Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Lucy7890 · 30/06/2023 19:21

@Chocolateship 'By cutting the medical degree by a year it will fall below the hours of study required by other countries for doctors, meaning UK trained doctors will no longer be able to work abroad'

A good way to make sure they will not emigrate....

SunnyEgg · 30/06/2023 19:19

Chocolateship · 30/06/2023 19:18

The long term plan is ridiculous. By cutting the medical degree by a year it will fall below the hours of study required by other countries for doctors, meaning UK trained doctors will no longer be able to work abroad. The appetite for forcing people to stay in the NHS for x years when they have to pay for the degree themselves is also insulting but both will no doubt happen and effectively trap people here whilst we still poach staff from abroad quite happily. None of the actual issues have been addressed, in fact they've been made worse as its laid out in black and white the fact that doctors are to be replaced really by PAs, AAs and whatever else. No plans to address the training bottlenecks but magically there's going to be scope to train these people- wtf.

The NHS came up with it.

Chocolateship · 30/06/2023 19:18

The long term plan is ridiculous. By cutting the medical degree by a year it will fall below the hours of study required by other countries for doctors, meaning UK trained doctors will no longer be able to work abroad. The appetite for forcing people to stay in the NHS for x years when they have to pay for the degree themselves is also insulting but both will no doubt happen and effectively trap people here whilst we still poach staff from abroad quite happily. None of the actual issues have been addressed, in fact they've been made worse as its laid out in black and white the fact that doctors are to be replaced really by PAs, AAs and whatever else. No plans to address the training bottlenecks but magically there's going to be scope to train these people- wtf.

Lucy7890 · 30/06/2023 19:14

I've heard a discussion today - 'If you're an NHS worker, what solution do you have for staffing crisis?' I wanted to email 'Run, and don't look back'. There is no easy solution and the public is in massive denial, made worse by the "our NHS' rhetiric paddled by clueless politicians who will never admit it's not solvable in the way that would win them the next election.

mumsneedwine · 30/06/2023 19:08

After the very funny document produced today many medical students are also looking into emigrating. Not sure who is going to train all these new people as there is not enough capacity to train what we have now. Many students are turned away as too many of them on one ward, or no one available to teach them.
And I'd love to know what 20% of the medical degree is being cut out - compassion and knowledge maybe.
The utter stupidity of this plan just seems incredible.
More students does not mean more, or well trained, staff.

MavisMcMinty · 30/06/2023 19:03

Massexodus · 30/06/2023 16:49

DP and I were both NHS GPs.
We've just emigrated.
Grateful patients, no no-win-no-fee lawyers and every Tom dick and Harry trying to sue at any opportunity, housing paid for, Private school fees partly paid, business class flights, 40 hour weeks, 10 weeks annual leave, £120K+ TAKE HOME pay.
This is for foreign government jobs in a place where healthcare is free at the point of need.
There are HUNDREDS of British trained GPs here and more arriving every month.
The UK has run on poaching foreign workers for a long time. Now it's getting a taste of its own medicine.
My heart breaks for my colleagues back home but I am so grateful DP and I got out when we did. It's no longer the vocation we signed up for. It feels more like a battlefield, constantly having to be defensive, patients and commissioners demanding more and more with no extra time or money given.
GPs are massively dehumanised in the UK. I don't think I'll ever forget being doubled over in pain with a sudden emergency condition whilst seeing a patient, who then shouted at me (whilst I'm bent over in pain) for not being able to deal with a second ridiculously minor problem of dry skin as I had to leave to go to hospital! UK Healthcare is heading for a shock!

This is so sad for the UK, but I’m sure also for you. Even in 2016 when I retired from nursing, some of our registrar-level doctors were applying to NZ, and moving out there for the quality of life. Such a waste, such a loss. Seems we can’t have nice things if we don’t look after them.

Massexodus · 30/06/2023 16:49

DP and I were both NHS GPs.
We've just emigrated.
Grateful patients, no no-win-no-fee lawyers and every Tom dick and Harry trying to sue at any opportunity, housing paid for, Private school fees partly paid, business class flights, 40 hour weeks, 10 weeks annual leave, £120K+ TAKE HOME pay.
This is for foreign government jobs in a place where healthcare is free at the point of need.
There are HUNDREDS of British trained GPs here and more arriving every month.
The UK has run on poaching foreign workers for a long time. Now it's getting a taste of its own medicine.
My heart breaks for my colleagues back home but I am so grateful DP and I got out when we did. It's no longer the vocation we signed up for. It feels more like a battlefield, constantly having to be defensive, patients and commissioners demanding more and more with no extra time or money given.
GPs are massively dehumanised in the UK. I don't think I'll ever forget being doubled over in pain with a sudden emergency condition whilst seeing a patient, who then shouted at me (whilst I'm bent over in pain) for not being able to deal with a second ridiculously minor problem of dry skin as I had to leave to go to hospital! UK Healthcare is heading for a shock!

BCCoach · 30/06/2023 15:01

Endlesssummer2022 · 30/06/2023 08:50

Because of people like this. They blame everything on foreigners whilst continually voting for parties with a poor track record in governance. The countries at the top of the pile are those with governments who can deliver strong long term strategies, not corrupt short termists who give all of the nations money to their favoured friends.

However, people like dotjones won’t be happy until we become destitute. They are easily fooled and distracted by the looters who tell them to focus on dinghy people. As long as one Albanian is stopped from coming over on a dinghy who cares if we starve and our infrastructure crumbles around us?

She also cannot explain what is so "inward looking" about Denmark, Norway and Switzerland. Doubt she's set foot in any of them.

Endlesssummer2022 · 30/06/2023 08:50

Dotjones · 27/06/2023 12:10

Yes we're screwed. We're watching because we're powerless to do anything about it and above all can't afford to do anything about it. Whatever party is in power after the next election, things will be worse than they are now. Our society is in a terminal decline. I think the reason for this is that we have moved away from the values that allowed us to be in a dominant position. We used to be a society that put our own interests above those of outsiders. That's no longer the case, many would say that's a good thing, but you can't be in the top few "best" countries to live in without screwing over those worse off than you.

Google tells me the top three countries for healthcare are Denmark, Norway and Switzerland. All inward looking countries. The Swiss are famed for their neutrality - but that has always been based on self-interest. Better not to fight the Germans and hoard their gold.

Because of people like this. They blame everything on foreigners whilst continually voting for parties with a poor track record in governance. The countries at the top of the pile are those with governments who can deliver strong long term strategies, not corrupt short termists who give all of the nations money to their favoured friends.

However, people like dotjones won’t be happy until we become destitute. They are easily fooled and distracted by the looters who tell them to focus on dinghy people. As long as one Albanian is stopped from coming over on a dinghy who cares if we starve and our infrastructure crumbles around us?

Lucy7890 · 30/06/2023 08:24

I've just left.

Kazzyhoward · 30/06/2023 08:10

malificent7 · 30/06/2023 07:04

Nhs worker here. Our health isn't 100% our responsibility though. Genetics is the main player I rekon. Obviously don't drink, smoke or get obese but it's not that simple...what about aging?

The NHS wouldn't be so stretched if people did more to look after themselves, leaving them with more time/resources to treat those with genetic issues/old age health issues, etc.

Reducing the burden on the NHS by being healthier, fitter, less obese, not smoking/drinking/drug taking, etc., would make a massive difference.

Walkden · 30/06/2023 07:22

"I think a large part of this is due to Brexit. We aren't recruiting from the EU, and those already here from the EU have often left due to feeling unwelcome. Who could blame them?"

Brexit is not the sole reason as austerity is a large factor but Brexit has accelerated the decline.

It has stunted if not reversed economic growth, added extra inflationary pressure, exacerbated demographic changes, and the government is telling public sector it can't afford even below inflation pay "rises" despite the highest tax burden in decades.....

We are a poorer country with less prospects so now are having medical staff poached from us when it used to be the other way around.....

malificent7 · 30/06/2023 07:04

Nhs worker here. Our health isn't 100% our responsibility though. Genetics is the main player I rekon. Obviously don't drink, smoke or get obese but it's not that simple...what about aging?

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 30/06/2023 06:37

Other gems from the just published NHS long term workforce plan;

  • Doubling medical school training places to 15,000 by 2031, with new schools and more places in areas with the greatest shortages;
  • Increasing GP training places by half to 6,000 by 2031;
  • Almost doubling the number of adult nurse training places, with 24,000 more nurse and midwife training places a year by 2031;
  • Allowing staff to 'earn while they learn', with apprenticeships that lead to a full degree but more-on-the-job training;
  • Greater reliance on 'associate' roles that can help with less demanding tasks, freeing up senior colleagues for complex cases;
  • Expanding training for clinical psychology and child and adolescent psychotherapy, with places rising by more than a quarter to 1,300 by 2031;
  • A renewed focus on retention with better opportunities for career development, improved flexible working and pension reforms to keep 130,000 staff working in the NHS for longer.

id imagine 99% of this is unachievable rubbish. I can promise you that midwifery training places can’t be increased. Nationwide there’s already too many students, they’re not getting enough time on labour wards and a significant proportion aren’t achieving the 40 births they should get to qualify. Hospitals are currently looking at telling universities they need to reduce their numbers! The NHS can’t knit up pregnant women for the students to practice on and with the falling normal birth rate I can’t see what they can do.

Unless the nmc do what they’ve done for nursing and say x amount of practice hours can be done in simulation rather than the hospital. Which would be insane. We already have newly qualified midwives who feel not confident and end up leaving soon after qualifying as they’re not prepared for qualification. So I don’t think playing around at delivering babies on mannequins will help.

sorry, I know this thread was really about doctors but I think it’s just indicative of the govts push for numbers at any cost. As long as there’s a good headline saying how they’re going to solve the staffing crisis they don’t actually care firstly about whether it will actually happen or not and secondly if it can happen is it a good idea!

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 30/06/2023 06:29

Well, just read that medical degree length is going to be cut to 4 years. It’s a bloody joke. Just devalues medicine and god knows how it will all be crammed into 4 years. Healthcare is getting more complex not less!

Shortkiwi · 29/06/2023 22:07

I’ve just checked my hourly rate on my payslip - band 5 nurse - £17.68 ph, against my DDs F2 doctor’s pay - £16 per hour. She has reached breaking point this week - walked out/gone off sick, after nearly 2 years of excellent work and being one of the most resilient people I know. How has it happened that junior doctors are so poorly paid? BMA - what have they let happen - why??

MavisMcMinty · 29/06/2023 00:10

TrixieFatell · 28/06/2023 23:44

It breaks my heart. All I have done today is apologize time and time again for the amount of time people are having to wait, chasing down the two Dr's we have to cover a whole maternity unit to make plans and review those needing reviews. I've seen people walk out and then I've had to write defensively in my notes to make sure they know I asked the woman to stay and be seen but she couldn't wait another couple of hours because she had to get home to her other children. I've had to deal with women stressed and anxious because they never see the same community midwife and they have ptsd from their last birth that they never managed to get counselling for because the waiting lists are so long. I have only been in the NHS 12 years but the decline has been steady, and then totally escalated post covid

It’s just intolerable, for staff and for patients. What a state we’re in, as a country. A global laughing stock, yet Tory supporters are still bleating on about Covid being the sole cause of all our problems. Oh, and Ukraine. Nothing to do with their political choices, not at all, dearie me no.

Yellowdays · 28/06/2023 23:46

Wait and see what the government answer is-lots more untrained staff doing doctors jobs, plus private for those who can pay. They are utter shits.

TrixieFatell · 28/06/2023 23:44

MavisMcMinty · 28/06/2023 07:05

I could weep when I see how the Conservative government have wrecked the NHS after all the improvements (PFI dependence excluded, obviously) of the 1997-2010 Labour government. Of my 35 years as an NHS nurse, those 13 years were the very best of my career. Services improved and expanded, and both patient and staff satisfaction was high. The improvements in cancer care and cardiac care were astonishing.

The Tories have been opposed to the NHS since its inception, and knowing they haven’t a chance at winning the next election are apparently trying to leave the biggest possible shitshow for the next government to have to deal with.

It breaks my heart. All I have done today is apologize time and time again for the amount of time people are having to wait, chasing down the two Dr's we have to cover a whole maternity unit to make plans and review those needing reviews. I've seen people walk out and then I've had to write defensively in my notes to make sure they know I asked the woman to stay and be seen but she couldn't wait another couple of hours because she had to get home to her other children. I've had to deal with women stressed and anxious because they never see the same community midwife and they have ptsd from their last birth that they never managed to get counselling for because the waiting lists are so long. I have only been in the NHS 12 years but the decline has been steady, and then totally escalated post covid

noworklifebalance · 28/06/2023 23:22

Olderandolder · 28/06/2023 21:35

Shockingly few people died in 2020 and 2021 when HMG shut off half the NHS.

Impact on death rate is not necessarily immediate.
Delayed diagnosis of cancer with reduced life expectancy is the big headline - the impact of which may be a year or more down the line.

SparklyShoesandTutus · 28/06/2023 21:41

It's not going to take 5 years!!

Using the car crash analogy the question is, will the air bags deploy? If so we may have some hope of rebuilding something from the wreckage. If not those worried about the cost of living now will find things an awful lot harder when they have to fund any health needs on top of everything else. Those that moan about the cost of vet bills will have their minds blown at the cost of healthcare.

Olderandolder · 28/06/2023 21:35

mumsneedwine · 28/06/2023 20:06

The trouble with the mass exodus from the NHS is that people die. Not enough staff so care is unsafe.
But hey, we are about to magically find £14 billion to bail out a private company that has paid dividends to their mates of £54 billion.

Shockingly few people died in 2020 and 2021 when HMG shut off half the NHS.

Olderandolder · 28/06/2023 21:33

startingagain13 · 28/06/2023 09:17

I have a conditional offer for med school and I must admit I feel quite nervous reading this. I am a psychologist considering medicine as I've always wanted to be a GP and think a mental health background would be useful in today's society. I feel a bit of an outlier in some respects reading this thread.

Safe job.
Govt floor under wages.
No clients.
Can be a high earner anywhere in the country, not just London.
Fantastic pension. Not as good as it was but way better then private sector.
Doctors always eat.

mumsneedwine · 28/06/2023 20:06

The trouble with the mass exodus from the NHS is that people die. Not enough staff so care is unsafe.
But hey, we are about to magically find £14 billion to bail out a private company that has paid dividends to their mates of £54 billion.

BelleMarionette · 28/06/2023 19:24

OMG12 · 28/06/2023 16:41

There’s a mass exodus from many professions- the rise in cost of living and the crap work life balance highlighted through covid has led people to realise these types of jobs just aren’t worth the stress!

I think a large part of this is due to Brexit. We aren't recruiting from the EU, and those already here from the EU have often left due to feeling unwelcome. Who could blame them?