Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social housing exchange - AIBU

310 replies

Brighton5555 · 26/06/2023 21:56

Hey

just need some assurance / reality check I guess. I have managed to find a housing swap after quite some time ( the feedback I get is lovely house but too small) so not beating off offers by any means despite my home being to a high standard and spent thousands on it…

im due to sign a exchange soon. The man has the same bedrooms as me and he has a house in a area I desire but if this house wasn’t in the area I want I don’t know if I would actually go for it..

bonus points are - neighbours on one side only, good garden size, extra toilet downstairs, larger kitchen than mine, larger bathroom and about same size of the 4 bedrooms BUT

its pretty gross. He has 7 animals including 4 dogs, it needs gutted from top to bottom as in complete new flooring and complete decoration and the bathroom will need ripped out. It’s in a very poor conditon but has passed all the checks they do for exchanging .. I viewed it for the 3rd time last week and the house had a lot of flies, I mean a lot I suspect from the animals . It was super clear to me on that viewing just how much money and work will need to be put in whereas here mine needs only a freshen up on the painting upstairs there are no other costs to him..

of course he’s lucky and it’s not his fault that our homes are very different but I just feel am I being crazy to take it on? I’m legit starting from the bottom again and will need to spend a few weeks living outside and at least £15,000 to have it okay to move into.

I have the means to do both but I know it’s going to a long slog. Again the benefits are extra toilet, larger kitchen and bathroom more manageable sized garden and a better area ..

I guess I feel daunted by it all

OP posts:
EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 18:01

The point is that the constraint on SH in some areas is so great that even those who are seen as 'high priority' aren't getting housing quickly

But again on these threads people will say that they just have to move to a less popular area then. And that this is what home buyers have to do all the time, as in buying in an area they can afford.

I did move areas just to get into the refuge in the first place (no spaces at my local one). Tbh I was glad for the chance to get away and be housed elsewhere. I wouldn't have felt safe staying where I was.

The issue is moreso people insisting they have to stay in their particular London borough for example. If they're not willing to look outside that area, why should someone else be forced out to accommodate them?

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 17:53

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 17:41

The “most in need” might be a woman and children fleeing domestic abuse and needing safe, stable accommodation. It might be someone who was fit and healthy but had a huge stroke, but they’re now physically disabled and unable to work and needs accessible stable, accommodation

These people are already prioritised. I was in a refuge after fleeing DV. We got housed much quicker than the general population. So while this argument is used time and again on these threads, the mechanisms are already in place to prioritise those people.

The point is that the constraint on SH in some areas is so great that even those who are seen as 'high priority' aren't getting housing quickly. Meanwhile someone that was allocated housing in their teens as a single parent could easily occupy a home for 60 plus years irrespective of their financial position, effectively blocking it for those most in need.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 17:52

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 17:33

So you want councils to have less money coming in, because they're paying themselves for the rents of their stock in the form of housing benefit?

Makes sense...

I live in a higher end HA spec.block of 10 flats. We all had to be assessed to see if we could afgord the rent.

In this block, most are either boomers who aren't particularly poor, and the rest (over 40, but no resident children), work.

Few claim any sort of UC/Housing element.

If they could throw everyone out for the neediest/poorest, then in this block alone, the housing benefit bill would shoot up.

Its pointless private renters getting stroppy with SH renters. We just need more SH.🙄

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 17:41

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 17:33

So you want councils to have less money coming in, because they're paying themselves for the rents of their stock in the form of housing benefit?

Makes sense...

Do you think they are not already paying people on the housing list HB? I think you really need to think through what you're posting.

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 17:41

The “most in need” might be a woman and children fleeing domestic abuse and needing safe, stable accommodation. It might be someone who was fit and healthy but had a huge stroke, but they’re now physically disabled and unable to work and needs accessible stable, accommodation

These people are already prioritised. I was in a refuge after fleeing DV. We got housed much quicker than the general population. So while this argument is used time and again on these threads, the mechanisms are already in place to prioritise those people.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 17:38

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/06/2023 17:20

Throwing new statistics in and ignoring the last one you chucked because it was shown to be a minute number of people doesn’t help your argument…

And a random statistic like that is utterly useless unless there is a locational breakdown and link to the rental cost of said social housing.

Trying to portray the myth that there are millions of people earning a fortune paying £90 a week in rent is just disingenuous bollocks.

The first statistic was to show just how much some people in SH earn. Of course it was only ever going to be a small percentage of SH tenants as only a small percentage of the UK population as whole earns this amount. My point was there are people earning (I would argue objectively) large salaries and still taking advantage SH.

The statistic on average wage isn't meaningless. It might not be as granulated as you like but it shows that 'often' SH tenants earn more than their private renting counterparts. Are you suggesting that if you had the data you want that it would disprove this? I think we both know it wouldn't.

I never said there are millions of people paying £90 a week. I am merely pointing out that a lot of the tenants aren't the most 'needy' in society. I am also pointing out that SH has many benefits which are particularly useful when you are in financial hardship hence why so many people are desperate to cling on to their entitlement for it. It is understandable that other needy people want a piece of the pie and point out the injustice. It is ok and morally justified to suggest reform. You can disagree about whether it is needed or not but trying to shout down anyone that suggests it and to imply we are mean spirited nasty people that just want to take things away from people for no reason is wrong.

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 17:33

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:55

Explain to me why this would be the case? The SH wouldn't stop existing, it would simply be allocated differently. If anything it would reduce housing benefit as a lot of the current encumbents that have relatively high incomes will not be entitled to housing benefit whilst the people most in need who would get the SH would be recipients of HB in most cases.

So you want councils to have less money coming in, because they're paying themselves for the rents of their stock in the form of housing benefit?

Makes sense...

Luxell934 · 27/06/2023 17:33

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 17:26

So ban private rentals then. Why should people profiteer from rent? From housing - a basic need.

Private landlords can sell their homes to social housing providers, or the larger private lettings companies can be purchased as a going concern and the homes and jobs merged into existing social housing companies.same amount of houses, but all of them will he regulated and rented out at a price which overs running a SH company.

Banning private rentals isn’t going to happen you know because of Capitalism and all that…which is what most people voted for at last general election. Nobody wanted Corbyns socialist agenda. (I did, voted for him but in general that’s not what people want)

Teder · 27/06/2023 17:32

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 16:36

Is that you trying to link it to benefits again?

What you're wanting is to chuck people out to give someone else a turn. Then chuck them out later on to give someone else a turn.

How that makes any sense is beyond me

I don’t agree with that poster’s views but I don’t see the link to benefits in that post.

The “most in need” might be a woman and children fleeing domestic abuse and needing safe, stable accommodation. It might be someone who was fit and healthy but had a huge stroke, but they’re now physically disabled and unable to work and needs accessible stable, accommodation.

I do think we need to utilise our limited resources to those who need it most. I don’t think it’s appropriate to bring up on a thread like this because we have no idea what OP’s need may be and it’s certainly not her fault. She does not need to justify herself to anyone.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 17:29

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 17:26

So ban private rentals then. Why should people profiteer from rent? From housing - a basic need.

Private landlords can sell their homes to social housing providers, or the larger private lettings companies can be purchased as a going concern and the homes and jobs merged into existing social housing companies.same amount of houses, but all of them will he regulated and rented out at a price which overs running a SH company.

There has always been private rentals. I rented a flat at the beginning of the 70's. Rents might need regulating but what we need is more SH. It's that simple.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 17:27

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 16:56

Obviously there would be some who would cut hours and do little work to not lose their council house

This was touted as an idea a few years ago. I remember reading about it in the news. I'm a contractor on an hourly rate. Yes, I would have cut my hours to stay within the threshold not to pay more. Why wouldn't I?

If I was left with the same money in my hand, after paying rent, for 30 hours work or 40 hours, then yes, I'll just do the 30 hours!

Well. Yes. That's why the idea was scrapped. 🙄

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 17:26

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 17:02

It currently raises nowhere near enough to build the SH we need. Charging more rent would obviously help close this deficit a bit and help contribute to the 'true' cost of renting an asset and it just the running costs.

So ban private rentals then. Why should people profiteer from rent? From housing - a basic need.

Private landlords can sell their homes to social housing providers, or the larger private lettings companies can be purchased as a going concern and the homes and jobs merged into existing social housing companies.same amount of houses, but all of them will he regulated and rented out at a price which overs running a SH company.

Bloodyleaverspartybollocks · 27/06/2023 17:24

I'd go for it. Sounds ideal.

SadGirl6 · 27/06/2023 17:22

Is he living alone in a four bed HA house with 7 animals (ew) while there are families living in overcrowded accommodation, no gardens etc?! Madness!

BelindaBears · 27/06/2023 17:22

If you were buying you’d spend a lot more than £15k on moving to a new area and decorating. No brainer to me, you say you want this area and “detest” where you are now. That’s the most important thing.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/06/2023 17:20

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:16

A fifth earn more than the average UK wage. There will obviously be a hell of a lot of people in the private sector on much less than the average wage or on benefits so yes I do think this warrants the word 'often'. Don't you?

Throwing new statistics in and ignoring the last one you chucked because it was shown to be a minute number of people doesn’t help your argument…

And a random statistic like that is utterly useless unless there is a locational breakdown and link to the rental cost of said social housing.

Trying to portray the myth that there are millions of people earning a fortune paying £90 a week in rent is just disingenuous bollocks.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 17:02

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 16:51

And what would the raised rents cover? The regulated rent already covers all costs which includes (drumroll) building more social houses!

It currently raises nowhere near enough to build the SH we need. Charging more rent would obviously help close this deficit a bit and help contribute to the 'true' cost of renting an asset and it just the running costs.

EmpressSoleil · 27/06/2023 16:56

Obviously there would be some who would cut hours and do little work to not lose their council house

This was touted as an idea a few years ago. I remember reading about it in the news. I'm a contractor on an hourly rate. Yes, I would have cut my hours to stay within the threshold not to pay more. Why wouldn't I?

If I was left with the same money in my hand, after paying rent, for 30 hours work or 40 hours, then yes, I'll just do the 30 hours!

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:55

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:50

I agree. Why make everyone suffer just to make private renters feel better? All that will do is increase the housing benefits bill. 🙄

Explain to me why this would be the case? The SH wouldn't stop existing, it would simply be allocated differently. If anything it would reduce housing benefit as a lot of the current encumbents that have relatively high incomes will not be entitled to housing benefit whilst the people most in need who would get the SH would be recipients of HB in most cases.

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:52

Tidsleytiddy · 27/06/2023 16:39

The companies act as the landlord. Nothing is subsidised. They make no profit. It all pays for itself.

As explained previously, the idea of subsidy isn't as clear cut as you suggest. There is a reason why SH rents are so low and much lower than a non for profit landlord could achieve. The price of capital is an important factor that mustn't and shouldn't be overlooked in this equation.

Lots of councils now own private housing companies. They aren't really what most people would think of when thinking of a private company.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 16:51

And what would the raised rents cover? The regulated rent already covers all costs which includes (drumroll) building more social houses!

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:51

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:46

I already explain how it isn't as clear cut as you suggest that SH isn't a form of benefit. Use semantics all you want but ultimately people are benefiting from the fact that the government isn't charging SH tenants for the use of a high capital asset in the way that a private landlord would have to even if they weren't making any profit. It's as simple as that. The fact you pay for maintenance and upkeep is great but it isn't representative of the true cost of renting assets in a capitalist economy.

Turn taking makes as much sense as first come first served with lifetime tenancies. Why does that make more sense? Being destitute at one point in the 1990s means that you have a lifetime entitlement to cheap housing irrespective of the fact that you are now no longer destitute and in no worse of a financial position than most people stuck on the private rental sector. Yes, that seems a totally fair and sensible policy.

Life isn't always fair. That's how it is.

Zebedee55 · 27/06/2023 16:50

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 16:47

Why though? Why should the rent go up? Why is private rental costs seen as the goal?

I agree. Why make everyone suffer just to make private renters feel better? All that will do is increase the housing benefits bill. 🙄

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/06/2023 16:47

Luxell934 · 27/06/2023 16:46

Perhaps if you have a life long tenancy but you earn over a certain amount councils should raise the rent in line with current private landlords. Most people would probably want to move out and find a private landlord in a better area, nicer house etc rather than stay in the council house but pay private rates.

Obviously there would be some who would cut hours and do little work to not lose their council house.

Why though? Why should the rent go up? Why is private rental costs seen as the goal?

Bumpitybumper · 27/06/2023 16:46

gamerchick · 27/06/2023 16:36

Is that you trying to link it to benefits again?

What you're wanting is to chuck people out to give someone else a turn. Then chuck them out later on to give someone else a turn.

How that makes any sense is beyond me

I already explain how it isn't as clear cut as you suggest that SH isn't a form of benefit. Use semantics all you want but ultimately people are benefiting from the fact that the government isn't charging SH tenants for the use of a high capital asset in the way that a private landlord would have to even if they weren't making any profit. It's as simple as that. The fact you pay for maintenance and upkeep is great but it isn't representative of the true cost of renting assets in a capitalist economy.

Turn taking makes as much sense as first come first served with lifetime tenancies. Why does that make more sense? Being destitute at one point in the 1990s means that you have a lifetime entitlement to cheap housing irrespective of the fact that you are now no longer destitute and in no worse of a financial position than most people stuck on the private rental sector. Yes, that seems a totally fair and sensible policy.