Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Tyrion was the villain?

119 replies

lilpeepgothboy · 26/06/2023 22:47

I mean who cares it ended ages ago but with the sequel of Jon Snow (I think is happening?) I’ve rewatched a few episodes.

He sacrificed Varys to save himself, a friend who saved his life. He was also a crap hand of The Queen. He encouraged Jon to kill Dani.

And he got away with no consequences. Loved him throughout but that final season

OP posts:
Takoneko · 27/06/2023 20:28

I agree with others that it’s GRRM who is the real issue.

The problem the show runners had is that the source material gets more and more convoluted over time. Martin has lost his grip on the story and has created so many subplots and characters that he’s clearly finding it impossible to pull it all back together in any satisfying way. When they started the GOT TV series it was never meant to outrun the books. The source material was meant to be finished and the show was meant to be an adaptation. There’s now been over thirty POV characters alone and it’s increasingly clear that Martin himself has no idea how to bring the whole thing to a close.

LoobyDop · 27/06/2023 20:16

I find it really odd the way some people think Dany’s descent was sudden- they’d been signalling it for years. I liked the ending. I liked that Cersei didn’t get some big dramatic comeuppance, just a quiet failed escape attempt- it felt real. I liked that Sansa won. It pissed me off that she didn’t have an army waiting at the wall to bring Jon home the second Greyworm left, but he was probably happier beyond the wall. The only thing that annoyed me was the lack of a detailed introduction of the random lords electing Bran, but I loved Sansa squashing her uncle. And I loved that Gendry was there, because he was always a favourite.

But to answer OP’s question, I didn’t vote because I don’t overall agree that Tyrion was a wrongun, but I can’t argue with your examples. I think he could have got Varys out.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 27/06/2023 20:08

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 20:03

Why does he need a face checker when he invented the inworld universe?

He's struggling to recall apparently

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elio_M._García_Jr._and_Linda_Antonsson

MelonsOnSaleAgain · 27/06/2023 20:08

Presumably because he’s waited so long to finish anything he has, quite literally, lost the plot(s)

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 20:03

Why does he need a face checker when he invented the inworld universe?

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 27/06/2023 19:55

RE the books, it has been said he has needed to employ fact-checkers such as Elio Garcia from the Westeros website to help him. The books are very far behind the show and going in so many different ways that it's basically going to be impossible to bring certain storylines around off the top of my head:

Sansa is still with Littlefinger Ramsey has a girl he believes is Arya but isn't
Tyrion is with a character that doesn't feature in the series but is significant in the books- a possible Targaryen
Jon has warged into Ghost
Davos is on the hunt for Osha and Rickon in order to get support from The North
Bran still in tree, no doors held yet.

Now I read the book 12 years ago so anyone can correct that happily if I'm off.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/06/2023 19:43

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 18:34

He's obviously a prolific and capable writer, so what's happened here? Severe writer's block? I haven't read the books, has he written himself into a corner? That's the problem with authors who don't plan, although after the way the TV series ended, he surely can't make it any worse. Just get Dani the Mad Queen to Dracarys the whole bloody planet if need be.

I think the corner situation is the most likely scenario. I mean he's worked on 7 books, 3 video games, 4 TV series and a short film since DoD, so seems to be able to write when needs be. From what Ive read in my slim hopes of an update many feel the books had gotten so complex with too many story lines running that it was always going to be a huge challenge to close them all out in a satisfactory way.

I did wondered if he gave the show writers a rough idea of how he planned to close out the books and the negative reception to that has scuppered those plans.

At this point I'd be happy if he just took what he'd written already for WoW and had the red commet slam I to Westeros, killing everyone. At least it would be an ending.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 27/06/2023 19:22

Tyrion was to the end who he always was. A survivor. There wasn't malice or psychopathy or an inherent thirst for power in him , and he knew the right thing to do and could see the bigger picture, but ultimately him staying alive came first. The self preservation instinct always came first when the chips were down.

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 18:54

SwordToFlamethrower · 27/06/2023 18:42

They're all villains. Absolutely gross the lot of them

Not Myrcella, Tommen, Sansa, Rickon or Robb.

latetothefisting · 27/06/2023 18:50

to be honest I think the whole last 2 seasons were so random and inconsistent that you can't trust any of the characterisation...

Tyrion was a political genius for 6 seasons and then as soon as he got back to westeros apparently lost all his braincells. None of his arguments made sense - Daenerys had the biggest army westeros had ever seen by that point, why did he keep discouraging her from just taking king's landing? Why was he so keen to save Cersei whom he'd spent his entire life hating?

Varys spent literal decades planning for Dany to take the throne but then changed his mind because he decided she was mad although she hadn't actually done anything to indicate that by that point...

Jaime spent 6 years growing as a character only to just go right back to Cersei with no explanation

Bran literally declared he was incapable of being the lord of winterfell because he was the 3 eyed raven but then was magically ok with being king?

Dany...I agree she's always had a dark side and therefore the potential to turn 'evil' (but then so did pretty much all of the other characters....) but her whole character arc was about not wanting to harm innocents - there was absolutely nothing to indicate that she'd randomly destroy the place she'd spent her whole life trying to get back to! They tried to give her some rationale about turning 'mad' because people didn't love her in westeros so she felt she had to rule by fear instead, but we'd literally just seen 2 seasons of the people in literally every other city she'd conquered uprising against her, so it's not as if she wasn't used to being unpopular and ruling by force!

SwordToFlamethrower · 27/06/2023 18:42

They're all villains. Absolutely gross the lot of them

Catspyjamas17 · 27/06/2023 18:36

BiscuitsandPuffin · 26/06/2023 22:51

OMG spoilers much????? Arrgh.
I know, I know, I shouldn't have clicked on it given that I never got around to finishing it but seriously.

Oh come on, it finished years ago.

Dorothy gets back home again in the Wizard of Oz as well.

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:35

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 18:34

He's obviously a prolific and capable writer, so what's happened here? Severe writer's block? I haven't read the books, has he written himself into a corner? That's the problem with authors who don't plan, although after the way the TV series ended, he surely can't make it any worse. Just get Dani the Mad Queen to Dracarys the whole bloody planet if need be.

I wonder if the ending he had planned was the TV series ending but then realised the public omg

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:34

Brefugee · 27/06/2023 08:16

Varys would have done the same thing if it came down to a "him or me" situation, as we know from his past

As Hand to the Queen he tried to steer Dani along the diplomatic route - a prosperous country with trade deals and diplomatic ties is more successful than one that wages a scorched earth policy over "rivals" who just want a better deal.

Encouraged Jon to kill Dani. Did you even see what was happening to her? it was the thing she feared the most, being a mad Queen like her forbears. What do you think he should have done? forgiven all for love? let her be burned to death?

you don't seem to have a grasp of nuance. Is GoT the right thing for you?

Varys should have been better than to openly plot like he did,

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 18:34

He's obviously a prolific and capable writer, so what's happened here? Severe writer's block? I haven't read the books, has he written himself into a corner? That's the problem with authors who don't plan, although after the way the TV series ended, he surely can't make it any worse. Just get Dani the Mad Queen to Dracarys the whole bloody planet if need be.

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:31

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/06/2023 18:29

There's only one villain in the whole ASOIAF saga is George R R Martin, the king of procrastination, emperor of delay, sultan of broken promises.

I still remember the foreword to DoD in 2011 where he apologies for the 6 year wait between it and the previous book and promises that his loyal readers won't have a wait like that again for winds of winter. I suppose he was kind of right cause it's been 12+ years now. Bloody prick.

It has took the biscuit writing the book

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:30

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 13:05

The problem with Jon ending up on the throbe is that the only people actually fit to rule are people who don't want to. And then they'll get toppled in that world if they aren't at least slightly arseholes.

True as they usually lack the Machiavellian abilities to play the game of thrones

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/06/2023 18:29

PicturesOfDogs · 26/06/2023 22:52

The only villains in the show were D&D.

It was such a good show, and they just fucked it up.

I’m so bitter. I just disregard anything that happened after s5

There's only one villain in the whole ASOIAF saga is George R R Martin, the king of procrastination, emperor of delay, sultan of broken promises.

I still remember the foreword to DoD in 2011 where he apologies for the 6 year wait between it and the previous book and promises that his loyal readers won't have a wait like that again for winds of winter. I suppose he was kind of right cause it's been 12+ years now. Bloody prick.

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:29

AmadeustheAlpaca · 27/06/2023 17:37

@DrSbaitso I really like your alternate endings. Dany as a white walker would be a great idea for a further series. However we don’t know if she’s actually dead as her dragon flew off with her and she could potentially be revived by a red priestess

I suspect the red priestess idea too, seems most likely

Hawkins0001 · 27/06/2023 18:28

DrSbaitso · 26/06/2023 22:52

I think most of them were meant to be complex characters.

That ending, though. I still haven't recovered.

King Bran, Doer of Nothing.

The other thing with bran is it's not actually bran as he's possessed by the being known as the three eyed Raven

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 27/06/2023 18:26

@MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking

I would try with HOTD

It was really good and the ending is already well established

Delphinium20 · 27/06/2023 18:04

MelonsOnSaleAgain · 27/06/2023 07:13

I am glad there are a few others who didn’t loathe the end. I really enjoyed it right through.

It was dark, morally dubious, bleak, and didn’t follow any traditional kind of narrative at the close.

As to Tyrion, I don’t agree he was the villain. I think virtually everyone had their dark side. They all played their game and some lost and some survived and winter was coming, then winter was there.

If anything winter was the villain. It’s like global warming we face, the world is facing a natutal disaster and bar a few people shouting about it, everyone’s too busy with their own machinations to care. GOT is an allegory for now.

This is how I feel about the ending as well! And smart assessment that winter was the winner and the ultimate villain, albeit w/out intent.

AmadeustheAlpaca · 27/06/2023 17:37

@DrSbaitso I really like your alternate endings. Dany as a white walker would be a great idea for a further series. However we don’t know if she’s actually dead as her dragon flew off with her and she could potentially be revived by a red priestess

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 27/06/2023 15:03

Only decent bit was Jon buggering back off to the Wall, he would have been a shite king. Not that Bran was any better. And Sansa being queen in the north was good, but that's it. I really thought they did Dany dirty, a cowed meek girl at the beginning, people trying to take advantage of her for whatever they could and she showed them all.

But nah. A woman with that much power? Let's send her off her rocker and kill her off instead. Replace her on the throne with a teenage boy who talks in fucking riddles 24/7 and everyone is just ok with that?

Night King, wrapped up sharpish. Dragons, meh. The whole dark magic thing, went out with a whimper. Cersei, just drop a ceiling on her and have done with it. The whole thing was just so lazy! Haven't even bothered with HOTD.