Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
mumsneedwine · 27/06/2023 19:55

Umm people mainly see junior doctors. They are the ones often doing your surgery, your CPR, an intubation at 2am on a 6 month old. Who do you think those people are ? Consultants ? Not v often.
Junior doctors needs to go as a name. Foundation, SHO, Registrar etc would give more impression of seniority. Many people think junior doctors are still doing their degree.
Oh and the laughable idea that F1s are fully supervised is nuts. I know several who have been left over seeing several wards over night. The supervision is that there is a more senior colleague somewhere in the building. That F1, on £14.09 an hour could be the one starting the crash cart on you.

Kazzyhoward · 27/06/2023 19:51

@Darhon

and the government were too slow to up numbers of training places until quite recently

Not helped by the BMA stance 15 years ago when they voted against new medical schools and not to increase the number of medical school training places.

https://www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

"to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.”

So blatant self interest!

BMA meeting: Doctors vote to limit number of medical students

Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical scho...

https://www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:50

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:43

I suggest that nurses who want to play doctor ought to go to medical school and become qualified, rather than furthering the government's plan to create a two tier healthcare service (because you can bet those with private healthcare aren't seeing nurses).

But they’re not playing doctor. They are utilising their skills in their specialty within their scope of practice. That is not playing doctor. You might not like the fact their scope of practice now includes prescribing and ordering x-rays, and indeed seemed unaware of that until just now, but there you go. The evidence backs the ANPs up for being able to do it and doing it well.

Theres plenty of stuff which doctors can do which nurses can’t. I don’t have any real knowledge of PAs, we don’t have any in our trust.

Out of interest (genuine question) who do you think is at fault for there not been more training places? Is this due to staffing or funding? The government or the deanery?

HRTQueen · 27/06/2023 19:49

We need to stop flogging a dead horse

the NHS needs to be replaced. It will take a huge amount of money and work but we have to look at non profit insurance based healthcare it will no longer be free at point of service

it will mean paying more and that doesn’t mean 1p on tax it will be considerably more for many

unfortunately parties use the NHS as a political football as they know how strongly many people feel about keeping the NHS

Wishiwasatailor · 27/06/2023 19:48

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:43

I suggest that nurses who want to play doctor ought to go to medical school and become qualified, rather than furthering the government's plan to create a two tier healthcare service (because you can bet those with private healthcare aren't seeing nurses).

they aren’t seeing junior docs either…. Except at night when you can see a non training house officer with minimal support no critical care outreach team in many private hospitals

MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 19:48

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:20

It's interesting that you frame this as a good thing, rather than a very dangerous symptom of the terminal decline of the NHS.

CNS-led services have excellent outcomes and high patient satisfaction, compared with their medical colleagues. Seriously, whether or not you actually intend to piss off everyone whom you consider subordinate and inferior to you, you’re coming across as a bit of a ducking aunt here.

Darhon · 27/06/2023 19:48

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 12:21

The doctor retention crisis is being papered over by the government consciously training people to become pseudo-doctors who wouldn't meet the admission criteria for a medical degree.

Qualified GPs replaced with ANPs, PAs and paramedics.

A&E doctors replaced with ANPs and PAs.

Surgical trainees replaced with PAs and Surgical Care Practitioners (whatever they are).

A Physician Associate (a graduate of any degree who does a 2 year masters) starts out on £40-£45k after graduation. They cannot legally prescribe any medications or even order an x-ray. A newly qualified doctor, who's studied medicine for 5 years, starts on £29k. Second year = £32k. And that's based on a 48hr week.

ANPs are band 7 - £40-£50k. Yet they can't do half of the things a doctor does and are less educated.

No wonder doctors leave. They are treated with contempt and replaced with I imitators who are better paid than them.

Lots of PA course want a science degree! There’s plenty of room for allied health professionals. But we have less bed space (by the way lack of bed space makes training more doctors extremely challenging as they are taught at the bedside) and the government were too slow to up numbers of training places until quite recently.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:43

Wishiwasatailor · 27/06/2023 19:41

Do you suggest that no nurse or AHP with the required experience apply for these advanced practice jobs to prove a point?

I suggest that nurses who want to play doctor ought to go to medical school and become qualified, rather than furthering the government's plan to create a two tier healthcare service (because you can bet those with private healthcare aren't seeing nurses).

Backstreets · 27/06/2023 19:42

I feel so weird about this stuff. Middle aged people has been claiming the world is going to hell in a hand basket since time immemorial, and now I’m 40 I feel exactly the same way. But at the same time - has any society changed as much in a couple generations as ours? The numbers I read in the paper are presumably real? Even people I know who are quite jolly can get pretty apocalyptic about the future. I just don’t know.

Missingmyusername · 27/06/2023 19:41

“The environment - because actually making a meaningful difference would require huge investment and sacrifice and very few people are prepared to do it.”

^This

I wouldn’t worry too much- the NHS or lack of will be the least of your worries!

Wishiwasatailor · 27/06/2023 19:41

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:39

Why would we need the others if we had enough qualified doctors?

Becuase they want to do the fun stuff doctors do without the requisite qualifications, and are using the NHS workforce crisis as a personal opportunity.

Do you suggest that no nurse or AHP with the required experience apply for these advanced practice jobs to prove a point?

AgeingDoc · 27/06/2023 19:40

You are correct a nurse is a nurse and a doctor is a doctor, the issue is an increasing amount of trusts and some individuals are blurring the lines to plug gaps and its an issue. It's not personal.
Precisely. And it is in the places where staffing is at its worst, hence there is the least supervision where this is most likely to happen. There is a role for ANPs and other advanced practitioners but there are plenty of places where they are being used - abused really - to do things that are outside of their scope of practice. I have seen this both professionally and as a patient. That is not necessarily a criticism of the individuals (though there are of course varying degrees of competence just as there are with doctors) or of the concept of the roles in general, but of the way they are being used. It's also often robbing Peter to pay Paul, again, particularly in smaller Trusts and/or more geographically isolated places where the staffing pool is smaller and recruitment more difficult anyway.
I was a Consultant in Anaesthesia and Intensive Care and I hugely value my nursing colleagues. But we have lost a great many excellent nurses to these roles leaving the general nursing levels depleted. It's understandable. The pay, and possibly job satisfaction is much better than being a regular staff nurse, especially given that prospects for promotion and pay progression are so poor for "normal" nurses.By the time I retired most of the Staff Nurses on the Unit I worked on were band 5s with a few Band 6s and one Band 7 for the Unit. Not that many years ago we had an 8, about 4 7s and roughly equal numbers of 5s and 6s. I don't blame good, experienced nurses for moving into practitioner roles - it could be a decade or more before the band 7 role becomes vacant and I'd probably be looking for alternatives in their shoes too. But at least some of them are taking on tasks inappropriate to their role and level of training and the knock on effect is that gaps are then created and again, sometimes inappropriately filled in other areas too. Certainly when I was first appointed as a Consultant there were no newly qualified nurses in our ICU at all - new starters all had significant experience in ward nursing already and they got a substantial period of mentoring and supervision before they looked after a ventilated patient solo. Not now.
And it is even worse on the general wards. Quality nursing care is the bedrock of the NHS. Siphoning off the best to plug the gaps created by inadequate medical workforce planning and not valuing or paying good, experienced nurses a wage commensurate with the importance of their role doesn't help anyone in my opinion.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:39

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:36

But I do of course agree we need more doctors and better paid doctors. But we should get that in addition to nurses, AHPs with extended roles/extra training/prescribing qualifications.

Why would we need the others if we had enough qualified doctors?

Becuase they want to do the fun stuff doctors do without the requisite qualifications, and are using the NHS workforce crisis as a personal opportunity.

mumsneedwine · 27/06/2023 19:38

PS I think ACPs are amazing. But if they are going to take the training opportunities from doctors then it's a problem. You can't be good at something if you don't practice it.

mumsneedwine · 27/06/2023 19:37

If you don't allow the new doctors to get the hands on training then there will be no consultants in a few years. So train all the ACPs you like (they are often paid more than the doctor next to them) but don't expect consultants to be as experienced in ten years. Or there to be any doctors left at all. PAs earn £40,000 for a 35 hour week and no shift work. F2s earn £34,000 for a 40 hour week, plus do nights and weekends, and they have to sign the prescriptions for the PA. Total utter madness.
Personally I'd like an anaesthetist who has a medical degree in case something goes wrong, not just training on how the machine works.
I don't know one F1 or 2 who is not planning an exit strategy at the moment.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:36

But I do of course agree we need more doctors and better paid doctors. But we should get that in addition to nurses, AHPs with extended roles/extra training/prescribing qualifications.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:33

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:20

It's interesting that you frame this as a good thing, rather than a very dangerous symptom of the terminal decline of the NHS.

I don’t think I framed it either way to be honest. I was just correcting your misinformation.

However I have had good service from nurses at such walk in /urgent treatment centres. Took Dd with a broken finger. This was in Tenby, it’s a nurse led cottage hospital. Nurse ordered and did the x-ray, reviewed the x-ray, splinted finger up and told us to get into fracture clinic once back home from holiday. Great service.

In home town have taken Dd to see a nurse when she had a uti, abx prescribed. Thought holistically about whether Dd had undiagnosed diabetes and did a BM.

Ive had a similar experience with an ear infection and abx prescribed.

DD treated by an ANP in a same day emergency care centre. Initially sent for an x-ray and then pulled out of x-ray just before they did it as her d dimer had come back high. Sent for a CTPA, no idea who authorised that but positive for multiple PE. ANP prescribed blood thinners and sorted out all follow up care and answered questions. I never felt the need to ask to see a doctor as I felt confident in her ability.

I’m not a nurse myself but I am a midwife so I do believe that when people have a lot of experience in an area they generally may well know what they’re doing regardless of job title. Thankfully on the labour ward I work on the doctors including the consultants seem happy to ask midwives their opinions. I’ve been asked by a consultant before if I thought the woman I was looking after needed an em lscs or not, literally asking for my input as she weighed up what to do with a suspicious CTG. Because she understands it’s team work, that I have my own professional expertise and that as someone who has been caring for that woman for x hours i probably know her best out of all the staff. That I’m good at ctg interpretation to the extent I teach other midwives about it, that I’m good at obstetric emergencies and teach midwives and doctors around the country how to manage them as part of my role as a PROMPT instructor. That sometimes I will be working with an SHO who literally does not know how to operate a speculum.

Wishiwasatailor · 27/06/2023 19:33

Think you’ll find all UTCs/MIus in Somerset Devon and Cornwall are nurse led with no medical cover except maybe Bodmin. Many nurse prescribers in post those that aren’t use PGDs to administer medications. Most have masters level qualifications or work within protocols for specific minor illness/injuries. Lots of time spent reassuring worried well with common sense and first aid for mild conditions, assessing minor injuries and ordering and reviewing X-rays if required and wound care inc suturing. They are able to refer direct to specialty if needed and have an Ed reg/cons adviceline. It frees up ED docs to see sick patients

LeanIntoChaos · 27/06/2023 19:30

Of course nurses and allied health professionals should be able to order x-rays within their scope of practice. They are highly skilled and knowledgeable. For example, I work with children with cerebral palsy. They require hip x-rays every so often, which the physiotherapists should absolutely be able to order, they can read them better than I can. But they shouldn't be able to order every test if it's outside their scope of practice. Similarly an Ed ANP should be able to order an x-ray of an arm of it is suspected that it is broken, because they can certainly learn to read it and it is well within their scope of practice. We are shooting ourselves in the foot by downplaying ANPs usefulness.

But we provide a different perspective which is more overarching because of the very different way we have trained, which is why oversight is required.

TokyoStories · 27/06/2023 19:28

What are your qualifications, @SisterDonnarix?

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 19:20

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:13

More pesky nurses ordering X-rays. https://www.somersetlmc.co.uk/nursepractitionersandahpsrequestingxrayandultrasoundinvestigations

just messaged a ANP friend of mine who says she can definitely prescribe and order X-rays. The walk in clinic she works at often has no doctors. Just staffed by ANPs and sometimes by paramedics.

It's interesting that you frame this as a good thing, rather than a very dangerous symptom of the terminal decline of the NHS.

MavisMcMinty · 27/06/2023 19:17

Spacecowboys · 27/06/2023 19:08

Yes they should. Years ago , fees were paid for nurses and the only debt was the maintenance loan. And this was paid off with time too. These days it seems the debt increases each year despite paying towards it. Complete mess.

…And of course years before that, we were paid apprentices, given subsidised on-site accommodation, belonged to our training hospital. Far lower rate of attrition too.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 19:16

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:13

More pesky nurses ordering X-rays. https://www.somersetlmc.co.uk/nursepractitionersandahpsrequestingxrayandultrasoundinvestigations

just messaged a ANP friend of mine who says she can definitely prescribe and order X-rays. The walk in clinic she works at often has no doctors. Just staffed by ANPs and sometimes by paramedics.

Yikes that's scary, no doctor on site at all? That's not good, I'd have refused to work there if I was any other HCP.

Yes they should. Years ago , fees were paid for nurses and the only debt was the maintenance loan. And this was paid off with time too. These days it seems the debt increases each year despite paying towards it. Complete mess.

Yeah its so sad, so many passionate people who would be an asset to the health service are priced out, and then of course so many amazing, capable people who are brilliant also leave once trained. The government don't care at all though :(

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 19:13

More pesky nurses ordering X-rays. https://www.somersetlmc.co.uk/nursepractitionersandahpsrequestingxrayandultrasoundinvestigations

just messaged a ANP friend of mine who says she can definitely prescribe and order X-rays. The walk in clinic she works at often has no doctors. Just staffed by ANPs and sometimes by paramedics.

Somerset LMCs: Nurse Practitioners and AHPs Requesting X-ray and Ultrasound Investigations

https://www.somersetlmc.co.uk/nursepractitionersandahpsrequestingxrayandultrasoundinvestigations

Spacecowboys · 27/06/2023 19:08

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 18:59

I think nurses and allied health professionals should have their fees paid too, and as they do in Wales, have it where if you stay for 2 years you don't pay a penny back but if you do leave you then have to get a loan and owe it. It's just a mess all over for everyone isn't it.

Yes they should. Years ago , fees were paid for nurses and the only debt was the maintenance loan. And this was paid off with time too. These days it seems the debt increases each year despite paying towards it. Complete mess.