Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
era12 · 27/06/2023 16:52

@DataNotLore it's literally in the opening post: Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study. The system is actively killing us at this point.

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 16:42

Pippippipi · 27/06/2023 16:02

Why has this turned into an anp bashing thread?

within my area of practice, I examine, diagnose, carry out procedures from cannulas to intubation, teach the former to junior doctors, prescribe, lead at resuscitations… the list goes on but I stress is confined to my narrow area of practice in which I’ve worked for 2 decades.

It’s nice to know that my band 8a salary which is as far as I’ll ever go is resented by colleagues who I support in their campaign for a fair salary. I am not a pretend doctor and have never claimed to be. I am however a knowledgeable specialist in my field and see this as what the anp role is as it’s best.

As I said before I’ve worked with some brilliant ACPs/ANPs and learnt lots from them. But on the whole they have less training and less responsibility than a registrar

I’m assuming you’re a Paeds ANP if intubating etc? I may be making an assumption here! I don’t know which specialty you’re in.

I think this issue is that as an 8a ANP you’re paid more per hour than an ST8 registrar who carries more responsibility and has undergone more rigorous training (including royal college membership exams), rotated round a region gaining subspec experience etc. I don’t think ANPs are overpaid I just think that doctors are underpaid. And ANPs have much better working conditions than doctors and as they’re not rotational are usually treated better by other permanent staff in my experience.

You don’t have huge tuition fee loans that you’ll never pay off due to interest. You were paid well to do your masters whilst doctors paid for their own professional exams and study in their own time. We just feel we’ve had a raw deal.

If there’s an emergency and there’s an ANP and an ST6 there it’s the ST6 leading it in almost all cases and it’s them who carries the most responsibility for the case, who’s had more training yet is being paid less than the ANP. Becoming the ANP was the smart move! Medicine is for fools now. And it is pretty terrifying how many doctors are jumping ship.

Usernamen · 27/06/2023 16:42

Spacecowboys · 27/06/2023 16:36

I hope you aren’t a doctor as you have been pretty disrespectful of other health care professionals here. There is nothing wrong with nurses, pharmacists, paramedics etc wanting to advance their practice and yes this will mean a blurring of roles and boundaries. That isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Junior drs issues with their pay have not been caused by those working in advanced practice.

Cross post. I also see nothing wrong with these professionals furthering their qualifications and expanding their remit. It really doesn’t bother me if I am seen by a nurse or a GP provided it’s a qualified professional who is able to prescribe what I need.

Often the GP is a locum who gives zero fucks, so it’s often preferable to get a nurse or pharmacist!

It’s not other healthcare professionals who are devaluing doctors, it’s doctors themselves, chasing money through locum work instead of committing to a practice and giving a shit about their patients and community.

MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 16:40

It’s a bit like when we had (still have? IDK) a shortage of HGV drivers, and the government just reduced the training and some of the skills required for the test, like reversing (or something equally necessary and difficult to do).

Quick fixes, sod industry norms. It’s what Brexit was for - cut corners, do everything on the cheap. It’s all very Oceangate.

(Will the Oceangate tragedy become known as Oceangategate, I wonder?)

Usernamen · 27/06/2023 16:38

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 12:21

The doctor retention crisis is being papered over by the government consciously training people to become pseudo-doctors who wouldn't meet the admission criteria for a medical degree.

Qualified GPs replaced with ANPs, PAs and paramedics.

A&E doctors replaced with ANPs and PAs.

Surgical trainees replaced with PAs and Surgical Care Practitioners (whatever they are).

A Physician Associate (a graduate of any degree who does a 2 year masters) starts out on £40-£45k after graduation. They cannot legally prescribe any medications or even order an x-ray. A newly qualified doctor, who's studied medicine for 5 years, starts on £29k. Second year = £32k. And that's based on a 48hr week.

ANPs are band 7 - £40-£50k. Yet they can't do half of the things a doctor does and are less educated.

No wonder doctors leave. They are treated with contempt and replaced with I imitators who are better paid than them.

Plenty of these ‘pseudo doctors’ can prescribe though, can’t they? Certainly plenty of nurses and pharmacists are independent prescribers. I don’t see a problem with this except they’re not that much cheaper than doctors so I doubt they’re going to sort out the NHS’s cost base.

Spacecowboys · 27/06/2023 16:36

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 12:21

The doctor retention crisis is being papered over by the government consciously training people to become pseudo-doctors who wouldn't meet the admission criteria for a medical degree.

Qualified GPs replaced with ANPs, PAs and paramedics.

A&E doctors replaced with ANPs and PAs.

Surgical trainees replaced with PAs and Surgical Care Practitioners (whatever they are).

A Physician Associate (a graduate of any degree who does a 2 year masters) starts out on £40-£45k after graduation. They cannot legally prescribe any medications or even order an x-ray. A newly qualified doctor, who's studied medicine for 5 years, starts on £29k. Second year = £32k. And that's based on a 48hr week.

ANPs are band 7 - £40-£50k. Yet they can't do half of the things a doctor does and are less educated.

No wonder doctors leave. They are treated with contempt and replaced with I imitators who are better paid than them.

I hope you aren’t a doctor as you have been pretty disrespectful of other health care professionals here. There is nothing wrong with nurses, pharmacists, paramedics etc wanting to advance their practice and yes this will mean a blurring of roles and boundaries. That isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Junior drs issues with their pay have not been caused by those working in advanced practice.

Gracebaker · 27/06/2023 16:34

I also second the commenters here talking about doctor ‘alternatives’ becoming the norm in the UK. It is the ultimate plan of the government to replace doctors with cheaper alternatives who haven’t been to medical school or had the training doctors have had. They will be marketed as ‘highly trained clinicians’, but aren’t doctors and dont have the same depth of training or experience. In reality, this means if you go to the GP or hospital you won’t see a doctor - you will see a nurse practitioner, physician associate, paramedic - hence reducing the number of doctors they need to train and employ. It will be healthcare on the cheap, as all the government cares about is quantity not quality. This is the model being used in USA - and it’s telling that they have worse health outcomes than we do. This could be avoided by paying doctors properly to stem the workforce crisis and training more UK doctors to become consultants. If you find the situation facing us scary or unacceptable - NOW is the time to do something about it!

MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 16:34

The BT engineer who came today used to be a healthcare assistant, and worked throughout the Covid pandemic. I asked if the horror of that had made her leave to be an engineer and while she agreed it probably sped things up, she’d have left sooner or later anyway, because of all the constant stress.

I retired early because of the stress and toll it took on my mental and physical health, and that was in 2016, so goodness knows how much worse things are now. And of course the more people leave, the fewer there to fill all the vacancies/do all the work, it has a knock-on effect.

Both the former HCA and I feel terrible guilt at having made things harder for our former colleagues in the NHS. It’s not just doctors who are leaving in disgust and despair.

You get what you pay for, and the NHS has been financially starved for 13 years. It’s hard to care for other people when your own employers care so little for you.

cptartapp · 27/06/2023 16:31

That’s right blame the people who have paid tax all their lives for the screw up now happening!

But they haven't all 'paid all their lives'. My frail elderly MIL with a multitude of health problems gave up work at 25 to raise two DC and has never worked a day in her life again. Like many women of her generation.
It's not blame, it's just a fact.
They're now starting a six month course of chemo on my frail 80 something FIL with two forms of aggressive cancer.
As long as we try and push everyone to live until they're 110 this issue will persist.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 16:29

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 16:02

Consultants have now voted to strike as well… says it all really

By a decent margin too. There's no one to act down as it were to cover these, I wonder if it'll finally make the government take these strikes seriously (doubtful sadly).

DataNotLore · 27/06/2023 16:28

era12 · 27/06/2023 16:26

I mean, but honestly, why do we want to preserve a healthcare system that is ranked so poorly in healthcare outcomes? We have to start again with this.

Is it?

era12 · 27/06/2023 16:26

I mean, but honestly, why do we want to preserve a healthcare system that is ranked so poorly in healthcare outcomes? We have to start again with this.

Gracebaker · 27/06/2023 16:18

Definitely not being unreasonable, this is a very valid concern. Doctors in this country have been squeezed to breaking point by endless pay cuts and increasing workload, and the pandemic thrown into the mix and understandably they have had enough. Hence why they are striking for better pay (initially) to improve retention and morale. Public support of doctor strikes is mixed, but ultimately - as you have said - it will be the public who suffer. If you feel worried about the future of the NHS and the continued exodus of doctors l encourage you to support the junior doctors and consultants strikes in any way you can - social media, writing to MPs etc.

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 16:02

Consultants have now voted to strike as well… says it all really

OP posts:
Pippippipi · 27/06/2023 16:02

Why has this turned into an anp bashing thread?

within my area of practice, I examine, diagnose, carry out procedures from cannulas to intubation, teach the former to junior doctors, prescribe, lead at resuscitations… the list goes on but I stress is confined to my narrow area of practice in which I’ve worked for 2 decades.

It’s nice to know that my band 8a salary which is as far as I’ll ever go is resented by colleagues who I support in their campaign for a fair salary. I am not a pretend doctor and have never claimed to be. I am however a knowledgeable specialist in my field and see this as what the anp role is as it’s best.

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 15:48

RedToothBrush · 27/06/2023 15:44

But we voted for £350 million for NHS....

... didn't we???

Well some fools thought they were….

I wonder if they are feeling a little short changed now?

SunnyEgg · 27/06/2023 15:45

TripleDaisySummer · 27/06/2023 15:29

I didn't and never have yet- I'm also in Wales where its not looking good despite being run by Labour - heard SNP Scotland NHS has problems.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-65616395

I'd hope a UK Labour government will turn on the money taps for NHS - and that will help and did hear shadow health secretary say they knew reform was needed but didn't get into details which this far put from election isn't a surprise.

However I've heard political commentators start to say behind scenes Labour are starting to worried that unrealistic expectation on what they can do may well fuck over once they do get in.

Labour in Wales doesn’t inspire confidence but some will say it will be different

I’m not sure where the funds will come from, based on what they’ve said so far

RedToothBrush · 27/06/2023 15:44

But we voted for £350 million for NHS....

... didn't we???

AgeingDoc · 27/06/2023 15:44

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 12:21

The doctor retention crisis is being papered over by the government consciously training people to become pseudo-doctors who wouldn't meet the admission criteria for a medical degree.

Qualified GPs replaced with ANPs, PAs and paramedics.

A&E doctors replaced with ANPs and PAs.

Surgical trainees replaced with PAs and Surgical Care Practitioners (whatever they are).

A Physician Associate (a graduate of any degree who does a 2 year masters) starts out on £40-£45k after graduation. They cannot legally prescribe any medications or even order an x-ray. A newly qualified doctor, who's studied medicine for 5 years, starts on £29k. Second year = £32k. And that's based on a 48hr week.

ANPs are band 7 - £40-£50k. Yet they can't do half of the things a doctor does and are less educated.

No wonder doctors leave. They are treated with contempt and replaced with I imitators who are better paid than them.

Completely agree.
I'm retired now, early, on ill health grounds, but if I hadn't been treated like complete shit by my employers and been already sick of seeing healthcare in this country going to hell in a handcart then there might well have been some way if keeping me making some kind of contribution even if I couldn't do my old job again.
I qualified in the 80s and worked ridiculous hours often with inadequate supervision. I am not advocating a return to those days, but I actually felt happier and more valued as a junior doctor in those days than I did as a senior consultant when I retired. And it's not all about money, it's about working conditions, feeling like you are valued and that you are able to do a good job. I am not saying money doesn't matter, and i was, in real terms, considerably less well paid when I retired than in my first years as a Consultant which isn't really how anyone expects their career to go, but that wasn't my biggest gripe. If I underwent some kind of miracle and was returned to health tomorrow I wouldn't go back to work, not for double the salary, unless the conditions changed dramatically.
The changes you describe are hailed as the answer whereas they are in fact part of the problem. Nursing has shot itself in the foot in my opinion. The only career progression for nurses these days is into management or one of these roles. Good nurses are not valued as good nurses any more. Jobs that used to be done by doctors are done increasingly by nurses or AHPs and their work is done increasingly by HCAs. Of course there are some excellent people in all these roles but overall the standard of care is falling in my experience. I have felt very unsafe as a patient in our local hospital in the last few years and the ANPs at our GP surgery have made several serious errors with the care of members of my family that, had I not known they were wrong and used my influence to get them into hospital would have been very serious and on one occasion definitely fatal. Obviously "normal" people can't do that though and it's a huge worry. Care is increasingly task orientated and delivered by people who may have skills in that particular task but don't have the breadth or depth of knowledge to provide holistic care and thus, in my experience, frequently miss significant things that fall outside their remit.
It wasn't money that made me glad to leave. It was being asked to do more and more with less and less whilst under ever more scrutiny. It was being told which patients to prioritise by managers with little or no clinical experience- certainly not compared to me - or being threatened with disciplinary action because I missed mandatory fire safety training on account of being a bit busy trying to save someone's life at the time. It was sleeping on my office floor on call because I daren't go home as the staffing on my Unit was inadequate both in terms of numbers and skills, or being one of the few actual medical staff on duty on a Bank Holiday and not being able to get any hot food despite being there for 20 hours. Whatever you pay people it won't solve recruitment and retention if actually going to work remains so stressful. Despite my poor physical health I am actually happier now than I have been in at least a decade. I do miss patient care, but I don't miss being an NHS employee in the slightest. And I am not alone. More or less every doctor I know around my age is aiming to leave as soon as they can afford to and wouldn't encourage anyone into the profession now.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 27/06/2023 15:38

nameschangg · 27/06/2023 12:12

i think we are already screwed with the ageing population issue.

Exactly this.

Our government seems obsessed with getting people to live longer and longer.

We don't want people to live in to their 80s. It will bankrupt us even more than we are bankrupt at the moment.

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 15:37

Well what I would say is that Labour would have a heck of a job to turn around the shit show that the Tories have made of the NHS. However they did it before…. Having said that though I think things are much harder now because of other worldwide pressures.

What they could do is have honest, and possibly brutally frank, conversations with the public about the state of the NHS and what might be needed to rescue it. We need a Government that can at least tell the truth and stop pretending everything is just hunky dory!

TripleDaisySummer · 27/06/2023 15:29

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/06/2023 15:10

This is what you get for voting Tory. Turkeys voting for Christmas.

I didn't and never have yet- I'm also in Wales where its not looking good despite being run by Labour - heard SNP Scotland NHS has problems.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-65616395

I'd hope a UK Labour government will turn on the money taps for NHS - and that will help and did hear shadow health secretary say they knew reform was needed but didn't get into details which this far put from election isn't a surprise.

However I've heard political commentators start to say behind scenes Labour are starting to worried that unrealistic expectation on what they can do may well fuck over once they do get in.

Hospital corridor

NHS Wales waiting times: Thousands still waiting two years

Waiting lists in Wales rise while thousands still wait two years for treatment, figures show.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-65616395

Purplesilkpyjamas · 27/06/2023 15:23

IrisGold · 27/06/2023 15:17

The nurse practioners at my GP surgery are excellent, knowledgable and professional and I've had great care from them over the years.

However they just took on a PA. I saw him recently for some alarming symptoms. He seemed bored and basically said come back in 3 weeks if not better. After three weeks I saw a GP who was appalled and referred me to hospital on a 2ww. So three weeks wasted on a possible cancer diagnosis.

Please report this. Hope you are ok.

WetBandits · 27/06/2023 15:23

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 15:08

@WetBandits I much prefer ANPs to PAs and the ones I work with now are excellent and have a clearly defined scope of practice and have taught me lots about the specialty. I think the issue many doctors have is that we’re paid less than many ANPs. Despite the fact that they have less responsibility that the registrar.

A good ANP who is proud of their nursing/paramedic etc background rather than being a “doctor lite” well trained in their area is worth their weight in gold. The ones proud to be their own profession who work within clearly defined scope are completely different to PAs.

Yep, exactly that! You’ve hit the nail bang on the head.

FWIW I think it’s sickening what junior doctors are paid for the responsibility they are expected to shoulder (and a lot of people don’t realise that ‘junior’ can mean anything from FY1 to ST8!)

However, a lot of people seem to be fighting the issue from the wrong angle; junior doctors should be paid fairly for what they do regardless of what other HCPs are being paid.

Purplesilkpyjamas · 27/06/2023 15:22

givemushypeasachance · 27/06/2023 14:04

I find physician associates to be a bizarre concept. And legally, they don't have the same standing as a doctor - they should always be "supervised" by a consultant or GP. So why would any doctor want to be stuck supervising/babysitting all decisions made by a PA, knowing that if the PA does something wrong it's the consultant/GP who will get it in the neck as a negligence claim against them. Doctors accept that they are responsible for supervising and training up their next generation of medical students and junior doctors, but that is for the wider purpose of ensuring there will be more well-trained professionals in the future. Supervising a PA, paid much more than a junior doctor, seems a thankless task.

I don't see how PA can be workable without them taking responsibility for their own actions and decisions. Otherwise they are wasting doctors time not helping them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread