Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?

339 replies

BoobsOnTheMoon · 27/06/2023 09:03

Not only is it an absolute pittance of £76 a week considering you need to be providing care to a disabled person for at least 35 hours a week to claim it in the first place.

BUT you also can't claim if you earn more than £139 a week.

AND if you claim low income benefits (ie UC), the Carer's Allowance is counted as income and taken off your entitlement £ for £.

It's just so insulting. People giving up their lives and careers to care for a disabled family member deserve better than this.

(Just feeling a bit down about the fact I will probably be poor until I die, even if my disabled child manages to leave home one day I'll be at least 50 by then with no prospects for earning decent money or building any sort of security for my own old age)

OP posts:
BoobsOnTheMoon · 28/06/2023 07:04

For those saying the money should go to the disabled person so they can pay carers.... Do you know how many hours of care £76 would buy you? Not very many. Maybe 5 or 6 if you employ someone directly, more like 3 if you go through an agency.

OP posts:
SouthCountryGirl · 28/06/2023 06:58

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

And use what money to pay for the other extra costs of being disabled?

Shittenshite · 28/06/2023 06:18

If you care for somebody 36 hours a week and receive £76, that's £2.11 per hour.

If you care for somebody 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, that's 45p per hour.

Anyone who voted this thread as 'unreasonable' ought to just think about that for a moment.

Catspyjamas17 · 28/06/2023 05:36

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 27/06/2023 09:25

yeah, my elderly dad (80) is looking after my wheelchair bound Mum (77). His state pension (only income) is enough to disqualify him from Carers Allowance. Just awful that he gets nothing when he cares for her, literally 100% 24/7.

They should apply for Attendance Allowance, that's the one you can get after retirement age.

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 05:29

Then you have people who claim it whilst working full time as self employed hairdressers. Yes, I know someone. They provide zero care and I mean zero. The disabled person can do everything for themselves, they go out, drive, clean, cook and garden. Totally self sufficient

It always amazes me how the benefit cheats known to Mumsnetters are so open and honest when it comes to revealing the details of their cheating.

HMRC and DWP data share, btw. So the hairdresser will get caught at some point.

BadNomad · 28/06/2023 03:41

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:54

I'm not saying PIP or DLA alone is enough but many disabled people get packages that include addition money to pay for carers.
People are allocated a social worker. They usually sort carers for you if you're unable to do it yourself. I feel if you're giving 35hrs worth of care it should be monitored in some way and you should be paid for your time from the disabled persons benefits. I don't the CA should exist. Healthcare is 'free' at the moment so it's mostly social care.

35 hours of care MINIMIM. Many disabled people need 24 hour care. "Care" doesn't just mean physical care. It can mean constant supervision because it is not safe to be left alone. The actual care services are on their knees. There is already not enough money in the system to provide adequate care for people, never mind trying to replace what unpaid carers do with paid services.

A carer on minimum wage for 35 hours a week would cost over £350. That's roughly £1500 a month. You think disabled people who aren't working can afford that? Along with all the other expenses that come with their disabilities. Now imagine what 24-hour care would cost. And who is supposed to be ensuring the carers are coming? Social workers don't make daily calls to check-in. You're lucky if you see one at all beyond the initial meeting.

Yes, unpaid carers should be paid better for the pretty much free care they provide. No, it shouldn't come out of the DLA/PIP.

MeinKraft · 28/06/2023 03:09

The low rate of CA directly impacts healthcare for all of us. The backlogs at A&E are in large part caused by lack of beds. Beds are not being freed up because people who require care at home can't be discharged if there isn't adequate care for them. They may have a spouse/child/parent who could provide this care, but who can't support them on £76 a week. That person has to work full time. So they have to wait for a care package to be put in place - they stay in hospital - other unwell people can't use that bed. It's costing the NHS a fortune, it's putting lives at risk because social workers are so stretched with trying to arrange care packages they can't put basic safeguards in place for people who need them. Then you get people having accidents in the home because there was no social worker out to do an assessment - they end up in hospital and have to wait for a care package.

Substantially increasing carers allowance would see a reduction in pressures on the NHS and the social care system (for the two go hand in hand) would be better for society, enable much better patient care and would have cost saving benefits as the need for care packages and residential care home places would be reduced.

Missingmyusername · 28/06/2023 02:59

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2023 09:18

Carer allowance need to complete overall. Too many people claiming it just because someone in their family claims PIP when they actually provide no more care than one would normally give to a loved one.

Increasing the amount significantly for those who genuinely provide 35h + hour care to someone who cannot live day to day without that level of care.

^ This

For those who are providing genuine care, they need proper remuneration.

Then you have people who claim it whilst working full time as self employed hairdressers. Yes, I know someone. They provide zero care and I mean zero. The disabled person can do everything for themselves, they go out, drive, clean, cook and garden. Totally self sufficient.

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:54

I'm not saying PIP or DLA alone is enough but many disabled people get packages that include addition money to pay for carers.
People are allocated a social worker. They usually sort carers for you if you're unable to do it yourself. I feel if you're giving 35hrs worth of care it should be monitored in some way and you should be paid for your time from the disabled persons benefits. I don't the CA should exist. Healthcare is 'free' at the moment so it's mostly social care.

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:46

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 22:54

That is a reasonable point, but the disabled person would need to be paid a lot more than the current level of Carer's Allowance to buy 35 hours of care a week!

I think many do when you factor in DLA, PIP. I don't think anyone in their right mind believes you could give 35hrs earth of care for that amount. I just don't understand why any money at all is being paid to the carer with no 'quality checks' as to what care they're giving.

BadNomad · 27/06/2023 23:16

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

DLA/PIP isn't enough to pay for full-time care. Plus, who is going to organise and manage that for them when their current carer can no longer care for them because they have to go get a job?

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 23:04

Cross post🙄. Time for bed I think!

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 23:02

Cross pist with ThomasWasTortured who set it all out better than me!

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 23:00

Also the higher PIP daily living component is £101.75 per week Again, not going to buy 35 hours of care a week as well as meet all the other extra costs of being disabled.

ThomasWasTortured · 27/06/2023 22:59

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

DLA/PIP is to help with the extra costs associated with disability. Claimants can, of course, use it to pay for care if they wish, but there are many other things it could also be needed for e.g. increased energy and water bills, increased food cost, specialist equipment/therapies not covered by other services, increased clothes/footwear cost, additional parking costs and fuel costs…

For many, DLA/PIP doesn’t cover the additional costs as it is without them needing to pay at least the equivalent of CA to the person who is currently receiving carer’s allowance. And if someone only receives the standard rate daily living component that is less than CA, so it would leave absolutely nothing for anything else.

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 22:58

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

But many disabled people would be unable to manage this- children for example can’t be employers and organise paying tax etc for their careers- they would need someone to do this work for them, as would many people with learning disabilities and various other types of disability.

People who are able/eligible for this type of funding already get it- carers allowance exists separately as a token remuneration for unpaid carers.

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 22:54

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

That is a reasonable point, but the disabled person would need to be paid a lot more than the current level of Carer's Allowance to buy 35 hours of care a week!

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 22:51

Turquoisflutterby · 27/06/2023 22:33

People requiring care are, of course, vulnerable to abuse. Your argument that being their official carer somehow makes that less likely is illogical. In fact, if there was more ofa moral duty for all family members involved they would actually be likely better protected.

Either way you are conflating two separate points. 1. That people needing care are vulnerable (true) and 2. That if society felt a moral duty to care for their relatives then they would somehow be more likely to be abused (no evidence at all)

Your argument that being their official carer somehow makes that less likely is illogical

That if society felt a moral duty to care for their relatives then they would somehow be more likely to be abused (no evidence at all)

Can you quote me the part of my posts where I made those arguments? Because I didn't.

My point was that putting moral pressure on people to become unpaid carers for relatives when they may not want to or feel able to does no one any favours and may even result in harm.

Preventing abuse of the vulnerable by paid carers is a whole other issue.

JudgeRudy · 27/06/2023 22:48

It seems a very odd system. Surely a disabled person (child or adult) receives disability benefits to pay for care if they need it? So PIP, DLA etc. If you're working elsewhere, it would be hard to put in 35 hours a week surely. I don't think carers allowance should exist. The payment should go to the disabled person so ghey can employ carers.

HerbsandSpices · 27/06/2023 22:39

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:42

Rubbish, 30 years ago was the 90s women were working out of the home then, back in the 50s or 60s maybe but not 30 years ago!

I was parenting 30 years ago and I knew almost no-one who had young children who worked more than part-time, if at all.

Turquoisflutterby · 27/06/2023 22:33

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 21:18

How is it ill informed? I am a carer. I know how hard it is. It is not something anyone should be forced to do if they don't feel able to. Doing so puts everyone involved at risk of harm.

People requiring care are, of course, vulnerable to abuse. Your argument that being their official carer somehow makes that less likely is illogical. In fact, if there was more ofa moral duty for all family members involved they would actually be likely better protected.

Either way you are conflating two separate points. 1. That people needing care are vulnerable (true) and 2. That if society felt a moral duty to care for their relatives then they would somehow be more likely to be abused (no evidence at all)

IClaudine · 27/06/2023 22:18

There's a social expectation that people will provide care to their loved ones without payment. To be clear I'm not saying I necessarily agree with this but it is arguably the case

Hmm. I would argue that it is more about the lack of financial worth attached to work that has traditionally carried out by women, tbh. Even now, there are still more female unpaid carers than male.

Yabbadabbadotime · 27/06/2023 22:06

I think the main issue is carers are comparing it to being paid in terms of an hourly rate of pay for care work.

The reality is, this is not what it is.

There's a social expectation that people will provide care to their loved ones without payment. To be clear I'm not saying I necessarily agree with this but it is arguably the case.

Carer's allowance is just an allowance reflecting that caring a) can cost you b) can reduce your earning capacity and leave you with a low income.

Yabbadabbadotime · 27/06/2023 21:59

Its not intended to be a full replacement for a working income.

Someone who ends up not able to work due to caring can often access a whole host of other income support eg housing benefit, low income universal credit etc.

jcyclops · 27/06/2023 21:56

The miserly amount probably means that the application process for Carer's Allowance is easy (when compared to PIP, DLA etc) as there are no assessments and nobody checks up once you are receiving it. I would think that if it was twice as much you would have to jump through more hoops to get it and would need to re-apply frequently.

The ONLY good thing about the Carer's Allowance is that the Carer gets full NI credit for the time they are receiving it.