Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is so RUDE and unprofessional?

91 replies

MrsClusterduck · 26/06/2023 18:08

Had 2nd interview at a big 4 London firm almost 2 weeks ago. Interviews involved travel into city so quite expensive. Interviews went really well and I was told a decision would be made by last Monday.

I was actually offered two other roles in the same week as the interview and put them on hold until I’d heard back from this one as this was the big one. I informed them of this at interview.

I emailed the HR lady last Wednesday asking if I could be informed of the outcome and have not had a response. She was very positive and chatty in previous emails as lots going back and forth. The director even moved their diary around to accommodate the interview as they were so keen to see me on the feedback from the 1st interview so I don’t know what I did wrong!

Obviously I’ve taken one of the other jobs now and will assume I haven’t been successful but AIBU to think this is really bad form from a very large firm?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Trying2understand · 27/06/2023 22:14

Agreed it's very likely you are the second candidate and they are doing references/checks etc of candidate one before letting you know.

I do think the days of being told the day of interview are mostly long gone. Busy departments and many people involved in hiring often mean that interviews happen over the course of a week or two. I was hiring somewhat recently and interviewed about 6 people and had to do it over about 8 business days. But I was also very upfront and let people know timelines and communicated the whole way through to be fair to them.

Hope you hear soon @MrsClusterduck

WisherWood · 27/06/2023 10:03

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2023 09:08

To be honest OP, if the job is managerial level especially, I would have expected you to take initiative to speak with someone directly to find out the outcome rather than just writing an email and leaving at that.

This is a common everyday working situation where you have to take matters into your hands. For all you know, it was part of the interview process, to test candidates on how they took initiatives to resolve an issue.

Yeah. No. I don't think it's up to an interviewee to solve other people's problems. Pretty much any good candidate will solve that 'everyday working situation' by thinking 'fuck that for a game of soldiers' and going to work elsewhere.

DrSbaitso · 27/06/2023 09:51

MrsClatterbuck · 27/06/2023 03:51

That's what my old boss back in the nineties called them.

Not much has changed.

blackbeardsballsack · 27/06/2023 09:44

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2023 09:08

To be honest OP, if the job is managerial level especially, I would have expected you to take initiative to speak with someone directly to find out the outcome rather than just writing an email and leaving at that.

This is a common everyday working situation where you have to take matters into your hands. For all you know, it was part of the interview process, to test candidates on how they took initiatives to resolve an issue.

Oh please

vivainsomnia · 27/06/2023 09:08

To be honest OP, if the job is managerial level especially, I would have expected you to take initiative to speak with someone directly to find out the outcome rather than just writing an email and leaving at that.

This is a common everyday working situation where you have to take matters into your hands. For all you know, it was part of the interview process, to test candidates on how they took initiatives to resolve an issue.

WisherWood · 27/06/2023 08:59

It's like HR expect everyone interviewing to automatically want the job when of course the good candidates are doing multiple interviews. It's a nightmare.

I think this is a lot of the problem with recruitment. Most organisations assume they hold all the cards and that you're desperate for a job with them. The reality is the interview is a two-way process and some of it is about the candidate deciding whether they want to work for them. And not just work for them, but whether they might want to be a customer in future. There are various organisations who don't realise how tainted their reputation is because they are rude and unprofessional during their recruitment process.

Fine, we all know they've got to turn down the majority of applicants. But be polite and prompt when you do it. Don't just decide it's a difficult conversation you don't want to have, and leave them hanging there.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 27/06/2023 06:54

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/06/2023 20:36

Have I missed the bit where she named the firm?

No 😂 that poster is just very worried about the feelings of an enormous corporate for some reason.

I’m guessing they don’t work in anything like that environment.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 27/06/2023 05:20

People keep on commenting and making up all these excuses. Maybe you just didn’t get the job? Yes they should have let you know but many, many companies don’t so it’s hardly surprising really

Theoldgreygoose · 27/06/2023 04:38

suburbophobe · 27/06/2023 03:26

I did a similar thing when I was about to leave school in the mid 1970s. I sent my CV to all the accountants and lawyers in town and received a reply from all of them, and a job offer from two.

This was my reality too in the 70's. Was a teenager, early 20's. Worked in offices, pubs, and all kinds of jobs.

But that was then, this is now 2023. yes it's shit for youngsters

Whether it is now or then is immaterial when it comes to replying to people who take the trouble to apply for jobs. It is so much easier now to send an email than it was in the 1970s, when an actual letter had to be typed and mailed. Many businesses now seem to have dropped the ball when it comes to being professional - and I will be applying for jobs again soon, with little expectation of hearing back about some of them.

MrsClatterbuck · 27/06/2023 03:51

DrSbaitso · 26/06/2023 20:01

Human Remains.

That's what my old boss back in the nineties called them.

suburbophobe · 27/06/2023 03:26

I did a similar thing when I was about to leave school in the mid 1970s. I sent my CV to all the accountants and lawyers in town and received a reply from all of them, and a job offer from two.

This was my reality too in the 70's. Was a teenager, early 20's. Worked in offices, pubs, and all kinds of jobs.

But that was then, this is now 2023. yes it's shit for youngsters

suburbophobe · 27/06/2023 03:20

He decided he didn’t want to work for a company who couldn’t spend a few minutes responding.

Good for him. Move on.

I worked in HRM for a famous NGO. One of my jobs was to sift through about 200 CVs hoping for a job without any job openings being advertised. Maybe 1% I could pass on to my recruitment officer because they had relevant experience.

Even doing voluntary work in whatever job shows you are willing to work.

BlockbusterVideoCard · 27/06/2023 02:59

YANBU, it's rude, unprofessional and lazy. If there's a reason for the delay, then they should say so (and apologise for the delay in outcome!). I'm sick of people justifying this trend in modern business practice. We have technology to help us now, it's not onerous to contact people who've taken the trouble apply, let alone actually have an interview. It's a quick and easy job.

coxesorangepippin · 27/06/2023 01:47

I feel your pain op.

I had the third stage of an interview on June 5. Followed up on June 7th. They replied saying they were still finalising things. No news since 🙄

Haven't heard anything since.

I think they're offering it to other people and I'm 4/5/6th choice, I think because I've asked for more money (or other candidates are better!)

Just comes across as totally unprofessional and puts me off working there!!

shazshaz · 27/06/2023 01:21

I do remember many years ago receiving a letter saying I was unsuccessful in a job application which I had made 6 months prior! I just remember thinking how inefficient it was and being grateful I didn't work there :)

Theoldgreygoose · 27/06/2023 01:17

mondaytosunday · 26/06/2023 21:35

Definitely poor form.
Back in the 1980s after I graduated I picked ten firms in my field of interest and sent them my CV on spec. I did get a couple interviews, but also EVERY single one wrote back to me! Even if it was a 'thanks but no thanks'. And this was when you had to actually write letters!

I did a similar thing when I was about to leave school in the mid 1970s. I sent my CV to all the accountants and lawyers in town and received a reply from all of them, and a job offer from two.

Formerpupil · 27/06/2023 01:06

DrSbaitso · 26/06/2023 21:05

I work in big 4. We outsource the HR back office and there can be big disconnects

Why? You're supposed to be one of the biggest companies in the industry, why can't you do it properly?

To cut costs and maximise partner profit share.

A lot of the client facing work is offshored/ outsourced too.

blueshoes · 27/06/2023 01:02

You are not their first choice and they are keeping you 'warm' or at least not blowing you out until the first choice accepts.

Or it could be disorganised HR or some key decision makers are not available to discuss the candidates and come to a decision.

Either way, it is not uncommon, having been on both sides of this. It's frustrating but it is the name of the game. If you went with a recruitment agent, they are often able to chivvy things out better.

You have accepted your other offer so this big firm lost out. That is the risk they take by not getting back to you in time.

user1473878824 · 27/06/2023 00:50

It’s massively shitty of them but you having to commute for an interview and it costing you isn’t really their problem

Namechangedforthis25 · 27/06/2023 00:37

without outing I’m senior in a big 4 firm and do a lot of 2nd round interviews.

i have interviewed 5 people in a week before. In reality the director has a day job and it’s not good but they may have forgotten to give feedback to HR on time (there’s usually a form to be completed) and HR May in then take time. And if there’s an agency that can add to the delay

Absences can then make emails be missed

tjis doesn’t make it ok but there can be a lot of people and red tape involved so I wouldn’t take it personally - yet

Equalitea · 27/06/2023 00:29

I would assume that you were on reserve list and if it doesn’t go well with their first choice they’ll send an apology for the delay email and ask when you can start!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/06/2023 22:30

ZenNudist · 26/06/2023 22:24

We are not big 4 (but one down!) And we let people know what is going on. Still interviews can take place over a period of weeks and we wouldn't want to accept anyone until we'd finished the interviews. So you are most likely still in the running if its only been 2 weeks but it is unprofessional not to have told you that.

Did you email and ask for an update? If it were me I'd be letting them know that you have other offers and need to make a choice. Force them to decide.

I once had deloitte badger me to interview with them and I explained to the recruiter that I was very happy where I was. They persuaded me into a telephone interview which I was expecting to be them explaining how the new team they were setting up would work.

The interview was a recruiter asking me things like my experience and salary expectations. I had to remind them they had been the ones who'd asked me to interview and that in terms of salary they could make me an offer.

So I gave up time on my non work day to take this call then I never heard back. It was very strange and I was left with the impression that their recruitment team was disorganised and didn't have a clue.

I think its often the case that in professional services recruitment they are used to recruiting for audit or tax and not very good to getting experienced hires into advisory.

My recruitment team are bloody awful at sticking to the graduate recruitment timeline for notification. They let good candidates go whilst we await first choice reply. First choice often has something else lined up. It's like HR expect everyone interviewing to automatically want the job when of course the good candidates are doing multiple interviews. It's a nightmare.

Just fyi, not heard good things about Deloitte at all, loads I know have left. You’re correct their recruitment team don’t have a clue, when they recruited me they were based in Eastern Europe and Poland I think. Nothing against that at all but I find in those circs they’re a bit removed from the real time processes.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/06/2023 22:27

OneSugar1 · 26/06/2023 21:20

If it’s really a big firm (ietens if thousands of employees) there will layers of bureaucracy which can b3 soul destroying. Often most of stuff like HR is offshored. We’ve lost good interviewees this way, but it’s the nature of such a large organisation unfortunately.

Actually it depends on the department of the huge corporation. My experience involved the admin staff of the exec office of this UK bank. I was very surprised that only a PA and the Business manager at this level interviewed me and followed up after my second interview and the first one. Nothing from HR, talent acquisition etc at all which in my experience all other companies tend to do. I think it was because it was for the exec office that they chose to handle it there. The situation with the internal candidate doing the job already and who ultimately got the job over me I sort of guessed was handled by their HR team. Maybe she’d wanted to be moved and had over 2 years service.

ZenNudist · 26/06/2023 22:24

We are not big 4 (but one down!) And we let people know what is going on. Still interviews can take place over a period of weeks and we wouldn't want to accept anyone until we'd finished the interviews. So you are most likely still in the running if its only been 2 weeks but it is unprofessional not to have told you that.

Did you email and ask for an update? If it were me I'd be letting them know that you have other offers and need to make a choice. Force them to decide.

I once had deloitte badger me to interview with them and I explained to the recruiter that I was very happy where I was. They persuaded me into a telephone interview which I was expecting to be them explaining how the new team they were setting up would work.

The interview was a recruiter asking me things like my experience and salary expectations. I had to remind them they had been the ones who'd asked me to interview and that in terms of salary they could make me an offer.

So I gave up time on my non work day to take this call then I never heard back. It was very strange and I was left with the impression that their recruitment team was disorganised and didn't have a clue.

I think its often the case that in professional services recruitment they are used to recruiting for audit or tax and not very good to getting experienced hires into advisory.

My recruitment team are bloody awful at sticking to the graduate recruitment timeline for notification. They let good candidates go whilst we await first choice reply. First choice often has something else lined up. It's like HR expect everyone interviewing to automatically want the job when of course the good candidates are doing multiple interviews. It's a nightmare.

thisisyoursign · 26/06/2023 22:23

You could have got the job - there’s a good chance they are just being slow. I would have used your other job offer to get them to respond quicker (with hopefully a job offer too!) and then use both offers to negotiate a higher salary at whichever one you wanted to take