Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want the dc in economy while we are in business?

316 replies

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 19:30

Would be great to get others opinions...
We had some flyer miles and managed to book a much looked forward to, long haul, trip in business class for us and our 2 DC - 10 &11 in the summer holidays. Fast forward a few months and the PIL have decided to join us for the beginning part of the trip and booked economy tickets to join us. (They don't have any miles and the price a few months later for business for them both was unaffordable.)I feel terrible that my in-laws who are in their 70s will be in the back of the plane while my DH, DC and I will have big seats to ourselves. My DH thinks that both DC should take the economy seats and that they will be okay alone for 8 hours given we aren't too far away if they need us but I think one of us parents should be with 1 DC in economy instead as I don't want them alone on the flight. He thinks IBU to not let them and that I should enjoy my seat and not sit in economy. (I don't mind either although business will be a nice start to the holidays) Am I being overprotective? (Kids are good flyers generally and have done quite a few long hauls in the past)

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 28/06/2023 14:58

Have the kids offered to swap or was this your dh 'asking' them "you're happy to swap with the gps so they can be comfortable aren't you?"

Katey83 · 28/06/2023 14:53

I’d be very surprised if an airline allow you and your husband/kids to keep swapping back and forth out of business and economy. I’m not even sure you can ‘give’ PIL seats to kids, you are not really supposed to sit in someone else’s seat, particularly not in a different class. You will have to pay to transfer them.

Flymeinbusiness · 28/06/2023 14:10

I think DH figures as they are smaller they'll need less space (DH is tall) and that they might like the independence. ( I'm sure they would!)

I'm happy to go in economy though and the kids (well, one of them anyway) won't mind travelling with one of us in economy if they'll let us swap. If not we'll just stick to our pre-booked seating.

My mind is made up though on not leaving the DC in another cabin. Good to know that I wasn't being over protective!

Didn't expect so many comments so thank you all!

OP posts:
ReachForTheMars · 28/06/2023 13:33

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 22:39

Thank you so much for all the comments! Lots to consider but I think the "What if something happens?" angle has made me feel like I need to stick to my guns and have at least one adult with a DC.. hopefully they won't mind one swap! We'll
ask first!
For context- we are pretty savvy with our miles credit cards and booking well in advance so have managed this a few times but my in-laws have never flown business and it'll be a huge treat for them.. plus - I think I'd feel uncomfortable sitting in a nice seat while the in-laws didn't especially as I've done it before- FIL has a bit of a tricky back too...They never travel more than 2 hours away and haven't left the UK for 3 years as they were nervous because of covid.. The way out is a day flight so I don't really mind being in economy with just 1 DC watching films...and I'd make DH swap half way - perhaps with the other DC so they both get a turn..
We aren't flying back with PIL so I'll enjoy my comfy seat on the way back.

PS: I definitely don't present a show with Phil but do love a good house programme!;)

Crazy idea, rather than asking your kids to make sacrifices for your inlaws so you look like nice guys, why dont you and DH fly economy and let the kids and PILS fly Business?

ReachForTheMars · 28/06/2023 13:29

Your husband seems like the sort that wants recognition for generosity that costs him nothing.

ReachForTheMars · 28/06/2023 13:28

Not volunteering to give up his seat is he?

In laws paid for economy because they are happy to fly economy.

Unless you want to give your kids the idea they are second class citizens then they keep their busi ess class seats.

StoreroomsCabinetsandCrates · 28/06/2023 13:25

@ChocChipHandbag yes but do the kids know this?

HisNibs · 28/06/2023 12:50

Mandoid · 28/06/2023 09:16

Not sure if anyone else has mentioned this, but if you paid less than the full price of an adult fare for your children, then allowing PIL to swap to their seats is rather cheeky. I'd see it as you trying to get the adult seats for cheap. (Though I dont know if it worked out cheaper to buy the business class seats with the airmiles)

Exactly what I was thinking. I would be surprised if the airline allowed this. Curious as to whether or not Op is planning to make any of these changes in advance of the flight or on the day. I doubt the cabin crew will be happy with people swapping around mid-flight.

If the plan is still to have the 10 & 11yr old children in Economy, they'll be unaccompanied minors which some airlines don't allow. Those that do charge for the service. I get that the parents are on the same flight but they're in a different part of the aircraft. In the event of an emergency, an adult needs to be with them immediately. There's another thread running discussing paying for seat reservations with the rules being that an adult has to be next to the minor be that next to, across the aisle or row in front/behind. The other end of the aircraft isn't acceptable.

The ILs had the opportunity to get better seats at a lower cost months ago. Instead, they've opted for a longer holiday and cheap seats.

ChocChipHandbag · 28/06/2023 12:47

StoreroomsCabinetsandCrates · 28/06/2023 12:44

I see the in-laws are flying back separately. You could say to the kids that if they behave impeccably in economy on the way out then they can travel business on the way back.

The kids’ business class return flights will already be booked, they’ll be flying back BC no matter how they behave in the way out.

StoreroomsCabinetsandCrates · 28/06/2023 12:44

I see the in-laws are flying back separately. You could say to the kids that if they behave impeccably in economy on the way out then they can travel business on the way back.

StoreroomsCabinetsandCrates · 28/06/2023 12:40

I am on the fence on this. The in-laws (especially at their age) are going to get a lot more benefit out of the business class seats than the kids are - the space, the food, the wine etc. I always think business class is a bit of a waste on kids who are usually just as happy in coach.

The children are 10 and 11 - perfectly able to plug into the in seat entertainment (watch whatever they want) and while away the flight in economy. They don't need as much space. If they are sat together then they have each other. I would visit them in their seats in economy from time to time (which is allowed - just not the other way around). You can visit them before take off and show them where the button is to call the attendant if they have any problems.

Do the kids know they are in business? If yes, it may be hard sell now to move them to economy.

In expat circles this would be very common - as would be kids their age travelling alone on such flights back to schools etc.

sevenbyseven · 28/06/2023 11:32

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

^^ This

Economy is completely standard and what most people travel in - yes, even over 70s! If you were all in Economy you wouldn't give this a second thought.

randomuser2019 · 28/06/2023 09:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Nordicrain · 28/06/2023 09:23

No way would I offer to swap seats.

  1. it's not your responsibility to upgrade your ILs who invited themselves
  2. a 10 and 11 year old shouldn't sit alone, with no supervising adults, for a longhaul flight.
coconutpie · 28/06/2023 09:21

Your DC need to be with you in business class in their seats that you have paid for (you have still paid for them, even if they were bought with miles). Your PIL can sit in their own seats in economy. There is no way you should be swapping seats.

Mandoid · 28/06/2023 09:16

Not sure if anyone else has mentioned this, but if you paid less than the full price of an adult fare for your children, then allowing PIL to swap to their seats is rather cheeky. I'd see it as you trying to get the adult seats for cheap. (Though I dont know if it worked out cheaper to buy the business class seats with the airmiles)

ChocChipHandbag · 28/06/2023 08:21

Don’t forget that the in-laws have an extra week of holiday to recover fully from their economy class flight.

What exactly did they say when they suggested joining you, and you told them you were flying business? You probably said it was on Miles too, right?

I bet it was a smile and “ooh, how the other half live!” and they then chatted between themselves about how full price BC seats were WAY too expensive for anyone to buy for a holiday and how they’d much rather spend extra money on a nicer hotel room or some lovely meals when there.

Does the flight have premium economy? Maybe your husband could pay to upgrade them to that as a treat?

Also, it’s long haul but only 8 hours, that’s not a very long flight in the grand scheme of things, it’s about the minimum to even qualify as long haul. Completely fine in economy.

Travelfan2021 · 28/06/2023 08:08

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 28/06/2023 08:04

You're bonkers to even consider swapping seats. DC should sit with you in business class - that's what was booked and arranged.

It's a shame your in-laws can't afford to join you but that's just life unfortunately.

Nevermind31 · 28/06/2023 07:58

If you fly as an unaccompanied minor your parents pay extra, you are marked as an unaccompanied minor, and staff will look out for you. Neither staff nor other passengers should have to deal with someone’s kids just because they didn’t want to pay for them to be upgraded

JaukiVexnoydi · 28/06/2023 07:36

@Flymeinbusiness ...and I'd make DH swap half way - perhaps with the other DC so they both get a turn.

I don't think they will let you do this.
When there's no turbulence people are allowed to wander about the plane a bit but when the seatbelt light is on everyone has to be strapped into the seat their ticket books them in to.

You're going to need to pay an admin fee to get the names changed if you go ahead with this plan, but it will be necessary to decide which seat is assigned to who and stick to that for the whole journey.

Your whole thought process makes no sense. If it did then everyone in business class should be gifting their seats to whoever seems most elderly and frail in Economy, and you could do that and gift your other two nice seats to two random strangers so that you and dh and both DC can all sit together. Obviously that sounds crazy but it's no less crazy than your plan.

Your PIL have made choices. They obviously aren't poor - they have decided to stay on in a hotel for an extra week after you go home. That will be costing them a fair whack and the same money could have been spent differently to give them a shorter holiday but more comfortable flights. Respect for elders includes respecting their mental capacity to make these decisions for themselves. I think over-ruling their choices, martyring yourself and forcing one of your DC to make the same unwilling sacrifice, will start the whole holiday off on a sour note and spoil everything.

eurochick · 28/06/2023 07:03

sewerrat · 27/06/2023 21:07

to add.
business class isn't a whole lot better for someone as disabled and frail as being suggested. they just get a bigger seat, extra space and legroom.
think its worth letting them know that its only first class with beds for them, maybe they'll go quiet then.

BA business seats have been flatbed seats for years. They are narrow but do turn into a bed.

Sugarfree23 · 28/06/2023 06:27

Op stop feeling guilty. If you must phone the airline and ask if you can swap seats.

Odds are they'll say the kids need to be accompanied, so either you swap with ILs or you all stay in your own seats.

Probationnotontarget · 28/06/2023 06:23

Respecting your elders isn’t about giving them your plane tickets!

It’s slowing down so you walk at their pace, it’s noticing they can no longer do something so you help out, it’s being there to listen ….

Id be horrified if my children offered me their seats! I’d say no.

Flymeinbusiness · 28/06/2023 06:18

PIL are staying with us for 10 days and then staying on an extra week in a hotel (they are retired) hence the different flights back as we need to get back for work.
I do think culturally I have always been taught to "respect your elders" which is why I probably feel so uncomfortable with the situation of us upfront and them in the back. They are great in-laws which I appreciate I'm lucky to have as that's not always the case with PIL.
On the flights - you still pay taxes etc so not completely free but obviously a lot less than a full price business fare and the DC tickets aren't much cheaper than our adult seats.
The DC are definitely not snowflakes and would be very happy sitting watching a film and eating snacks/lunch etc -as would be the case on most uneventful flights - they'd probably love the independence but I agree that I'd probably worry about them the whole time if I was in a different cabin in case there was turbulence/there was a strange person nearby whereas my DH would expect them to enjoy the flight no matter what the cabin. He is much more relaxed than I am!

OP posts: