Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?

339 replies

BoobsOnTheMoon · 27/06/2023 09:03

Not only is it an absolute pittance of £76 a week considering you need to be providing care to a disabled person for at least 35 hours a week to claim it in the first place.

BUT you also can't claim if you earn more than £139 a week.

AND if you claim low income benefits (ie UC), the Carer's Allowance is counted as income and taken off your entitlement £ for £.

It's just so insulting. People giving up their lives and careers to care for a disabled family member deserve better than this.

(Just feeling a bit down about the fact I will probably be poor until I die, even if my disabled child manages to leave home one day I'll be at least 50 by then with no prospects for earning decent money or building any sort of security for my own old age)

OP posts:
caringcarer · 27/06/2023 18:15

@Cornettoninja I see you did not claim as you were working, but you actually spend 35 hours every week dealing with your Dad's issues. I'm only questioning it because DH and I offer support/care to my MiL who is 250 miles away and we facetime twice a day for 5-10 mins each time to check she is ok. We manage her direct debits/bills. We order her online shop each week. We click the button to get her repeat prescription and delivery. We organise things like boiler service or workman for any repairs, do any paperwork she might have, chat to her everyday. It all takes less than about 4 hours a week. We do also go up once every 5 or 6 weeks to visit in half term. But it still works out far less than 35 hours every week. I'm really sorry your Dad's care package was pulled though. It must be stressful working and caring and yes it will probably be affecting your performance if you are worrying about your Dad.

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 18:04

OriginalUsername2 · 27/06/2023 16:39

  • giving emotional support
  • helping someone cope with or seek help for a mental health problem
  • budgeting and looking after finances
  • helping others understand the needs of the person you are caring for
  • arranging medicine or providing medical care
  • checking they are safe
  • Advocating on their behalf – this means helping them express their views and wishes

Here are some things from the list that might apply.

All of the above might take 5 hours a week not 35 hours. I'm not saying a person far away can't offer support but things like organising a prescription takes one click of a button. My DH and I do all of the above and more for MiL and it takes us about 30-40 mins between us a day. That included other little things like getting her boiler serviced too.

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 17:46

SouthCountryGirl · 27/06/2023 16:57

I didn't say that. But if you got PIP just on the basis of epilepsy, how would you then be well enough to care for someone 35 hours a week, including preparing food? And yes I do have experience of epilepsy.

look, you can have a couple where one can do A,B & C tasks, and the other can do X,Y and Z tasks- they can just about manage when they have each other (although frequently with a lower quality of life than non disabled people) but otherwise would each need a carer.

This is not a drain on the system.

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 17:03

SouthCountryGirl · 27/06/2023 16:57

I didn't say that. But if you got PIP just on the basis of epilepsy, how would you then be well enough to care for someone 35 hours a week, including preparing food? And yes I do have experience of epilepsy.

Well that’s just how life works out sometimes. If you live with a partner who can manage emergencies well enough to ensure your safety during/after a seizure (even if that’s calling for 999 or other support, the key being that someone is actually there to alert those people to a problem) but they have mobility issues meaning that other tasks are beyond them then the situation arises they are effectively caring for each other.

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 16:58

OriginalUsername2 · 27/06/2023 16:39

  • giving emotional support
  • helping someone cope with or seek help for a mental health problem
  • budgeting and looking after finances
  • helping others understand the needs of the person you are caring for
  • arranging medicine or providing medical care
  • checking they are safe
  • Advocating on their behalf – this means helping them express their views and wishes

Here are some things from the list that might apply.

This is a valid answer. This is how my life was set up when my dads care package had the funding withdrawn without notice of replacement and I was living over 100 miles away. I didn’t claim any allowances because I work but it had a huge impact on my performance and I wouldn’t hesitate to describe it as caring despite not actually physically being there 24/7.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/06/2023 16:57

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 16:54

What?!? Do you think people with epilepsy spend their lives wrapped up in cotton wool just waiting for the next seizure?

I didn't say that. But if you got PIP just on the basis of epilepsy, how would you then be well enough to care for someone 35 hours a week, including preparing food? And yes I do have experience of epilepsy.

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 16:54

SouthCountryGirl · 27/06/2023 16:42

If your epilepsy was severe enough to need care, how would you be able to prepare food safely?

What?!? Do you think people with epilepsy spend their lives wrapped up in cotton wool just waiting for the next seizure?

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 16:52

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 15:58

@Cornettoninja, I referenced a poster up thread stating a she knew a man who claimed CA for his Aunt who lived 200 miles away. I don't know this person but it is clearly happening.

I don’t think I could be so certain on third hand information that this was indeed happening to the extent you’re implying by making it a hill to die on.

Tbh my primary concern would be that a vulnerable person is being financially abused if someone is claiming benefits on the basis someone isn’t receiving the care they’re entitled to. If you have details of this you’re, morally at least, obliged to report it. Or that poster is.

What it’s not, imho, is a starting point to cast all claimants, with issues you personally have no understanding of, as frauds.

EasterBreak · 27/06/2023 16:46

Agree. I don't qualify for carers allowance as I work school hours but I do get extra money from working tax credits because my childs disabled. I'm much better off financially working school hours.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/06/2023 16:42

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 12:20

But what if an elderly couple are ok together but both prone to falls and can’t get up- they each need someone there 24/7 to help them up or call an ambulance.

Or if one has epilepsy and can’t be alone for long in case an ambulance needs to be called/meds given etc, but their spouse has m.s and needs help dressing/toileting/preparing food.

Or a million other scenarios where two disabled people are able to cope when they have each other but otherwise would each require a separate career.

It isn’t scamming the system- it’s SAVING THE SYSTEM A FORTUNE on having to pay full wages to two separate carers.

If your epilepsy was severe enough to need care, how would you be able to prepare food safely?

OriginalUsername2 · 27/06/2023 16:39

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:52

I''m simply pointing out that some people are scammers and are actually not caring for people but claiming they are. Please answer the question how do you care for a person for 35 hours a week whilst living 200 miles away?

  • giving emotional support
  • helping someone cope with or seek help for a mental health problem
  • budgeting and looking after finances
  • helping others understand the needs of the person you are caring for
  • arranging medicine or providing medical care
  • checking they are safe
  • Advocating on their behalf – this means helping them express their views and wishes

Here are some things from the list that might apply.

starfishmummy · 27/06/2023 16:13

Archeron · 27/06/2023 12:31

My friend has looked after her mum for years and claimed care allowance. She also has two small sons. The eldest son has been diagnosed with autism so my friend has been awarded benefits to look after him (not exactly sure which benefit).

The upshot is that my friend is now getting paid for looking after her son so she can no longer get paid for looking after her mum, even though she still has to do it. AND the amount she gets paid for her son is less than what she got paid for her mum. So her burden has doubled but she now gets less money. It’s a stupid system.

Then it wouldn't be carers allowance.

It's a set sum and you either get it or you don't. No.slidong scale. So she would get the same looking after a child as she dian for an adult.

ohsuzannah · 27/06/2023 16:06

Sahara123 · 27/06/2023 09:25

As I approach retirement age I’ve discovered that carers allowance stops when you get your state pension. Oh right so my 24 hours a day caring for my adult daughter will somehow magically stop then will it ?!

Yes! I am now 70 and caring for my dd who has ASD and adhd. When I got my state pension ( huge sum of £139) they took the carers allowance off me 😡

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 15:58

@Cornettoninja, I referenced a poster up thread stating a she knew a man who claimed CA for his Aunt who lived 200 miles away. I don't know this person but it is clearly happening.

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 15:53

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 14:05

You clearly don’t understand disability.

@Alltheclogs, this is my original post. Clearing mentioning both if a person can't care for themselves effectively that they need 35 hours a week care from a carer, which is a lot of care, how can they care for another person for 35 hours a week AND referencing another poster who said a person claimed it for caring for his Aunt but lived 200 miles away.

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 15:18

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:44

Oh I do, but how do you care for a person if you live 200 miles away? My MiL is elderly 82 and has had a few falls now this year (4) but if you think she can have a carer just in case she falls I can tell you she can't. SS would never authorise it.

um, you can’t care for someone from 200 miles away… but the people in your original post about not allowing each half of a couple to have caters allowance are a couple… presumably in the same house.

If your point had been you can’t care for someone for 35 hours a week if you live 200 miles away from them, I would have agreed with you.

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 15:08

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:52

I''m simply pointing out that some people are scammers and are actually not caring for people but claiming they are. Please answer the question how do you care for a person for 35 hours a week whilst living 200 miles away?

‘Please answer’ - your writing as if I directly ignored a direct question. You posed a lot of questions in that post.

the only answer I have to your questions is another question to evidence how widespread any of these problems actually are? You’re sharing anecdotes that I personally have never, ever come across. It does lead me to wonder about your circle and whether you would agree that it’s probably more constructive to report those cases you find disagreeable than argue to remove support from people with a legitimate need.

medianewbie · 27/06/2023 14:57

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 13:51

When I read about David Cameron's disabled son, I wondered if his experience of parenting him might help Cameron himself grow as a person. This might lead to more empathy from the Govt inself for the experience others have across the country but with the added HUGE pressure of not enough money to live on also. Of course I cannot say whether Cameron did make any mental connections, but afaik he claimed DLA for the child (as was his right) but CA didn't improve.

If I remember rightly this exact point was raised directly with him in parliament and he got incredibly defensive and decided that his personal experience wasn’t up for discussion.

Take from that what you will.

That's interesting @Cornettoninja
I wasn't sure if it was fair to raise a point about someone else's disabled child (now sadly deceased) but I thought about it & I think I posted as I hoped it was clear it was really Cameron's experience of being a Carer that I meant. It's interesting that someone else has raised it in Parliament too. I do think that Politicians can have charmed lives / outsource the difficult bits but when your own child has such difficulites surly the opportunity is there to understand others experience a bit more? (not meant to be any kind of attack on DC, just sad really ).

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:52

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 14:42

so why are you trying to gatekeep a hierarchy of disability?

Carers allowance is a pittance, there’s no room to scale it to the corresponding disability, it’s one size fits all. It certainly isn’t fit criteria to judge someone else’s needs by.

I''m simply pointing out that some people are scammers and are actually not caring for people but claiming they are. Please answer the question how do you care for a person for 35 hours a week whilst living 200 miles away?

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:44

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 14:26

Then you would think that you would understand that everyone with a disability has a different experience.

Oh I do, but how do you care for a person if you live 200 miles away? My MiL is elderly 82 and has had a few falls now this year (4) but if you think she can have a carer just in case she falls I can tell you she can't. SS would never authorise it.

AmenAmin · 27/06/2023 14:42

HerbsandSpices · 27/06/2023 10:22

Back then it was far more common to have a parent (mother generally) in the home or working part-time. So people either did it harder financially or added to the caring burden of (primarily) women.

The other part is medical care improved. My brother died at 3 years old, but today would have most likely lived into adulthood. Life expectancy was pretty grim for many conditions

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 14:42

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 14:12

I am disabled myself. I absolutely do understand disability.

so why are you trying to gatekeep a hierarchy of disability?

Carers allowance is a pittance, there’s no room to scale it to the corresponding disability, it’s one size fits all. It certainly isn’t fit criteria to judge someone else’s needs by.

Poppies26 · 27/06/2023 14:41

@Turquoisflutterby do u care for someone? Do u know how completely isolating caring for someone can be? It's is sometimes easier to stay in, rather than go out. How family are normally busy with jobs and their own family. In other cultures it is still normally the women who are undertaking this care. Sometimes with v little other family support. If families from the Asian and Middle Eastern communities were all looking after their elderly members of the family, then why are there care homes and at home care existing in these countries?

ThomasWasTortured · 27/06/2023 14:38

X-posted.

ThomasWasTortured · 27/06/2023 14:38

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 14:34

@OwlRightThen did you? How did you manage that? I was caring for my mum while finishing my MA (which was entirely self taught/research- all the lectures/time at uni/placement etc was finished) and I applied to claim CA and was turned down because apparently if you are doing any academic work then you can’t possibly have 35hrs a week to be doing caring.

But that was 10 years ago so maybe it has changed?

As long as you are not studying for 21 or more hours a week you can claim CA.

Swipe left for the next trending thread