Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?

339 replies

BoobsOnTheMoon · 27/06/2023 09:03

Not only is it an absolute pittance of £76 a week considering you need to be providing care to a disabled person for at least 35 hours a week to claim it in the first place.

BUT you also can't claim if you earn more than £139 a week.

AND if you claim low income benefits (ie UC), the Carer's Allowance is counted as income and taken off your entitlement £ for £.

It's just so insulting. People giving up their lives and careers to care for a disabled family member deserve better than this.

(Just feeling a bit down about the fact I will probably be poor until I die, even if my disabled child manages to leave home one day I'll be at least 50 by then with no prospects for earning decent money or building any sort of security for my own old age)

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 23:51

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/06/2023 18:10

You are living in cloud cuckoo land.

High rate pip is £690 per month. No social worker. No care package. No support at all. 24/7 care..how much care do you think that would buy?

Well there's social care and healthcare. I don't think everyone has a social worker no, and those that do don't have someone 'on the books' or at their disposal because theyre not needed day in day out. I don't think £690 would buy an awful lot of care, no. If someone essentially needs a babysitter surely that's healthcare. Disabled/elderly people don't just get PIP, they get addition benefits because they're unable to work. The £690 would buy a few hours a week though. I'm not against paying Carers Allowance, I just think the cash should go to the patient/service user.

Alltheclogs · 28/06/2023 22:39

KarmaStar · 28/06/2023 18:06

Yanbu at all.
But there are thousands of people who claim it who are not carers at all.

@KarmaStar how do you know this?

JenniferBooth · 28/06/2023 22:25

Don’t even get me started on how the disability has to be long term or permanent in order to claim care allowance! My mum nearly died and I had to take 8 weeks unpaid leave to care for her during her recovery. But I couldn’t claim care allowance to tide me over because they said my mum’s need for care was temporary and you can only claim if it’s expected to last more than 3 months

And then you get people on here (including some NHS workers) moaning about lazy relatives who wont look after their elderly family members to free up a hospital bed.

Gerrataere · 28/06/2023 21:51

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 21:45

Gerrataere I am so sorry, that all soundsabsolutely exhausting. Your societal worth is sky high in my eyes. xx

It is but I mention the worst of it simply to get across how much caring can affect the individual not just mentally, but financially and more over a lifetime. I work bloody hard but I am rewarded in more love than anyone could ask for. It’s worth every moment but I will not have what little I and others get as a financial aid be dismissed as something unnecessary. Thank you though, you’re very kind!

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 21:45

Gerrataere I am so sorry, that all soundsabsolutely exhausting. Your societal worth is sky high in my eyes. xx

Gerrataere · 28/06/2023 18:53

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:54

I'm not saying PIP or DLA alone is enough but many disabled people get packages that include addition money to pay for carers.
People are allocated a social worker. They usually sort carers for you if you're unable to do it yourself. I feel if you're giving 35hrs worth of care it should be monitored in some way and you should be paid for your time from the disabled persons benefits. I don't the CA should exist. Healthcare is 'free' at the moment so it's mostly social care.

Of anyone wants to come ‘monitor’ the care I do they are more than welcome to. They can watch me run around the house trying to dress my child and watch him kick me because he is screaming his socks are too warm/cold/soft or whatever he’s decided that day. They can watch me have to restrain him to perform basic hygiene tasks such as teeth brushing or wiping after the toilet. Oh, that’s when I can get him on/off the toilet, they can come into the school with me when I’ve been called in to help him there. They can stay up with me all night as well if they please! Maybe they’ll help hold the spray bottle after I’ve cleaned up some more smearing at 11pm. Or stop him running around the house rather than go to sleep, running taps and eating anything he can find (edible or not). Please put this idea forward, especially to DLA who just refused to up his personal care rate because apparently all that and so much more doesn’t qualify for the highest rate of care.

In the meantime CA is the only thing that’s paying towards my pension credits. Right now I cannot work due to being on call 24/7. The gap in my CV means I’ll never likely ever have a career worth mentioning, if I even get a look in for a job ever again. If and when my caring duties come to an end, I’m fucked. Sorry to be crass but it’s true. My societal worth (which by some of the comments here is already minimal) will be in the toilet. I can barely get positive credit rating for not being in employment. Most landlords didn’t even look at my applications when I was house hunting. I’ve already been told by others that it seems ‘unfair’ that I get paid to ‘look after your own child’ because apparently that’s what parenting is.

So please, please get these people around to monitor us, maybe someone will actually dig out an ounce of respect for what we carers do and how badly it affects us in every part of our lives now and in the future.

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 18:31

alexdgr8 · 28/06/2023 16:26

and if it's such an attractive option, why don't all those who think it's such a doddle, give up their paid work and find someone in receipt of a qualifying benefit and get them to agree to you being their carer.
for £76 a week.
nice little earner.
the life of reilly indeed.

Yes indeed. It is a doddle.

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 18:29

KarmaStar · 28/06/2023 18:06

Yanbu at all.
But there are thousands of people who claim it who are not carers at all.

Evidence please.

BoobsOnTheMoon · 28/06/2023 18:24

KarmaStar · 28/06/2023 18:06

Yanbu at all.
But there are thousands of people who claim it who are not carers at all.

But you can only be awarded CA if the person you claim to be caring for is in receipt of certain disability benefits, which are extremely strictly assessed! So anyone getting one of those benefits does need extra care/help.

OP posts:
SouthCountryGirl · 28/06/2023 18:22

KarmaStar · 28/06/2023 18:06

Yanbu at all.
But there are thousands of people who claim it who are not carers at all.

Have you reported them?

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/06/2023 18:10

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:54

I'm not saying PIP or DLA alone is enough but many disabled people get packages that include addition money to pay for carers.
People are allocated a social worker. They usually sort carers for you if you're unable to do it yourself. I feel if you're giving 35hrs worth of care it should be monitored in some way and you should be paid for your time from the disabled persons benefits. I don't the CA should exist. Healthcare is 'free' at the moment so it's mostly social care.

You are living in cloud cuckoo land.

High rate pip is £690 per month. No social worker. No care package. No support at all. 24/7 care..how much care do you think that would buy?

KarmaStar · 28/06/2023 18:06

Yanbu at all.
But there are thousands of people who claim it who are not carers at all.

alexdgr8 · 28/06/2023 16:26

and if it's such an attractive option, why don't all those who think it's such a doddle, give up their paid work and find someone in receipt of a qualifying benefit and get them to agree to you being their carer.
for £76 a week.
nice little earner.
the life of reilly indeed.

Alltheclogs · 28/06/2023 15:21

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 13:36

Yes, I'm happy for those people to be paid but I think if they're being paid there should be some sort of auditing. So there's a care need, a relative has said they'll meet that need and they're able to demonstrate they are carrying out those duties to a minimum level. No problem with that, but if you're being paid it should be monitored.

Oh good, more hassle, stress and jumping through hoops for people who are already slogging their guts out. If the caring wasn’t being done, the people would be ending up in hospital or dead…

How exactly would you monitor it? Send someone round to shadow a carer for an hour? A week?!

Of course a small number of people will be trying to scam the system, and an even smaller number will get away with it, but that is not a justification for punishing all carers.

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 14:32

Auditing just would not be possible or effective. How would it work? On the spot unannounced checks?

The Social Care system can't even even prperlymonitor the work of professional carers and care homes. Look at the abuse that has gone on. Where would the resources come from to audit and monitor the 1.3 million unpaid carers who recieve CA?

PickAChew · 28/06/2023 14:09

And don't suggest social workers because we don't have enough of them, as it is. I've lost track of the conveyor belt of different ones I've seen over the past 3 years just to be able to access the 3 hours a week of outreach care (ie someonr takes him for a walk and our heads stop spinning for a bit) we've been getting for Ds2 for just over half a year.

ThomasWasTortured · 28/06/2023 13:42

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 13:36

Yes, I'm happy for those people to be paid but I think if they're being paid there should be some sort of auditing. So there's a care need, a relative has said they'll meet that need and they're able to demonstrate they are carrying out those duties to a minimum level. No problem with that, but if you're being paid it should be monitored.

And who exactly is going to do that monitoring and who will fund it? It isn’t workable.

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 13:36

Alltheclogs · 28/06/2023 12:47

People popping into grandma once a day aren’t getting carers allowance- you have to be providing at least 35 hours a week care. Ffs.

If they're unable to do the basics safely alone then the state should provide carers.

And presumably pay these carers a decent wage?… so why not just pay the people already doing the caring a decent wage instead of a piss poor carers allowance?!

Yes, I'm happy for those people to be paid but I think if they're being paid there should be some sort of auditing. So there's a care need, a relative has said they'll meet that need and they're able to demonstrate they are carrying out those duties to a minimum level. No problem with that, but if you're being paid it should be monitored.

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/06/2023 13:14

Yabbadabbadotime · 27/06/2023 21:59

Its not intended to be a full replacement for a working income.

Someone who ends up not able to work due to caring can often access a whole host of other income support eg housing benefit, low income universal credit etc.

No mortgage help and UC is less than £350 for a single person.

It's not possible to live.

Alltheclogs · 28/06/2023 12:47

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 11:18

I get that care comes in many guises. My point is that if a person isn't safe to be left alone then surely they need 24hr care so eg I have a friend who works for Mencap in a 'cluster' home, so 4 LD disabled people sharing a home. There's a member of staff on hand all the time 24/7. That's paid for by the state and deductions are made from their benefits. I also know elderly/ill people needing care at home. Maybe not 24/7 but considerable hours. Again the nursing care they recieve is paid for by the state.
I don't think someone popping in to grandma's every day to see if she needs anything should be paid or eg helping that person take a bath/shower. If they're unable to do the basics safely alone then the state should provide carers.

People popping into grandma once a day aren’t getting carers allowance- you have to be providing at least 35 hours a week care. Ffs.

If they're unable to do the basics safely alone then the state should provide carers.

And presumably pay these carers a decent wage?… so why not just pay the people already doing the caring a decent wage instead of a piss poor carers allowance?!

alexdgr8 · 28/06/2023 12:03

i agree IClaudine.
JudgeRudy, have you ever had to care for someone with complex needs ?
do you realise how much extra costs are involved in just daily living eg constant electricity use for beds, air mattress, hoist, maybe wheelchair, riser recliner chair, extra heating or fan, extra laundry, and bedding, continence supplies, special diets and preparation, blending of food, special cups to be able to hold, clothing that is non-standard, etc.
and then there are the mental tasks, trying to book hosp transport, advocating to social workers, district nurses, OTs, physios, GPs, podiatrist, diabetic eye screening, (return to trying to book hosp transport, and get them to actually turn up in time, another missed appt, re-booking..).
if you ever manager to get the person there, going with them to hosp appts, co-ordinating prescriptions, calling out of hours nhs, begging for antbx for recurrent infections, to avoid hosp admissions, where most of the specific care needs are neglected, leading to further deterioration...
now even if the council provided professional careworkers, do you think they would do any of this.
could they. how many clients do they rush around to.
many of them have only basic english.
and anyway they wouldn't have the background knowledge of the client to do all this liaising.
they do mostly physical tasks, washing, dressing, continence care, maybe basic food prep.
so who does it.. ?
oh yes, those layabouts, shirking employment.

IClaudine · 28/06/2023 11:35

I don't think someone popping in to grandma's every day to see if she needs anything should be paid or eg helping that person take a bath/shower. If they're unable to do the basics safely alone then the state should provide carers

Given that the cared for person needs to be in receipt of one of the following:

Personal Independence Payment - daily living component
Disability Living Allowance - the middle or highest care rate
Attendance Allowance
Constant Attendance Allowance at or above the normal maximum rate with an Industrial Injuries Disablement Benefit
Constant Attendance Allowance at the basic (full day) rate with a War Disablement Pension
Armed Forces Independence Payment
Child Disability Payment - the middle or highest care rate
Adult Disability Payment - daily living component at the standard or enhanced rate

It is very likely that they need more care than help with shopping or paying bills. Also, not being able to safely shower or bathe alone counts as "unable to do the basics", surely?

The more I read on this thread, the more I realise that some people have not a clue about what it is like to be an unpaid carer. I sincerely hope none of you ever find out.

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 11:18

BadNomad · 28/06/2023 03:41

35 hours of care MINIMIM. Many disabled people need 24 hour care. "Care" doesn't just mean physical care. It can mean constant supervision because it is not safe to be left alone. The actual care services are on their knees. There is already not enough money in the system to provide adequate care for people, never mind trying to replace what unpaid carers do with paid services.

A carer on minimum wage for 35 hours a week would cost over £350. That's roughly £1500 a month. You think disabled people who aren't working can afford that? Along with all the other expenses that come with their disabilities. Now imagine what 24-hour care would cost. And who is supposed to be ensuring the carers are coming? Social workers don't make daily calls to check-in. You're lucky if you see one at all beyond the initial meeting.

Yes, unpaid carers should be paid better for the pretty much free care they provide. No, it shouldn't come out of the DLA/PIP.

I get that care comes in many guises. My point is that if a person isn't safe to be left alone then surely they need 24hr care so eg I have a friend who works for Mencap in a 'cluster' home, so 4 LD disabled people sharing a home. There's a member of staff on hand all the time 24/7. That's paid for by the state and deductions are made from their benefits. I also know elderly/ill people needing care at home. Maybe not 24/7 but considerable hours. Again the nursing care they recieve is paid for by the state.
I don't think someone popping in to grandma's every day to see if she needs anything should be paid or eg helping that person take a bath/shower. If they're unable to do the basics safely alone then the state should provide carers.

Alltheclogs · 28/06/2023 10:46

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 02:54

I'm not saying PIP or DLA alone is enough but many disabled people get packages that include addition money to pay for carers.
People are allocated a social worker. They usually sort carers for you if you're unable to do it yourself. I feel if you're giving 35hrs worth of care it should be monitored in some way and you should be paid for your time from the disabled persons benefits. I don't the CA should exist. Healthcare is 'free' at the moment so it's mostly social care.

24hr care at NMW is circa £6,800 a month. Or £82,000 a year. Add into that rent/mortgage/food/clothes/equipment costs/utility bills/prescription costs etc.

Do you really think people are regularly being given benefits packages that pay for this?! And then having the LA provide them with a social worker who has the time to organise their care?!

BoobsOnTheMoon · 28/06/2023 07:07

And whoever mention that claiming Carers Allowance means you get the Carers Element on your UC - yes, but the Carers Allowance is taken off your entitlement and then the Carers Element is added at a lower rate (£184 a month whereas Carers Allowance is about £330 a month). So no, you aren't really gaining much and you certainly aren't seeing even the full £76 a week!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread