Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
mumsneedwine · 28/06/2023 07:50

I just don't understand what this pathetic corrupt bunch of idiots want. No health service at all, because that is what is going to happen v shortly. Even they or their families might need A & E. If they really hate the NHS then at least have the decency to offer an alternative.
And why promote those PA and ACP jobs when they are costing more than doctors ?
They are either v v v stupid or, nope. Can't think of an or.
Anyway, we'll have no one educated soon to do the jobs since loads of teachers leaving too.
I think we need to be more French and get more angry.

MavisMcMinty · 28/06/2023 07:05

I could weep when I see how the Conservative government have wrecked the NHS after all the improvements (PFI dependence excluded, obviously) of the 1997-2010 Labour government. Of my 35 years as an NHS nurse, those 13 years were the very best of my career. Services improved and expanded, and both patient and staff satisfaction was high. The improvements in cancer care and cardiac care were astonishing.

The Tories have been opposed to the NHS since its inception, and knowing they haven’t a chance at winning the next election are apparently trying to leave the biggest possible shitshow for the next government to have to deal with.

LunaTheCat · 28/06/2023 00:10

I have needed urgent care twice n the UK in last 10 yrs… both times seen by a nurse practitioner.. once seen only by NP then another time the NP referred me to an after hrs GP.. I was incredibly impressed with standard care and knowledge both times ( I am a GP)
On the other hand I worked with a NP in an after hrs role and when I asked what her role was ( NP are new where I practice) she said “ I have the heart of a nurse and skills of a doctor “.Quite offensive to suggest I have no heart and it quickly became apparent that her clinical skills where not flash.
With every clinician .. NP, GP, anaesthetist or whatever then the most important trait is humility and knowing what you don’t know, asking for help. Any practitioner who lacks that insight is dangerous!

Roste · 27/06/2023 23:41

I agree with this by EffortlessDesmond.
And much more emphasis on public health, including the message that your health is your responsibility.

Too many people still reject taking personal responsibility for their own health and have unrealistic expectations of what the NHS can then provide to ease the often inevitable health problems caused by poor lifestyle choices.

BelleMarionette · 27/06/2023 23:39

Yup, I'm a doctor and most of my colleagues have already left the country. Australia pays so much better,and treats their doctors much better. Those that haven't left the country are leaving medicine.

It's tragic what is happening. There is no point training doctors if we can't retain them. So many people are against pay restoration for doctors, but are also quick to complain about waiting times.

Junior doctors are also treated appallingly. We are infantilised and abused on a regular basis. Not able to have breaks at work, access study leave, or even annual leave. Being forced to rotate resulting in expensive transport and childcare.

TaylorSwiftFan · 27/06/2023 23:18

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:33

@Afishcalledwand well we were paid 35% more in 2008. I’m a junior doctor (new registrar) and it’s only in the past 20 years that our pay has massively dropped.

Everyone’s pay has dropped in real terms but none more so than doctors. When I become a consultant my pay will be HALF of what I would have been paid in 1999/2000 in real terms.

I got top A levels, I have a 6 year medical school degree, I have passed royal college post grad membership exams (paid for myself as all doctors do) and multiple other compulsory assessments. I’ve been a doctor for 5 years.

As of August at night I will be the most senior medical doctor overnight in the hospital. I will be the first called to lead cardiac arrests and other emergencies. Alongside my colleagues in ED and critical care I will be called to see the very sickest patients in the hospital.

For some reason my hourly rate is far below the advanced nurse practitioners that I work with who (whilst being fantastically skilled) do not have the training or level of responsibility that I have. I will earn less per hour than other professions that I supervise.

Physician associates who do not go through the rigours and demands of junior doctor rotational training and only have a 2 years masters and are not allowed to even prescribe paracetamol are paid more than many junior doctors.

We have made huge professional and personal sacrifices. We work longer hours than anyone else in the NHS (before overtime our “full time” contracted hours are usually 45-48 per week (unlike rest of nhs on 37.5/40).

We feel so undervalued and demoralised. With the cost of commuting to hospitals we get sent to at little notice, finding childcare to cover shifts, professional fees and paying for our own exams if you’re now two registrars in acute specialties you literally cannot afford children and a house.

I wish I’d been an ANP. Better money, less responsibility, more autonomy over where you work and consultants treat you better as you don’t keep rotating.

Im striking again in July. Because our pay and conditions are intolerable and I’m terrified that so many of my colleagues are leaving, I’m really scared that no one will stay and become a consultant in the UK. If I need surgery I want the best and the brightest operating on me, but they’re leaving for Aus/NZ/canada/pharmaceuticals/law.

@Medstudent12 I'm sorry you and your colleagues need to strike. You deserve so much better

Flowers
Gracebaker · 27/06/2023 23:01

Not in this area but as a hospital receiving team we end up with ALOT of inappropriate referrals from nurse led MIUs, essentially increasing our workload and decreasing efficiency

Olderandolder · 27/06/2023 22:54

We have been watching this slow motion car crash since 1948

The best health care system in the world in 1948 was turned over to command economy and Govt monopoly.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/06/2023 22:52

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 22:03

I'm certain your wish will be granted @TooBigForMyBoots . But I don't think they will do much better, frankly, although I hope I am wrong.

They will have a massive hill to climb. But we cannot begin to recover while the Tories are in power.

Ever taken a position where you had to call all your suppliers and clients to tell them that your incompetent, arrogant predecessor has gone? And hope that relationships and business can be rebuilt? That's what our next government will have to do.

First call will probably be to the IMF.

Gracebaker · 27/06/2023 22:44

ANPs and PAs have a role for sure. I don’t think anyone disputes that. It’s when the conversation turns to them being on an equal footing with doctors it becomes problematic. These health professionals are, and need to be, supervised - by doctors! Because they don’t have the depth or breadth of knowledge. Yes they may know a great deal about one area of healthcare E.g respiratory. But patients rarely fit into one box, they often have multiple issues and co morbidities, and knowledge of how these integrate can only come from medical training. ANPs and PAs may see ‘simple’ cases in GP or ED, but again problems can arise here, in our area a patient had seen an ANP in a GP practice repeatedly and was treated multiple times for a urine infection, when actually the patient had an endometrial cancer which was missed, because the ability to think broadly is not always there. So no, whilst ANPs and PAs may have a role, they are not equal to doctors, nor will they ever be. The government plans to increase doctor alternatives, and likely extend their scope and independence, which is honestly terrifying and will be a massive gamble. Unfortunately the public will be the Guinea pigs in this purely cost saving experiment, the politicians and the rich will be paying to see doctors privately.

nolongersurprised · 27/06/2023 22:25

Wishiwasatailor · 27/06/2023 19:48

they aren’t seeing junior docs either…. Except at night when you can see a non training house officer with minimal support no critical care outreach team in many private hospitals

I am in Australia with a hybrid public/private system. If health care in England follows a similar model the main difference will be private consultants working outside of the public system (although many do a mix of both).

And yes, the pay is better than public work, set up costs and practice costs notwithstanding. Some people pay so they can choose their doctor, others so they can see the same person every time. private care is a lot cheaper than in the UK though, because the government partially funds the private consultations, lab tests, X-rays ans the like

squillionth · 27/06/2023 22:23

Doctors teachers yep, under-appreciated basically. :(

Courgeon · 27/06/2023 22:19

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 21:43

I remain to be convinced that a change of government will change anything significant. It will be rearranging the deck chairs because IMO no government, including the one we have now, has (or ever will have) the capacity/funds/resources to fund the bottomless pit of health demand imposed by a population who cannot be bothered to take even the slightest modicum of responsibility for their health and that of their children.

Yep. Totally agree with this. Worked as a health. Professional in the NHS for 17 years before being poached by a private company. The general public abuses the NHS and takes very little responsibility for their own health. The reason I left the NHS wasn't pay it was due to being abused and attacked by the general public and expected to wave a magic wand over insoluble problems.

That's not to say the current government isn't an utter shit show and hasn't contributed to the current chaos but the British public are very entitled and embedded in the belief that the NHS is there to fix them. Whenever I treated patients from other countries they were aghast at the British attitude towards the NHS. There's bullying, micromanagement, incompetence and to be blunt not very bright people in senior positions who got there by nepotism running one of the biggest organisations in the country . And badly.

Caradonna · 27/06/2023 22:11

I was listening to a programme with a bit about asset management
https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/thinking-allowed/id261548752?i=1000616039890
These businesses run everything - such as the water company that pours sewage into rivers but gives large payments to their shareholders, or invest in rental properties again to make profits for their shareholders, or farms or harbours. Also these people are accountable to no one.
So much of the population’s bills are paid into the pockets of the (usually already wealthy) shareholders whilst standards of service aren’t maintained.
Also there is non Dom status where money is removed from the country to avoid tax.
I can’t help feeling that the money we expect to be used to run things eg trains, the NHS is being siphoned off. And no one including the Labour Party cares, whilst things become more and more run down.
Govs just seem to pander to the latest DM headline or Twitter spat instead of tackling issues.
There is no money for Doctors salaries - but why? Where do we start to fix this?

Thinking Allowed: High Finance on Apple Podcasts

‎Thinking Allowed: High Finance on Apple Podcasts

‎Show Thinking Allowed, Ep High Finance - 7 Jun 2023

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/thinking-allowed/id261548752?i=1000616039890

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 22:03

I'm certain your wish will be granted @TooBigForMyBoots . But I don't think they will do much better, frankly, although I hope I am wrong.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/06/2023 21:57

I remain to be convinced that a change of government will change anything significant.

The most significant change will be that whoever comes next are not the reckless, chaotic, corrupt, unstable Tory Party who have wrecked our economy and made us uninvestable.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 21:46

Sorry, I should probably moderate my statement above to say that there is a significant proportion (hopefully a minority) of the population who ignore all and any health advice.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 21:43

I remain to be convinced that a change of government will change anything significant. It will be rearranging the deck chairs because IMO no government, including the one we have now, has (or ever will have) the capacity/funds/resources to fund the bottomless pit of health demand imposed by a population who cannot be bothered to take even the slightest modicum of responsibility for their health and that of their children.

Dente · 27/06/2023 21:34

Yup! I’m one of those looking to leave! It’s not just the money, it’s the watering down of the profession, lack of training, lack of autonomy over rota/location, workload, toxicity, management, scope creep and the fact that i constantly feel like I am disappointing patients due to the above. I really can’t take any more feel like I’m trudging through mud. Patients are getting annoyed and taking it out of healthcare professionals despite the fact it’s out of my hands.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 27/06/2023 21:23

We are so screwed. I recently had an emergency admission to hospital; spent 50 hours in a corridor on a reclining chair (!!) without seeing a doctor. I was essentially in a queue to see a doctor, in a corridor for over two days. There just weren't enough doctors (or other medical staff) for all of patients.

My grandfather is currently in hospital- one more than 50 miles from where he (and we) live as there was no space in our local one- and has been since last Wednesday. We haven't yet had a phone call from the doctor taking care of her and twice a day when we phone we are told that they will phone to update us as soon as possible, but the doctor has three times as many patients than he should have. When my parents went down there last Thursday they stayed for over 36 hours and even in person never managed to consult with his doctor. They didn't even see any evidence that he has a doctor.

All we can do is vote in a Labour government. And remember all of this and not vote the Tories in ever again- or at least until they prove they won't do this again, in a decent manifesto that puts people first.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 21:16

sleepsforwimps1 · 27/06/2023 20:33

Reading this thread I think I will jump ship now! Been considering it a while, been out of the NHS a couple of years having children but been a qualified nurse 15 years. When I first started staffing levels where good, paper work half of what it is now, I had time to do a proper job.... now it's diabolical! We all know the Tory plan is to get rid but the private sector don't pay enough, and if medical cover on current wage is the only option I think there will be a mass jumping of ship for over seas..... there will be nothing left of this country in a couple of years

Plenty of opportunities outside of the NHS if you want to continue with nursing, or loads of transferable skills. Someone I used to work closely with does school imms now (adult trained nurse, no extra qualification needed) and works school hours (with a bit of work to do at home which is paid as admin hours) and term time only, for example.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/06/2023 21:15

I think, personally, that the significant error (and it's a whole societal failure IMO) is the title of the National Health Service. It should be called the Illness Service, and tasked to deal with illnesses. The onus should be on the population to take care of their health and only turn to it as a service for elderly, sick, and diseased people with serious conditions. Help with acute care, plus maternity, childbirth and acute ill health including a pandemic of a previously unknown source, and accidental injury. And much more emphasis on public health, including the message that your health is your responsibility.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 21:13

Thomasina79 · 27/06/2023 20:41

Those older generational people you are all so scathing about have paid taxes and NI contributions all their working lives. This is paying for their care now. Yes there are so called bed blockers, but this is because there is no intermediate care between leaving hospital and going home. They are fit to leave, but where to?

This is the question. Carers are so criminally underpaid and care homes being made into businesses was just so misguided that hospitals are left to deal with it. Even more investment won't provide much of an answer to be honest.

Didiplanthis · 27/06/2023 21:05

I can promise you its not about the money for many.. I have recently left medicine after 25 years. And am now working in a non medical minimum wage job... I never ever want to step foot in a medical job again..not for ANY money... the job has become impossible to do how you know it could, and should, be done as the system is utterly overwhelmed and I no longer felt I could safely practice in it. Our PA was great but I had to supervise her (fully qualified) and check all her consults and prescriptions as well as doing my own job which had no finite limit to the amount of work that could be added to.my list 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread