Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not need "the village"?

393 replies

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 14:57

Prompted to ask this by a number of threads over the last few days, and particularly today (childless friends with friend with baby, person whose family is all on holiday without them, childless weddings), where people end up asking "where is the village nowadays?" The concept of needing "a village" to be a parent seems to be such an online Mum-ism of the last few years, and I just don't get it. I've never felt the need for a big group of friends and relatives to pitch in with child-raising, or for me to pitch in with them, and I don't see it in the parents around me either.

I suppose I'm lucky in some senses as I have a great husband who is completely 50/50 on all home and children things, and we earn enough money that we have been able to pay for the nurseries that we've needed over the years, but that's not to say it's always been easy. But we've just gotten on with it, as have most of my peers who have children. Both our sets of parents are abroad, and we don't have other family in the UK, so it's not like we're getting loads of family help either.

I guess I just don't recognise this craving for a village, or a bemoaning that the UK isn't like other countries who apparently are better at child raising in this collective way. It's nice that our children (and us!) have close friends and that our families love our kids and feel close to them, which they do, but this collaborative parenting isn't something we've ever looked for.

Does anyone else feel that the mystical "village" actually sounds a bit OTT, or am I just the odd one out on here?

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 27/06/2023 16:07

about the woman who expects her childless friends to help her on a rota

I have never heard anything like this in RL.

Whataretheodds · 27/06/2023 16:07

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:05

But that's not the village that everyone on here talks about, it's the threads I've referenced with people talking about family and friends

Yes, because they don't have the things you have:
Supportive husband
Enough money to pay for reliable childcare

Presumably also employers/jobs that allow for some flexibility when the above arrangements fall through/child is sick. The ability to check a personal phone at work to arrange appointments etc.

FancyFanny · 27/06/2023 16:06

FourTeaFallOut · 27/06/2023 15:02

It's not necessarily just about support but it's a village to provide a tapestry of people that your child can be around and learn from, to interact the different people and personalities, to see their different skills and perspectives.

This!

Meepme · 27/06/2023 16:06

Jeez Op, you seem really entitled. I didnt realise the importance of community till i was in an abusive relationship. I am an intelligent, professional woman yet i couldnt confide in friends, and i spend long periods of time with two small children, aimlessly wandering, dreading going home. I ended up one day at a church playgroup and the church people clearly spotted me and took me in in terms of giving me a chance to confide in people. I then saw how they helped others including many who couldnt speak English, or had difficult partners. Im not even Christian. It made me realise that we need to nuture relationships all round as you never know when you might need this.

I guess what im saying is you are really lucky you have lots of money and a husband that pulls his weight and shares the childcare. Not all of us have this.

Chickenkeev · 27/06/2023 16:06

I was in hospital for an extended time a while back and we would have been lost without my daughter's friends parents minding her while my husband came to visit me. One of my mates drove me to hospital. Another mum/neighbour brought over food to my husband. Genuine kindness that meant the world to us. So imo it does take a village, i'd like to think we would be there for people in the same way they were there for us.

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 16:06

whoateallthecookies · 27/06/2023 15:59

So what would you have done if your husband fell ill (very ill) and needed an ambulance when your children were preschoolers? Because you really don't want to take a 2 year old to A&E if you can avoid it, let alone two children, especially if you need to be talking to medical staff as your husband can't, and you're not sure what the diagnosis/outcome/prognosis will be. This is my lived experience, and I was very grateful to the friends who could take DC and care for them so I didn't have to supervise and care for DC in a cubicle in A&E while doctors and nurses tried to keep DH alive and figure out what was wrong (DH is mostly fine now).

This happened to us, actually. When I was pregnant with my 2nd I needed to be rushed to hospital in the middle of the night, unconscious. My husband brought our daughter with him, following the ambulance. It wasn't ideal but we made it work, and I'm not sure if in the moment even if there had been a Granny 10 minutes away he would have taken her there first, I think probably both our instincts would be to have just thrown her in the car. He then had to juggle our daughter and visiting me for the week I was in hospital. I guess it's things like that where I look back and we made it work, so I don't think about needing others now.

OP posts:
Embelline · 27/06/2023 16:06

Well it’s one way to start a bun fight, OP, I’ll give you that.

Tandora · 27/06/2023 16:05

Stickybackplasticbear · 27/06/2023 15:07

This is one of the most smug things I've read on here and that's saying something.

Well done you I guess.

That was my reaction too 🤣🤣

Sheep Thumbs GIF
CecilyP · 27/06/2023 16:05

SouthLondonMum22 · 27/06/2023 15:38

I can't imagine not having my ''village''.

Nursery
Family
Friends

All either look after my baby regularly or step in if there's an emergency. Grandparents also have him overnight once a month just because.

Again, I think that’s really nice to have. But many of us had to manage without any of that. Thankfully never experienced an emergency but would definitely have been a worry!

ArcticSkewer · 27/06/2023 16:04

My mother was very, erm, self sufficient (read: undiagnosed autism) like that too.
It's okay if your kids are also introverted/self sufficient/cold but it's a bit shit on the ones who quite like other people and hanging out in big communities.

I never realised what I had missed til I left home and saw how other people lived.

Obviously I absolutely haven't brought my own children up the same way. Heaven forbid. But if it works for you, great. I know my mum could have written your first post. She just wouldn't have got it at all. I'm not sure it's possible to explain really if you don't feel that need. The trouble is .. it's not just about you.

Vintagejazzing · 27/06/2023 16:03

I think you're taking the expression a bit literally. It really means that a child should be brought up as part of a community, enabled to learn skills and get involved in things through local activities; have neighbours watch out for them; accept being told off by someone if they're trespassing, making too much noise etc; learn about diversity, cross generational relations and so on through mixing and mingling within their community; and generally understand that they are part of a wider society with all the benefits and responsibilities that brings.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/06/2023 16:03

holycannaloni · 27/06/2023 15:05

But that's not the village that everyone on here talks about, it's the threads I've referenced with people talking about family and friends

Because you can comfortably buy your village and other people can't or would prefer not to.

You're not raising your child isolated and alone, you have a marriage and friends and paid care and interested family.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/06/2023 16:02

How would you cope if, heaven forbid, your husband passed away or left you? Would you need a "village" then?

islandofserenity · 27/06/2023 16:02

whoateallthecookies · 27/06/2023 15:59

So what would you have done if your husband fell ill (very ill) and needed an ambulance when your children were preschoolers? Because you really don't want to take a 2 year old to A&E if you can avoid it, let alone two children, especially if you need to be talking to medical staff as your husband can't, and you're not sure what the diagnosis/outcome/prognosis will be. This is my lived experience, and I was very grateful to the friends who could take DC and care for them so I didn't have to supervise and care for DC in a cubicle in A&E while doctors and nurses tried to keep DH alive and figure out what was wrong (DH is mostly fine now).

Totally agree cookies. I had to call an ambulance for my oh when our youngest was 3. He had to go in the ambulance himself.

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 16:02

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Oh I breezed through the teen years with the eldest - and then very much needed “a village” with the next! Like I said to OP don’t assume that the teen years will be easy just because they can be more independent. Life isn’t just about logistics.

islandofserenity · 27/06/2023 16:00

You are indeed speaking from a very privileged position!!! I always say walk a mile in someone's shoes before judging them!"
do you know what it's like to have a huge debt run up with gas and electricity because you used the tumble dryer over the winter? There are 5 of us in my family- I have to do a wash everyday.
People like you are very entitled.

Dogstar78 · 27/06/2023 16:00

The village is not just childcare. It's a network of trusted adults that help your child navigate life. Teach them skills you don't have. Alternative viewpoints, rather than just yours/ your partners. Thinking you have the full toolkit to be a parent feels shortsighted to me. I know my toolkit is light and sometimes my patience is short. I have been a single mum and in a relationship. Sometimes the village help is practical heavy lifting support, sometimes it's the stuff above.

Your child will massively benefit from trusted adults that are not you or your partner to share their problems with and talk to.

The village is how kids were raised up until they disappeared behind a screen with anxiety.

whoateallthecookies · 27/06/2023 15:59

So what would you have done if your husband fell ill (very ill) and needed an ambulance when your children were preschoolers? Because you really don't want to take a 2 year old to A&E if you can avoid it, let alone two children, especially if you need to be talking to medical staff as your husband can't, and you're not sure what the diagnosis/outcome/prognosis will be. This is my lived experience, and I was very grateful to the friends who could take DC and care for them so I didn't have to supervise and care for DC in a cubicle in A&E while doctors and nurses tried to keep DH alive and figure out what was wrong (DH is mostly fine now).

mewkins · 27/06/2023 15:59

MelaniaT · 27/06/2023 15:03

I’ve always understood the expression to be more about the importance of community and collective wisdom in raising children, rather than being about free childcare etc.

Me too. I think community is really important. Not for childcare as much (it's much more structured now than when I was little) but more for looking out for others, ensuring your kids realise the impact of their behaviour on others (especially when they hit the teen years), having empathy for those around us, ensuring we all take care of the area in which we live.

The village analogy has recently been used on threads regarding adults picking children up on rudeness etc, which I think is a good thing. I grew up with people who round me who cared for me a huge amount but also weren't afraid to let me know if I was being rude.

CecilyP · 27/06/2023 15:58

IMustDoMoreExercise · 27/06/2023 15:34

What would you do if you had a baby and a toddler and your partner ended up in hospital?

You would have to get a childminder to look after your children.

That is where the village can step in.

But who actually would step in if you didn’t have extended family? Not many of the people or organisations that posters have referenced as the village.

autieawesome · 27/06/2023 15:57

Based on the information provided it seems you haven't needed a village due to your circumstances. I could have really done with a village when my son was ill, my mum had terminal cancer and my grandfather (who I was responsible for) was on end of life all at the same time. My son is disabled and can't access regular childcare, a village would be useful.

Saying you have managed without a village is a bit like a rich person saying they are doing fine in the col crisis.

Anoisagusaris · 27/06/2023 15:57

Do you never share lifts to activities/matches/parties with other parents?

FuckOffTom · 27/06/2023 15:56

MelaniaT · 27/06/2023 15:03

I’ve always understood the expression to be more about the importance of community and collective wisdom in raising children, rather than being about free childcare etc.

I agree with this

islandofserenity · 27/06/2023 15:55

oh and my in laws lived 10 miles away but were useless. Their daughter had her 2nd baby days after my son was born. She has always been numero uno!!! They didn't care about me or my son

Cantstaystuckforever · 27/06/2023 15:54

@LocalHobo Personality traits probably play a part here. I adored the fact my maternity hospital allowed me to find my own way to breastfeed for example, whereas some of my contemporaries complained about lack of intervention which they would have seen as helpful.

Are you seriously attributing other women's struggles with breastfeeding to 'personality traits'? This thread is really bringing out people who were born on third base but think they hit a home run... 😵