Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social housing exchange - AIBU

310 replies

Brighton5555 · 26/06/2023 21:56

Hey

just need some assurance / reality check I guess. I have managed to find a housing swap after quite some time ( the feedback I get is lovely house but too small) so not beating off offers by any means despite my home being to a high standard and spent thousands on it…

im due to sign a exchange soon. The man has the same bedrooms as me and he has a house in a area I desire but if this house wasn’t in the area I want I don’t know if I would actually go for it..

bonus points are - neighbours on one side only, good garden size, extra toilet downstairs, larger kitchen than mine, larger bathroom and about same size of the 4 bedrooms BUT

its pretty gross. He has 7 animals including 4 dogs, it needs gutted from top to bottom as in complete new flooring and complete decoration and the bathroom will need ripped out. It’s in a very poor conditon but has passed all the checks they do for exchanging .. I viewed it for the 3rd time last week and the house had a lot of flies, I mean a lot I suspect from the animals . It was super clear to me on that viewing just how much money and work will need to be put in whereas here mine needs only a freshen up on the painting upstairs there are no other costs to him..

of course he’s lucky and it’s not his fault that our homes are very different but I just feel am I being crazy to take it on? I’m legit starting from the bottom again and will need to spend a few weeks living outside and at least £15,000 to have it okay to move into.

I have the means to do both but I know it’s going to a long slog. Again the benefits are extra toilet, larger kitchen and bathroom more manageable sized garden and a better area ..

I guess I feel daunted by it all

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 14:39

If people earning well were then evicted out of their SH (which some seem to be suggesting happens!) where is the incentive to work hard and progress in your career?

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 14:37

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 14:30

In my experience most of the negative comments regarding social housing have come from those with big mortgages.

Which is weird considering they're always having the lingering threat going on about losing everything. Maybe that's why...

Now we've got everyone should get a turn of SH. Chuck those out into a shit landlords hands and give a shot of fair rents to someone else in 'need' and after a bit, they need to be chucked back to give someone else a shot.

The relentless mission to link SH to benefits is the most strange. Looked thick saying it is and then changing to maybe it should be.

Always entertaining these threads.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 14:30

In my experience most of the negative comments regarding social housing have come from those with big mortgages.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 14:26

ThreeFeetTall · 27/06/2023 14:12

But in the 1970s many council tenants were (relatively) well off and I don't think it was the same struggle to get council housing.

Yes those 5000 people could move out. But I think the waiting list in England is something like 1.6m households. It's not the main issue here.

I'm not saying it's the main issue. I'm saying that it's going to stir up animosity and jealousy because it's patently unfair that people are allocated SH and then allowed to stay irrespective of their circumstances. People on this thread are desperate to belittle those questioning the system, calling them 'snidey' etc when in reality there is intrinsic inequality that needs tackling.

Do we need more SH? Yes
Is it going to be easy to build enough SH to meet demand? Absolutely not
Do we need to reform the system so that the housing stock we do have is allocated according to need as opposed to who got in first and secured themselves a lifetime tenancy? Yes

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 14:21

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 13:52

What gets me (and amuses me) about these threads. That people look in others bowls to make sure they don't have more than them. The one section or housing that is secure, in their minds needs to be brought in along side the misery of private renting.

The problem isn't in SH. Private rents are out of control. Look at that rather than misery loves company.

The snidyness on this thread is well sad man. Plenty to say about how things should be, yet I'll bet the same people would NIMBY all over the shop if a council estate was planned for building near them.

100 per cent

ThreeFeetTall · 27/06/2023 14:12

But in the 1970s many council tenants were (relatively) well off and I don't think it was the same struggle to get council housing.

Yes those 5000 people could move out. But I think the waiting list in England is something like 1.6m households. It's not the main issue here.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 13:57

ThreeFeetTall · 27/06/2023 13:53

@Bumpitybumper
"The poor and struggling that are in desperate need of SH often can't get the housing because it is often occupied by relatively financially comfortable people the amount of social housing available has reduced due to decades of government underinvestment."

Fixed it for you

21000 council or housing association tenants earn more than £60k a year. Up to 5000 earn more than £100k.

I stand by my original statement thanks.

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 13:54

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 12:47

I think it depends on the circumstances. If you have a lifetime tenancy and you intend to stay there for life (as I do), it made sense to get the place exactly how I wanted it.

It might be different if you intend to move at any point.

I intend to stay

The only reason I might move from here would be to one of the properties my council has in various coastal or small town areas.
Its for the over 55s and basically its mainly 1 bedroom bungalows or small blocks of flats.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 13:54

bleepbloopImABot · 27/06/2023 13:27

@Bumpitybumper if I wasn’t in social housing I would be “poor and struggling” and quite possibly insecurely housed.

I have a nice little nest egg in the bank due to an inheritance. It’s an odd thing because I have no hope of getting a mortgage (self-employed, cancer survivor which makes work difficult at times) and it isn’t enough to even buy a garage where I live. I can’t leave this city (not that I want to) as I cannot and would not want to move my children away from my their father. But I couldn’t afford to live here without social housing.

At the end of the day the best I can do is recognise my privilege and try to do my best to help others.

OP, sorry for the derail. If you think the cleaning really can be done, then I’d say go for it. As others have said the cleanup will be massive, but in a few months or so you should be more settled and hopefully much more happy in your new place.

I hope you realise I wasn't having a go at you or anybody else really. I can see why you (and to be honest I'm sure most other people with lifetime tenancies) want to keep them and feel that they improve your life. As I said previously, turkeys don't vote for Christmas and I would probably do the same as you in your situation and feel similar levels of gratitude that I was one of the lucky ones.

My point is just that there will be people just like you in similar or worse situations that won't be able to access this housing because it is occupied by people with lifetime tenancies. They will have no choice but to live in unsecure housing in a location not of their choice away from their social network and family. It is not strange or wrong for them to feel jealous or envious of you or to want the system to be reformed so that they can have a chance of getting some of what you have. I don't think these people should be shouted down or made to feel bad for questioning the rules and wanting them to be revised.

ThreeFeetTall · 27/06/2023 13:53

@Bumpitybumper
"The poor and struggling that are in desperate need of SH often can't get the housing because it is often occupied by relatively financially comfortable people the amount of social housing available has reduced due to decades of government underinvestment."

Fixed it for you

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 13:52

What gets me (and amuses me) about these threads. That people look in others bowls to make sure they don't have more than them. The one section or housing that is secure, in their minds needs to be brought in along side the misery of private renting.

The problem isn't in SH. Private rents are out of control. Look at that rather than misery loves company.

The snidyness on this thread is well sad man. Plenty to say about how things should be, yet I'll bet the same people would NIMBY all over the shop if a council estate was planned for building near them.

Clarinet1 · 27/06/2023 13:42

FarTooHotForMe · 27/06/2023 12:11

I would go for it, short term pain for long term gain.

Precisely what I was going to say!
PS - I cannot believe some of the ignorant comments on his thread about SH and also the idea that, just because you are an SH tenant, you shouldn’t be able to make a comfortable, pleasant home for your family.

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 13:30

I got my council place when I left my abusive partner. I was in a 2bed flat with a boy and girl for many years (had them both prior to leaving my partner). We waited a long time to get a 3 bed house (one DC was already at high school at this point). The one we eventually got, had been lived in by one old man until he died (his wife died 20 or so years earlier). The next door neighbour was an old lady (also 3 bed house) living in one room downstairs as she couldn't get upstairs.

The house was disgusting. The council had left the old mans pee filled foam toilet seat in the bathroom, I found the guys false teeth in a cupboard! Then fleas emerged from the floorboards! There was horrible wood chip wallpaper everywhere and the garden was a jungle. I hated the house and the area but in those days you couldn't bid, you had to just take what you were given.

I did so much work on that place purely to get an exchange. Which I did after 4 years, to my current home. I love my current home and have put a lot of work into this also to make it nice. A lot of long term SH tenants will have similar stories. You don't usually get your ideal home, just the right size, right area etc from day 1. It is SH after all!

This is why then in turn people are reluctant to move when they finally get what they want. Nobody made way for me when I needed another bedroom. I had to wait for someone to die! It's shit when you're at the bottom. So when you finally get to the top you're going to hang onto it.

You can't change the system overnight. Lifetime tenancies are becoming more rare. We'll see what effect that has in years to come.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 27/06/2023 13:28

"Why should anyone give up their properties because other people didn't plan their lives better - like having children when you can't afford to house them???"
I don't actually believe this 👆 but I thought I would match the energy of the more nuttier comments I have read on here.

bleepbloopImABot · 27/06/2023 13:27

@Bumpitybumper if I wasn’t in social housing I would be “poor and struggling” and quite possibly insecurely housed.

I have a nice little nest egg in the bank due to an inheritance. It’s an odd thing because I have no hope of getting a mortgage (self-employed, cancer survivor which makes work difficult at times) and it isn’t enough to even buy a garage where I live. I can’t leave this city (not that I want to) as I cannot and would not want to move my children away from my their father. But I couldn’t afford to live here without social housing.

At the end of the day the best I can do is recognise my privilege and try to do my best to help others.

OP, sorry for the derail. If you think the cleaning really can be done, then I’d say go for it. As others have said the cleanup will be massive, but in a few months or so you should be more settled and hopefully much more happy in your new place.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 13:08

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 12:56

Well is there any wonder really? I do wonder what people honestly expect.

The poor and struggling that are in desperate need of SH often can't get the housing because it is often occupied by relatively financially comfortable people with lifetime tenancies. The people with the lifetime tenancies seem to believe their entitlement to this scarce housing should be welcomed and celebrated by all? Any talk of adjusting entitlement to take account of changing circumstances is shut down immediately.

The gulf between SH and the private rental sector has meant that lower and middle earners who don't satisfy the criteria for SH are condemned to a life of inferior private renting whilst those who get themselves into real financial difficulty are rewarded with SH tenancies that last a lifetime. There was a poster on this thread who got allocated a SH property as a teenage mum. It's a hard pill to swallow for those who try and work their way out of poverty and hardship when they are denied the benefits and entitlements of the very poor but can't earn enough to be able to afford a mortgage to own property themselves either. I think this is made even worse when the SH tenants go on to earn the same or more than those that have never been entitled to SH and yet the SH tenants get to enjoy the security and often lower rents associated with SH for the rest of their lives.

What I meant was, people with ridiculous mortgages that are struggling and wouldn’t want to live in social housing anyway. It’s just a group of people to be bitter about and look down on. Yes most of the properties are lifetime tenancies. Rightly or wrongly. If any government built more affordable housing it would ease the problem we currently have but that would mean houses would lose their value because the prices are only at a premium because of the shortage so in reality those that are buying a home don’t really want housing to be in abundance

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 12:56

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 11:28

It’s the usual bitterness and jealousies coming out as soon as Social Housing is mentioned, usually by people who are piss poor themselves and struggling

Well is there any wonder really? I do wonder what people honestly expect.

The poor and struggling that are in desperate need of SH often can't get the housing because it is often occupied by relatively financially comfortable people with lifetime tenancies. The people with the lifetime tenancies seem to believe their entitlement to this scarce housing should be welcomed and celebrated by all? Any talk of adjusting entitlement to take account of changing circumstances is shut down immediately.

The gulf between SH and the private rental sector has meant that lower and middle earners who don't satisfy the criteria for SH are condemned to a life of inferior private renting whilst those who get themselves into real financial difficulty are rewarded with SH tenancies that last a lifetime. There was a poster on this thread who got allocated a SH property as a teenage mum. It's a hard pill to swallow for those who try and work their way out of poverty and hardship when they are denied the benefits and entitlements of the very poor but can't earn enough to be able to afford a mortgage to own property themselves either. I think this is made even worse when the SH tenants go on to earn the same or more than those that have never been entitled to SH and yet the SH tenants get to enjoy the security and often lower rents associated with SH for the rest of their lives.

ActDottie · 27/06/2023 12:54

I wish I had £15k to spend on my home…

GabriellaMontez · 27/06/2023 12:50

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 27/06/2023 11:31

Sorry but if you have £15k to spend on renovations then no way should you be in social housing.
I'm being made homeless with several young children and we are terrified.
We are stuck on a waiting list, no idea how long it will take and there are people like you sat in social housing that have 15k kicking about.
Wtaf.

You honestly think the op should give up her life long tenancy and take a private rental (costs more, no security)?

And risk being made homeless in 6 months, having used her savings to pay more rent..?

oOiluvfriendsOo · 27/06/2023 12:48

Sarahtm35 · 26/06/2023 22:25

I’m mean this in the kindest way possible but if you have spent thousands of ££s and can afford to spend £15k on this new place then you really should not be eligible for social housing.
when we got our social housing we could barely afford paint. That’s why we needed the house because we weren’t well off. We have a huge homeless issue in this country and so it upsets me that there are people living in them that clearly have other choices with their renovations and fancy new kitchens. Sorry but i had to rant

What a ridiculous comment. People in council housing do have jobs and savings, they aren't breaking any law by doing so.

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 12:47

tanyaturneristhegoat · 26/06/2023 22:35

What HA/LA does upgrades every 5 years?

Not mine.

We did have upgrades but I was in my old home then (and been here in my "new" one for 9 years)

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 12:47

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 12:41

Neither would I, especially if its council.

I myself live in a council house on an estate so no dissing there, just how I feel and I would not spend out that sort of cash. Different if I was buying it.

I think it depends on the circumstances. If you have a lifetime tenancy and you intend to stay there for life (as I do), it made sense to get the place exactly how I wanted it.

It might be different if you intend to move at any point.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 12:45

wineschmine · 27/06/2023 11:38

Sorry OP, but I have r I agree with this.

I saw your reply to this poster and it just doesn't cut it for me, I'm afraid.

Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

There are huge waitlists for social housing, for people who are in dire need of a home.

I also feel these homes should be for the people who really need them.

But I guess that's on the council and the whole system. You're not doing anything legally wrong, you are entitled to the house. Ethically though is a different thing.

Have spent "thousands" on your current council house and now have £15k to do up another. Just doesn't sit right with me.

Having ethics is a wonderful thing, but it doesn't pay the bills. SH is (generally) secure, more reliably maintained than private lets (usually), and cheaper.

£15k wouldn't go anywhere near a deposit where I live (London/NW Kent).

The answer is more SH - not infighting between tenants.

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 12:45

Dinnaehinksae · 26/06/2023 22:39

Would he be allowed to exchange if the house is so bad? I know my housing association do an inspection before you're allowed to exchange and the house has to be upto a certain standard or it is not allowed to go ahead. The tenant is given a certain amount of time to do the repairs and make good of any issues before hand though.

This

I done an exchange 9 years ago now, from a 3 bedroom maisonette to a 2 bedroom house (same estate, different part of it).
Both of us had to fix our repairs before they would let us sign the papers needed to exchange.
We had 3 weeks I recall and then somebody from the Housing came to sign it off. We then went to sign over possession to each other on a Friday morning and we moved to each others former homes the next morning.

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 12:41

Shinyandnew1 · 26/06/2023 22:21

If the windows need replacing, that will cost thousands-are you planning to pay for that as well?

I wouldn’t be willingly moving into somewhere that needed that much work.

Neither would I, especially if its council.

I myself live in a council house on an estate so no dissing there, just how I feel and I would not spend out that sort of cash. Different if I was buying it.