Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All the doctors I know are leaving. Are we going to be screwed for healthcare in 5 years time ?

334 replies

Gigihadr · 27/06/2023 12:01

Our NHS now has some of the worst health outcomes out of 19 wealthy nations compared in an international study.
But in 2010 the NHS regularly ranked 1st or 2nd in most international studies.

The UK is under-doctored, we have a 3rd fewer doctors per 1000 people than Germany or Spain

Our government response to the doctors we have left has been to erode working conditions and pay, ensure they have record levels of inflation and rocketing student debt

They are moving to better paid, better resourced systems/employers (they are a competitive international commodity) and I can’t blame them for that.

AIBU to think we are utterly screwed? why are we just sitting back and watching this slow motion car crash ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
SwayingInTime · 27/06/2023 14:17

We don’t really have PAs in maternity but I always assumed that the NHS like them as a concept because they can’t leave as not internationally recognised? Really short sighted though if so.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 14:12

WetBandits · 27/06/2023 14:09

Lots of ANP bashing on this thread and comparing them to PAs…they are totally and utterly different roles.

ANPs are not being used to ‘replace’ doctors either, they are upskilled and highly trained nurses. I’ll be doing my ANP course in a year or so and it’s not so I can pretend to be a doctor (if I had wanted to be a doctor, I would have applied to medical school!)

Modern nursing and its career development opportunities offers so much more than just playing handmaiden to a doctor, which is what a lot of people seem to think nurses should be limited to.

I’ve never worked with a PA that I’ve thought highly of, though. We had one on a ward I worked on and nobody knew quite what his job role was including him as he couldn’t (or wouldn’t) do anything he was asked to do.

Can you define what an "upskilled nurse" is and what their role is?

Tyrionapproach · 27/06/2023 14:12

Yes. My parents grew up during World War Two - pre NHS. We're going back there. I'd start researching medicinal plants and folk medicine if I were you. Unless, of course, you're going to be in a position to afford insurance premiums for those shiny new health companies that are about to make our MPs even wealthier.

WetBandits · 27/06/2023 14:09

Lots of ANP bashing on this thread and comparing them to PAs…they are totally and utterly different roles.

ANPs are not being used to ‘replace’ doctors either, they are upskilled and highly trained nurses. I’ll be doing my ANP course in a year or so and it’s not so I can pretend to be a doctor (if I had wanted to be a doctor, I would have applied to medical school!)

Modern nursing and its career development opportunities offers so much more than just playing handmaiden to a doctor, which is what a lot of people seem to think nurses should be limited to.

I’ve never worked with a PA that I’ve thought highly of, though. We had one on a ward I worked on and nobody knew quite what his job role was including him as he couldn’t (or wouldn’t) do anything he was asked to do.

huntingcunting · 27/06/2023 14:06

TokyoStories · 27/06/2023 13:37

LOLing at the level of ignorance and misinformation around PAs and ANPs on this thread.

So instead of loling and posting 😂when quoting someone's post, why don't you tell us something about PAs and ANPs?
I've asked about PAs because I now live in another country and don't know what their role is.
Totally unhelpful to LOL at people without contributing.

givemushypeasachance · 27/06/2023 14:04

I find physician associates to be a bizarre concept. And legally, they don't have the same standing as a doctor - they should always be "supervised" by a consultant or GP. So why would any doctor want to be stuck supervising/babysitting all decisions made by a PA, knowing that if the PA does something wrong it's the consultant/GP who will get it in the neck as a negligence claim against them. Doctors accept that they are responsible for supervising and training up their next generation of medical students and junior doctors, but that is for the wider purpose of ensuring there will be more well-trained professionals in the future. Supervising a PA, paid much more than a junior doctor, seems a thankless task.

Caradonna · 27/06/2023 14:02

Our population has risen by 5 million since 2010 that’s an 8% increase.
has everything else increased by 8% - doctors, train service, schools etcetc

no the opposite

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:59

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:42

The training for PAs etc must improve. Doctors can't endlessly complain they are overworked and then reject help that is offered.

PAs say basic ward work (discharge letters, cannulas etc) is boring. The junior doctor rotates every 4 month and has no say on where they work. Consultant does not care about junior doctor as they’ll get a new one in a few months but wants to retain the PA.

PA gets to do procedures with consultant and go to clinic. Junior doctor is on call at 3am on a Sunday looking after sick patient but can’t do that chest drain because they’ve not been taught as the consultant has trained the PA (who works 9-5) to do it instead. PA can be trained in niche area but does not have depth and breadth of knowledge to cope with complications or patients with multiple co-morbidities.

PA wants to be equivalent to reg on the ward but because they’ve not done exams and out of hours shifts etc when a patient acutely deteriorates on the ward they cannot manage it without help from the doctor.

We’re becoming woefully undertrained registrars because associate professions are taking training opportunities and they are able to do this as permanent staff. I’ll be rotating until I’m 40.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:56

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:54

I know, hence my posts...

Sorry, was agreeing with you, but also think we ought to stop qualifying criticism of PAs with "but they're intelligent/competent/I know a nice one" etc. to soften the blow.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:55

Admittedly realised my post should say doesn't mean it ISNT damaging.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:55

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:51

@hopeishere I’m a doctor and wary of PAs. Particularly the ODPs who do a two year cause to be anaesthetic associates. Anaesthetists are known for being intelligent, skilled and having some of the hardest post grad exams of all specialties. When things go wrong in anaesthetics it’s life or death, in minutes, they command a lot of respect from other specialties. If I need an anaesthetic I want a doctor doing it, I’ve worked with other professions/associates. They’re great, but they’re not a doctor and many are working outside their scope currently.

Yes, it's funny how anaesthetic trainees have to pass such rigorous exams with extensive knowledge of physics and chemistry required, yet an ODP can be let loose with intubation and independently manage someone under anaesthesia without ever having to sit a proper medical exam.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:54

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:51

It doesn't actually matter how intelligent a PA is.

There are many highly intelligent people with PhDs in specialist areas. That doesn't mean they should waltz into A&E after watching a view PowerPoint presentations and start managing sick patients.

You need a medical degree to practice medicine. End of story.

I know, hence my posts...

Pearlsaminga · 27/06/2023 13:53

nameschangg · 27/06/2023 12:12

i think we are already screwed with the ageing population issue.

Surely this applies worldwide?

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:51

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:48

PAs aren't qualified to give any diagnosis though, yet some are in positions where they make attempts to do so. On no planet would I prefer to be under the care of a PA over a doctor. That's not being rude or narrow minded, there are lots of highly capable and intelligent PAs but that doesn't mean the scope creep is damaging both to doctors who it affects and to patients.

It doesn't actually matter how intelligent a PA is.

There are many highly intelligent people with PhDs in specialist areas. That doesn't mean they should waltz into A&E after watching a view PowerPoint presentations and start managing sick patients.

You need a medical degree to practice medicine. End of story.

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:51

@hopeishere I’m a doctor and wary of PAs. Particularly the ODPs who do a two year cause to be anaesthetic associates. Anaesthetists are known for being intelligent, skilled and having some of the hardest post grad exams of all specialties. When things go wrong in anaesthetics it’s life or death, in minutes, they command a lot of respect from other specialties. If I need an anaesthetic I want a doctor doing it, I’ve worked with other professions/associates. They’re great, but they’re not a doctor and many are working outside their scope currently.

3BSHKATS · 27/06/2023 13:50

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:45

If they want the same opportunity as doctors then they should complete a medical degree. Let's be real here, would you rather a PA or a qualified and experienced GP or other doctor diagnose you?

I would take a diagnosis from anyone who was qualified to make it be that a doctor or PA or whoever. Regulation etc needs addressed but like I say all of medicine needs to change.

I’ve only ever had to deal with a PA once, and their diagnosis and suggestion was utterly wrong and inappropriate and luckily I was assertive enough to insist on meeting the GP.

As a direct result of that interaction, I bought private medical insurance that day.

3BSHKATS · 27/06/2023 13:49

This train has been coming over the hill at an alarming speed for the last 10 years. And it’s certainly hasn’t been helped by the recruitment process from the universities over the past three years. Two of my DD’s friends were all set to become doctors. Both the parents are doctors. It was a natural path for them to choose. Covid screwed them both over with their exam results downgraded their A levels. The universities didn’t accept them. They are both now on far easier, career path’s where they will learn much more money for a lot less stress. It is literally our loss in both cases.

Zarataralara · 27/06/2023 13:48

I would say the benefit to being a lowly 19th is that there is plenty of good practice to copy. If the NHS followed the way health services in France and Spain are run they’d save money and get things done.

Chocolateship · 27/06/2023 13:48

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:45

If they want the same opportunity as doctors then they should complete a medical degree. Let's be real here, would you rather a PA or a qualified and experienced GP or other doctor diagnose you?

I would take a diagnosis from anyone who was qualified to make it be that a doctor or PA or whoever. Regulation etc needs addressed but like I say all of medicine needs to change.

PAs aren't qualified to give any diagnosis though, yet some are in positions where they make attempts to do so. On no planet would I prefer to be under the care of a PA over a doctor. That's not being rude or narrow minded, there are lots of highly capable and intelligent PAs but that doesn't mean the scope creep is damaging both to doctors who it affects and to patients.

Medstudent12 · 27/06/2023 13:47

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:26

The pay is not rubbish. It's low at the start but there's good career progression. Why wouldn't they be paying for housing? We all do.

Also diversifying the medical field with different career routes is a good idea. Shorter career paths to get people into the workforce and specialising earlier in their career - no rotating round specialties they've no interest in.

Well the pay is rubbish if you compare us to our other nhs colleagues. We’re not on agenda for change pay scales like nurses. As I said before. The only doctors paid more per hour than some ANPs I work with are consultants. So very very senior registrars leading teams, performing surgery etc etc are on less than other team members with far less skills and experience. How is that fair? Why as doctors should we be paid less than colleagues with less responsibility for patients?

And re housing because I’ll be well into my 30s and at short notice can be told to go work 2.5 hours away in a rural area for a year. Never mind having kids in primary school. There’s no educational benefit to me working in a rural district general instead of my local district general but no one wants to work there and the physician associates etc won’t so they force the rotational registrars. So we pay a mortgage and rent for a second place. On a salary that as of 2022 was 35% less than a doctor would have got in 2008. How is that fair?

If doctors aren’t underpaid then the rest of the nhs are overpaid. They’re not. I don’t resent my colleagues being paid more per hour than me, they deserve that wage and nurses are still underpaid. But why are doctors paid less than non prescribers? When it’s the doctor taking all of the legal responsibility?

There was a telegraph article that says becoming a hospital consultant typically costs £20,000 of a junior doctors own money on exams, moving costs, professional fees, courses etc etc. My exams are compulsory. I’m sacked from my job if I fail them too many times, but I have to pay for each and every attempt (I’ve spent £4k so far).

Since 2012 graduates will pay 9% tax on everything they earn over £25k. My loan interest is so obscene that even as an nhs consultant I won’t pay it off like my previous counterparts did.

This is a hugely demanding, stressful and expensive job to do. It doesn’t matter if the public think we’re paid well enough, we’re not being paid well enough to retain us and we will leave. Being a doctor used to be a tough job that was financially rewarding. It’s still tough, but the financial rewards have dwindled.

Rotating round other specialties is useful! I’ve done surgical jobs so I can think hmmm is this acute porphyria or a surgical abdomen etc etc, we have a breadth and depth of knowledge that various associates will never have.

We train for longer, we do rigorous exams and each year we work we are doing 25% more weekly hours than them. I wish I’d become a PA! Or an ANP! They’re the smart ones. Being a doctor is not worth it, I discourage anyone who expresses an interest.

Alsogoingtogetslated · 27/06/2023 13:47

Yes we are screwed. Yet there have been so many threads on here with people saying doctors are paid too much, don’t work enough hours, don’t deserve more pay etc etc

MissyB1 · 27/06/2023 13:45

Afishcalledwand · 27/06/2023 13:37

Because the percentage of the national budget that the NHS takes rises exponentially every year. It’s wholly unsustainable. Did you know that when the NHS was founded the budgets forecast that the cost of the NHS would fall over time as the populace got healthier? NHS is getting more expensive every year. The last thing this country can afford is a 35% pay rise for junior doctors.

Well they shouldn’t have run it down so badly should they? Yes costs increase every year anyway, but it’s a damn sight more expensive in the long run if you don’t invest! And as a society we have to accept if we want the NHS to continue (and I suspect the vast majority do) then it has to be a political and financial priority. It is possible - but will cost!

As for the 35% pay rise - don’t blame the doctors, they didn’t take the decisions to let their pay fall so far behind. That again was a political choice. Now it will cost a fortune to try and put right.

Austerity was a bloody disaster and many people warned that it would be. Take note of what is being said about this in the Covid inquiry.

Zarataralara · 27/06/2023 13:45

We don’t have to wait 5 years, we’re totally screwed now. Thank you Tory governments.

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:45

If they want the same opportunity as doctors then they should complete a medical degree. Let's be real here, would you rather a PA or a qualified and experienced GP or other doctor diagnose you?

I would take a diagnosis from anyone who was qualified to make it be that a doctor or PA or whoever. Regulation etc needs addressed but like I say all of medicine needs to change.

SisterDonnarix · 27/06/2023 13:44

hopeishere · 27/06/2023 13:42

The training for PAs etc must improve. Doctors can't endlessly complain they are overworked and then reject help that is offered.

They aren't offering useful help.

They were meant to be assistants putting in cannulas, ordering routine bloods and writing for the consultant on the ward round whilst the juniors got on with being doctors.

Now they refuse to do any of that and want to be treated as SHO/reg level doctors, taking away training opportunities from real doctors and endangering patients.

Swipe left for the next trending thread