Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:44

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:42

The training for PAs etc must improve. Doctors can't endlessly complain they are overworked and then reject help that is offered.

This is the point, they're not being utilised for the purpose the role was created for because they complain that's boring. Which is ridiculous.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:42

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:35

@Chocolateship As long as the training is solid then why shouldn't PAs branch out? Are they not allowed to build their careers too? I think juniors should specialise earlier.

I think doctors have enjoyed the prestige of the career for a long time - they will have been top in their school, top a uni, move into a prestigious career and now hate the idea of some of that prestige being taken away.

Because it's outside their scope of practice. Because they aren't regualted. Because they aren't subject to the same level of post qualification training, examinations and whatever else that doctors are. Because the role was meant to serve a particular purpose (of which the short training reflects). Because they can't prescribe or order scans. Because their training isn't in depth enough for them to have the appropriate knowledge and deeper understanding of some of the roles some have slipped into. Because they're often favoured because they don't rotate for example and so are more worth investing in by a ward- but that's not the fault of doctors that they aren't.

If they want the same opportunity as doctors then they should complete a medical degree. Let's be real here, would you rather a PA or a qualified and experienced GP or other doctor diagnose you?

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:42

The training for PAs etc must improve. Doctors can't endlessly complain they are overworked and then reject help that is offered.

HostessTrolley · 27/06/2023 13:40

I'm told by my Dd (5th year med student) that the training of med students and junior doctors is being impacted by PAs - that they push in front to do stuff so the med students and junior doctors are getting to the point of being qualified without opportunities to develop clinical skills that they should be competent at.

TokyoStories · 27/06/2023 13:40

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:38

The "training" is far from solid. It's a total farce.

Doctors have to be the brightest students for good reason: practicing medicine well is bloody hard work. The course is as long as it is for good reason, too.

Should the hospital porters be given prescribing rights too? After all, they have the right to progress their careers and doctors are elitist for objecting.

😂

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:38

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:35

@Chocolateship As long as the training is solid then why shouldn't PAs branch out? Are they not allowed to build their careers too? I think juniors should specialise earlier.

I think doctors have enjoyed the prestige of the career for a long time - they will have been top in their school, top a uni, move into a prestigious career and now hate the idea of some of that prestige being taken away.

The "training" is far from solid. It's a total farce.

Doctors have to be the brightest students for good reason: practicing medicine well is bloody hard work. The course is as long as it is for good reason, too.

Should the hospital porters be given prescribing rights too? After all, they have the right to progress their careers and doctors are elitist for objecting.

Coldcoldheartdualipa · 27/06/2023 13:37

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/06/2023 13:08

Probably, unless there’s a change of Government next year.

Oh yes because Labour have a farm full of fully qualified medics just champing at the bit to get out there and practice 🤔

Afishcalledwand · 27/06/2023 13:37

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 13:32

It’s perfectly possible to have an excellent NHS and fairly paid well motivated Doctors. Why do you assume that isn’t possible? It’s all about political choices, and the public need to accept that healthcare staff aren’t working for a charity!
When my dh became a consultant in 2004, the NHS was doing well, there had been a big investment from the Government of the time, Dh felt well paid, he was able to keep on top of his workload, and was proud of what he was achieving. Waiting lists were at an all time low, he was instrumental in the rolling out of the National Bowel Cancer Screening Programme.
Then in 2010 came a new Government and austerity, very quickly the effects began to be felt, and now here we are……
Oh and he hates his job now, he’s totally burnt out, and despairs at what has become of the NHS that he used to love.

Because the percentage of the national budget that the NHS takes rises exponentially every year. It’s wholly unsustainable. Did you know that when the NHS was founded the budgets forecast that the cost of the NHS would fall over time as the populace got healthier? NHS is getting more expensive every year. The last thing this country can afford is a 35% pay rise for junior doctors.

TokyoStories · 27/06/2023 13:37

LOLing at the level of ignorance and misinformation around PAs and ANPs on this thread.

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:35

@Chocolateship As long as the training is solid then why shouldn't PAs branch out? Are they not allowed to build their careers too? I think juniors should specialise earlier.

I think doctors have enjoyed the prestige of the career for a long time - they will have been top in their school, top a uni, move into a prestigious career and now hate the idea of some of that prestige being taken away.

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:33

@Afishcalledwand well we were paid 35% more in 2008. I’m a junior doctor (new registrar) and it’s only in the past 20 years that our pay has massively dropped.

Everyone’s pay has dropped in real terms but none more so than doctors. When I become a consultant my pay will be HALF of what I would have been paid in 1999/2000 in real terms.

I got top A levels, I have a 6 year medical school degree, I have passed royal college post grad membership exams (paid for myself as all doctors do) and multiple other compulsory assessments. I’ve been a doctor for 5 years.

As of August at night I will be the most senior medical doctor overnight in the hospital. I will be the first called to lead cardiac arrests and other emergencies. Alongside my colleagues in ED and critical care I will be called to see the very sickest patients in the hospital.

For some reason my hourly rate is far below the advanced nurse practitioners that I work with who (whilst being fantastically skilled) do not have the training or level of responsibility that I have. I will earn less per hour than other professions that I supervise.

Physician associates who do not go through the rigours and demands of junior doctor rotational training and only have a 2 years masters and are not allowed to even prescribe paracetamol are paid more than many junior doctors.

We have made huge professional and personal sacrifices. We work longer hours than anyone else in the NHS (before overtime our “full time” contracted hours are usually 45-48 per week (unlike rest of nhs on 37.5/40).

We feel so undervalued and demoralised. With the cost of commuting to hospitals we get sent to at little notice, finding childcare to cover shifts, professional fees and paying for our own exams if you’re now two registrars in acute specialties you literally cannot afford children and a house.

I wish I’d been an ANP. Better money, less responsibility, more autonomy over where you work and consultants treat you better as you don’t keep rotating.

Im striking again in July. Because our pay and conditions are intolerable and I’m terrified that so many of my colleagues are leaving, I’m really scared that no one will stay and become a consultant in the UK. If I need surgery I want the best and the brightest operating on me, but they’re leaving for Aus/NZ/canada/pharmaceuticals/law.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:33

huntingcunting · 27/06/2023 13:30

What exactly can physicians associates do? They can't prescribe and they can't order x-rays. I live abroad now so I've missed the introduction of them - heard them talked about but what is the actual point of them?
Is it like 20 years ago when teaching assistants were being made to teach whole class lessons (planned by teachers) basically to save money on salaries and yet so many of the TAs I worked with felt really uncomfortable with the whole thing because whole class teaching was not what they signed up for and not what they had trained for and they were being taken away from the very valuable roles they originally had.

They can't do anything.

They were originally called Physician Assistants. The point of them was to do cannulas, take blood, scribe on the ward round and write discharge summaries so that junior doctors could actually attend clinics, gain theatre experience, receive training from consultants and be trained to perform procedures essential to their role (chest drains, LPs etc).

But PAs have pushed to diagnose and assess patients like doctors do. Yet they can't prescribe or order scans. They are trained to examine patients and read test results but only have 2 years of education and their courses don't require significant academic achievement.

Essentially you've got pseudo-doctors practicing medicine without a license, and only doing half the job as well.

(For over £10k more a year).

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:33

Regarding housing they're forced to move around if they want a job, military are too but they get cheap digs, why not JDs whilst they're forced to rotate? A JD also has huge responsibility and is a qualified doctor from the day they start F1, I don't see why well they progress and eventually get more is a decent reason to not pay them fairly.

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 13:32

Afishcalledwand · 27/06/2023 13:21

We either have a free at the point of use NHS and doctors earn what they earn now, or we have an NHS partly funded elsewhere (perhaps via employers contributions such as in Germany) and doctors get the remuneration they want.

Currently doctors proclaim to love the ethos of the NHS but piss off aboard because they don’t like the associated pay. Seems a bit hypocritical to me, and the UK public are suffering.

Let’s learn from systems other counties use, get other funding streams on board and get a better NHS.

It’s perfectly possible to have an excellent NHS and fairly paid well motivated Doctors. Why do you assume that isn’t possible? It’s all about political choices, and the public need to accept that healthcare staff aren’t working for a charity!
When my dh became a consultant in 2004, the NHS was doing well, there had been a big investment from the Government of the time, Dh felt well paid, he was able to keep on top of his workload, and was proud of what he was achieving. Waiting lists were at an all time low, he was instrumental in the rolling out of the National Bowel Cancer Screening Programme.
Then in 2010 came a new Government and austerity, very quickly the effects began to be felt, and now here we are……
Oh and he hates his job now, he’s totally burnt out, and despairs at what has become of the NHS that he used to love.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:31

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:26

The pay is not rubbish. It's low at the start but there's good career progression. Why wouldn't they be paying for housing? We all do.

Also diversifying the medical field with different career routes is a good idea. Shorter career paths to get people into the workforce and specialising earlier in their career - no rotating round specialties they've no interest in.

Well why can't junior doctors opt out of rotating then? Most hate it and find it adversely affects their lives yet they're forced to. Why can't they specialise sooner? Filling these gaps with less knowledgeable and less qualified people is dangerous and reckless. PAs for example were introduced to support doctors, now they've started to branch out into all sorts of areas.

nameschangg · 27/06/2023 13:30

The pay is not rubbish. It's low at the start but there's good career progression. Why wouldn't they be paying for housing? We all do.

pay is rubbish for many people particularly younger ones because of wage stagnation. 35k in the early 00s is equivalent to 63k now...

Of course they should pay for housing but again housing takes up a much higher % of a younger persons income then it used too.

My point was of course talented people will look abroad if they can get a better deal.

huntingcunting · 27/06/2023 13:30

What exactly can physicians associates do? They can't prescribe and they can't order x-rays. I live abroad now so I've missed the introduction of them - heard them talked about but what is the actual point of them?
Is it like 20 years ago when teaching assistants were being made to teach whole class lessons (planned by teachers) basically to save money on salaries and yet so many of the TAs I worked with felt really uncomfortable with the whole thing because whole class teaching was not what they signed up for and not what they had trained for and they were being taken away from the very valuable roles they originally had.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:29

You are not wrong, all public services are crumbling to be honest, they have been held up by goodwill for a fair few years but post covid that's (rightfully) crumbling. The government's plan, instead of addressing retaining doctors, is to just introduce lesser qualified and lesser experienced 'associates' and hope the public doesn't notice that patient care is being compromised. They're also not listening to doctors when they say it's not just money but things like a lack of training places, anaesthetics for example is highly oversubscribed so many doctors don't get to enter the programme; the government's plan to address a shortage of anaesthetists? Introduce a lesser role instead of investing in doctors. Outrageous and downright dangerous. More will leave, be interesting to see the results of the consultant strike which are due this week.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:28

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:26

The pay is not rubbish. It's low at the start but there's good career progression. Why wouldn't they be paying for housing? We all do.

Also diversifying the medical field with different career routes is a good idea. Shorter career paths to get people into the workforce and specialising earlier in their career - no rotating round specialties they've no interest in.

There's money to pay PAs £40k as new grads but mysteriously doctors aren't worth that amount.

nameschangg · 27/06/2023 13:26

That’s right blame the people who have paid tax all their lives for the screw up now happening!
l

Stating that they are issues with our changing demographics doesn't mean older people haven't paid tax.

Honestly I despair at the stupidity.

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:26

nameschangg · 27/06/2023 12:14

It's not just pay though there's a host of younger people who are having to take on huge student debt. they then get a good job but the pay is rubbish & tax is high & they still spending most of that income on housing. What's the point?

The pay is not rubbish. It's low at the start but there's good career progression. Why wouldn't they be paying for housing? We all do.

Also diversifying the medical field with different career routes is a good idea. Shorter career paths to get people into the workforce and specialising earlier in their career - no rotating round specialties they've no interest in.

SamanthaCaine · 27/06/2023 13:25

kelsaycobbles · 27/06/2023 12:21

So out population is ageing faster than Europe as a whole ?!?

Yes that's right. I age by at least 3 years every time I try to book an appointment to see my Dr.

mrsneate · 27/06/2023 13:24

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 12:56

Have you heard the latest terrifying proposal from this idiot Government? Apprentice Doctors! They don’t go to medical school they just do an apprenticeship instead! So at 18 fresh out of your A levels, just follow one of the senior doctors around and start practicing, what could possibly go wrong?! 🤦‍♀️

Christ 🤦🏼‍♀️ some of the doctors we get through now are half clueless and terrifying to work with!

Afishcalledwand · 27/06/2023 13:21

We either have a free at the point of use NHS and doctors earn what they earn now, or we have an NHS partly funded elsewhere (perhaps via employers contributions such as in Germany) and doctors get the remuneration they want.

Currently doctors proclaim to love the ethos of the NHS but piss off aboard because they don’t like the associated pay. Seems a bit hypocritical to me, and the UK public are suffering.

Let’s learn from systems other counties use, get other funding streams on board and get a better NHS.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 27/06/2023 13:19

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 13:16

And in the same breath as fantasising about “apprenticeships” they now announce they will increase medical school places in the new “workforce plan”. But will there be any senior Doctors to supervise them? It all seems very confused and panicky to me. Too bloody little too late.

Don’t worry the physician associates can look after them.

years ago as a band 6 midwife I used to teach the med students weekly when on their obs and gynae rotation. They were meant to have clinical teaching from a consultant but they were too busy so they subcontracted it to me. And paid me! Can only imagine it’s worse now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread