Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not need "the village"?

393 replies

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 14:57

Prompted to ask this by a number of threads over the last few days, and particularly today (childless friends with friend with baby, person whose family is all on holiday without them, childless weddings), where people end up asking "where is the village nowadays?" The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years, and I just don't get it. I've never felt the need for a big group of friends and relatives to pitch in with child-raising, or for me to pitch in with them, and I don't see it in the parents around me either.

I suppose I'm lucky in some senses as I have a great husband who is completely 50/50 on all home and children things, and we earn enough money that we have been able to pay for the nurseries that we've needed over the years, but that's not to say it's always been easy. But we've just gotten on with it, as have most of my peers who have children. Both our sets of parents are abroad, and we don't have other family in the UK, so it's not like we're getting loads of family help either.

I guess I just don't recognise this craving for a village, or a bemoaning that the UK isn't like other countries who apparently are better at child raising in this collective way. It's nice that our children (and us!) have close friends and that our families love our kids and feel close to them, which they do, but this collaborative parenting isn't something we've ever looked for.

Does anyone else feel that the mystical "village" actually sounds a bit OTT, or am I just the odd one out on here?

OP posts:
VivaVivaa · 27/06/2023 15:54

The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years

Id say the complete opposite. DM was a SAHM as was DMIL when myself/DH and our siblings were small. Neither me or DH come from
money and both had dads who were away for ages on end. No local extended family as kids

Both of them think parenting has become a lot more insular compared to their day. They were always popping round to other people’s houses, or going to stay and plays, or having kids round to the garden or having other people’s DC in an emergency. That included working mothers too - mums best friend worked throughout and her kids were frequently at others and it was just the norm. It may have not been called a ‘village’ but there just seemed to be a lot more collaboration. Amongst my friends now, including those who are SAHMs (which granted, isn’t many) this just isn’t so much of a thing anymore. People do their own things as a nuclear family and then struggle in an emergency, or even just in the day to day. I’d say the concept of the village is talked about more because it’s what’s really lacking in a lot of working parent families, aside from paid for childcare.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/06/2023 15:54

Children need a village as well as parents.

islandofserenity · 27/06/2023 15:53

Cantstaystuckforever · 27/06/2023 15:44

This. You have raised children with a support network around, you've just paid for it. If you had ill health or lost a job, you (or your kids) would have had to find more of a 'village'. It's also about living in a human society - John Donne's hardly recently, and he's the one who said 'no man is an island'. There's an epidemic of loneliness out there, of people who don't feel they're part of a 'village' and maybe of people who never bothered to be part of one themselves and are now feeling the impact.

One day we'll mostly be old, and mostly alone, and also need a village. I wouldn't want my kids to be responsible for my care in old age, but do hope that if we've done a decent job as parents, they'll want us to still be part of each others' lives, and that they'll be a part of their community too - not live like privileged islands, unaware of how much of society depends on us depending on each other.

Totally agree with this.
@Cantstaystuckforever when my 1st was born, my partner was working 6 days a week ,12 hr days, my Mum had died 6 years previously and my Dad got remarried and moved 100 miles away 3 weeks before my son was born. I had been seeing a counsellor for over a year- but couldn't continue as i had no one to look after my son. He had colic, a tongue and didn't sleep for more than an hr at a time for weeks and weeks. PND was an unwelcome visitor. the HV told me about a baby massage group that I managed to get to eventually. this was 10 miles away and i felt i shouldn't be driving-i felt drunk the 1st time i drove. We had very little money. My sister came up twice from where she lived (60 miles away) to get me a food shop and another time she let me go for a half hour sleep.
You had childcare, friends, money, a supportive husband etc
I felt so alone and missed my Mum hugely. HTH

Needmorelego · 27/06/2023 15:52

@CecilyP your child must have attended some type of school though. I didn’t mean the one that it’s literally the village primary. Whatever school your child attended was part of their “village “ aka community.

Forestfriendlygarden · 27/06/2023 15:51

Not your what your definition of a 'village' is...

Mine includes my postman/woman. People at the local shop. The chemist a few yards away - for prescriptions etc. The local pub (very family friendly).
My next door neighbours...

Delivery drivers....DD's friends and their families...the school/college/uni...

SweetStrawberrie · 27/06/2023 15:51

So is your point that you don't understand people wanting extended family heavily involved in their children's lives?

Aside from this, look up the meaning of it takes a village to raise a child.

It doesn't just mean childcare.

I also think it's lovely if a child is exposed to their extended family (as long as they are non toxic of course) and if you are lucky enough to have a good family/friends exposure to all kinds of different people is great for a childs development and sense of self, their understanding of the world.

Yes school is one part of it but close friends and family is something very different isn't it?

All of it combined shapes a child and their view of the world.

BatsInSpring · 27/06/2023 15:51

I read 'Hold onto your kids' by Gabor Mate and he talks about the emotionally dangerous trend towards 'peer orientation' in teens and young people. He describes why adult relationships outside of parents are important. I won't do it justice if I try to explain but the book is worth a read. It made me want to make sure my children have adults around them that are a positive influence and that model the things I value.

CecilyP · 27/06/2023 15:50

Needmorelego · 27/06/2023 15:32

@CecilyP school and all the people connected to it - other parents, staff, after school club leaders, the cleaners (basically anyone your children and you would interact with) are part of the “village “

I left before DS started school, but the village school about 16 kids and one teacher, I’ve no idea who cleaned it, though I know someone must have prepared the lunches. There were certainly no after school clubs! Parents were pretty spread out though some would have known each other socially!

SusiePevensie · 27/06/2023 15:50

Maybe look at it the other way round. There's a lot of evidence that social ties, especially helping other people, is at the root of happiness. As someone who - right now - is lucky you might not need help, but you are losing out on the opportunity to help.

Doopersuper · 27/06/2023 15:49

I think it’s really interesting you say your kids are 12 & 8 and you think you’re mostly through the more involved part of parenting. I found the babies/young children/tween stage pretty much a doddle by comparison to dealing with my teens. None of them are in any way particularly difficult but it is far more emotionally involving and tricky to navigate. Having other adults who will give them alternative perspectives to yours (because teens don’t always want to give credence to what their parents say) is extremely helpful.

Thehonestbadger · 27/06/2023 15:49

@holycannaloni

There is absolutely nothing wrong with you not wanting or needing family and friends in put but when considering the need of ‘the village’ you have to erase your personal privileges and consider motherhood as a whole.

Having a supportive 50/50 partner and being able to afford ‘all the nursery you need’ is unfortunately not the average mums position so judging or indirectly ‘looking down’ on them for feeling that need for external support reads an awful lot as your ignorance to your own privilege.

I say this as a mum who also has a very good DH and whose two small children do go to a lovely nursery a couple of mornings a week whilst I’m a SAHM. I’m extremely privileged, but one of my children is disabled and extremely high needs which has altered my parenting experience dramatically. I definitely do need ‘the village’ else our lives would be unbearably limited but had both children been healthy I suspect I’d have felt like you.

It’s easy not to need free help when you can afford to pay for professional help.

It’s easy to manage without emotional support when your life is going reasonably well and you have no significant health, financial or emotional crisis going on.

Toddler101 · 27/06/2023 15:49

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:36

But unless you're bringing your child up homeschooling in some kind of completely isolated area of the world your children are going to experience that through just living their life, no? And that's not a village, that's just living in society.

I agree with you OP.

LocalHobo · 27/06/2023 15:48

I feel exactly the same, and my DC are now young adults.

You absolutely DO need outside input!
I guess it could be the semantics of the phrase, of course I used schools, universities and health care, but I certainly didn't have nor did I desire, child rearing support from family and friends. My DH and I chose to have DC and are responsible for them and decisions regarding them.
I am very grateful to live in a civilised society.

Personality traits probably play a part here. I adored the fact my maternity hospital allowed me to find my own way to breastfeed for example, whereas some of my contemporaries complained about lack of intervention which they would have seen as helpful.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/06/2023 15:46

saraclara · 27/06/2023 15:37

Yep. I think a lot of MNers misunderstand the term. I've always understood the phrase to mean the people in your community who look out for your children, whether you know them or they're strangers who see your child about to run into the road and grab them. Or maybe their cub leader, or your neighbours who show an interest in them and stop to chat with them.

It's not about a village doing practical care, it's about people around you whose influence might seem small, but when combined with everyone else's, plays a part in your child's well-being

This is true too!

We’ve certainly made/ joined a village of that kind where we live now and it does make a difference

Mary46 · 27/06/2023 15:45

Yes nice to have the village. But if you dont you just manage. Had good neighbour in an emergency. Was always bit envious of those with loads of help.

ExcitingTimes2021 · 27/06/2023 15:45

I don’t have much of a ‘village’. To be honest I don’t even really have a friends who just drop a text to see how we are doing anymore, never mind offering to help. Can’t even remember the last time someone rang or visited just to a chat or a catch up.

I would bloody love a village, or even a friend who would take time out of their lives to see me and my child. It’s hard going, and we sort of manage. But life would be so much more enjoyable if we had more people to engage with x

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I'm sorry but I will not count my husband as part of 'my village' - that's ridiculous and so reductive of the role of Dad's. That's why so many men get away with being rubbish parents - he is as much of an equal parent as I am, he is not an extra support in the same way as childcare for goodness sake.

(And where did I say we have 'unlimited funds'? We struggled massively during childcare years, although obviously not as much as others and for that I'm grateful)

OP posts:
Cantstaystuckforever · 27/06/2023 15:44

GloomySkies · 27/06/2023 14:59

You have a supportive husband, money, reliable childcare, you and your children have close friends - and you simply cannot picture that other people in a less fortunate position may wish they had support? Honestly?

This. You have raised children with a support network around, you've just paid for it. If you had ill health or lost a job, you (or your kids) would have had to find more of a 'village'. It's also about living in a human society - John Donne's hardly recently, and he's the one who said 'no man is an island'. There's an epidemic of loneliness out there, of people who don't feel they're part of a 'village' and maybe of people who never bothered to be part of one themselves and are now feeling the impact.

One day we'll mostly be old, and mostly alone, and also need a village. I wouldn't want my kids to be responsible for my care in old age, but do hope that if we've done a decent job as parents, they'll want us to still be part of each others' lives, and that they'll be a part of their community too - not live like privileged islands, unaware of how much of society depends on us depending on each other.

NumberTheory · 27/06/2023 15:44

I never thought of the village as being the close family and friends who might babysit or bring you a lasagna when you’re sick. I always thought of it as referring to much less closely connected people looking out for children all the time. So if you’re at the park and your 2 year old is pulling in one direction while your 5 year old is running in the other, the village is the teen lad playing footy, or the dog walker, or other mum, who stops to intercept the 5 year old before they make it out of the gate. The village is the lady at the post office who kindly distracts your kid while you rummage in your purse for your card. The village is the man sailing a remote control boat on the lake who’s never met your kid before but takes the time to let them have a go and explains how boats tack against the wind.

lieselotte · 27/06/2023 15:44

Not sure the "village" helps with special needs. I imagine most people stay well away from any child/family who is considered to be "difficult" or "not like my children". We see enough posts on here about ND children who don't get invited to birthday parties.

I am sure it must be lovely to have heaps of friends who will step in if you are ill or have other problems. In the real world, I don't think it happens very often.

MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 15:43

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:36

But unless you're bringing your child up homeschooling in some kind of completely isolated area of the world your children are going to experience that through just living their life, no? And that's not a village, that's just living in society.

I’m not sure you understand what the “village” is, tbh. It IS society, and as others have said, not really about childcare. Everything said and done around your watching/listening children has an influence on who/what they turn into, that’s what the village means.

WaterIris · 27/06/2023 15:43

saraclara · 27/06/2023 15:37

Yep. I think a lot of MNers misunderstand the term. I've always understood the phrase to mean the people in your community who look out for your children, whether you know them or they're strangers who see your child about to run into the road and grab them. Or maybe their cub leader, or your neighbours who show an interest in them and stop to chat with them.

It's not about a village doing practical care, it's about people around you whose influence might seem small, but when combined with everyone else's, plays a part in your child's well-being

That's my understanding as well.

And crucially, that children misbehaving would be pulled up by neighbours, friends, the local shop keeper etc. When I was growing up, if an adult told you off for being naughty you were hoping beyond hope that if you apologised then they'd let it go and wouldn't tell your parents. Contrast that with the current thread about behaviour in schools now...

The point about the village is that it isn't just a one-sided thing - it's about a community helping to teach children right and wrong and how to behave.

There was quite an entertaining bunfight on Nextdoor a few weeks back, where one bloke had posted bemoaning the lack of 'village'. He quickly backpedalled when a neighbour pointed out that they'd recently told his DS off for dropping litter - only to be confronted by the bloke and told in no uncertain terms that they weren't to discipline his son, who has carried on dropping litter because 'Dad said you can't tell me off'.

WestwardHo1 · 27/06/2023 15:43

I've always taken the phrase to mean that parents aren't the only ones who should be guiding and setting boundaries for their children. The community around them should feel it is able to do this. Many parents are hopeless - if the "village" - wider family, teachers, neighbours, community leaders - has no say at all in the upbringing of the children in their midst, then those children grow up with no discipline whatsoever. And that's a problem.

Mariposa26 · 27/06/2023 15:42

To be honest it just sounds like you are very privileged and have been very lucky not to have struggled or fallen on hard times where you needed outside help. I’m not sure what the point of starting this thread was.