Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not need "the village"?

393 replies

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 14:57

Prompted to ask this by a number of threads over the last few days, and particularly today (childless friends with friend with baby, person whose family is all on holiday without them, childless weddings), where people end up asking "where is the village nowadays?" The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years, and I just don't get it. I've never felt the need for a big group of friends and relatives to pitch in with child-raising, or for me to pitch in with them, and I don't see it in the parents around me either.

I suppose I'm lucky in some senses as I have a great husband who is completely 50/50 on all home and children things, and we earn enough money that we have been able to pay for the nurseries that we've needed over the years, but that's not to say it's always been easy. But we've just gotten on with it, as have most of my peers who have children. Both our sets of parents are abroad, and we don't have other family in the UK, so it's not like we're getting loads of family help either.

I guess I just don't recognise this craving for a village, or a bemoaning that the UK isn't like other countries who apparently are better at child raising in this collective way. It's nice that our children (and us!) have close friends and that our families love our kids and feel close to them, which they do, but this collaborative parenting isn't something we've ever looked for.

Does anyone else feel that the mystical "village" actually sounds a bit OTT, or am I just the odd one out on here?

OP posts:
MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 19:24

sunglassesonthetable · 27/06/2023 19:22

I never wanted the village as it usually comes with all manner of strings, paybacks, nosiness and pettiness along with people feeling entitled to have opinions on you and your family, and I'm fairly private.

Hmm - what a nasty place it sounds to you.

I think that 'usually comes ' is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

Think we established early on that the OP didn’t understand what “village” really means.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/06/2023 19:22

I never wanted the village as it usually comes with all manner of strings, paybacks, nosiness and pettiness along with people feeling entitled to have opinions on you and your family, and I'm fairly private.

Hmm - what a nasty place it sounds to you.

I think that 'usually comes ' is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

CurlewKate · 27/06/2023 19:01

I do think that some people are resistant to the "village" because they think they will be taken advantage of in some way. This fear seems to be very prevalent on Mumsnet where people seem incredibly transactional. Less so in real life, IMO.

Orders76 · 27/06/2023 18:58

I never wanted the village as it usually comes with all manner of strings, paybacks, nosiness and pettiness along with people feeling entitled to have opinions on you and your family, and I'm fairly private.
But I would agree the comments that being able to be like that is only if don't need any help.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/06/2023 18:40

Last night was my son's prom - my village was the Wapp group of parents letting each other know where different kids were and when they'd got in and if any picking up was needed.

My son and his friends have a very friendly relationship, with lots of banter, with one of the school bus drivers. They all had a photo at the end of the year. He is part of the village .

GCalltheway · 27/06/2023 18:35

Sorry for typos!

GCalltheway · 27/06/2023 18:35

You have been very fortunate to avoid serious ill health or that of your children.

We are pretty self sufficient but have good networks but no family nearby. I don’t think it’s optimal to raise children entirely alone, independence is importance but so is asking for help and learning to do so directly. No personal is an island we are all inter related.

Yfory · 27/06/2023 18:34

Ive been a lone parent since both of my kids were preschoolers, so thats 18 years now. No family locally. And no useful family that arent local. No village either. Its been blooming hard tbh. Doable but hard. Id LOVE a village.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/06/2023 18:32

I think you do have a village OP. You don't realise it though.

It's not just about help and childcare.

There are the school teachers in your kids lives that they see every day.

The sports coach.

The theatre/drama teacher.

Your adult friends who see your children.

This is just from what you have mentioned. It's not just about rotas of people bring around casseroles.

Livelovebehappy · 27/06/2023 18:31

It’s not unreasonable for people to ‘want’ a village, but totally different to when people actually feel entitled to one. Supportive hands on friends and family is lovely to have, and I felt grateful for it when I needed them, but equally if they weren’t hands on, I wouldn’t have judged them for it. I just feel that some parents have an expectation that everyone should rally round when they start a family, without having any discussion beforehand with members of the ‘village’, which is from an unfair position of self entitlement. Having lots of help is a bonus and shouldn’t be automatically assumed.

Stompythedinosaur · 27/06/2023 18:25

I've never thought the phrase was intended to convey that parents should expect to offload their responsibilities on others. I think it's about the fact that it is preferable for dc to grow up as part of a community (as in, part of extended family, part of school, local community etc), that living in siloed families is missing something about how we are meant to live.

Didimum · 27/06/2023 18:23

With kindness, OP, I do think you need to check your privilege. Not on your 50/50 husband, but many of the other things you have said - particularly the waiting until you were older and more established, and selecting the ‘right’ husband, before deciding to have children. Many people can’t even climb that rung of establishment before their fertile years are over. Many people (men and women both) are let down by who they thought was the ‘right’ partner. Using nursery was your village - it doesn’t really matter if you think it was or not. The people who do regard themselves as needing a village would need a much smaller one by far if they could afford nursery.

You say you ‘struggled massively’ during the childcare years. OK - so you wouldn’t have appreciated more of a village then? If not, then why describe yourself as having struggled massively?

Irrespective of all the above, even if you haven’t ever felt that way and always felt fine and dandy ‘getting on with it’, what is the point in a post disparaging people who need extra support, for any one of the hundreds of reasons someone might need extra support? Or not feel as if they have the means to ‘get on with it’? And if you didn’t feel fine and dandy, then what’s your point?

‘It takes a village’ is also a phrase old enough to predate fathers being expected to join in child rearing 50/50 and before nurseries and play groups etc became the norm for socialisation and support.

For what it’s worth I have a 50/50 husband and the means to employ a nanny. Do I still feel like I need a village to do a good job? Absolutely.

vacances · 27/06/2023 18:23

We have 4 'children' aged 20 (now at uni), 18 (about to go to uni), 15 and 13. We are in Central London. I have been a SAHM the whole way. I can say we have had no family help whatsoever for our kids as both sides are overseas. I have taken them to every club / activity / you name it (or DH has on weekends), until they were old enough to go themselves. They went for three short mornings (9.15- 12.15) to a playgroup nursery from the age of three to when they started reception. Apart from that - nothing. But they are very independent. The eldest worked overseas / travelled the world alone before uni. None of them are clingy. Loads of friends but we never relied or asked 'favours' from anyone. My husband used to work abroad a lot as well. I did find lots of people used to try and palm their kids off with me during holidays ('because you're there anyway'), but in the end, I just told people 'no' if it didn't suit our plans.

ModernLifelsRubbish · 27/06/2023 18:22

theleafandnotthetree · 27/06/2023 17:48

I am trying not to be mean but what scenario were you in that you had NO friends? (Or family but I guess one doesn't always have a choice with that). How could you go through your whole life including raising small children where they have friends and you at least become acquainted with their parents and have absolutely nobody? Did anyone ever ask you for support or help? Maybe it's a rural Irish thing but I am genuinely puzzled - and feel genuinely sad for you - if what you say is true. Lovely people are out there, lots of them!

I moved to a new city when DD was a baby and didn't make any friends. Not by choice, I tried (went to parent and toddler groups, got involved with the PTA, etc) but everyone seemed to be sorted in their own friendship groups and seemed to see me as an outsider. My friends from my home city drifted away (I didn't have many anyway) as they got married and had DC of their own. DH has never had friends and isn't interested in having any. I'm disabled now and haven't worked since before DD was born (hoped to go back when she was at school but chronic illness/disability put paid to that) so haven't made friends that way. DD didn't have many friends when she was little, she was never invited to parties or to people's houses.

Nobody ever asked for help. I used to offer to pick up other parents' DC from school or offer to babysit but nobody ever wanted me to. If I asked other mums if their DC would like to come for tea or whatever they always said no/they were busy/maybe another time.

Family wise DH is NC with his and mine are dead, there was only me and DM and DF who both lived hundreds of miles away anyway but died when I was in my 20s.

It's been very lonely and it still is. I moved from one major English city to another so not rural at all, but people here never accepted me. I once overheard other parents laughing at me and DD's accents in the playground and doing impressions of us. It was always very clear we didn't fit in, even though we tried to.

Twentypastfour · 27/06/2023 18:22

CaptainMum · 27/06/2023 17:31

You are either insular, which is sad for your kids, or have a 'village' but know it by a different name.

Have you had friends (possibly with their kids) over for dinner? American up with other families at the park? Made a friend whose had a baby a meal? Visited a friend with a sick child in hospital? Walked someone's dog when they're ill? Asked another friend to drop your child off on the school pick up as you've another child off ill? All of these things are in my week this week. This is my village and I love it. Sadly my family all live far away, so we can't include them in the community. You may not have the capacity to help other or want to be helped, that's just a bit sad for you.

I agree.

It’s quite sad if there is none of this “village” in a child’s life (and it would be like a permanent Covid lockdown!). It doesn’t need to mean grandparents who live locally and who are young enough and have enough spare time to do lots of childcare.

I didn’t grow up with close grandparents but I grew up with neighbours who popped by, friends of my parents I saw regularly, their young kids that I eventually started babysitting for as a teenager.

My kids have play dates. I have NCT friends I still see. They have music lessons with a local teacher. All of these and much more add up to my “village”.

Lavenderflower · 27/06/2023 18:22

I don't the term village is really about childcare per say. It is more about an entire community of people to interact positively for a child to grow positively in a safe and healthy. It suggests parents cannot meet a child's every need and children need a variety of positive role models.

Oldermum84 · 27/06/2023 18:17

I really dislike threads like this - "I don't understand why I'm so amazing at coping and others aren't".

crostini · 27/06/2023 18:17

But you've got a village!
You said you have close family friends, and nursery!

Sunsetandsunrise · 27/06/2023 18:08

saraclara · 27/06/2023 15:37

Yep. I think a lot of MNers misunderstand the term. I've always understood the phrase to mean the people in your community who look out for your children, whether you know them or they're strangers who see your child about to run into the road and grab them. Or maybe their cub leader, or your neighbours who show an interest in them and stop to chat with them.

It's not about a village doing practical care, it's about people around you whose influence might seem small, but when combined with everyone else's, plays a part in your child's well-being

Yes this is what it’s supposed to be about and it’s a lovely idea actually, but people have rebranded the term for their own convenience.

Even in this thread some people talking about how the village is so important to them are just discussing it in terms of what people do for them eg. Babysit their kids, walk their dog when ill etc…

YouJustDoYou · 27/06/2023 18:03

I am almost completely alone when DH is abroad with work. No family nearby. No friends available. No neighbours available. Just me. So for days and days at a time It's just me and the kids, not a soul around to "help out" in an emergency. A "village" to help would be nice. But it is what it is.

GabriellaMontez · 27/06/2023 17:58

I agree, the phrase is overused and twee.

But, obviously,you do have a 'village', you pay for yours.

Twentypastfour · 27/06/2023 17:58

We don’t have family close by at all, but I still feel like I have a bit of a “village” and I’d like more.

The only time I felt completely isolated was lockdown. Normally we have friends that we are - DC play with their kids and the adults have a drink and a chat for instance. School parents that I chat to in person and ask advice from (how’s the sizing on the new school jumpers? Did they move PE this week? etc). When I was ill a few months ago a neighbour who has kids at the same school dropped them home for me.

I have friends with older DC who pass hand me downs to me. A neighbour with a dog that always stops to chat to DC and encourages them to pet the dog. Lots and lots of little things that help you get through the day and lots of varied interactions that are so good for children.

Sunsetandsunrise · 27/06/2023 17:57

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:21

I am speaking from a position of privilege with some of these things, but I waited until slightly later in life to have children with a man I knew would be an equal, competent parent for this reason. I made choices specifically to enable this. And obviously I know some people's lives change drastically due to tragedy etc. so I don't include them in this, but I do wonder, for example, about the woman who expects her childless friends to help her on a rota - this is clearly taking advantage. And yet people on that thread were suggesting all her friends should be part of 'her village'. That to me just seems irresponsible parenting.

I agree with a lot of what you said especially when I got to this post. I have a friend who never bothers to even send me a text on my birthday but she’s often hinting about now she and her (useless) partner don’t get any help from their families and how they need this or that. I know she’s trying to make me feel bad.

The irony is her in-laws and friends with kids help her out more than she helps them. For many people it’s just an excuse to take the piss out of others, and the same ones who want child free people to babysit would often be quick to say people without kids shouldn’t ever hold opinions about parenting because “what do they know”

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 27/06/2023 17:54

I grew up in the 50s and 50s and my parents did the parenting - not a ‘village’. It wasn’t expected. We had no relatives anywhere near, so I dare say it’s different if you do - but many people don’t nowadays.

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/06/2023 17:53

@holycannaloni

I am speaking from a position of privilege with some of these things, but I waited until slightly later in life to have children with a man I knew would be an equal, competent parent for this reason. I made choices specifically to enable this. And obviously I know some people's lives change drastically due to tragedy etc. so I don't include them in this, but I do wonder, for example, about the woman who expects her childless friends to help her on a rota - this is clearly taking advantage.

You are speaking from a position of privilege and this post is very smug and ever so slightly insulting. I see posts like this a lot from people who say they chose the right man, job done etc. As if it were that easy.

I also chose a man I thought would be an equal, competent parent. And he was, until he had a mental breakdown and turned into a raging alcoholic. Men who will cheat, or drink or be abusive or neglectful don't come complete with a chip which you can scan which tells you they are a risk. Some of us just draw a bad hand.

I've been a single parent for most of my DD's upbringing and I've managed. Mainly because I'm lucky enough that I have a fairly well-paid job (which I guess makes me fairly privileged). I don't "need" a village in the sense that you mention it and haven't got one: my closest relative lives 60 miles away from me and I sure as hell have not expected anyone to give me free childcare. I've paid for 95% of the childcare I've had over the years. But I do think a village would have enriched my life and I'm extremely grateful to have close female friends who have played a central role in my DD's life.

As many PPs have posted here it isn't just about support or childcare. I think its very important for children to grow up with significant figures in their lives outside of the nuclear family. Even with a very strong marriage, it's not desirable for a child's life to be entirely bound by its parents and siblings. It's limiting in so many ways to regard the immediate family as the only support network and its important to have perspective outside that.