Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social housing exchange - AIBU

310 replies

Brighton5555 · 26/06/2023 21:56

Hey

just need some assurance / reality check I guess. I have managed to find a housing swap after quite some time ( the feedback I get is lovely house but too small) so not beating off offers by any means despite my home being to a high standard and spent thousands on it…

im due to sign a exchange soon. The man has the same bedrooms as me and he has a house in a area I desire but if this house wasn’t in the area I want I don’t know if I would actually go for it..

bonus points are - neighbours on one side only, good garden size, extra toilet downstairs, larger kitchen than mine, larger bathroom and about same size of the 4 bedrooms BUT

its pretty gross. He has 7 animals including 4 dogs, it needs gutted from top to bottom as in complete new flooring and complete decoration and the bathroom will need ripped out. It’s in a very poor conditon but has passed all the checks they do for exchanging .. I viewed it for the 3rd time last week and the house had a lot of flies, I mean a lot I suspect from the animals . It was super clear to me on that viewing just how much money and work will need to be put in whereas here mine needs only a freshen up on the painting upstairs there are no other costs to him..

of course he’s lucky and it’s not his fault that our homes are very different but I just feel am I being crazy to take it on? I’m legit starting from the bottom again and will need to spend a few weeks living outside and at least £15,000 to have it okay to move into.

I have the means to do both but I know it’s going to a long slog. Again the benefits are extra toilet, larger kitchen and bathroom more manageable sized garden and a better area ..

I guess I feel daunted by it all

OP posts:
Luxell934 · 27/06/2023 16:46

Perhaps if you have a life long tenancy but you earn over a certain amount councils should raise the rent in line with current private landlords. Most people would probably want to move out and find a private landlord in a better area, nicer house etc rather than stay in the council house but pay private rates.

Obviously there would be some who would cut hours and do little work to not lose their council house.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:39

The companies act as the landlord. Nothing is subsidised. They make no profit. It all pays for itself.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:38

It makes no sense does it. Social housing isn’t something “we own” as a country. It is run by private not for profit companies

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 16:36

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:19

It's not about feeling superior, it's about fairness and equality. I don't think there is anything morally unjust in suggesting SH is an asset we own as a country that should be used to best advantage to help those most in need.

Is that you trying to link it to benefits again?

What you're wanting is to chuck people out to give someone else a turn. Then chuck them out later on to give someone else a turn.

How that makes any sense is beyond me

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 16:34

I said single accommodation, as in hostels and the like. Not SH residents.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:34

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:30

Perhaps you could petition government to get the policy changed and therefore flood the already oversubscribed private rental market. Just an idea

Why would the private market be flooded? Where do you think the vast majority of those who are in most in need of SH currently live? They don't appear out of nowhere and are currently being house somewhere. The overall number of people needing to be housed somewhere wouldn't change, it would just be who is housed where.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 16:34

We don't need the kind of reform you suggest.

What we need is for govt regulated non profit rentals to be the only rental option and for there to be sufficient supply. So the options are (1) rent social housing at a non profit rate, with there being a reasonable supply of homes to meet need. No private landlords at all. Or (2) purchase and live in a home you have a mortgage/own outright.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:32

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 16:29

I've seen things in other countries that work. More stable, long term, cheaper private rentals. Single accommodation of a good standard, that isn't filled with drug users and alcoholics like it generally is in this country. We have a huge gap between SH and owning your own home, that is filled with poor options. It's true we can't build enough SH for everyone, so we need to find better options for those in the middle who have very little choice right now. Chucking a few people out because they're under occupying or earning too much would be a drop in the ocean and would come with it's own issues.

I know SH residents who work full time and don’t drink or do drugs. It’s a stereotypical, misinformed observation you make

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:30

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:22

I understand that hence why I suggested reform is needed. My question was more trying to understand how anyone can justify how this kind of policy is fair or just.

Perhaps you could petition government to get the policy changed and therefore flood the already oversubscribed private rental market. Just an idea

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 16:29

I've seen things in other countries that work. More stable, long term, cheaper private rentals. Single accommodation of a good standard, that isn't filled with drug users and alcoholics like it generally is in this country. We have a huge gap between SH and owning your own home, that is filled with poor options. It's true we can't build enough SH for everyone, so we need to find better options for those in the middle who have very little choice right now. Chucking a few people out because they're under occupying or earning too much would be a drop in the ocean and would come with it's own issues.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:27

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:22

I understand that hence why I suggested reform is needed. My question was more trying to understand how anyone can justify how this kind of policy is fair or just.

The government don't care, nor will Labour, and as people like me have a legally binding "life tenancy" I'm not sure how far ethics will get with this....🙄

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:24

Trinity65 · 27/06/2023 13:54

I intend to stay

The only reason I might move from here would be to one of the properties my council has in various coastal or small town areas.
Its for the over 55s and basically its mainly 1 bedroom bungalows or small blocks of flats.

I'm in a property, built as some sort of Millennium project (in London), that's for over 40's - no resident kids or pets.

It's higher spec, more expensive than most SH, but it suits me, especially since DH died.

Large 2 bed garden flat, no next door neighbours (the design of it), a lovely maintained landscape garden, and all maintenance carried out promptly.

Im going nowhere, despite the higher than normal SH rent.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:22

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:18

SH tenants are ‘spared’ from it because they are in social housing and that is the policy

I understand that hence why I suggested reform is needed. My question was more trying to understand how anyone can justify how this kind of policy is fair or just.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:19

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 15:41

They won't stop until it is though. People can't stand the thought that people in council houses might be better off than them. They couldn't give a shit about the people they're banging on about. They just want to feel superior again.

It's not about feeling superior, it's about fairness and equality. I don't think there is anything morally unjust in suggesting SH is an asset we own as a country that should be used to best advantage to help those most in need.

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:18

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:12

It really depends on how you define 'benefit'.

In a capitalist society it is definitely unusual to be able to rent such an expensive asset without the asset owner making a profit or the value of the capital used to purchase the asset being accounted for in the rental value (e.g. due to mortgage interest). There is a reason why private landlords can't charge the same as SH even if they wanted to (you may have noticed the mass exodus of landlords from the private market despite them charging higher rents). SH is very unusual in that technically it isn't 'subsidised' because the rent charged meets the costs of maintenance etc of the house, however if I said that I was living in my friend's house rent free but was paying enough to cover running costs and maintenance then many people would suggest I was in fact being subsidised by my friend because I was enjoying an expensive asset without paying anything towards the fact their money was tied up in the asset and could be used elsewhere where they could get a better return.

Your arguments about people losing out and losing their homes if they earn more money are strange. Social housing is a finite source and there isn't enough of it to go round. You are more than happy for the people that don't have a chance in hell of getting social housing to never get the chance to enjoy lower rents or more security in their tenancies because you are worried some people might get evicted from their home. This literally happens frequently to private renters who often don't have any way of getting a respite from this so why should SH tenants be spared from this for their entire life? Why is such a two tier system acceptable? If you can answer this without simply saying 'build more SH houses' then I will be shocked.

SH tenants are ‘spared’ from it because they are in social housing and that is the policy

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:18

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 12:56

Well is there any wonder really? I do wonder what people honestly expect.

The poor and struggling that are in desperate need of SH often can't get the housing because it is often occupied by relatively financially comfortable people with lifetime tenancies. The people with the lifetime tenancies seem to believe their entitlement to this scarce housing should be welcomed and celebrated by all? Any talk of adjusting entitlement to take account of changing circumstances is shut down immediately.

The gulf between SH and the private rental sector has meant that lower and middle earners who don't satisfy the criteria for SH are condemned to a life of inferior private renting whilst those who get themselves into real financial difficulty are rewarded with SH tenancies that last a lifetime. There was a poster on this thread who got allocated a SH property as a teenage mum. It's a hard pill to swallow for those who try and work their way out of poverty and hardship when they are denied the benefits and entitlements of the very poor but can't earn enough to be able to afford a mortgage to own property themselves either. I think this is made even worse when the SH tenants go on to earn the same or more than those that have never been entitled to SH and yet the SH tenants get to enjoy the security and often lower rents associated with SH for the rest of their lives.

This is because not enough SH is being built. Those on here, that are older, got SH years ago.

Why on earth would they give it up to go into expensive, insecure private lets?

No sense in doing that.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:16

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/06/2023 15:39

26000 out of 4.4 million social housing homes in England…

That’s hardly “often”

A fifth earn more than the average UK wage. There will obviously be a hell of a lot of people in the private sector on much less than the average wage or on benefits so yes I do think this warrants the word 'often'. Don't you?

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:12

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 15:33

Social housing is not a benefit it just not rented at a profit like private let's.

Also, actual benefits to prop up low/no earnings are swapped for wages on the case of successful employment progression. So you aren't without. Nor are you penalised by being evicted from your home

People seriously need to understand that social housing is not a benefit

It really depends on how you define 'benefit'.

In a capitalist society it is definitely unusual to be able to rent such an expensive asset without the asset owner making a profit or the value of the capital used to purchase the asset being accounted for in the rental value (e.g. due to mortgage interest). There is a reason why private landlords can't charge the same as SH even if they wanted to (you may have noticed the mass exodus of landlords from the private market despite them charging higher rents). SH is very unusual in that technically it isn't 'subsidised' because the rent charged meets the costs of maintenance etc of the house, however if I said that I was living in my friend's house rent free but was paying enough to cover running costs and maintenance then many people would suggest I was in fact being subsidised by my friend because I was enjoying an expensive asset without paying anything towards the fact their money was tied up in the asset and could be used elsewhere where they could get a better return.

Your arguments about people losing out and losing their homes if they earn more money are strange. Social housing is a finite source and there isn't enough of it to go round. You are more than happy for the people that don't have a chance in hell of getting social housing to never get the chance to enjoy lower rents or more security in their tenancies because you are worried some people might get evicted from their home. This literally happens frequently to private renters who often don't have any way of getting a respite from this so why should SH tenants be spared from this for their entire life? Why is such a two tier system acceptable? If you can answer this without simply saying 'build more SH houses' then I will be shocked.

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 15:41

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 15:33

Social housing is not a benefit it just not rented at a profit like private let's.

Also, actual benefits to prop up low/no earnings are swapped for wages on the case of successful employment progression. So you aren't without. Nor are you penalised by being evicted from your home

People seriously need to understand that social housing is not a benefit

They won't stop until it is though. People can't stand the thought that people in council houses might be better off than them. They couldn't give a shit about the people they're banging on about. They just want to feel superior again.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/06/2023 15:39

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 13:57

21000 council or housing association tenants earn more than £60k a year. Up to 5000 earn more than £100k.

I stand by my original statement thanks.

26000 out of 4.4 million social housing homes in England…

That’s hardly “often”

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 15:33

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 14:50

You could make that argument about any means tested benefit or entitlement .Does that mean that we should all get lifelong access to all these things because otherwise we are being penalised for hard work when we go over whatever threshold is in place and the benefit/entitlement is removed?

Social housing is not a benefit it just not rented at a profit like private let's.

Also, actual benefits to prop up low/no earnings are swapped for wages on the case of successful employment progression. So you aren't without. Nor are you penalised by being evicted from your home

People seriously need to understand that social housing is not a benefit

BlueYazoo · 27/06/2023 15:13

Yeah this post seems off. When I was allocated social housing I was given a roller, tray and one can of white paint. I had less than £50 to my name, all the flooring was ripped out by the council and I was left with floorboards and original tiles even having 2 young children, this was in 2004. If you have thousands to spare on decorating and can live outside for a few weeks whilst it’s done then IMHO you should be looking for a private rental and giving the social housing to someone in genuine need.

caringcarer · 27/06/2023 15:05

I'd stay put until something better comes up for swaps. The place you describe sounds vile.

bleepbloopImABot · 27/06/2023 14:51

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 13:54

I hope you realise I wasn't having a go at you or anybody else really. I can see why you (and to be honest I'm sure most other people with lifetime tenancies) want to keep them and feel that they improve your life. As I said previously, turkeys don't vote for Christmas and I would probably do the same as you in your situation and feel similar levels of gratitude that I was one of the lucky ones.

My point is just that there will be people just like you in similar or worse situations that won't be able to access this housing because it is occupied by people with lifetime tenancies. They will have no choice but to live in unsecure housing in a location not of their choice away from their social network and family. It is not strange or wrong for them to feel jealous or envious of you or to want the system to be reformed so that they can have a chance of getting some of what you have. I don't think these people should be shouted down or made to feel bad for questioning the rules and wanting them to be revised.

I didn’t take it personally @Bumpitybumper 😊. I know that I’m privileged to have secure housing, but if I didn’t have my council flat I would quite possibly very quickly be in a council-funded B&B with my children. Private rental is so precarious and my income is such that I doubt I could afford even a 2-bedroom flat at current rates. I would love to buy but it’s not going to happen any time soon.

I believe that the real problem is the housing crisis, which has been brewing for years. And, as always, the government has done a great job at getting people to blame each other for it rather than trying to do anything about it. Just like they do with benefits (which I’m not eligible for by the way).

I do agree that people should be incentivised to move on to other housing once their situation changes. Often the council makes this very difficult. My neighbour wanted to move somewhere smaller to free up her family-sized house for, well, a family once her children had left home. She tried all sorts of things for a decade but it turned out to be way too expensive (her rent would have increased massively!) and the offerings were pitiful. It was only when some rules changed last year that she could finally afford a nice little one-bedroom flat which was all she’d wanted all along.

But forcing low- to middle-income earners to move because they have “too much” money to live somewhere while they still don’t have enough money to live somewhere else would be a disaster. I just don’t see how it would work. Ultimately we all have to live somewhere.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 14:50

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 14:39

If people earning well were then evicted out of their SH (which some seem to be suggesting happens!) where is the incentive to work hard and progress in your career?

You could make that argument about any means tested benefit or entitlement .Does that mean that we should all get lifelong access to all these things because otherwise we are being penalised for hard work when we go over whatever threshold is in place and the benefit/entitlement is removed?

Swipe left for the next trending thread