Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jury service - what do I need to know?

140 replies

C1239 · 27/06/2023 19:26

I’ve been called for jury service in a couple of months time, just wondering for those of you who have done it before what would your top advice be? I’ve heard there can be some waiting around so take a book. During the two weeks if you aren’t required one day do you go to work as normal? What if you are only in court for half a day do you then go to work, do they tell you work when you are and aren’t in?!

OP posts:
Forthegloryofmerlin · 28/06/2023 08:39

I'm so terrified of being called up. I have inattentive ADHD and wasn't able to concentrate in school, back pain from my spinal condition that means if I sit for more than an hour without walking around I'm in agony and a v weak bladder. It honestly sounds like a nightmare. I sincerely doubt they make any kind of allowances for any of those things so I'd be a terrible juror because there's no way I'd be concentrating on anything but the pain and not pissing myself if we had to sit there all day 😬

InMySpareTime · 28/06/2023 08:17

I recently did jury service and the only waiting around was on the first day. After that, I just called the voice bank each evening to see if I was needed the next day. After 10 days my cohort was dismissed. I was never called in (though pretty much all the others were, some several times) and have not yet set foot in a courtroom.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/06/2023 08:12

Two of the jurors on my panel had made up their minds about the guilt of the defendant before hearing any of the evidence. TBH it was the sort of case where I wondered at first how on earth I was ever going to decide whether G or NG. But the witnesses did swing it, and in the end 10 of us (vs. the 2) did bring in a NG verdict.

It was impressed on us by the judges in both cases, that if we had the slightest doubt about a defendant’s guilt, we must return a NG verdict. Must say I did find the whole process quite reassuring - better IMO to return a possibly doubtful NG, than convict someone innocent.

As a pp said, any googling of the defendant or the case is strictly prohibited. On our jury room wall was a poster about someone who had - a university lecturer, no less - who ended up in prison for 8 months for her pains.

And yes, do take a book! There were also jigsaws in our jury room - might be nice to take one.

Delphigirl · 28/06/2023 07:58

Em2ds1dd · 28/06/2023 05:57

Hi, please can I ask a question?
I appreciate that when you’re deliberating you’re not allowed out of the room, but are you actually locked in the room?
Might seem like an odd question but I get extreme claustrophobia and can’t bear to be in a place where I cannot physically leave. Would be fine knowing I have to stay In a room, but not if I was locked in. Hope that makes sense.

Not locked in!!! Not sure the fire regs would allow it… !

Grumpyfroghats · 28/06/2023 06:56

Something I always wonder about is how it goes with charges that depend on very intricate details like fraud or money laundering. Maybe it's not a problem in practice but I would think you need to really pay attention to understand who is guilty and who is not.

There does seem to be some evidence that juries are more likely to aquit but it's hard to know whether that is because judges are more cynical or juries more credulous

Em2ds1dd · 28/06/2023 05:57

Hi, please can I ask a question?
I appreciate that when you’re deliberating you’re not allowed out of the room, but are you actually locked in the room?
Might seem like an odd question but I get extreme claustrophobia and can’t bear to be in a place where I cannot physically leave. Would be fine knowing I have to stay In a room, but not if I was locked in. Hope that makes sense.

Sheranovermytoes · 28/06/2023 04:09

I'd hate jury service and avoid it as much as I can. I'm terrible at sitting still if I know that I can't wander about.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 28/06/2023 02:55

The judge told them .... 'a reasonable doubt was the sort of doubt that might affect the jurors' minds if they were making decisions in matters of importance in their own affairs, their own lives'.

That's pretty much what the judge said to the jury at Harriet Vane's trial in Strong Poison:

"You may perhaps wish to hear from me exactly what is meant by those words 'reasonable doubt.' They mean, just so much doubt as you might have in every-day life about an ordinary matter of business. This is a case of murder, and it might be natural for you to think that, in such a case, the words mean more than this. But that is not so.... They only mean that the proof must be such as you would accept about a plain matter of buying and selling, or some such commonplace transaction.

OneTC · 28/06/2023 02:10

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:59

Vetting juries is a very slippery and dangerous slope. It is an essential part of the rule of law that we are judged by a random selection of our peers, and that may include unreasonable and stupid people.

Yeah I don't think there's a better system it was just pretty eye opening

ejbaxa · 28/06/2023 01:54

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 01:29

I'd rather be judged on a serious offence by a completely unbiased and random selection of twelve people from all walks of life whatever their individual biases or limitations might be than a single judge. Particularly one 'specially' trained. You only have to look at the influence some lobby groups have on judicial training (looking at you Stonewall) to see what can happen.
I'll stick with Lord Denning's view that juries are 'the lamp that shows that freedom lives' thanks very much.

As long as you understand that the “freedom” you speak of includes a lot of criminals being free.

I don’t think one judge should judge. I think there should be a panel, like a jury. But not a jury - instead people who are trained/qualified etc.

my take home from my jury service was that people can commit crimes and just say “it didn’t happen” or “it wasn’t me” and that they will get away with it.

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 01:33

Sorry, Lord Devlin, not Denning. Past my bedtime.

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 01:29

I'd rather be judged on a serious offence by a completely unbiased and random selection of twelve people from all walks of life whatever their individual biases or limitations might be than a single judge. Particularly one 'specially' trained. You only have to look at the influence some lobby groups have on judicial training (looking at you Stonewall) to see what can happen.
I'll stick with Lord Denning's view that juries are 'the lamp that shows that freedom lives' thanks very much.

ejbaxa · 28/06/2023 01:16

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:59

Vetting juries is a very slippery and dangerous slope. It is an essential part of the rule of law that we are judged by a random selection of our peers, and that may include unreasonable and stupid people.

Having recently served as a juror, I can assure you that juries no longer function as intended. There are people who do not understand what they have been asked to do. And there are people who do understand what they have been asked to do (try the defendant based on the evidence given in court) and they won't do it.

Jury service needs stopping IMO.

ejbaxa · 28/06/2023 01:06

rainbowsandrainclouds · 27/06/2023 21:33

This should be explained to you at court if you do end up on the jury but if there's even a slight thought in your head that the person isn't guilty based on what you've heard and the evidence provided then you must vote not guilty. You have to be 100% certain beyond all reasonable doubt that they are guilty to give that verdict.

Also, it will be surprising, and sometimes rather worrying, to hear what other jurors thoughts on things are.

This is wrong.

You do not have to be 100% certain. Being sure is not being 100% certain. This very common misconception is leading to defendants being found not guilty. So dangerous for society - and completely the fault of our legal system that people think sure = 100% certain.

It's a DM article - but whatever: Judges told to stop using 'beyond reasonable doubt' because jurors don't understand what it means | Daily Mail Online
During a trial in 2018, the compendium reveals, a jury 'asked exactly such a question' and wanted to know if the standard of proof was '100 per cent certainty' or 'beyond reasonable doubt' and, if the latter, what 'beyond reasonable doubt' actually means.
The judge told them they were 'not required to be 100 per cent certain', that 'sure and beyond reasonable doubt meant the same thing' and 'a reasonable doubt was the sort of doubt that might affect the jurors' minds if they were making decisions in matters of importance in their own affairs, their own lives'.

Judges told to stop using 'beyond reasonable doubt'

British judges have been told to stop using the phrase 'beyond reasonable doubt' because there are concerns that jurors don't understand what the phrase actually means.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8257467/Judges-told-stop-using-reasonable-doubt-jurors-dont-understand-means.html

BuffyTheCat · 28/06/2023 01:05

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:59

Vetting juries is a very slippery and dangerous slope. It is an essential part of the rule of law that we are judged by a random selection of our peers, and that may include unreasonable and stupid people.

I’m coming to the opposite view: that juries are not a useful route to justice. Most countries don’t have them, and the comments on this thread about other jurors seem to support my view. I suspect that specially trained judges would be better than juries for most charges.

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:59

Vetting juries is a very slippery and dangerous slope. It is an essential part of the rule of law that we are judged by a random selection of our peers, and that may include unreasonable and stupid people.

ejbaxa · 28/06/2023 00:47

TellySavalashairbrush · 27/06/2023 20:18

I found it very boring . The most alarming thing was the level of intelligence among some of my fellow jurors. You are looking at the evidence presented and deciding whether someone is guilty or not- one or two in my group really struggled to understand the most basic of things. I truly believe there should be a vetting process to be a juror.

Agree.

In my case, there were 2 people who simply did not understand the task. One was able to listen to others' explanations and grasp it. Then proceeded fine. The other refused to listen to explanations offered. Astonishing - and dangerous for society.

CheesesandWines · 28/06/2023 00:44

So most jury duty stretches are two weeks but depending on the trial it could be longer I understand from the thread ? What reasons would be a valid argument for you not being able to serve longer than two weeks ?

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:41

If you are using public transport be aware you may find yourself unavoidably on the platform or at the bus stop with witnesses, lawyers etc If that might bother you wear headphones or even sunglasses. I didn't want to stand out in any way and wore unremarkable clothes every day.

Delphigirl · 28/06/2023 00:30

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:29

To be clear, lawyers are not allowed to challenge prospective jury members because they don't like the look of them or they think there are too many or too few women/men, black/white/old /young people etc and hope to get a more 'favourable' selection. In this country, as far as I know, the only grounds for challenge/withdrawal are if a member of the jury knows any of the defendants, witnesses or lawyers.

Bias or unsuitability (eg obviously illiterate in a document heavy case)

Delphigirl · 28/06/2023 00:29

sandandsangria · 28/06/2023 00:14

As someone who works in the legal field this is how it goes in our system:

Everyone called for jury service will be told to come to a meeting place (there's usually a jury service room in the court or in our case they are currently using a local hotel) Names are selected at random and you will be called into the courtroom. However, solicitors are allowed to challenge people, if you are challenged you won't be part of the jury. But that doesn't mean your name won't get called for another case!

I'm sure you already know these rules but:

You cannot be part of the jury if you know anyone involved in the case or if you have heard about it/know what's going on

You can't discuss the case with friends/family

You aren't supposed to research the case online or on social media for information relating to it

In terms of breaks in our system you are allowed to leave the court and will be told when to come back. Food was also provided in the local hotel for jury members.

There is no set time for the duration of your service as it depends on the case. It could be 2 days or 2 weeks, it's never set in stone and it doesn't always follow a 9-5 schedule. Some days you could be finished at 2pm and others late at night but if you have an early finish on certain days you won't go back to work that day. Your employer must allow for however long it takes. I have seen cases where the jury was empanelled in the morning and the accused pleaded guilty in the afternoon - so the jury was excused without having to do anything and their service was complete.

Finally it's nothing to be anxious about so don't be worrying yourself. You may not even be selected but if you are a lot of people actually find it fairly interesting. Make sure to have something to keep you occupied like a book as the others have said and pay attention to what is going on as coming to a verdict is very important.

Good luck!

You will never, ever, be kept late at night.this is simply not true. Most court buildings are locked up and security goes home at 6.

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:29

To be clear, lawyers are not allowed to challenge prospective jury members because they don't like the look of them or they think there are too many or too few women/men, black/white/old /young people etc and hope to get a more 'favourable' selection. In this country, as far as I know, the only grounds for challenge/withdrawal are if a member of the jury knows any of the defendants, witnesses or lawyers.

Xomega · 28/06/2023 00:25

I served on a trial which took three weeks. For the last week we were put into juror protection after a credible threat was made in court by someone with an interest in the defendant. I and the rest of the jury were accommodated in a hotel and transported to court by minibus.

sandandsangria · 28/06/2023 00:14

C1239 · 27/06/2023 19:26

I’ve been called for jury service in a couple of months time, just wondering for those of you who have done it before what would your top advice be? I’ve heard there can be some waiting around so take a book. During the two weeks if you aren’t required one day do you go to work as normal? What if you are only in court for half a day do you then go to work, do they tell you work when you are and aren’t in?!

As someone who works in the legal field this is how it goes in our system:

Everyone called for jury service will be told to come to a meeting place (there's usually a jury service room in the court or in our case they are currently using a local hotel) Names are selected at random and you will be called into the courtroom. However, solicitors are allowed to challenge people, if you are challenged you won't be part of the jury. But that doesn't mean your name won't get called for another case!

I'm sure you already know these rules but:

You cannot be part of the jury if you know anyone involved in the case or if you have heard about it/know what's going on

You can't discuss the case with friends/family

You aren't supposed to research the case online or on social media for information relating to it

In terms of breaks in our system you are allowed to leave the court and will be told when to come back. Food was also provided in the local hotel for jury members.

There is no set time for the duration of your service as it depends on the case. It could be 2 days or 2 weeks, it's never set in stone and it doesn't always follow a 9-5 schedule. Some days you could be finished at 2pm and others late at night but if you have an early finish on certain days you won't go back to work that day. Your employer must allow for however long it takes. I have seen cases where the jury was empanelled in the morning and the accused pleaded guilty in the afternoon - so the jury was excused without having to do anything and their service was complete.

Finally it's nothing to be anxious about so don't be worrying yourself. You may not even be selected but if you are a lot of people actually find it fairly interesting. Make sure to have something to keep you occupied like a book as the others have said and pay attention to what is going on as coming to a verdict is very important.

Good luck!

Delphigirl · 27/06/2023 23:57

rainbowsandrainclouds · 27/06/2023 21:43

It is correct. It's a turn of phrase to say 100% sure. I wasn't implying they give percentages on a piece of paper.

But you must be certain they are guilty and cannot vote guilty if there is even a slight belief that they may not be. The judge should inform the jury of this.

It is wrong to say 100%. The only test is whether the prosecution have satisfied you so that you are sure. If you are not sure - not guilty. Sure is an ordinary English word - it is wrong to try and quantify it in terms of percentages.