Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not need "the village"?

393 replies

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 14:57

Prompted to ask this by a number of threads over the last few days, and particularly today (childless friends with friend with baby, person whose family is all on holiday without them, childless weddings), where people end up asking "where is the village nowadays?" The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years, and I just don't get it. I've never felt the need for a big group of friends and relatives to pitch in with child-raising, or for me to pitch in with them, and I don't see it in the parents around me either.

I suppose I'm lucky in some senses as I have a great husband who is completely 50/50 on all home and children things, and we earn enough money that we have been able to pay for the nurseries that we've needed over the years, but that's not to say it's always been easy. But we've just gotten on with it, as have most of my peers who have children. Both our sets of parents are abroad, and we don't have other family in the UK, so it's not like we're getting loads of family help either.

I guess I just don't recognise this craving for a village, or a bemoaning that the UK isn't like other countries who apparently are better at child raising in this collective way. It's nice that our children (and us!) have close friends and that our families love our kids and feel close to them, which they do, but this collaborative parenting isn't something we've ever looked for.

Does anyone else feel that the mystical "village" actually sounds a bit OTT, or am I just the odd one out on here?

OP posts:
saraclara · 27/06/2023 15:42

But unless you're bringing your child up homeschooling in some kind of completely isolated area of the world your children are going to experience that through just living their life, no? And that's not a village, that's just living in society.

Yes, and that's the whole point of the saying @holycannaloni ! It takes a village to raise a child. And it does, and has for virtually all of us when we were children.

It doesn't mean that something has to actively be provided or else a child misses out. It's staying the obvious. That children are influenced and helped by the.community around them. Society IS the village.

It's just been misinterpreted by some posters on mumsnet.

Purpleboat · 27/06/2023 15:41

I tend to agree that my definition of a village would be a little wider, those involved with your child, including those who you seek advice from etc. I think you do have a privileged position to afford aspects of ‘your village’ I share these privileges and like you have worked hard and had DC older to be in this position. I have however relied on ‘my village’ for childcare within the families and close friends through choice. I’ve also had several friends have severe illnesses and have lost one recently, so I absolutely value the closeness of my village. You never know what’s round the corner. I also recognise that some don’t have the same opportunities be that wealth or family/friends so I am grateful of my good fortune and can appreciate why others would want a village or wonder where theirs is if no support is forthcoming.

Stressfordays · 27/06/2023 15:41

Having a village isn't just about childcare. Having emotional support and someone to go to for advice is equally as important.

That said, you shouldn't feel too smug about not needing a village. Life can change on a sixpence no matter how well you think you've planned things. One of my 'village' had a seemingly perfect life, had her child older whilst in a loving marriage, they were well off and had no issues. Until her husband emptied the bank accounts out of nowhere and buggered off with another school mum. She was very grateful for her 'village' then who all jumped in to support her.

Travelfan2021 · 27/06/2023 15:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Straightsidedcircle · 27/06/2023 15:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/06/2023 15:41

You have a supportive husband, money, reliable childcare, you and your children have close friends - and you simply cannot picture that other people in a less fortunate position may wish they had support? Honestly?

This! You’ve got your village.

I would really love more of a village. I have excellent, reliable childcare and have always made sure I have this to varying degrees, but no local relatives. Often really wish I had family locally who I could ask to just “pop in” if I need to work a bit late or attend an evening event - I’m a single mum working fully time, and it’s really hard explaining to people that you don’t really have any time to spare for them!

Permanentlyexhausted · 27/06/2023 15:40

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:21

I am speaking from a position of privilege with some of these things, but I waited until slightly later in life to have children with a man I knew would be an equal, competent parent for this reason. I made choices specifically to enable this. And obviously I know some people's lives change drastically due to tragedy etc. so I don't include them in this, but I do wonder, for example, about the woman who expects her childless friends to help her on a rota - this is clearly taking advantage. And yet people on that thread were suggesting all her friends should be part of 'her village'. That to me just seems irresponsible parenting.

I think you underestimate quite how many families deal with 'tragedies' and quite how lucky you've been (so far).

Waiting until slightly later in life to have children with a man I knew would be an equal, competent parent won't necessarily protect you from developing cancer (as one friend of mine recently has), or prevent your children from developing serious life-threatening illnesses which mean you have substantial amounts of time where one child is in hospital hours away from your home whilst your other child(ren) need to continue with their day to day life at home as myself and another 3 of my friends have.

It's pointless saying "so I don't include them in this" when you obviously have no idea just what a large proportion of families that applies to.

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:38

@Lalalalalalalalalalal I'm sorry you went through that. I don't think I'm smug but I have found parenthood pretty easy, certainly compared to the current narrative of how awful it is which seems to be everywhere.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 27/06/2023 15:38

I can't imagine not having my ''village''.

Nursery
Family
Friends

All either look after my baby regularly or step in if there's an emergency. Grandparents also have him overnight once a month just because.

saraclara · 27/06/2023 15:37

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 27/06/2023 15:12

The "village" raising a child isn't about having free childcare necessarily. It's about having a support structure around, having different people who are able to assist without you feeling worried that your child is unsafe.
The lady in the shop who hands you the dropped dummy
The man in the street who holds up the bus so you can get on
The girl across the road who helped your DC at school because they were alone
The teenager who helped direct your DC home/walked them home when they got lost
The boy next door who shares his sweets every day
The old lady at church who smiles at your baby when they start crying, relaxing you so you don't feel you're doing wrong
The old man who feeds the ducks in the park and always shares his seeds with the kids so they can too...

Yep. I think a lot of MNers misunderstand the term. I've always understood the phrase to mean the people in your community who look out for your children, whether you know them or they're strangers who see your child about to run into the road and grab them. Or maybe their cub leader, or your neighbours who show an interest in them and stop to chat with them.

It's not about a village doing practical care, it's about people around you whose influence might seem small, but when combined with everyone else's, plays a part in your child's well-being

starrynight21 · 27/06/2023 15:36

My DC are both adults now and I never had this village which people talk about. My husband was in the defence forces, we never lived anywhere near family, and friends came and went. My husband was never much help either. But I loved being a mum, and had a blast bringing them up.I didn't need a village !

Lalalalalalalalalalal · 27/06/2023 15:36

My husband suffered severe postnatal anxiety and I really needed help - it was such a struggle being away from family. This whole thing comes across as a bit smug tbh… congrats for finding it so easy?!

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:36

Somanycats · 27/06/2023 15:34

The village isn't for you! It's for the child. A child brought up just by parents however well meaning is at a big disadvantage. A child needs to see different sorts of relationships, see different religions, mix with people of different ages, politics, with academics and people who love sports or art or are clannish about a football team or a brand of technology. It's cultural capital, and its what makes people confident, interesting, not afraid to take risks, have diverse freindship groups and resilience.

But unless you're bringing your child up homeschooling in some kind of completely isolated area of the world your children are going to experience that through just living their life, no? And that's not a village, that's just living in society.

OP posts:
Giveuprobot · 27/06/2023 15:35

Lol, yes, the idea of 'a village' is modern phenomenon developed online.

Not many people know that tribal societies only formed in the late 90s.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 27/06/2023 15:34

Toddler101 · 27/06/2023 15:03

When does this need start though? I have 2 kids and yet to see this need for a village either.

What would you do if you had a baby and a toddler and your partner ended up in hospital?

You would have to get a childminder to look after your children.

That is where the village can step in.

Somanycats · 27/06/2023 15:34

The village isn't for you! It's for the child. A child brought up just by parents however well meaning is at a big disadvantage. A child needs to see different sorts of relationships, see different religions, mix with people of different ages, politics, with academics and people who love sports or art or are clannish about a football team or a brand of technology. It's cultural capital, and its what makes people confident, interesting, not afraid to take risks, have diverse freindship groups and resilience.

DPotter · 27/06/2023 15:34

Thank you "MavisMcMinty"

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:34

It seems like some people use 'village' to mean - the basic running of society (school staff/cleaners etc.) Which I don't think is the way I see a lot of people using it on here, or how I've always understood it. But it is interesting how differing views are on this!

OP posts:
Plmoknijbuhv · 27/06/2023 15:33

I don't "need" extended family for my children to manage, but my children's lives are massively enriched by having them in their lives. Other people bringing different ideas and experiences to them that we would not provide. Once at school childcare becomes much more difficult with no nursery running 51 weeks a year. In my experience school aged children would rather not need to spend long periods at holiday clubs

Needmorelego · 27/06/2023 15:32

@CecilyP school and all the people connected to it - other parents, staff, after school club leaders, the cleaners (basically anyone your children and you would interact with) are part of the “village “

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:32

@CecilyP @Travelfan2021 thank you! I think some people just constantly love to say how much worse the next stage always is..... I expect that at some point they'll say an adult child is even harder than anything that came before!

OP posts:
CecilyP · 27/06/2023 15:32

I suppose ‘it takes a village’ can mean anything you want it to mean as shown by the diversity of responses on this thread. So that unless you’re a total hermit, you will have a village of some sort.

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:30

@Harryyourenogoodalone I'm sorry you feel that way about your upbringing. Insular in what way? Our children have wide circles of friends both in and out of school, and we have friends who they encounter as well. I wouldn't describe us as insular, just not reliant on others around us.

But it seems as if there are a lot of different interpretations of a village, and maybe what we have does count as one after all!

OP posts:
gogomoto · 27/06/2023 15:30

You are essentially buying "the village" but my advice isnt to be too confident, everyone comes to a point where that breaks down

randomsabreuse · 27/06/2023 15:30

The only person you can really rely on is yourself. So "village" is great until you really need them then they piss off on their other more important things or just interfere unnecessarily and screw things up worse.

"Villages" are an illusion at best