2023 00:47

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 22:39

Thank you so much for all the comments! Lots to consider but I think the "What if something happens?" angle has made me feel like I need to stick to my guns and have at least one adult with a DC.. hopefully they won't mind one swap! We'll
ask first!
For context- we are pretty savvy with our miles credit cards and booking well in advance so have managed this a few times but my in-laws have never flown business and it'll be a huge treat for them.. plus - I think I'd feel uncomfortable sitting in a nice seat while the in-laws didn't especially as I've done it before- FIL has a bit of a tricky back too...They never travel more than 2 hours away and haven't left the UK for 3 years as they were nervous because of covid.. The way out is a day flight so I don't really mind being in economy with just 1 DC watching films...and I'd make DH swap half way - perhaps with the other DC so they both get a turn..
We aren't flying back with PIL so I'll enjoy my comfy seat on the way back.

PS: I definitely don't present a show with Phil but do love a good house programme!;)

If you're going to put this 'compromise' to your DH at least get him to do the first half in economy, in case the airline says no to you swapping.

YeahIsaidit · 28/06/2023 00:36

RogersOrganismicProcess · 27/06/2023 19:51

Do the PILs have any mobility issues that would make sitting in a cramped position painful? If so I would do one adult and child in BC on the way there, and the other parent and child in BC the way back.

They decided to invite themselves along and booked their own seats, if they have mobility issues etc they should have considered that when booking, not a chance in hell should the kids get bumped in favour of granny and grandad who muscled in

EconomyClassRockstar · 28/06/2023 00:33

I'd personally stay in the seats I booked and my parents would laugh their heads off as they headed to the back and my kids and I all waved and cheered as they went past. Which is exactly what we did!

Seddon · 28/06/2023 00:33

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/06/2023 23:08

I flew overseas as an unaccompanied minor at that age, with no problems. My parents weren't even on the aircraft let alone a cabin's length away.
What exactly are you worried about? Can they not use the entertainment system, sleep, eat, read, talk among themselves?

Put the kids in economy, let your in-laws enjoy an adult treat and relax.

When you fly as an unaccompanied minor the airline allocates a staff member to be responsible for looking after you. It's not the same as people just plonking their kids next to strangers at the back of the plane and hoping for the best. The seatbelt sign could be on for most of the flight and they wouldn't be able to get to their parents if they needed to.

ChocChipHandbag · 28/06/2023 00:18

PiL will be allowed to visit you in BC if there's any spare room, and may even be selected for upgrade if it's one of those flights where there's been a mixup and you manage to let the cabin crew know that you're part of the same family.

”One of those flights where there’s been a mixup”? Do you mean a flight which has been overbooked in economy, where there are free seats in BC? So a few lucky economy passengers are selected to move up a class and free up some space in economy?

I’m sorry to tell you that “being part of the same family” doesn’t get you to the front of the upgrade queue. Upgrades are most likely to go to people who have lots of loyalty point.

Remaker · 28/06/2023 00:08

It’s only 8 hrs! My mother did multiple 20+ hr trips on her own in economy when she was in her 70s.

No way would I ever fly separately from my kids. If your DH feels so strongly then he should pay to upgrade them.