Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jury service - what do I need to know?

140 replies

C1239 · 27/06/2023 19:26

I’ve been called for jury service in a couple of months time, just wondering for those of you who have done it before what would your top advice be? I’ve heard there can be some waiting around so take a book. During the two weeks if you aren’t required one day do you go to work as normal? What if you are only in court for half a day do you then go to work, do they tell you work when you are and aren’t in?!

OP posts:
Jules912 · 05/07/2023 10:44

When I did it I spent a day and a half waiting a round and not being picked, probably because it was at the Old Bailey and I was excused from long cases due to being pregnant. Eventually got picked for a drugs trial which was actually fascinating, but agree with the previous comments about intelligence of fellow jurors. Some couldn't seem to follow logic even when it had been spelt out. Was allowed out for lunch most days but told to bring it in on the last day as we were deliberating. Finished Friday lunchtime of the first week and got told I didn't need to do the second as they had no more short trials.

Dotjones · 05/07/2023 10:31

C1239 · 01/07/2023 08:38

Another couple of things I’ve wondered - what if you are ill and it’s in the middle of the case? Do they have to start all over again? Or what if an emergency comes up for one of the jury?
And like others have said what if it’s a really disturbing case? I’m guessing you don’t get the option to say you don’t think you could deal with it?
Getting a bit nervous now!

If a juror is ill they'll usually either postpone the case whilst the juror recovers or start a new trial from scratch. It depends how long the case has been running and how long it's likely to take. Sometimes you have alternate jurors, a couple of extra people who sit through the evidence but won't actually be involved in making a decision unless another juror drops out.

Generally an "emergency" for a juror won't excuse them from attending unless it's their own medical emergency. A family member being ill or your home being flooded wouldn't usually be seen as a legitimate excuse to not turn up.

You won't be allowed to avoid a case because it will be disturbing. Some courts have therapists on hand to help people who are disturbed by what they here. It's kind of pot luck though. Some people get PTSD from what they hear.

If a case is particularly bad or long the judge may excuse you from future jury service for a period of time, in that case you wouldn't be called up again for that period.

MarkWithaC · 05/07/2023 10:21

We didn't get lunch brought in! At the end of the last day before the case was due to wrap up and we were going to start deliberations, we were told to bring in lunch the next day as we wouldn't be able to leave.

C1239 · 04/07/2023 18:11

Thank you @nokidshere thats good to know!

OP posts:
nokidshere · 04/07/2023 18:08

My son is on jury service this week. Obviously he won't tell me anything but he said there are permanent counsellors in the building in case the case is distressing.

He also says there is zero dress code, just be comfortable. If you can't go out for lunch they bring it in for you. Court isn't sitting on Friday so he's back at work then but still has to go back to court on Monday.

C1239 · 04/07/2023 12:18

If you aren’t needed for a day are you meant to go to work that day? What happens if you are poorly during the two weeks ? I’m half looking forward to it half dreading it!

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 01/07/2023 09:45

I was summoned for jury duty many years ago, but at the time had an EBF baby of 3 months, and was excused on those grounds. But a Canadian relative of MiL’s who was staying with her, told me that in Canada I’d have had to do it anyway!

MiL was quite put out, since she’d have loved to do it, but had never been summoned.

Jubaju · 01/07/2023 09:29

Go with an open mind. I was dreading it but ended up really enjoying it and found it interesting. Totally depends what case you get though.

C1239 · 01/07/2023 08:38

Another couple of things I’ve wondered - what if you are ill and it’s in the middle of the case? Do they have to start all over again? Or what if an emergency comes up for one of the jury?
And like others have said what if it’s a really disturbing case? I’m guessing you don’t get the option to say you don’t think you could deal with it?
Getting a bit nervous now!

OP posts:
Freyya · 30/06/2023 13:47

@sandandsangria re this: “You cannot be part of the jury if you know anyone involved in the case or if you have heard about it/know what's going on”

What if it’s a really high profile case where most people will have heard about it from the news?

theclockticksslowly · 30/06/2023 13:45

I dread getting picked for jury duty. Aside from the childcare issues (do they take that into account at all?), the thought of being on the jury for any sort of harrowing case terrifies me. Are you allowed to be excused from certain types of cases if you think you really couldn’t cope with gruesome details, photos etc? I’m guessing not - who on earth would volunteer for that. Do they have any sort of counselling service for jury members should they have been affected by things they’ve seen/heard?

C1239 · 30/06/2023 13:36

Thank you for all the replies!

OP posts:
CosmosQueen · 28/06/2023 13:55

DH did it earlier this year he said it was very boring., crappy coffee and poor ventilation in the courtroom.
The jury were not allowed out at lunchtime, the day started at 9 and ended at 7pm.
He isn’t driving at the moment so left home at 7am, bus to train station, got there at 8.45, got home at 9pm.
If you plan on driving and get held up by road works etc you get fined, but not if using public transport.
You claim back your expenses.
IHis session would have ended after 2 weeks but one juror had further questions for the judge so everyone had to traipse back the following week.

My neighbour has been called 3 times, for one she ended up doing a 76 mile round trip every day for three weeks yet never got into the courtroom.
Personally I hope I never get called, I’m deaf and it would be a nightmare (apparently deafness doesn’t preclude you, they will provide someone to sign…but I don’t use signing 🙄)

Doggymummar · 28/06/2023 13:39

Em2ds1dd · 28/06/2023 05:57

Hi, please can I ask a question?
I appreciate that when you’re deliberating you’re not allowed out of the room, but are you actually locked in the room?
Might seem like an odd question but I get extreme claustrophobia and can’t bear to be in a place where I cannot physically leave. Would be fine knowing I have to stay In a room, but not if I was locked in. Hope that makes sense.

We weren't licked in, but there has a guard on the outside and we would have had to ask permission to leave, cigarette breaks for example had to be planned in advance and everyone went together whether you smoked or not. We were in a violent drugs case that had been tried and failed twice before due to juror intimidation so they were taking no chances.

Doggymummar · 28/06/2023 13:35

HarpyValley · 28/06/2023 10:46

There must be more to it than that...did they threaten you in some way? Defendants can only be remanded in custody for a breach of their bail conditions, not because it's a bit awkward for a juror to spot them on the 9.17 from Stoke.

It was a violent drug gang and was intimidating. They were talking about the case and the lies they were going to tell on the stand. We weren't permitted to come into contact with them, they were in a sealed box in the court and we had our breaks at different times and in different areas. It was made very clear to us to not be anywhere near them. And we were to tell the judge of any contact.

MarkWithaC · 28/06/2023 13:05

I think I was lucky with my fellow jurors; they struck me as intelligent and thoughtful and I came out with, overall, a lot of respect for them.
Apart from one youngish man who said at one point that women weren't so suited to 'certain jobs' (we were talking about sciency/techie jobs). Hmm

My other tip is that I agree with the pp who says how draining it is. One of my cases was a sexual assault one and I found it so upsetting. I think it was a combination of that and the earlyish starts/the commute (I WFH and am freelance, so don't usually have a massively rigid routine), plus the airless atmosphere of the court building, and eating rubbishy sandwiches etc, but I found myself quite tearful, forgetting my way on the tube, etc.
Having said that, I'm glad to have had the experience. It is a valuable insight into what goes on behind the scenes of all the court stuff you read and hear about.

GlassWall · 28/06/2023 12:59

Forthegloryofmerlin · 28/06/2023 08:39

I'm so terrified of being called up. I have inattentive ADHD and wasn't able to concentrate in school, back pain from my spinal condition that means if I sit for more than an hour without walking around I'm in agony and a v weak bladder. It honestly sounds like a nightmare. I sincerely doubt they make any kind of allowances for any of those things so I'd be a terrible juror because there's no way I'd be concentrating on anything but the pain and not pissing myself if we had to sit there all day 😬

If you are called, you write back stating these things that make you unable to fulfil jury duty.

Totallyaddictedtoshoes · 28/06/2023 12:49

This thread is so interesting, I'd quite like to do it I think, obviously I may not feel the same if called depending on the case. Do you only get called to courts relatively close to you?

SqueakyDinosaur · 28/06/2023 11:31

I did it at the Old Bailey, and it was a 2-week case where the defendant had pleaded guilty to manslaughter but the prosecution was going for murder. So the facts weren't in question, which made it simpler in one way. But some of the evidence was still pretty horrible to hear.

You have a clerk who herds you up and shepherds you around - at the OB there are so many courts it looks like loads of school trips being led around!

Our judge kept the sessions quite short (in answer to the pp worrying about toilet breaks). Sometimes it felt like they'd barely got started before it was time for another break, but it definitely helped me to concentrate.

If you are genuinely unclear on something and think it's important that you understand it, jurors can pass a note to the judge via the clerk, and he or she will either clarify or ask the appropriate barrister to do so.

The point about not researching the case is really important and was one of the things I found hardest, as a lot of my work has always been research.

It definitely felt like an important thing to do, and I was pleased and surprised by how seriously all my fellow jurors took it. When you're deliberating, the judge will send a clerk in after a period to find out if you are unanimous or if youthink unanimity may be reached. After a couple of rounds, the judge will indicate willingness to accept a majority verdict. I believe this has to be 11-1 or 10-2. I suspect our judge may have accepted earlier than some might because it was Friday afternoon!

bnotts · 28/06/2023 11:08

When my partner did it his work released him but weren't required to pay him - and despite him having worked for them for 15 years they didn't!!! You can claim up to £64.95 ( it goes up to 129.91 a day if it's longer than 10 days) to help cover your loss of earnings and the cost of any care or childcare outside of your usual arrangements.
Luckily he was only required for 3 days as I was on maternity leave as it didn't cover his loss of earnings.

HarpyValley · 28/06/2023 10:46

Doggymummar · 28/06/2023 10:31

I was on the same train as the accused on day. I sent a note to the judge and they were remanded in custody and brought in a van for the rest of the trial.

There must be more to it than that...did they threaten you in some way? Defendants can only be remanded in custody for a breach of their bail conditions, not because it's a bit awkward for a juror to spot them on the 9.17 from Stoke.

Nordicrain · 28/06/2023 10:34

Delphigirl · 27/06/2023 19:30

So firstly you may be needed for more than 2 weeks. Your work has to release you for as long as it takes. Secondly, you may be waiting around a lot and then released mid morning and told to come back the next day, or you may have a day or so break in a trial. Up to you if you go back to work in that time. There is no communication from court to your work it is a matter for you.

Well not quite. Someone in my team was sked to do a 6 week trial, she stated she couldn't as it would impact the business and they let her off.

She got called back and forth loads, lots of waiting around to just be told to go home etc. In her second week she has now been given a 1 week trial. She worked remotely - both from the court and from home when she got sent home.

Doggymummar · 28/06/2023 10:31

ArmTights · 28/06/2023 00:41

If you are using public transport be aware you may find yourself unavoidably on the platform or at the bus stop with witnesses, lawyers etc If that might bother you wear headphones or even sunglasses. I didn't want to stand out in any way and wore unremarkable clothes every day.

I was on the same train as the accused on day. I sent a note to the judge and they were remanded in custody and brought in a van for the rest of the trial.

twoshedsjackson · 28/06/2023 10:14

I have done jury service twice, at different courts (living at different addresses) and I found the two differed in some ways, depending on the types of trial which came up.
On the second occasion, I was on the panel for a court dealing with a lot of short cases (may just have been the time when I was there) and even if all courts were in session, we would be kept until lunchtime, in case a new, short trial could begin after lunch. Sometimes, a defendant will decide at the last minute to plead guilty before the case proceeds, matters move on swiftly to sentencing, and the room is free for the next case in the afternoon.
Contrast this to somewhere like the Old Bailey, where the administrators know that a courtroom will be occupied for several weeks, and potential jurors can be sent home early, knowing that they will not be needed that day.
At one time, I was asked to call in during the morning, to see if it was necessary to come in; if they know that cases are running in all courts, no point in you going in to hang around.
Towards the end of each fortnight, the staff avoid putting you on a case which might run into the following week.
I took my knitting as well as a book, and taught a fellow juror how to knit as we sat and waited!
At the second court, potential cases for the day were posted on a noticeboard in the lobby. I had to tell one official that I had spotted a familiar name ("declaring an interest") as the defendant should not be known to you. I'd moved house, and he was an ex-pupil from where I previously lived.
You will only be kept in over lunchtime if the case has reached a crucial point, but be warned; food sent in may not suit dietary requirements. We had the offer of ham sandwiches or (ordinary) cheese sandwiches, neither of which catered for our Rastafarian juror. We managed to sustain him with bits of our own packed lunches which met "Ital" standards!

Fatat40 · 28/06/2023 09:22

TellySavalashairbrush · 27/06/2023 20:18

I found it very boring . The most alarming thing was the level of intelligence among some of my fellow jurors. You are looking at the evidence presented and deciding whether someone is guilty or not- one or two in my group really struggled to understand the most basic of things. I truly believe there should be a vetting process to be a juror.

This. And prejudice based on their own experience.

You can take book / laptop etc but you'll go through security every day.

You can go out for lunch

We were finished by 3pm each day.

The court system is slow and archaic. We once spent half a day while the ushers tried to get the dvd player to work. Then they played the wrong interviews.

I had obvious questions and was surprised the barristers didn't address them. I wasn't particularly impressed by either the defence or prosecution arguments.

Swipe left for the next trending thread