Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?

339 replies

BoobsOnTheMoon · 27/06/2023 09:03

Not only is it an absolute pittance of £76 a week considering you need to be providing care to a disabled person for at least 35 hours a week to claim it in the first place.

BUT you also can't claim if you earn more than £139 a week.

AND if you claim low income benefits (ie UC), the Carer's Allowance is counted as income and taken off your entitlement £ for £.

It's just so insulting. People giving up their lives and careers to care for a disabled family member deserve better than this.

(Just feeling a bit down about the fact I will probably be poor until I die, even if my disabled child manages to leave home one day I'll be at least 50 by then with no prospects for earning decent money or building any sort of security for my own old age)

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 15:49

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:38

JudgeRudy have you ever been a carer?

Not fulltime no. I've been an unpaid carer for 2 elderly relatives, a physically disabled friend and a mentally disabled neighbour. I have a relative who's a fulltime carer to an autistic child. She seems to love him but her life revolves around his needs. I'd never be up for that. I know my limitations but she seems to love him very much.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:43

if eg grandma needed 24hr care I would expect someone to be paid to do it. If it was social care then it would be means tested and the recipient would pay. If they can't, (or their partner cant) the state steps in and offers bare minimum. If it's healthcare it hould be free, however i don't think you should becable to choose exactly what you want

There is a massive shortage of carers right now. My local council recruit carers from abroad and there still aren't enough. Care homes are closing down too, so the aim is to keep people in their own homes for as long as possible. Unpaid carers are saving the day right now.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:38

JudgeRudy have you ever been a carer?

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:36

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 15:26

You've not understood. I'm not saying carers shouldn't he paid for the work they do, I'm saying the 'allowance' should be allocated to the person who needs the care. If it was a child it probably would be a parent. I get caring for a disabled child is hard. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't be able or willing to do it, but I don't necessarily think you should be paid to care 24/7...not for sure child however if eg grandma needed 24hr care I would expect someone to be paid to do it. If it was social care then it would be means tested and the recipient would pay. If they can't, (or their partner cant) the state steps in and offers bare minimum. If it's healthcare it hould be free, however i don't think you should becable to choose exactly what you want.

Paying the allowance to the cared for person, who then pays it to the person who is the carer would be hugely complicated. Not least because the carer would then be employed by the cared for person and all the legal, financial and practical issues that involves would kick in, including paying the minimum wage.

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 15:33

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 15:32

No I’m referring to the poor excuse of an apology that I responded to a few posts back.

@IClaudine ot was meant to tag @Concernedneighbour21 not you, sorry about that, I mixed the two usernames!

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 15:32

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:28

Do you mean you want Babyroobs to respond rather than me?

No I’m referring to the poor excuse of an apology that I responded to a few posts back.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 15:28

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 15:07

Could you please answer the post I tagged you in, I’m interested in your reply. Honestly even those who claim CA simply ‘not to look for work’ are in a very small minority. Not just for the reasons I gave in my own post (mostly that it is a non profitable benefit in monetary sense) but the fact that living from CA in itself leaves you in a financially poor position. UC as a system doesn’t work for those who simply refuse to have a job, that’s why the old benefits system was overhauled in the last few years. It makes little sense to claim UC just to add caring to your claim, carers allowance would be wholly deducted and you ‘make’ no money whilst also losing other UC Back to Work initiatives.

Do you mean you want Babyroobs to respond rather than me?

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 15:26

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/07/2023 14:00

I'm not against paying Carers Allowance, I just think the cash should go to the patient/service user.

You sound just like those men who seem to think that they can support their dc without actually paying anything to their mother, even though she’s the one who who houses, heats and feeds them.

Carers aren’t trying to scam anyone. They can work a few hours a week, that’s it. They are already struggling to get by and now you are saying that they should be funded from the paltry amount the person they care for receives to live on?

£690 would buy approximately 66 hours of care at minimum wage (that’s just for care, I’m not sure how you expect them to actually live). Carers receive just over £150 for 70 hours. How the fuck can you sit there and argue that they shouldn’t even receive that?

You've not understood. I'm not saying carers shouldn't he paid for the work they do, I'm saying the 'allowance' should be allocated to the person who needs the care. If it was a child it probably would be a parent. I get caring for a disabled child is hard. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't be able or willing to do it, but I don't necessarily think you should be paid to care 24/7...not for sure child however if eg grandma needed 24hr care I would expect someone to be paid to do it. If it was social care then it would be means tested and the recipient would pay. If they can't, (or their partner cant) the state steps in and offers bare minimum. If it's healthcare it hould be free, however i don't think you should becable to choose exactly what you want.

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 15:07

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 14:21

You can insult me as much as you like @babyroobs. I stand by everything I have said.

Could you please answer the post I tagged you in, I’m interested in your reply. Honestly even those who claim CA simply ‘not to look for work’ are in a very small minority. Not just for the reasons I gave in my own post (mostly that it is a non profitable benefit in monetary sense) but the fact that living from CA in itself leaves you in a financially poor position. UC as a system doesn’t work for those who simply refuse to have a job, that’s why the old benefits system was overhauled in the last few years. It makes little sense to claim UC just to add caring to your claim, carers allowance would be wholly deducted and you ‘make’ no money whilst also losing other UC Back to Work initiatives.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 14:21

You can insult me as much as you like @babyroobs. I stand by everything I have said.

Babyroobs · 02/07/2023 14:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 14:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have never once said people aren't claiming CA fraudulently.

I don't think your clients would be happy to know you are sharing details about them, even anonymously. The detail you gave would be enough for someone to recognise themselves if they were reading this thread.

Cornettoninja · 02/07/2023 14:08

@Babyroobs i bet that attitude is positively an attribute in the kind of role you claim to have.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/07/2023 14:04

nokidshere · 30/06/2023 20:24

Oh and whilst I am ranting, just think about the thousands of children caring for adults before, after, and sometimes instead of, going to school. It's a fucking disgrace.

It is a disgrace. What kind of civilised society allows this?

Babyroobs · 02/07/2023 14:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/07/2023 14:00

JudgeRudy · 28/06/2023 23:51

Well there's social care and healthcare. I don't think everyone has a social worker no, and those that do don't have someone 'on the books' or at their disposal because theyre not needed day in day out. I don't think £690 would buy an awful lot of care, no. If someone essentially needs a babysitter surely that's healthcare. Disabled/elderly people don't just get PIP, they get addition benefits because they're unable to work. The £690 would buy a few hours a week though. I'm not against paying Carers Allowance, I just think the cash should go to the patient/service user.

I'm not against paying Carers Allowance, I just think the cash should go to the patient/service user.

You sound just like those men who seem to think that they can support their dc without actually paying anything to their mother, even though she’s the one who who houses, heats and feeds them.

Carers aren’t trying to scam anyone. They can work a few hours a week, that’s it. They are already struggling to get by and now you are saying that they should be funded from the paltry amount the person they care for receives to live on?

£690 would buy approximately 66 hours of care at minimum wage (that’s just for care, I’m not sure how you expect them to actually live). Carers receive just over £150 for 70 hours. How the fuck can you sit there and argue that they shouldn’t even receive that?

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 13:54

Have I hit a nerve, @Babyroobs?

I am not an idiot. What I am is sick of people trotting out unsubstantiated evidence about benefit fraud. Especially in the case of CA.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 13:45

Alltheclogs I thought you could still get CA if you or the person you care for goes on a short holiday?

Babyroobs · 02/07/2023 13:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IClaudine · 02/07/2023 13:36

I'm not saying it happens frequently but it does happen

So why bother mentioning this on a thread that is about the low rate of CA, not about CA fraud? Secondly, your client was very open with you about her daughter's intention to fraudulently claim CA to get out of work commitments for Universal Credit. It always amazes me how open these fraudsters,are. Thirdly, you have broken client confidentiality.

Babyroobs · 02/07/2023 13:30

Alltheclogs · 02/07/2023 13:00

How is it an easily abused benefit?

  1. You have to be really disabled for someone to be able to claim carers allowance- if someone is claiming it then not providing the care then they are committing elder/child abuse and neglect- it would be work to cover this up and carries the possibility of massive punishment if you are found out - it seems a bit much to think that loads of people would do this for the sake of £76 a week.

  2. if you have anything approaching a normal job/pay you won’t get carers allowance- they do check and communicate with Hmrc and are very quick to stop payments and issue fines (I got a fine when someone took my mum away for a week and I forgot to tell them immediately- I called and told them a few days after they went away and I was fined £50).

  3. if they are on other befits then they are reduced £ for £… so they would be committing benefit fraud (and as I said child or elder abuse if the person isn’t receiving the care they need) in order to get pension credit- again I don’t think there are loads of people that would go to those lengths for so little reward.

I have had a client ask me recently if her daughter could claim carers allowance for her so that she didn't have to look for work on UC. Daughter did not provide 35 hours of care a week because client's husband was her main carer but couldn't claim carers allowance because of being state pension age. daughter wanted to claim it and in fact could do because no-one checks up how much caring is being done, and it would have got her out of any work commitments on UC. Of course it would have been a fraudulent claim, but anyone could say they were checking up on relatives etc frequently. I'm not saying it happens frequently but it does happen.

Alltheclogs · 02/07/2023 13:00

Concernedneighbour21 · 01/07/2023 19:58

I wholeheartedly apologise to those who took offence to my previous (now deleted) post. It was awfully written and it definitely read as though I believed carers did not deserve the ridiculously low payment they receive.

When I said people were doing it for the money only, I meant those that took advantage of the system by claiming carers allowance for people they didn't actually care for. Its an easily abused benefit especially when it concerns vulnerable people.

Those that are carers are vastly underpaid, especially when taking into consideration what it would cost to have paid carers, nursing homes and other support.

I DO believe the system needs to be changed so that those who are caring for somebody are paid significantly more for their time and effort. The only way to do this is to get rid of those who claim it falsely.

How? I don't know. I don't believe genuine carers should be subjected to extra checks. They have enough to worry about. This is why I'm not a politician.

I also believe young carers should be paid.

Again, I'm sorry. My last post was poor.

How is it an easily abused benefit?

  1. You have to be really disabled for someone to be able to claim carers allowance- if someone is claiming it then not providing the care then they are committing elder/child abuse and neglect- it would be work to cover this up and carries the possibility of massive punishment if you are found out - it seems a bit much to think that loads of people would do this for the sake of £76 a week.

  2. if you have anything approaching a normal job/pay you won’t get carers allowance- they do check and communicate with Hmrc and are very quick to stop payments and issue fines (I got a fine when someone took my mum away for a week and I forgot to tell them immediately- I called and told them a few days after they went away and I was fined £50).

  3. if they are on other befits then they are reduced £ for £… so they would be committing benefit fraud (and as I said child or elder abuse if the person isn’t receiving the care they need) in order to get pension credit- again I don’t think there are loads of people that would go to those lengths for so little reward.

Gerrataere · 02/07/2023 11:26

@Concernedneighbour21

Its an easily abused benefit especially when it concerns vulnerable people.

I genuinely want to know how people can ‘abuse’ this benefit. You concede that it’s a pittance. You have been told how you cannot claim it if you’re earning over £140 a week (also a pittance). You have been told how it’s taken £1 for £1 from universal credit, therefore a carer isn’t actually ‘profiting’ from claiming. The only benefit to the one claiming is that it pays towards pension credit. So who are these many many people who are allegedly playing the system for £305 a month?

Concernedneighbour21 · 01/07/2023 19:58

I wholeheartedly apologise to those who took offence to my previous (now deleted) post. It was awfully written and it definitely read as though I believed carers did not deserve the ridiculously low payment they receive.

When I said people were doing it for the money only, I meant those that took advantage of the system by claiming carers allowance for people they didn't actually care for. Its an easily abused benefit especially when it concerns vulnerable people.

Those that are carers are vastly underpaid, especially when taking into consideration what it would cost to have paid carers, nursing homes and other support.

I DO believe the system needs to be changed so that those who are caring for somebody are paid significantly more for their time and effort. The only way to do this is to get rid of those who claim it falsely.

How? I don't know. I don't believe genuine carers should be subjected to extra checks. They have enough to worry about. This is why I'm not a politician.

I also believe young carers should be paid.

Again, I'm sorry. My last post was poor.

HerVagestyTheQueef · 01/07/2023 00:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, I claimed CA just because I can.
I used to be a teacher, of many years standing and with extra responsibility, so decent enough pay.
However, I jacked it all in to get to get CA of £76 per week because that's just as good and hey, just because I could.

Idiot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread