Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a 5year fix on your mortgage is a con right now?

81 replies

Bluffysummers · 26/06/2023 17:01

Admittedly this isn’t really my opinion more of wonderment?

my fix is coming to an end (joy) and when I last took out my mortgage, you paid more to fix longer and now it’s the opposite it’s the shorter rates that are more expensive.

traditionally you paid a bit more for security, and now it’s less? Is that a ‘sneaky’ (not the right word but let’s go with it) tactic from lenders to lock in customers at a higher rate for longer as they are envisioning the BR and thus their interest rates going down?

what are people thinking 2 v 5 year? I was thinking intially 2 due to the predictions that inflation will be close to the BoE target in mid point 2025 and therefore interest rates will come down (probably not to what they once were, but down none the less) so if you’re locked in for 5 years, you’re stuck. But then 5 years grants you the ability to budget for 5 years

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lcb123 · 27/06/2023 10:27

We're buying now and getting a 5 year fixed, luckily got the mortgage offer in March. We know rates may reduce but we just wanted the certainty of the monthly payments for that period

lljkk · 27/06/2023 10:09

It's been same dilemma for savers, though. I put cash in a fixed rate account last year, now earning a pittance compared to savings rate I could get today.

Or FTB. DS has dreamt of buying for years, he exchanges today. Maybe that investment will go south. All a pain.

Nordicrain · 27/06/2023 09:36

Bluffysummers · 26/06/2023 18:18

That’s why I said a con isn’t really my opinion, it’s as you said, the base rate is expected to come down in that 5 year period so might not be worthwhile taking years

It's not a con, it's how pending works. It's super shit for the borrower at the moment though.

Bluffysummers · 27/06/2023 09:28

If it was 3/4% I’d definitely go 5 but now I’m seeing the 5/6% and god it’s more than double actually close to triple what we were paying 😫

OP posts:
Onegingerhead · 27/06/2023 08:51

We locked in a new rate of 4.07% starting from September and fixed for 5 years.
My reasoning: a) it’s affordable b) there is only £50 difference between this rate and 3% should it fall soon and c) if there is a huge fall in rates in 2 years or so (sub 0%, lol), the EPC won’t be massive then so I ll pay and refix

LittleBumblebee3 · 26/06/2023 21:35

Completely agree with those saying it’s more about buying piece of mind 👍🏻 we’re in that position. Bought at the end of last year and fixed for 10 years at 3.2%. Quite a few people tried to steer us away from the 10 year fix but for us, the next 10 years should (hopefully!) cover us having a second child if we decide to and the childcare years etc. We know we can afford that even with me being on SMP again or if we were to decide I wouldn’t return to work if we had a 2nd child (DH works away for long periods of time so this is a likely option).

JaninaDuszejko · 26/06/2023 21:04

We fixed for 5 years at 3.99% a couple of months ago. We are in our 50s and have a low LTV. 3.99% is a historically low rate and we can easily afford it so not going to worry too much.

Thatusernamewastaken · 26/06/2023 20:55

Think I’d be holding my nose and going for a 2 year and would expect rates to have come down a bit by the end of that. With current borrowing levels I just don’t see it being sustainable for a lot of people beyond that sort of time frame.
On a fix at 1.4% for another 4 years but regret not going for 10. Was really a coin flip between the 5 or a 10 year at 1.6% or whatever it was. Where did I think rates were gonna go 😂Ah well, definitely can’t complain, but we won’t see rates that low again for a lonnnggg time and will still probably be a costly mistake.

headcheffer · 26/06/2023 20:51

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 26/06/2023 19:16

I've not had to contemplate this for a long time but I viewed it like this.
With a fix you are buying peace of mind. If interest rates going up would cripple you its right to fix but accept that the price is for peace of mind.

This is my view too. It's less about the amount you'll pay and more about your own financial position. Are you relatively financially secure and further increases in COL and mortgage rates wouldn't really affect you too much - if so, go tracker or short term fix. You can essentially afford to take the risk. If the current higher rates are getting you to the edge of your current financial comfort then fix for longer for the security of knowing what your mortgage payment will be for the next 5 years. I think in the current market it wouldn't be wise to fix for 10, as within 10 years there's a stronger chance rates will come down.

Cramlington567 · 26/06/2023 20:45

Hoping to borrow more at next renewal in March to fund extension. How does that work, do they give you the money on application completion or can you say to them I want the money just before my builder needs it so as not to be paying extra interest.

Wrapunzel · 26/06/2023 20:41

I fixed for ten years in April. I'm 44 and have always felt like 4% is cheap for a mortgage, and the past 15 years have been a (long) blip. Even if I'm wrong, 4% is affordable for us and we have certainty over rhe decade. I'm a chartered accountant with a keen interest in personal finance but v interested to read economists' and IFAs' views (even if I'm locked in until 2033 Grin)

boomboom109283 · 26/06/2023 20:39

We have just fixed for three years on the advice of our broker. We have always been on a tracker but makes sense at the moment to fix. Hopefully it's long enough for things to stabilise but not so long we feel trapped by it.

Remmy123 · 26/06/2023 20:34

I fixed at 5.5% when the banks crashed and it was a huge regret I won't be doing that again so going for 2 years.

Bluffysummers · 26/06/2023 20:24

foxynoxy · 26/06/2023 20:18

Another factor that you need to take into account on the 2yr v 5yr is the amount of equity in your house. House prices are likely to experience a correction in the short term (I don't envisage a crash per se but I think up to a 10-15% drop in some areas is looking increasingly likely).

Anybody that has bought recently with a 10% deposit could end up with very little equity when they come to renew in 2yrs which will make remortgaging very difficult.

Our fixed is not up until July 2024 so am hoping by some miracle that something happens before then to provide some clarity on best way forward!!

We’ll actually be ok in terms of equity I think, we’re at a 60% ltv bracket right now with about 45% being mortgaged. We’ll need to take some additional borrowing for some improvements but it’s not cost effective to do that now, so will bring down the balance more and then do additional borrowing at a later date

OP posts:
indigovapour · 26/06/2023 20:21

"And that’s because the thought is that rates will come down? (Hence why the insurance on the longer term rates is different?)"

Exactly, that's the basic idea. You get a lot of people on threads like these trying to prove their intelligence by wanging on about SONIA and yield curves which is largely correct, but a bit unnecessary for a Monday evening on Mumsnet.

At the end of the day it's currently cheaper for lenders to manage risk around 5 year loans than around 2 year loans and that's that.

foxynoxy · 26/06/2023 20:18

Another factor that you need to take into account on the 2yr v 5yr is the amount of equity in your house. House prices are likely to experience a correction in the short term (I don't envisage a crash per se but I think up to a 10-15% drop in some areas is looking increasingly likely).

Anybody that has bought recently with a 10% deposit could end up with very little equity when they come to renew in 2yrs which will make remortgaging very difficult.

Our fixed is not up until July 2024 so am hoping by some miracle that something happens before then to provide some clarity on best way forward!!

edwinbear · 26/06/2023 20:13

@ChittyBangabang my ISA’s are all fixed too 😊

edwinbear · 26/06/2023 20:12

The view currently, re swap rates, is that they will come down across all tenors. Most economists believe the market has over reacted to the BoE decision last week (panicked a bit), and that inflation is obviously sticky. The employment market is still very tight, with pressure on all employers (public and private) to increase wages. Once/if we start seeing unemployment growing and wage pressure comes off that, combined with lower energy prices, should see inflation fall, enabling the BoE to lower rates.

The big question, which of course nobody knows, is when this will happen. It’s really very dependent on the labour market. If that continues to hold strong, it might not be until later in 2025 but it’s real crystal ball gazing. I saw retail sales figures were lower again today, which suggests things might be starting to bite - but like everyone else, obviously I don’t know.

I advocate the view that if you can find a fix you can afford and it gives you peace of mind, 2 or 5 years of paying a bit higher than you might have needed to isn’t a bad decision. It’s a relatively short time out of a 20-25 year mortgage.

OhFGSwhatTFnow · 26/06/2023 20:02

My five year fixed was up in February and I was offered the chance to lock in a new deal last October.

Repayments have gone up by £115 per month, however if I'd not locked that deal in they'd have gone up by nearly £300.

I'm a single parent, just getting back into work after a period as a full time carer for elderly parents during the pandemic and cant afford to take risks atm.

LadyRoughDiamond · 26/06/2023 19:58

Well, I fixed for seven years a few months ago at 3.4%. I think the days of interest rates at 2% and lower are gone, and that inflation won’t be sorted any time soon, as the reasons behind it aren’t going to be easily resolved.

ChittyBangabang · 26/06/2023 19:44

I'm locking in an ISA 5 year deal as think interest rates will plummet

StillWantingADog · 26/06/2023 19:42

I think 2 years is not enough time to guarantee they will go down, 3 might be a better bet but either way I can see how 5 would be appealing as at least you know where you stand for 5 years and if they haven’t come down by then then we’ll all be in a lot more trouble than we are now

Comety · 26/06/2023 19:41

I don't think it's "sneaky", it's an indication that the markets think rates will fall. If you do end up paying over the odds, that's the premium you've paid for stability, as you say. No one knows what will happen really, I expect it to go a bit higher yet, but what do I know?

Bluffysummers · 26/06/2023 19:37

edwinbear · 26/06/2023 19:27

Swaps are not like insurance at all. They are how banks and big corporates fix their debt. So, when I sell a swap (fix) to a big client who is borrowing say £100m, we enter into a swap whereby we agree with another bank that we'd like to receive a floating interest rate from them (usually SONIA) for 5 years and in return we'll pay to them a fixed rate of say 4.90%.

I then agree with my client that they will pay me a fixed rate of say 5.00% and I will pay them the market floating rate. As a bank, we lock in the difference between 4.90% (the rate we've managed to get) vs the 5.00% the client has agreed to fix at.

From that point on, regardless of where rates go, I'm paying 4.90% to one bank and receiving 5.00% from my client. So it doesn't matter in the slightest where rates go - I pay 4.90% and receive 5.00% for 5 years. (The floating elements net off against each other).

Now, just replace my big £100m client with lots of smaller clients with £250,000 mortgages, it works the same, but we just have a group of customers instead of one.

Banks don't play the markets - they can't from a regulatory perspective and it's also a guaranteed way to lose money. In terms of your mortgage, could you fix say half of it? That way, if rates go up you've got half locked in, but if rates fall you can benefit on half of it.

Yeah I used to work in current accounts and it’s similar to how loans and current accounts and that work so this makes sense to me. Thanks for taking the time explain in this context

I dont think I’ve got the option for splitting it, and if it was surely it would be leaving in on svr? which is so much higher than fixes. I could if i had additional borrowing and had them on two separate rates.

is there any prediction in how the swaps are going to be in the future? Or knowing what you do, what your knowledge saying to you on 2/5 yr?

OP posts:
edwinbear · 26/06/2023 19:27

Swaps are not like insurance at all. They are how banks and big corporates fix their debt. So, when I sell a swap (fix) to a big client who is borrowing say £100m, we enter into a swap whereby we agree with another bank that we'd like to receive a floating interest rate from them (usually SONIA) for 5 years and in return we'll pay to them a fixed rate of say 4.90%.

I then agree with my client that they will pay me a fixed rate of say 5.00% and I will pay them the market floating rate. As a bank, we lock in the difference between 4.90% (the rate we've managed to get) vs the 5.00% the client has agreed to fix at.

From that point on, regardless of where rates go, I'm paying 4.90% to one bank and receiving 5.00% from my client. So it doesn't matter in the slightest where rates go - I pay 4.90% and receive 5.00% for 5 years. (The floating elements net off against each other).

Now, just replace my big £100m client with lots of smaller clients with £250,000 mortgages, it works the same, but we just have a group of customers instead of one.

Banks don't play the markets - they can't from a regulatory perspective and it's also a guaranteed way to lose money. In terms of your mortgage, could you fix say half of it? That way, if rates go up you've got half locked in, but if rates fall you can benefit on half of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread