Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want the dc in economy while we are in business?

316 replies

Flymeinbusiness · 27/06/2023 19:30

Would be great to get others opinions...
We had some flyer miles and managed to book a much looked forward to, long haul, trip in business class for us and our 2 DC - 10 &11 in the summer holidays. Fast forward a few months and the PIL have decided to join us for the beginning part of the trip and booked economy tickets to join us. (They don't have any miles and the price a few months later for business for them both was unaffordable.)I feel terrible that my in-laws who are in their 70s will be in the back of the plane while my DH, DC and I will have big seats to ourselves. My DH thinks that both DC should take the economy seats and that they will be okay alone for 8 hours given we aren't too far away if they need us but I think one of us parents should be with 1 DC in economy instead as I don't want them alone on the flight. He thinks IBU to not let them and that I should enjoy my seat and not sit in economy. (I don't mind either although business will be a nice start to the holidays) Am I being overprotective? (Kids are good flyers generally and have done quite a few long hauls in the past)

OP posts:
Donsyb · 29/06/2023 21:23

Talia99 · 29/06/2023 19:02

Something that occurs to me - if these are upgrades with airmiles, are you even allowed to transfer them to parents? I’m pretty sure my air miles say immediate family only and there is a list. Children are on it but not parents.

You can buy other people tickets with your airmiles. We buy partners tickets with mikes often and they’re not on any list.

Donsyb · 29/06/2023 21:21

viques · 27/06/2023 19:56

I don’t think the cabin staff will let people randomly swap seats half way through a flight unless there is a very pressing reason.

People swap seats on planes all the time. I have swapped with my other half when he got upgraded and donated it to me (he then got upgraded anyway), and people are always asking other people to swap so they can sit next to people.

Leaving kids in economy on their own us a different issue. No one else should have to monitor your kids on a plane.

pollymere · 29/06/2023 20:07

It's a huge treat for the kids. Why spoil their treat because your PIL invited themselves along? You will also have to travel with the kids which means one adult and one child will get separated quite early on in both directions and have access to lounges etc. Keep things the way they are.

margesimpson40 · 29/06/2023 19:57

Phos · 27/06/2023 19:32

Your in laws have invited themselves along. If they wanted to sit in business class with you, they should have booked that.

This ... I did business class when i was just older than them 10 and i loved it, let the wrinklies sit at the back.

Devastateddaughter · 29/06/2023 19:51

RogersOrganismicProcess · 27/06/2023 19:51

Do the PILs have any mobility issues that would make sitting in a cramped position painful? If so I would do one adult and child in BC on the way there, and the other parent and child in BC the way back.

If the pils have mobility issues then they shouldn't have booked seats in economy

thegreylady · 29/06/2023 19:51

I am nearly 80 and fly economy if I fly. I like an aisle seat and am fine.

2bazookas · 29/06/2023 19:25

Blindingly obvious to me.

DH should travel in economy with DC so that HIS parents and wife can travel in more comfort

GingerNutMe · 29/06/2023 19:25

I very much doubt that the airline would entertain the idea of 'unaccompanied minors' when the parents are sat elsewhere on the plane. It is what is!

FictionalCharacter · 29/06/2023 19:09

Phos · 27/06/2023 19:32

Your in laws have invited themselves along. If they wanted to sit in business class with you, they should have booked that.

This!
“Respecting your elders” doesn’t mean giving them something they haven’t paid for. They chose not to pay the extra for business class seats.
Plenty of people in their 70s fly economy all the time. It isn’t luxurious but it’s perfectly adequate.

Talia99 · 29/06/2023 19:02

Something that occurs to me - if these are upgrades with airmiles, are you even allowed to transfer them to parents? I’m pretty sure my air miles say immediate family only and there is a list. Children are on it but not parents.

whittingtonmum · 29/06/2023 18:35

No way in hell would I leave an 10 and 11 year old alone in Economy for eights hours. No way.

If you are so concerned about your in laws you and DH need to sit in economy and the kids can sit with their grandparents in business class so they are being looked after by their grandparents. That's the only way this would work in my world.

angela99999 · 29/06/2023 18:29

Takoneko · 27/06/2023 19:50

I don’t think the airline would allow this. I’d be surprised if they are willing to sit minors that far from their parents because in an emergency it compromises the safe and swift evacuation of the plane. A frantic parent desperately trying to go against the flow of people evacuating to try to get to their 10 year old in a totally different part of the plane would be a huge problem.

Yes, this. I don't like flying anyway and would be very uncomfortable not to be with them.

born2runaway · 29/06/2023 18:02

No, the kids sit with you. They're only young. They need their parents

Gosh, i do hope in laws aren't toooooo awfully uncomfortable in economy. Poor dears

Snowpixi · 29/06/2023 18:00

Absolutely this.

Probationnotontarget · 29/06/2023 17:11

angierae

Not true - they did a head count on the bus and then one friend - not going on the holiday - got off the bus.

That’s why they didn’t realize he was missing.

ChocChipHandbag · 29/06/2023 16:12

YeahIsaidit · 29/06/2023 15:46

Please don't dump em out of their seats and sit them on their own. There's a difference between being sensible and polite in class and being left alone surrounded by strangers and not being able to get to your parents/someone you know and trust. If ILs wanted business class, they should have booked it and I'd be horrified if people would willingly take something, including a nice seat away from DGCs

She’s already said she won’t put them both together alone in economy without a parent.

YeahIsaidit · 29/06/2023 15:46

Flymeinbusiness · 29/06/2023 15:42

Thanks! I have great in-laws - we are really happy they can join us for a holiday together.

Also - I'd never ever expect someone else to look after my children and I'm definitely not the parent in the park expecting other kids to look after them as someone suggested!

They are good kids in general who are more often than not are good in class, kind to their friends and polite to other adults. They are kids so not saying they wouldn't fight but with snacks and unlimited movies they'd probably be no problem at all to other passengers but I do worry that in the unlikely event of an emergency they'd need a parent nearby.

Please don't dump em out of their seats and sit them on their own. There's a difference between being sensible and polite in class and being left alone surrounded by strangers and not being able to get to your parents/someone you know and trust. If ILs wanted business class, they should have booked it and I'd be horrified if people would willingly take something, including a nice seat away from DGCs

Flymeinbusiness · 29/06/2023 15:42

Thanks! I have great in-laws - we are really happy they can join us for a holiday together.

Also - I'd never ever expect someone else to look after my children and I'm definitely not the parent in the park expecting other kids to look after them as someone suggested!

They are good kids in general who are more often than not are good in class, kind to their friends and polite to other adults. They are kids so not saying they wouldn't fight but with snacks and unlimited movies they'd probably be no problem at all to other passengers but I do worry that in the unlikely event of an emergency they'd need a parent nearby.

OP posts:
Whitestuanton · 29/06/2023 14:02

Your children are 10 and 11 so too young to fly alone for safety reasons. No airline would take them alone. If you put them in economy (so lots of rows away with a curtain so you can't see them they are in effect flying alone. You are expecting another passenger to babysit them for you. Did you ask that passenger, Are you going to financially compensate that passenger. Is that passenger interested in looking after your children for 8 hours. Ask yourself the following questions

Who is responsible for and who will assist your children in the event (God forbid)

  1. A cabin decompression so needing an oxygen mask
  2. A ditching help with a life vest
  3. Sever turbulence
  4. Air sickness
  5. Bad behaviour or they fall out..it's 8 hours..they are going to fall out they are tweens....

Is the person next to them CRB checked https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/violation-at-30000-feet-in-flight-sexual-assaults#:~:text=FBI%20data%20indicated%20a%2065,for%20help%20following%20an%20attack.

Violation at 30,000 Feet: In-Flight Sexual Assaults | FBI: Law Enforcement Bulletin

Knowing the patterns used by offenders who commit sexual assaults onboard aircraft can lead to successful prosecutions.

https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/violation-at-30000-feet-in-flight-sexual-assaults#:~:text=FBI%20data%20indicated%20a%2065,for%20help%20following%20an%20attack.

familybythesea · 29/06/2023 12:44

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/06/2023 23:24

Oh, FFS.

Provide them with snacks ahead of time.
The odds of getting sick and/or being molested by an airborn perv are extremely low.
If they are prone to bickering and falling out in public, they shouldn't be in public. The parents should be ashamed that they can't be trusted to behave properly on an aircraft.

Happened across this comment and felt compelled to say this is naive. As a teenager I ended up sat next to a man who, when the lights were lowered, proceeded to touch my leg, press himself against me and scare me half to death. I look back and wonder why I didn’t shout out or press the attendant button, but honestly I was just so frightened and panicked. It stayed with me as something that was shameful and my fault for many many years. Please don’t ever leave your children to potentially face this alone.

Lucyh999 · 29/06/2023 08:51

This sounds like a total non-issue though and you’re making a mountain out of a mole hill. Are you bored?

It seems very simple, you booked your family into business, some others tagged onto the trip that didn’t. That’s lovely and I’m sure on holiday which is the main reason you’re travelling you’ll all have. A nice time together. The 8 hour flight is a very small proportion of that and I’m sure your PIL will be fine in standard class like
most people. That’s where they’ve booked after all. Done.

EggInANest · 29/06/2023 08:38

Interesting that nowhere does the OP indicate that the PIL are unwelcome in the trip, ‘invited themselves’, ‘gatecrashed’ etc or that she is unhappy with their presence per se.

And yet many posters assume this.

meatbaseddessert · 29/06/2023 08:26

To be totally clear

  • you cannot swap seats in different cabins mid flight.
  • economy passengers cannot visit business class
  • people do not get upgraded just because some of their family are in business class
  • you cannot suddenly decide to swap seats without changing the tickets. If it's true long haul then you will have separate boarding lines/air bridges for different cabins and your name/passport is checked on boarding.

So the PILs either need to buy business class tickets or you need to do a full name change on the tickets if you want PILs to take kids seats. Or they just suck it up in coach.

Wanttomakemincepies · 29/06/2023 08:20

PIL stay in the seats they booked. They have gatecrashed your trip. Keep the children near you.

MumblesParty · 29/06/2023 08:14

Dontworkmondays · 28/06/2023 23:54

You sound like a lovely person and great mother and daughter in law.
I would be the same, unable to enjoy my business seat as elderly relatives sat in discomfort.
I personally think business class is an unnecessary luxury for children, they don’t need the space nor care for the expensive foods and can’t drink. Flying is fun regardless for kids and they will enjoy feeling grown up sitting alone together, a different type of adventure.

These threads always show up the type of parents whose kids I’ve ended up looking after. They’re the parents who despatch their young kids to the park and pat themselves on the back for having such independent children, ignoring the fact that other parents are looking after their kids. While they lie on the settee reading, other parents are giving their kids drinks, wiping their cut knees, answering their questions etc. If I ended up having to deal with 2 kids on a flight while their parents drank champagne in business class I’d be bloody livid.

Anyway OP is apparently going to treat the plane like a train, and shuffle all the seats around at will. Who knew that was possible?!!!