Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?

339 replies

BoobsOnTheMoon · 27/06/2023 09:03

Not only is it an absolute pittance of £76 a week considering you need to be providing care to a disabled person for at least 35 hours a week to claim it in the first place.

BUT you also can't claim if you earn more than £139 a week.

AND if you claim low income benefits (ie UC), the Carer's Allowance is counted as income and taken off your entitlement £ for £.

It's just so insulting. People giving up their lives and careers to care for a disabled family member deserve better than this.

(Just feeling a bit down about the fact I will probably be poor until I die, even if my disabled child manages to leave home one day I'll be at least 50 by then with no prospects for earning decent money or building any sort of security for my own old age)

OP posts:
PickAChew · 27/06/2023 13:05

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:50

I’m basing it on two couples I know, one couple have played the system for years, he can’t work because he wants to see the children grow up, has a bad back, she has a bad chest, cough cough but smokes 60 a day, they care for each other apparently, they are early 30s , the other couple care for each other , one walks with a stick but attends dog shows with her dogs and miraculously forgets she needs a stick when doing to dog obstacle course…yes these people are playing the system taking money from people that struggle to claim anything who need it more than shirkers!

Got to love a bit of anecdata.

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/06/2023 13:03

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 12:58

@MrsSlocombesCat it’s possible to have the mobility element of pip without the care element.

Also, while many people may technically be able to have someone to claim carers allowance for them, that relies on there being someone available to claim it which there isn’t always, so the family as a unit miss out on the money.

As I said earlier- someone could claim carers allowance for me, and a separate someone could claim it for my son- but my wife earns too much and my parents get their pensions. So we have 2 people in the house who require a high level of care and the people doing it don’t get carers allowance.

Yes, I already know that. My son gets standard rate for living but not mobility. And I claim carers allowance. You haven’t answered my question as to why someone wouldn’t be able to claim CA if they are caring for someone on PIP.

Soupsetscared · 27/06/2023 13:01

Also don't forget that when you start to receive state pension then carers allowance stops.
Even though the person you care for is still disabled.

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/06/2023 13:00

Let’s not forget the three yearly PIP assessments that you as a carer have to fill in forms for and persuade your autistic child to attend. And that what you tell the Capita assessor seems very different from what they write in their report. So then your son’s PIP is stopped, along with your carers allowance, and UC suddenly demand twenty mile round trips to the Job centre. Then you’re forced to apply for jobs that you know you won’t be able to do, and nobody will take you on anyway because you have been self employed earning a pittance for the last 20 years. Then you send in a mandatory reconsideration which is turned down despite having all the same information as the one that was successful last time. So then you appeal and when they ask for reasons you tell them exactly that and suddenly they’re ringing and saying that we don’t need to go to appeal because they’ve reinstated it. After three months of stress and anxiety which was completely unnecessary. I didn’t get my carers allowance reinstated for a further three months because they wanted all my accounts from my self employment. Initially they asked for two months but then six weeks later they wrote and requested my accounts from 2022/3. Incidentally nobody told me I could claim a carers component on UC! I did get extra money when my son’s PIP was reinstated so now the back pay of CA will be deducted from my UC. I wouldn’t wish this stress on anyone.

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 12:59

@MrsSlocombesCat also there are different levels of PIP.

To think Carer's Allowance is a fucking disgrace?
Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 12:58

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/06/2023 12:26

It does though. When I claimed carers allowance they asked if I was caring for someone with an eligible benefit. PIP is because there is no low rate, unlike DLA.

@MrsSlocombesCat it’s possible to have the mobility element of pip without the care element.

Also, while many people may technically be able to have someone to claim carers allowance for them, that relies on there being someone available to claim it which there isn’t always, so the family as a unit miss out on the money.

As I said earlier- someone could claim carers allowance for me, and a separate someone could claim it for my son- but my wife earns too much and my parents get their pensions. So we have 2 people in the house who require a high level of care and the people doing it don’t get carers allowance.

MrsLilaAmes · 27/06/2023 12:53

It's the utter illogic and hypocrisy of it that gets to me most.

Carers Allowance is treated as pseudo employment - the DWP consider it as if you are working, providing care, for minimum full time hours, and they want to see proof that any previous employment has ended, they want to restrict your ability to do a 'second job' more than most employers would, and obviously if you reach state retirement age that means you must be going to give up your caring 'job'.

All of that might be a reasonable approach to take - it is a full time job and more, even if the person cared for is able to attend school. It is often hard, draining work, and pushing yourself as the carer to work a job as well as caring can be too much. Many people at state retirement age would be reasonably advised to quit a caring role too for the benefit of their own health and wellbeing.

But if you grant all of that, why for the love of God pay a pittance - nominally £2.17 per hour? I earned more than that as a teenager before national minimum wage was ever introduced. If the carer is effectively functioning as a state employee, pay the statutory legal minimum at least! And why not recognise that so many carers roles are much closer to 80 or 100 hours per week than 35. In salaried roles where you tend to work what is needed to get the job done, there are strict controls aimed at ensuring no one is accidentally working for less than the minimum hourly wage.

Or, if you are absolutely ideologically wedded to the idea that £2.17 is enough of a sop for 'helping out' family members from time to time, that it is nothing like 'hard work', then drop this facade of rigorous checks about employment status and other work, and recognise that often someone in their retirement years will 'help out' at least as much as in their working years.

It's the government trying - and mostly succeeding - to eat their cake and have it too, to our detriment.

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:52

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:50

I’m basing it on two couples I know, one couple have played the system for years, he can’t work because he wants to see the children grow up, has a bad back, she has a bad chest, cough cough but smokes 60 a day, they care for each other apparently, they are early 30s , the other couple care for each other , one walks with a stick but attends dog shows with her dogs and miraculously forgets she needs a stick when doing to dog obstacle course…yes these people are playing the system taking money from people that struggle to claim anything who need it more than shirkers!

Also it was pointed out that elderly people don’t get carers once they retire, so what age do you say is elderly? 50 is not elderly 70 is and they can’t claim it!

medianewbie · 27/06/2023 12:52

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 10:38

It’s been the same way for at least 25 years, although of course it used to go much further.

It is highly disgusting but has never had the momentum behind it to improve. Too much mileage in getting people to hate anyone claiming any support from the government.

This.
When I read about David Cameron's disabled son, I wondered if his experience of parenting him might help Cameron himself grow as a person. This might lead to more empathy from the Govt inself for the experience others have across the country but with the added HUGE pressure of not enough money to live on also. Of course I cannot say whether Cameron did make any mental connections, but afaik he claimed DLA for the child (as was his right) but CA didn't improve.

It is particularly sad that people are not able to study at home, even part time, if claiming Carers allowance. It would allow people who have been out of the workforce for some time to update their skills & be ready to re-enter if possible.
It is economically illiterate & driven by ideology not financial logic.

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:50

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 11:19

I mean, it absolutely not a ‘con’ and no where near ‘massive’.

An elderly couple only managing to function independently because they have each other 24/7 isn’t some sort of grift. You’ll find that when one half of these couples passes the surviving half immediately has to access carers or move to a home.

What’s wrong with your analytical skills that you think two elderly people claiming carers for each other is the issue rather than the fact that they have to care for each other and don’t have any other support?

I’m basing it on two couples I know, one couple have played the system for years, he can’t work because he wants to see the children grow up, has a bad back, she has a bad chest, cough cough but smokes 60 a day, they care for each other apparently, they are early 30s , the other couple care for each other , one walks with a stick but attends dog shows with her dogs and miraculously forgets she needs a stick when doing to dog obstacle course…yes these people are playing the system taking money from people that struggle to claim anything who need it more than shirkers!

loislovesstewie · 27/06/2023 12:46

What is so utterly disgusting is that carers actually save the government an absolute fortune. By paying carers a proper amount they would still be saving money, the carer would be valued as a person and the person receiving the care would not feel a burden. We are a rubbish country, the rich can but what they want including care and the poor suffer.

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 27/06/2023 12:45

Clymene · 27/06/2023 11:46

Why is she not claiming attendance allowance?

she is.

the thread was about carers allowance, hence my comment about my dad being a carer.

ThomasWasTortured · 27/06/2023 12:44

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/06/2023 12:26

It does though. When I claimed carers allowance they asked if I was caring for someone with an eligible benefit. PIP is because there is no low rate, unlike DLA.

The person being cared for needs to be in receipt of the daily living component of PIP (or be in receipt of another qualifying benefit). There are some people who only receive the mobility component of PIP, which doesn’t entitle a carer to claim carer’s allowance.

Throwncrumbs · 27/06/2023 12:42

HerbsandSpices · 27/06/2023 10:22

Back then it was far more common to have a parent (mother generally) in the home or working part-time. So people either did it harder financially or added to the caring burden of (primarily) women.

Rubbish, 30 years ago was the 90s women were working out of the home then, back in the 50s or 60s maybe but not 30 years ago!

placemats · 27/06/2023 12:42

To the so many people here having to juggle, struggle and keep going on, despite the endless caring (never stops), it should be renamed 'just about bloody coping' allowance.

placemats · 27/06/2023 12:38

Archeron · 27/06/2023 12:34

Don’t even get me started on how the disability has to be long term or permanent in order to claim care allowance! My mum nearly died and I had to take 8 weeks unpaid leave to care for her during her recovery. But I couldn’t claim care allowance to tide me over because they said my mum’s need for care was temporary and you can only claim if it’s expected to last more than 3 months.

Even if you are on Carer's Allowance if you need to look after someone else during that time, and I've had to help my mum as well, get other people to help care for the main person you are caring for, it's deducted.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 12:38

Cornettoninja · 27/06/2023 11:19

I mean, it absolutely not a ‘con’ and no where near ‘massive’.

An elderly couple only managing to function independently because they have each other 24/7 isn’t some sort of grift. You’ll find that when one half of these couples passes the surviving half immediately has to access carers or move to a home.

What’s wrong with your analytical skills that you think two elderly people claiming carers for each other is the issue rather than the fact that they have to care for each other and don’t have any other support?

This.

Been here, done that, got the TShirt. We couldn't claim it though, because over overlapping benefits.

If we could gave got it, I'd have claimed it. Some people have no idea of the daily grind of disability.🙄

Gerrataere · 27/06/2023 12:35

It infuriates me that it’s take £1 for £1 from UC. We have to claim benefits because we cannot work due to level of care needs, yet any other paid position wouldn’t be taken away from UC top ups in exact amount. And the amount is pitiful for what we do, carer, cleaner, support worker, admin, some have to homeschool, nursing, list is endless.

What angers me more is the lack of future support. Those of us who are carers in the time others are building a career and we’re left with years of an empty cv. If and when our carer duties come to an end, so does the pay and nothing to help us rebuild our own lives. It’s a hellish catch 22 situation, I fear not only for my disabled children’s futures but my own as well.

ZZpop · 27/06/2023 12:34

"I do wonder where you draw the line to care for someone because they're your family member and its the right thing to do vs wanting to be paid for it."

It is not about wanting to be paid for it it is about not being able to do paid work because you are providing care.

During any respite hours my son has overnight respite which costs social care around £500 a night or he requires 3:1 support from specially trained paid carers.

Archeron · 27/06/2023 12:34

Don’t even get me started on how the disability has to be long term or permanent in order to claim care allowance! My mum nearly died and I had to take 8 weeks unpaid leave to care for her during her recovery. But I couldn’t claim care allowance to tide me over because they said my mum’s need for care was temporary and you can only claim if it’s expected to last more than 3 months.

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/06/2023 12:33

Alltheclogs · 27/06/2023 09:50

You have to receive the correct level of pip in the correct category- I don’t (I’m a wheelchair user, added to which I have M.E, Fibromyalgia, POTS and JHS)- I don’t get any care component or any moving around/mobility component in my pip (so no one can get carers allowance for me)

My mum is on DLA on all the highest rates- we get carers allowance for her.

My son is on a mix of middle and higher dla- we could get carers allowance for him except you can’t claim it for more than one person.

My dad can’t claim carers allowance at all because he has his state pension.

My wife can’t claim carers allowance because she works full time (so that we don’t all starve…).

So- 2 lots of dla, one lot of PIP and one lot of carers allowance. It is not as simple as ‘anyone who has a relative on pip can claim carers allowance’.

I’m confused - if you don’t get the care OR mobility component of PIP what is left?

StillMedusa · 27/06/2023 12:33

I recently claimed for the first time.. My DS2 is an adult with autism. He walks he talks and has a job in a supermarket... But do I provide 35 hours a week care? You bet I do. He can't live independently, he has a medical condition that involves appointments, lots of needs, tests. His mental health is a fine balance and when things go wrong it's intense. I was burned out trying to juggle work and his needs and so now I work up to the CA limit.
His care needs are a lot simpler in many ways to someone who has 24hr round the clock disabilities but they still prevent him from living a 'normal' life and I will be responsible for him till I die, so I dont
think that £79 a week is too much to ask!!

Archeron · 27/06/2023 12:31

My friend has looked after her mum for years and claimed care allowance. She also has two small sons. The eldest son has been diagnosed with autism so my friend has been awarded benefits to look after him (not exactly sure which benefit).

The upshot is that my friend is now getting paid for looking after her son so she can no longer get paid for looking after her mum, even though she still has to do it. AND the amount she gets paid for her son is less than what she got paid for her mum. So her burden has doubled but she now gets less money. It’s a stupid system.

placemats · 27/06/2023 12:26

10% saying YABU OP.

Who are these heartless people? Have you no shame?

ohtowinthelottery · 27/06/2023 12:26

When my severely disabled DD turned 18, we were granted 40 nights a year overnight respite at a cost (to the NHS) of £340 PER NIGHT! (and that was 10 years ago).The other 325 days I provided care for the paltry sum that is Carers Allowance. The respite costs didn't even include food as DD was tube fed so all prescription feed (and other supplies - meds, incontinence products)went with her from home.