Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not need "the village"?

393 replies

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 14:57

Prompted to ask this by a number of threads over the last few days, and particularly today (childless friends with friend with baby, person whose family is all on holiday without them, childless weddings), where people end up asking "where is the village nowadays?" The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years, and I just don't get it. I've never felt the need for a big group of friends and relatives to pitch in with child-raising, or for me to pitch in with them, and I don't see it in the parents around me either.

I suppose I'm lucky in some senses as I have a great husband who is completely 50/50 on all home and children things, and we earn enough money that we have been able to pay for the nurseries that we've needed over the years, but that's not to say it's always been easy. But we've just gotten on with it, as have most of my peers who have children. Both our sets of parents are abroad, and we don't have other family in the UK, so it's not like we're getting loads of family help either.

I guess I just don't recognise this craving for a village, or a bemoaning that the UK isn't like other countries who apparently are better at child raising in this collective way. It's nice that our children (and us!) have close friends and that our families love our kids and feel close to them, which they do, but this collaborative parenting isn't something we've ever looked for.

Does anyone else feel that the mystical "village" actually sounds a bit OTT, or am I just the odd one out on here?

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 27/06/2023 17:48

ModernLifelsRubbish · 27/06/2023 17:14

Me and DH had absolutely nobody when we were bringing DD up. No friends, no family, nothing. I'd have loved the support of a tiny secluded hamlet in the middle of nowhere, let alone a village.

When you have nobody to have a cry to when they're throwing their teenage worst at you, nobody to ask for advice when they're teething, nobody to share their achievements with, nobody to babysit (we didn't have an evening out for 14 years and only went away together overnight for the first time when she was 16), nobody just to have a chat to... Yes. You really feel it.

I am trying not to be mean but what scenario were you in that you had NO friends? (Or family but I guess one doesn't always have a choice with that). How could you go through your whole life including raising small children where they have friends and you at least become acquainted with their parents and have absolutely nobody? Did anyone ever ask you for support or help? Maybe it's a rural Irish thing but I am genuinely puzzled - and feel genuinely sad for you - if what you say is true. Lovely people are out there, lots of them!

Wannabegreenfingers · 27/06/2023 17:47

As a single parent I absolutely need a village, no supportive partner. Up until 2 weeks ago I had the most fabulous child minder who died suddenly. I'm trying to navigate my children through grief, theirs and mine and working around school hours whilst still doing a full time job.

thecatsthecats · 27/06/2023 17:40

FourTeaFallOut · 27/06/2023 15:02

It's not necessarily just about support but it's a village to provide a tapestry of people that your child can be around and learn from, to interact the different people and personalities, to see their different skills and perspectives.

Yes, this is how I take it.

It's why adults who've never lived outside of the family home can be a bit underexposed to other standards and ways of life. This is how we eat/how we take care of ourselves/what we believe.

Doesn't go for all cases obviously, but the most tedious kinds of people are those who only understand one set of standards and behaviours, and who won't accept that others are different.

Malarandras · 27/06/2023 17:39

It really depends on 1) circumstances, and 2) personality.

I am a lone parent, so I need some help. But my kids are not little anymore so I don’t need as much help as I used to. When I need help my family is there. Some of my friends have kids but they live far away from me so we can’t really help each other in every day things.

I’m very independent and self-sufficient, partly as a result of a completely useless and unsupportive late husband, so I tend to rely on myself. I’m fortunate in that circumstances are such that I don’t need a lot of help anymore.

Sunshineishere1988 · 27/06/2023 17:36

We haven’t had ‘the village’ to help raise our kids other than pre school/school if you count that. We have lots of friends but I wouldn’t ask for help unless it was an absolute emergency (need emergency childcare which has been very rare). Also, our kids are hardly ever ill so we have been lucky in that sense. I can imagine lots of different scenarios where people do need alot of people to help out (for example a long term sick parent/child, single parents etc).

I dont think we need ‘the village’ either but plenty of people without the luck/stability that we have probably do.

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 17:34

@CaptainMum ALL of those things are things you're doing this week?!

I'm sorry but that sounds like you're spreading yourself much too thin. My husband and I couldn't possibly manage to do all that alongside our normal lives whilst also making time for our own children. It sounds like you're being taken advantage of to be honest.

I would maybe do those things every now and then, but no one in my life would need that kind of support, and certainly not all in the same week.

OP posts:
CaptainMum · 27/06/2023 17:31

You are either insular, which is sad for your kids, or have a 'village' but know it by a different name.

Have you had friends (possibly with their kids) over for dinner? American up with other families at the park? Made a friend whose had a baby a meal? Visited a friend with a sick child in hospital? Walked someone's dog when they're ill? Asked another friend to drop your child off on the school pick up as you've another child off ill? All of these things are in my week this week. This is my village and I love it. Sadly my family all live far away, so we can't include them in the community. You may not have the capacity to help other or want to be helped, that's just a bit sad for you.

MzHz · 27/06/2023 17:30

My ‘village’ tried to make matters worse - purposely- and then fucked off to the furthest side of fuck

I don’t need a village. I’m my own village. I do now however have a couple extra people in my village and we’re very good at looking out for each other.

it’s better with good people around you. when I had only bad people around me it was soul destroying. I was close to knowing utter despair- then found one friend. I realised that you only really need one good person in your life for it be better. I love that friend with everything. Still.

Scottishgirl85 · 27/06/2023 17:29

YABU to use the word "gotten"

longestlurkerever · 27/06/2023 17:28

What about during covid? What did you do when you had to isolate and the supermarkets weren't delivering? The village stepped up, delivering essentials to each other, making sure the vulnerable had what they needed, walking siblings to school if they were negative. It was the one thing I liked about lockdown, realising the fabric of society was still there. Surely it's more efficient to help each other out rather than try to do everything yourself. Sometimes a little favour costs little to offer and is worth a lot to the recipient, and then you can ask for the same in return.

MysteryBelle · 27/06/2023 17:28

MollyNameChange · 27/06/2023 17:27

@FourTeaFallOut is on the right lines. It isn't the close care side of family life. It is the incidental contacts that we used to have. The shop assistant we see 2 or three days a week, the bus driver. The lady down the road with those big blue flowers in her garden who always says hello.
The staff in a restaurant who speak to the child.
These people will be the eyes and ears when the children go out for themselves.
You OP will contribute and play your part by being the nice lady who smiles and lets them get their ball back from your garden or says hello and try's to help the harassed mum with a 2yr old trying to get the buggy and baby off the bus.

This is it exactly.

Mumtothreegirlies · 27/06/2023 17:28

My village was always very limited. I have my sister and my mum and my husband. My husbands parents didn’t want to be part of our village but were happy to be part of my brother in laws village.
I wouldn’t have been able to cope without my mum and sister. It’s not so much the babysitting it’s just the shared love for my children that I appreciated when they were young.
I think the fact you and your husband both work and your support network are out the country and your children go to nursery, means you have a very different dynamic for your family then we do. I wouldn’t have wanted to pay anyone else to care for my children, nor would I have been comfortable taking on a full time job before they could speak and were in school.
it sounds like you have a different take on life to to others, perhaps a more stoic approach to your children. The ‘village’ isn’t just for the parents it’s for the child too, which is often forgotten when both parents are busy at work and unable to comprehend what the baby/toddler goes through when they’re in a care setting and not with those they love.
glad it worked out for you and your husband though 👍

MysteryBelle · 27/06/2023 17:27

Families used to be bigger too so the older kids would look after the younger ones. My oldest brother and sister took care of us a lot.

MollyNameChange · 27/06/2023 17:27

@FourTeaFallOut is on the right lines. It isn't the close care side of family life. It is the incidental contacts that we used to have. The shop assistant we see 2 or three days a week, the bus driver. The lady down the road with those big blue flowers in her garden who always says hello.
The staff in a restaurant who speak to the child.
These people will be the eyes and ears when the children go out for themselves.
You OP will contribute and play your part by being the nice lady who smiles and lets them get their ball back from your garden or says hello and try's to help the harassed mum with a 2yr old trying to get the buggy and baby off the bus.

Peppadog · 27/06/2023 17:24

I kind of agree with you OP, although I can see why people who can't afford childcare and can't live on one income need support and a 'village'.
My MIL used to take care of neighbours kids to enable their mums to work in a relatively poor area of her home country, what an amazing woman she was.
However I do find that lots of quite wealthy people think they need a village because they expect parenthood to be easy, and it's not, it's relentless but also very rewarding. I don't ask or expect any outside help except my childminder, but appreciate I'm privileged to be able to afford one. I don't want to bother other people, I like to be independent and me and DH share everything equally.

AuntieJune · 27/06/2023 17:24

You don't need other people until you do need them.

If disaster befell you, you'd look for a village pretty quick. Eg I know a family where one spouse is having chemo. One child, good income, happy family - but they need help because it's a struggle. Things can change super fast. If you see yourself as within a network and help others, you have a network if you need it plus your children learn from it.

The only way you'd live without any village is if you were marooned somewhere - you rely on people, you just don't appreciate it!

Notjustabrunette · 27/06/2023 17:23

I actually the more I think about it, it’s not just for practicalities. We both work FT, so in holidays my kids go to holiday club. As much as they enjoy it, they like a bit of down time too and go to my parents one or two days per week. They normally just hung out playing board games or getting the bus into town for a McDonald’s or something like that. I think it’s great that they get that time with them. We also have a neighbor where we help each other out sometimes with school pickups and drop offs etc. we can get by without it, but it’s great having plan B.
I think even if you don’t need the village, life is better with it.

scootoot · 27/06/2023 17:21

You sound a bit insular.

I love seeing my children's relationship with their grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, as well as friends (theirs and ours) flourish.

Yes DH and I can get by on our own, but dropping the kids off for their play dates, or them being looked after by the grandparents and that relationship blossoming is nice. I think these all enrich their life.

You're not winning just because you're able get by without a "village".

TheCheeseTray · 27/06/2023 17:18

Ok I’ll bite.

I have abusive parents and a disengaged extended family.

I met someone who had a heavily involved family and I believe him when he said we were 50/50 on childcare, housework etc turned up it was all an act - Mr Cyclist had other ideas. All the women in his family stayed home - he didn’t want me staying home as I earnt twice his salary but he also wanted me to the do the stay at home told. His parents didn’t see why I was so lazy - out at work 8-5 pm and then I would pick the children up from nursery and so all of that - make him dinner whilst he went to work, went out cycling and left me to do it all. Every time I pulled him up on it I got told off as he was a new dad and his mum didn’t see why I shouldn’t get up. Our marriage became abusive and after court and police we divorced.

So I have two children under 5 and I need to be in work or leave for work at 7.15 am nursery doesn’t open until 8. I finish at 5.30 pm but being a teacher this is without marking, prepping or anything else. Then of course, my own children have clubs, homework etc and I have nobody to tag team to do 50% I do it all. Every last bit. I can’t be ill - I just can’t.

I can’t ask another mum to drop mine off every morning for me and have them an hour before school - that’s proper cheeky fuckery.

money wise I don’t qualify for benefits. But I don’t get CMS either.

I’ lucky I have a fab church and great friends - if I have a parent evening or something I need it.

do you really not get how having a lovely supportive partner means you can take your eyes off them, go out, go in the bath - lessen the physical and mental load - are you so arrogant you can’t see your privilege?

MysteryBelle · 27/06/2023 17:17

And we walked to our grammar school which was about nine blocks away. The best school ever. Big old beautiful building full of character. A giant fallen log we’d take turns leaping over at recess.

MysteryBelle · 27/06/2023 17:15

It may just mean you’re introverted or that you prefer your circle to be closer in—your husband and children. And since your husband is 50 50 and is very supportive, and you’re both in good shape physically, emotionally, and financially, and so are your children, then it’s fine and of course you don’t crave or need anything else, as to be honest, being married and having children, that day to day is all encompassing and busy and there’s little room for much else including friends or wider family.

But yes, the concept of the village, the community, here in the USA we have neighborhoods, same idea. I will say that sense of community is not the same as it was. When I was growing up, our neighborhood felt like an extension of our house and garden. Safe to explore but feel independent as a kid. Sidewalks and wide streets, church bells ringing on Sunday mornings, little stores, gas station, mostly houses. We kids would ride our bikes or walk to the nearest park (7 blocks) which had a tennis court and swings, there is a little store down the street from my parents where we’d get candy, and a pharmacy across the street from there that had (still has) a soda fountain and made hamburgers and hot dogs and fries, it was a treat to have that for lunch and cold cups of coke with ice. The neighbors were all around and seemed to look out for each other. We spent time with the close neighbors beside and a lady behind us, trick or treated, there was even an old condemned house at the edge of our neighborhood that we kids ventured to on our bikes, it was exciting. Played outside til dark. I’m sure a lot of people have similar experiences. Cousins came over in the summer and for 4th of July cook outs. Aunts and uncles. My mother gets regular visits from church pastor and others from church now that she can’t get there as often.

People do seem more to themselves now. My son played with one neighborhood boy and we do have a neighborhood garden club but I relied more on other moms mostly whose children were my son’s age, and my mother, sister and SILs. ‘Playdates’ were the thing. And watching each other’s children when one of us was working.

You all have the ‘village pub’ and different kinds of communities but it’s all the same idea. When I watch escape to the country, every couple wants to be in a village near the pub 😀. That sounds nice to me.

ModernLifelsRubbish · 27/06/2023 17:14

Me and DH had absolutely nobody when we were bringing DD up. No friends, no family, nothing. I'd have loved the support of a tiny secluded hamlet in the middle of nowhere, let alone a village.

When you have nobody to have a cry to when they're throwing their teenage worst at you, nobody to ask for advice when they're teething, nobody to share their achievements with, nobody to babysit (we didn't have an evening out for 14 years and only went away together overnight for the first time when she was 16), nobody just to have a chat to... Yes. You really feel it.

Greenpin · 27/06/2023 17:12

"The village "stepped in when a family member was diagnosed with cancer. They cared for her three ,young children and husband , were by her side emotionally and practically until the end and when she died her friends organised the wake. They carried on caring and just being there for years afterwards.
Family helped obviously, but were several hours away. These were local friends and they could not have managed without them.

StuffyHuffyPuffy · 27/06/2023 17:11

Surely a 'village' is more than just you and your DH?

I'm sure you're great parents, you have ensured your family have had what they need. But maybe if your kids had more access to a 'village', you'd see it differently- through their eyes as well as your own?

My (single) mum certainly benefitted from 'the village.' But I did too. I have close relationships with male and female cousins who are quite like siblings now. I've layers upon layers of grandparents/elders, uncles, aunts, family friends etc. I feel absolutely protected and supported. Unsurprisingly, it comes from being parented by these people at some point, alongside my cousins (we all got the same treatment... good and bad.. but we could be absolute monsters lol). I observed and contributed to how people can support one another over the years (I am truly honoured that I got the chance to help care for all 4 of my grandparents before they died). I remember when an uncle had a MH 'breakdown' but I got to spend an entire summer with my youngest cousin (she stayed with us). It was the best summer ever for me, and my cousin remembers it fondly as she was completely shielded. She is now very successful (think Hollywood), yet she is still in frequent contact with us all.

The support I have received from them means the world to me also. I can't even begin to describe it for fear of happy tears. I am now happily married with 2 DC, who are fully established members of the above village, as well as their fathers lol. Maybe that's one slightly bigger village, instead of 2 separate ones?

Anyway, I could go on, but I guess my point is to look further than yourself when it comes to the needs of your family. Imo, unless you are truly secluded, you already have a village. Embrace it.

headcheffer · 27/06/2023 17:10

You do have a "village" though. You have a husband, childcare, school, friends with kids who you are close to... I think the "collaborative parenting" you reference is something else entirely. I think when someone lacks "the village" it means they have no one to fall back on. I don't want to "collaboratively parent" with anyone, they're my kids. But I am appreciate of my privilege to put them in nursery, and of the weekends I spend with my friends and their kids which gives them a community to grow up in, and of my friends who will have them overnight or collect them from school if I get stuck at work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread