Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social housing exchange - AIBU

310 replies

Brighton5555 · 26/06/2023 21:56

Hey

just need some assurance / reality check I guess. I have managed to find a housing swap after quite some time ( the feedback I get is lovely house but too small) so not beating off offers by any means despite my home being to a high standard and spent thousands on it…

im due to sign a exchange soon. The man has the same bedrooms as me and he has a house in a area I desire but if this house wasn’t in the area I want I don’t know if I would actually go for it..

bonus points are - neighbours on one side only, good garden size, extra toilet downstairs, larger kitchen than mine, larger bathroom and about same size of the 4 bedrooms BUT

its pretty gross. He has 7 animals including 4 dogs, it needs gutted from top to bottom as in complete new flooring and complete decoration and the bathroom will need ripped out. It’s in a very poor conditon but has passed all the checks they do for exchanging .. I viewed it for the 3rd time last week and the house had a lot of flies, I mean a lot I suspect from the animals . It was super clear to me on that viewing just how much money and work will need to be put in whereas here mine needs only a freshen up on the painting upstairs there are no other costs to him..

of course he’s lucky and it’s not his fault that our homes are very different but I just feel am I being crazy to take it on? I’m legit starting from the bottom again and will need to spend a few weeks living outside and at least £15,000 to have it okay to move into.

I have the means to do both but I know it’s going to a long slog. Again the benefits are extra toilet, larger kitchen and bathroom more manageable sized garden and a better area ..

I guess I feel daunted by it all

OP posts:
Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 12:32

You could have been allocated the property when you were in need then inherited some money. I’d say if the inheritance was a million you’d be unlikely to stay put but that’d be up to the individual.

Skinthin · 27/06/2023 12:29

Brighton5555 · 27/06/2023 12:05

Yeah £15k will only covering flooring, moving , and decorations plus door replacements and some but not all of the bathroom… the rest will be outside of the initial input .

I assume most of the ignorance on social housing comes from people who have never needed to apply. You do not have to be poor or homeless to be able to apply and sure they have increased the rules to apply now ( for example where I live you cannot apply until you have lived in the area for at least 5 years ) but you can work and have one , you can have one with a million pound in your bank… you can also have one if on benefits . Tenancy for life is another reason why there are one or just two people occupying large family
homes because it’s their right to stay.

it’s not free housing . For sure I’m lucky to have one but I’ve been a social housing tenant for over a decade .

you can have one with a million pound in your bank

it’s completely disingenuous to make statements like this. Yes anyone can apply, but they are allocated to those most in need as they should be. The issue being debated is whether that should continue indefinitely regardless of ongoing need, when there are many, many others in dire need who can’t get access to affordable housing. I certainly don’t have the answers, but it’s a legitimate debate

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/06/2023 12:27

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 12:14

Also if you have a lifetime tenancy and mutual exchange/swap with another tenant, you lose your lifetime tenancy and have to sign a new agreement for regular assessment, initially every six months

This is correct now in a lot of cases (whilst not applying to the OP) and is one of the things that is going to make it harder for SH tenants to downsize, when DC leave home. I have a lifetime tenancy currently and no way would I swap that for one that's regularly reviewed as you're opening yourself up to failing criteria which could change over time. So even if you think you're initially ok, they could bring in a rule before your next review that sees you out on the street. So whilst I can see they're trying to phase out lifetime tenancies, currently it's going to lead to more people staying put.

And with a bit of thought that could have sorted.

Allow people swapping to smaller properties to keep their lifetime tenancies to actively encourage them to move.

Shopper727 · 27/06/2023 12:19

Just because op has savings doesn’t mean she’s eligible for a mortgage depends on earnings as well as deposit. I wouldn’t do that exchange if I had to spend 15k tbh.
op has likely been able to save because of social housing and it being more affordable.

I really struggled in rented as a single parent paying 1k plus a month and bills (5 years ago so not recently) we were made homeless as landlord sold up and were in temp accommodation for 5 years before getting our permanent house in March. It’s small (4 kids) but we make do and I am a little better off but happy to have a bit of security and I do not grudge others that despite my own situation.

mrssilky · 27/06/2023 12:18

the rules for exchange and lifetime tenancies vary based on when your tenancy first began, whether the property you're moving into is classed as an 'affordable rent' property and who your social landlord is.
It certainly makes swapping more difficult and can hinder the movement of people to 'correct' size properties. Another Tory fail.

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 12:14

Also if you have a lifetime tenancy and mutual exchange/swap with another tenant, you lose your lifetime tenancy and have to sign a new agreement for regular assessment, initially every six months

This is correct now in a lot of cases (whilst not applying to the OP) and is one of the things that is going to make it harder for SH tenants to downsize, when DC leave home. I have a lifetime tenancy currently and no way would I swap that for one that's regularly reviewed as you're opening yourself up to failing criteria which could change over time. So even if you think you're initially ok, they could bring in a rule before your next review that sees you out on the street. So whilst I can see they're trying to phase out lifetime tenancies, currently it's going to lead to more people staying put.

FarTooHotForMe · 27/06/2023 12:11

I would go for it, short term pain for long term gain.

mrssilky · 27/06/2023 12:10

i was considering a swap to a similar state of property but even the council said it was in too much of a state to swap to without remedial works being done, so swap was cancelled .
I certainly don't have 15k to do any place up. with swaps, although i wouldnt leave a place in a shit state myself, you have to lower expectations of what others will do. they'll be dog shit in the garden, the floors will be rank etc etc. I fully expected to have to bleach the place top to bottom and paint all the floors and walls. That isn't a huge expense to have it liveable to start with i think.

If the bathroom is just knackered but functional, you can get it clean to use for yourself. If however, parts of the suite are missing i doubt the swap would be able to go ahead?

Beezknees · 27/06/2023 12:09

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 27/06/2023 11:31

Sorry but if you have £15k to spend on renovations then no way should you be in social housing.
I'm being made homeless with several young children and we are terrified.
We are stuck on a waiting list, no idea how long it will take and there are people like you sat in social housing that have 15k kicking about.
Wtaf.

So if you get a housing association property I presume you will leave it in the future when you no longer need it.

Bremusa · 27/06/2023 12:06

Apologies, Brighton not Bristol!

Brighton5555 · 27/06/2023 12:06

Bremusa · 27/06/2023 12:04

Op, I'm assuming you live in Bristol from your username which is a different area to me, but I would check with the council if I were you. In my area (West Yorkshire) there are no lifetime tenancies any more, they're regularly reviewed. Also if you have a lifetime tenancy and mutual exchange/swap with another tenant, you lose your lifetime tenancy and have to sign a new agreement for regular assessment, initially every six months. Just a heads up, might be worth you checking, although Bristol may be different. Otherwise definitely go for it.

It’s been confirmed as he has a life
time as do I so we are technically swapping tenancies x

OP posts:
Brighton5555 · 27/06/2023 12:05

Yeah £15k will only covering flooring, moving , and decorations plus door replacements and some but not all of the bathroom… the rest will be outside of the initial input .

I assume most of the ignorance on social housing comes from people who have never needed to apply. You do not have to be poor or homeless to be able to apply and sure they have increased the rules to apply now ( for example where I live you cannot apply until you have lived in the area for at least 5 years ) but you can work and have one , you can have one with a million pound in your bank… you can also have one if on benefits . Tenancy for life is another reason why there are one or just two people occupying large family
homes because it’s their right to stay.

it’s not free housing . For sure I’m lucky to have one but I’ve been a social housing tenant for over a decade .

OP posts:
Bremusa · 27/06/2023 12:04

Op, I'm assuming you live in Bristol from your username which is a different area to me, but I would check with the council if I were you. In my area (West Yorkshire) there are no lifetime tenancies any more, they're regularly reviewed. Also if you have a lifetime tenancy and mutual exchange/swap with another tenant, you lose your lifetime tenancy and have to sign a new agreement for regular assessment, initially every six months. Just a heads up, might be worth you checking, although Bristol may be different. Otherwise definitely go for it.

Locutus2000 · 27/06/2023 12:02

There are huge waitlists for social housing, for people who are in dire need of a home.

The people already living there also have a dire need of a home. There are no private rentals, where do they go?

Yerroblemom1923 · 27/06/2023 11:42

People saying OP shouldn't have savings or that £15000 is a lot.... it really isn't much when it comes to decorating etc. We've been pricing up new kitchens and you're looking at £12000 minimum. I know the OP talking about the bathroom but would imagine that'll be easily £6000.

wineschmine · 27/06/2023 11:38

Sarahtm35 · 26/06/2023 22:25

I’m mean this in the kindest way possible but if you have spent thousands of ££s and can afford to spend £15k on this new place then you really should not be eligible for social housing.
when we got our social housing we could barely afford paint. That’s why we needed the house because we weren’t well off. We have a huge homeless issue in this country and so it upsets me that there are people living in them that clearly have other choices with their renovations and fancy new kitchens. Sorry but i had to rant

Sorry OP, but I have r I agree with this.

I saw your reply to this poster and it just doesn't cut it for me, I'm afraid.

Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

There are huge waitlists for social housing, for people who are in dire need of a home.

I also feel these homes should be for the people who really need them.

But I guess that's on the council and the whole system. You're not doing anything legally wrong, you are entitled to the house. Ethically though is a different thing.

Have spent "thousands" on your current council house and now have £15k to do up another. Just doesn't sit right with me.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:36

Sorry, I didn’t see your previous post. I’m sorry for your situation but I meant it’s usually nastiness by people who look down on SH tenants than those who are in dire need

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:35

Which bit?

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 27/06/2023 11:32

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:28

It’s the usual bitterness and jealousies coming out as soon as Social Housing is mentioned, usually by people who are piss poor themselves and struggling

Yes, I am 100% bitter.
This is a ridiculous situation.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 27/06/2023 11:31

Sorry but if you have £15k to spend on renovations then no way should you be in social housing.
I'm being made homeless with several young children and we are terrified.
We are stuck on a waiting list, no idea how long it will take and there are people like you sat in social housing that have 15k kicking about.
Wtaf.

HeckinBamboozled · 27/06/2023 11:28

If you have the money you might as well move. Location makes a massive difference.

Get a forensic clean after removing all of the flooring. It'll probably make quite the difference. Get Shelter's support if the council won't play ball on replacing the windows. With the current focus on reducing damp you should be able to get that sorted quickly.

ohdamnitjanet · 27/06/2023 11:28

So OP should spend her £15000 hard earned savings on a years private rent, run out of money then apply for social housing? This isn’t a communist state, people are allowed to have savings even if they claim benefits.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:28

It’s the usual bitterness and jealousies coming out as soon as Social Housing is mentioned, usually by people who are piss poor themselves and struggling

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 11:14

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 10:49

averaging just over £90 a week MAX

Hahaha, I wish! My HA rent is £180 a week! Double your "MAX" amount. Yes in some parts of the country, for some property types, you can pay less than £100 a week but we don't all have such low rents. Yes it's still cheaper than private renting but it is close to a third of my income. I pay it all, claim zero benefits.

I did chuckle at the max bit. Grin

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:11

ThreeFeetTall · 26/06/2023 22:31

I'd do it, once he and the pets are gone and you've aired it and wiped the walls it probably won't be so bad. Even just ripping up the carpets and having rugs for a year or two would be ok.

I wonder where people live if 15k is a deposit? And that they can know that OP could get a mortgage just because she's got some savings? Confused

Exactly this. My son needed a £50k deposit for a mortgage on a one bed apartment. Where would £15k get you. Not everyone in social housing are poor. Most work. Most tenancies are assured for life

Swipe left for the next trending thread